Everything posted by Nny
-
Mark Buehrle
If he's put on the block, a ton of teams go after him, basically creating an auction and putting him at a price higher then he's worth. He's also making 9.5m this year, so if the Whitesoxs were to eat most of his salary (Which they'd have to if we were to obtain him), it'd raise his price even more. And he's a free agent after this year, we wouldn't be able to re-sign him, so...no thank you.
-
Possible Heat Trade Ideas
Yeah...none of those would happen.
-
Michael Barrett to the Padres
Just reported by Buster Onley on Mike and Mike, no details on who the cubs got back. My only thought is...uh, Josh Bard? Why would the Padres want Barrett? edit: Here's a link: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=2910079 doesn't have any info at the moment, but will probably updated as info is known.
-
Marlins interested in Michael Barrett
He repeated rookie ball, he didn't set the SAL on fire, and to me, didn't make a tremendous name for himself in the FSL. To look at his Jupiter numbers as a definitive end all isn't fair or accurate. He did walk, that's not debateable, but the FSL is also notorious for raw developing pitchers. Still, walking's great. However, that Jupiter walk total screams aberration...why? It was more than 150% of any other single season walk total...and a 5 year minor league career is a decent sample size. His R through A numbers aren't debateable; they're bad, plain and simple. But I don't view them as that much of an example of what he can do now. Age 17-20, kids are still learning the game at that age. Some progress fast, some progress slow. But he did show progression in his last two minor league years, and that's what matters. And while you do bring up a good poin about his JUP numbers, you also don't say anything about his CAR numbers. Yes, he didn't have as many ABs, but 230 ABs is still a good enough sample size. His walk total did increase in JUP, but he's AB/BB ratio (8.14) was online with what he did the rest of his minor league career (R 1st year-6.97, 2nd-5.82, 3rd-9.04, A-8.97, AA-10.95, average of all years minus his JUP numbers-8.28). The most depressing thing looking at that is the decrease in the ratio in AA, but his AB/K numbers are only a little worse from AA then they were in JUP (Car-5, JUP-5.42). Here's another problem I have with your analysis, his minor league career OBP (since let's be honest, this is his main selling point) would need to remain fairly static for him to have value in the majors. He's not an efficient base-stealer, nor an efficient slugger, so to have any value as a starter, he'd still need to hang an OBP around .330 to have any redeeming qualities warranting 500 AB's a season. Considering that total would represent a mere .020 shaving off his minor league average, it's tough to look at him as a projectible major league starter. Now I do agree with you on this, that he needs a good OBP to be a league average starter, due to faults in his other game (Nobody can honestly expect him to be amazing out there in OF this year, he had make a couple of rookie mistakes in his short time up already. And it's not even that it's a rookie, it's that he's 23. His SB% deffinatly leaves a lot to be desired, and I do think that that would increase with experience...but wouldn't be for another couple of years. And ofcoarse no power, but excluding Carroll (He's same boat as De Aza in my eyes, waiting until he gets experience before calling his name or calling for his head), our real only option with power now is Reggie, and I doubt I even need to go there, and Ross, who has struggled against RHP). But it's actually about .03 shave off, not .02. The Baseball Cube (Which I assume you're using) is missing his first Rookie ball year, I'm using Minor Leage Splits. And I know that he deffinatly isn't a Pierre, but if you look at Pierre's OBP and SLG (.377 and .392), they aren't much ahead of De Aza's (.363 and .379). You can't really compare Pierre and De Aza yearly, because Pierre went to college. Obviously a big difference in .BAA, but also a big difference in BB. Pierre's drop off-.027 OBP, .022 SLG. Now I'm just using Pierre because a lot of people have said that he's essentially a weaker version of Pierre. I do think he could maintain around a .330-.340 OBP this year against RHP. Including LHP, I really don't know if he could...but again, with the assumption that Ross would be out there against LHP (I know Fredi said he wasn't going to platoon De Aza at the start of the year, but I'm sure a platoon would happen if De Aza struggled against LHP).
-
Marlins interested in Michael Barrett
Do you have any idea what you're saying?You said that because De Aza's a rookie, there's absolutely nothing that suggests he'll be below average.Ignore the career .266 minor league batting average, or the career that never really got above A ball except a brief stint. Ignore that he basically repeated A ball three times. Ignore that he never hit .300 in any full season in the minors.Ignore all that. Just pretend that his 5 games in the bigs are all that matter, and that the future is impossible to predict. And that because he's a rookie, he can't possibly be any worse than league average. First to preface, I am not saying that De Aza is going to be some amazing player. But 1) He didn't repeat the same level of A ball. He repeated Rookie ball three times, all years as a teenager so I wouldn't view that as that big of a deal. After moving up to A ball at 20, he's moved up a level every year (A+ at 21, AA at 22). I also wouldn't call his AA stint "brief", he essientially played the entire year there. 2) You of all people point to his .baa as to why he's going to be bad? Common man. Rather then looking at the combined stats from his R-ball years, why not look at what matters more - his past two years at A+ and AA? At Jupiter, he hit .286/.370/.394. At Carolina, he hit .278/.346/.374, and if you look at his righty splits (Which matters more, expecially if we run Ross out there against LHP), he hit .299/.367/.412. Again, I'm not saying he's going to be some amazing player. He's not our knight in shining arm that will sweep us off our feet when he gets back. And I have no problem at all if people don't have faith in him. But he could easily be league average, and I'd much rather see what he can do at this level before writing him off.
-
Marlins/White Sox Post game thoughts....
I thought Olivo was going to fall over on that one swing...I think it was the second pitch, maybe the third.
-
We need Elijah Dukes
Quite a difference between chemecial addictions, which says nothing about the person's character, and assaulting your wife or girlfriends on several occasions, multiple arrests for battery, and, you know, multiple death threats. It'd be one thing if he was 13. He'll be 23 in like a week, he's a man, not a boy. Getting a "second chance" my ass, he's had plenty of chances. If he checked himself into an anger management class and actually tried to be a better man, I'll give him credit then. But he's shown nothing but him going to be a punk for life.
-
Marlins interested in Michael Barrett
Yuck, Cubs want to move him because he sucks why would we want him? That happens with many players. Look at the trade for Kim. The Rockies thought he was garbage. Sometimes people just need a change of scenery. I am not saying Kim is the answer, just saying that is doing better over here. Well, the issue is is that he overexemplifies what's wrong with Olivo - bad deffense. Barrett is far and away the worst deffensive starting catcher in the league. Considering that our biggest problem this season has been our pitching, not our offense, I think downgrading our catcher deffensively would be counterproductive even though it would be an upgrade offensively.
-
We need Elijah Dukes
He came from a hard past and really needs to get away from tampa (where he was born area) and start fresh. Once a punk, always a punk. This isn't like the Mets-Milledge situation, where Milledge was just acting his age and upset members of the clubhouse with his 'unprofesional' attitude. The worst things he did was make a generic rap song and have sex with high school girls while he himself was in high school. A fresh start away from that is what Milledge needs. Dukes is going to be a criminal where ever he goes, a 'fresh start' isn't going to do sh*t for him. And I'd rather not sell out and give up morales for talent to better our chances of winning. I'd rather lose then sell out.
-
We need Elijah Dukes
I'd rather not be the Bengals of Baseball. Corey Patterson is falling quickly with the O's, he's in and out of their lineup now, and probably wouldn't cost much since he's a FA at the end of the season. Someone with a career OBP under .300 isn't exactly what I would want at the plate, but he's got a lot of speed and a good glove, and has some pop in his bat to atleast make up for his abismal OBP. Come on now. First of all, you don't become the Bengals of baseball by acquiring one player with a questionable past. If we have 3,4,5 Elijah Dukes, then I would be worried. One? Not so much. The talent level difference between Dukes and Patterson is not even close, plus Dukes is a cheap,long term answer that would both probably cost the same level of prospect. Corey Patterson is only a notch above a Reggie Abercrombie. I never said Dukes = Patterson, and Patterson is quite an upgrade over Abercrombie. Earlier in the season Patterson, would have costed too much, but he's fallen a lot in the O's FO. Considering he's in a contract year, I think he'd done very well here (I'm not saying great, but upgrade over what we are using). And Dukes, I'd rather not even have one. It's not like it's just a few instances...it was, what, a week ago that, upon finding out he got another girl pregnant (Which that alone I don't really care about), he threw a gatoraid bottle at her, which even if it wasn't that bad (although it must have been bad enough that the girl contacted the police), it shows that he'll likely never be able to control his anger and would just be problem after problem after problem. I'm not denying his skills, the guy is talented. But I'd rather not have any players on my team that I wouldn't be able to cheer for due to issues they have. I'm not one to turn a blind eye. I'm not expecting every player to be a choir boy, I realize that that's just not realistic. Everybody makes a few mistakes and that's one thing. It's another to have a guy who's just batshit insane. And as far as being liked by his teamates (You didn't say it but someone else in the thread did)...well, considering the fact that the Durham Bulls won't let Dukes back on their team, I do have to question that.
-
who goes down??
Reggie atleast gives us speed off the bench. Borchard is a LOT better hitter, but it's always useful to have a guy with speed there. Just look at today's game, if Carroll gets a single there we tie the game (not a hate on Carroll, just sayin'). If we didn't have Abercrombie, we'd have to get more then a single by Carroll to be able to score. Given the option with how our bench is currently set up, I'd rather have Abercrombie then Borchard. But ofcoarse, Borchard doesn't have options, so no problem at all with Abercrombie getting the knife.
-
who goes down??
And Borch is out of options
-
We need Elijah Dukes
I'd rather not be the Bengals of Baseball. Corey Patterson is falling quickly with the O's, he's in and out of their lineup now, and probably wouldn't cost much since he's a FA at the end of the season. Someone with a career OBP under .300 isn't exactly what I would want at the plate, but he's got a lot of speed and a good glove, and has some pop in his bat to atleast make up for his abismal OBP.
-
6/17/07: Marlins @ Royals
How did Carroll look? Did he atleast hit the ball hard?
-
6/17/07: Marlins @ Royals
There they go again "Amahzaga" It's Am-eh-zaga Haha, last year during a Cardinal game...I had MLB.TV last year, and it wasn't on TV here so I was watching it on there, and it was the Card's FSN crew. When Amezaga came up to bat, the PBP guy couldn't say his name, he kept starting it it "Amah...Amah...Amah", but couldn't figure out how to finish it. Then the color guy chimed it, all matter-of-factly, with "It's Amahzaga". Made me giggle
-
Brett Carroll Called Up
Small sample size v.s. the hundreds and hundreds of ABs from his 6 previous years of playing pro ball. Law of averages, he'll work his way back up from it.
-
Brett Carroll Called Up
I have no idea why you would want to bench Hammer v.s. Lefties, he absolutely crushes them. Really, his only options are getting the CF job, Hermida continue to struggle, or Hammer gets injured. How the hell did he go from day to day injury to 60 day Dl. In Todays MLB that shouldn't happen. It happens all the time in all sports, it's nothing worth making a conspiracy theory out of. Hell, just look at the NBA. You here all the time of a player being out day to day with an ankle sprain, and then having to miss months (thanks for screwing David Lee out of the 6th man and most improved player awards :thumbdown ). Ankle sprains are hard to tell. The fact that they missed it being a fracture is "ehhhhh" but common, no reason to starting coming up with conspiracys about it.
-
Brett Carroll Called Up
He might just be bench material instead of starting though. Good time to be called up though, since he should get some starts atleast somewhere in the OF with us DHing at the time being. Is De Aza's 60 retroactive, or will he not be able to come off for another 60 days?
-
6/16/07: Marlins @ Royals
Olivo's always done well against LHP.
-
How much longer will the Marlins show patience?
I don't even see why you guys are bothering, it's clear you're not going to change his mind regardless of the facts you throw out.
-
The Defense
Hammer isn't an above average defender...he's improved a lot, I'll give him credit for that, he's leaps and bounds ahead of where he was last year. But he's not above average. Ramirez has shown good range and the potential to be avery very good defender. The problem is he has a lot of brain lapses and f***s up a lot of plays. If he focuses more, we have a GG-calibur shortstop right there. And Cabrera has shown last year that he can be a good fielder, and he has done pretty fine since that one stretch when he was flat out horrible. Still muck ups, but nothing like that one stretch when if he actually managed to field a ball, he threw it into the stands. If/when he skims down, he'll do well I'd also call Uggla an average defender. And really, what would you want to replace those guys with? I've been frustrated with our deffense, but fact remains we don't have many options. The only real change we could (should) make is have Treanor start against RHP. We've done better since that one stretch of having like 3+ errors every game.
-
Benches Clear In Wrigley
Just saw the replay on WPN...looked like Lee was gonna get his ass kicked if Giles didn't tackle Young.
- Cubs fans are morons
-
The Jones debate
I personally dont see what Stark said was so bad. Jones is still good in his opinion, just not what he once was 10 years and 1000 big macs ago. I think that's the main problem with people's perception of overrated; most people can't understand that a player can be overrated, but can still be a very very good player.
-
Post Game thoughts... (June 15th)
A ground ball pitcher pitching to the best batter in the lineup with runners on second and third, with a fast runner on third...meaning you'd have to play the infield in (creating more holes) and even if you can field the ball, it's not a guarentee to get the guy at home since he has speed Or set up what would be an easy double play that would end the inning if the ground ball doesn't find the whole by pitching to a slow ass guy who has a .723 OPS on the year with a ground ball pitcher on the mound. And since you like to quote RISP, Mark Teahen OPS is nearly .230 points higher then Sweeney's with RISP this year, in only a 4 AB difference.