Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Current NL Allstar vote leaders

Featured Replies

God, I hate Met fans. They have a player in the top five in almost every category. How the hell is Beltran beating Soriano?

Fortunately the fan vote only affects who gets to start, so it doesnt make a difference if a player gets voted 2 or 22.

 

Of course Paul Lo Duca is in line to start at catcher, and he has an OPS of .701. Thats 49 points lower than our own Miguel Olivo :) There are a whopping 10 NL catchers with at least 100 ABs who have a higher OPS than Lo Duca. Of course there is more to being a catcher than just hitting, things like throwing out baserunners counts too. Of course Lo Duca is in the bottom half at that too :)

Eventually voting will be taken away from the fans again. I look forward to that day.

 

 

Me too. The All-Star game should be based on talent not popularity.

Somebody wanna start complaining about the Cards fans this time around? It's balancing out.. except the Mets fans..

 

I'm kidding but trust me while you have the best record in the NL.. it's not always best to vote your stars into the All-Star game as one team.. trust me.. it never works with the Cards :lol

 

And yes unless some drastic happens Id expect Albert to play.. he could return this week!

 

My biggest beef isnt the voting crap, it's the crap result of the ASG :banghead

Still no Uggla or Phillips even in the Top 5 of voting.

 

joke

Seriously bro. BP and Uggla def deserve some recognition here in a category that is already weak behind Utley and Kent.

 

So basically we get to watch a subway series all star game? Wonderful. At least they will have some decency to allow Jason Bay to represent Pittsburgh in there home stadium.

God, I hate Met fans. They have a player in the top five in almost every category. How the hell is Beltran beating Soriano?

 

 

Reyes and LoDuca are questionable. Wright and Beltran deserve their spots.

 

Wright is having an amazing season at the plate, argue all you want for Miggy but Wright has more homers, rbis, a higher SLG%, and is better in the field.

 

Beltran deserves to start, whether he finishes first or second in the voting doesn't really matter. They'll both start.

God, I hate Met fans. They have a player in the top five in almost every category. How the hell is Beltran beating Soriano?

 

 

Reyes and LoDuca are questionable. Wright and Beltran deserve their spots.

 

Wright is having an amazing season at the plate, argue all you want for Miggy but Wright has more homers, rbis, a higher SLG%, and is better in the field.

 

Beltran deserves to start, whether he finishes first or second in the voting doesn't really matter. They'll both start. Wright is doing it in a dangerous lineup that is respected. Miguel can't help it if he is only getting junk thrown at him, and yet is still geting on base at a high rate. RBIs are really meaningless. That doesn't mean he doesn't deserve a spot. In fact I believe he and Miguel should be the third basemen no questions asked.

 

Wow I just realized something. We may have the best third basemen division in the league:

 

Miguel Cabrera

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman

Chipper Jones

 

 

Wow. All four of those guys are some of the best hitters in the game right now and all are solid to above average defensively.

God, I hate Met fans. They have a player in the top five in almost every category. How the hell is Beltran beating Soriano?

 

 

Reyes and LoDuca are questionable. Wright and Beltran deserve their spots.

 

Wright is having an amazing season at the plate, argue all you want for Miggy but Wright has more homers, rbis, a higher SLG%, and is better in the field.

 

Beltran deserves to start, whether he finishes first or second in the voting doesn't really matter. They'll both start. Wright is doing it in a dangerous lineup that is respected. Miguel can't help it if he is only getting junk thrown at him, and yet is still geting on base at a high rate. RBIs are really meaningless. That doesn't mean he doesn't deserve a spot. In fact I believe he and Miguel should be the third basemen no questions asked.

 

Wow I just realized something. We may have the best third basemen division in the league:

 

Miguel Cabrera

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman

Chipper Jones

 

 

Wow. All four of those guys are some of the best hitters in the game right now and all are solid to above average defensively.

 

Not quite sure I get that, Wright plays in a good line-ups so his lead in RBIs and HRs don't really matter -- but Cabs is getting pitched around, so shouldn't his OBP and BA be looked in the same light? They're both tremendous players and difference between them is so small that both are deserving to play and both will. I don't think you can really complain that Wright doesn't deserve to start. Same goes for Cabs.

God, I hate Met fans. They have a player in the top five in almost every category. How the hell is Beltran beating Soriano?

 

 

Reyes and LoDuca are questionable. Wright and Beltran deserve their spots.

 

Wright is having an amazing season at the plate, argue all you want for Miggy but Wright has more homers, rbis, a higher SLG%, and is better in the field.

 

Beltran deserves to start, whether he finishes first or second in the voting doesn't really matter. They'll both start. Wright is doing it in a dangerous lineup that is respected. Miguel can't help it if he is only getting junk thrown at him, and yet is still geting on base at a high rate. RBIs are really meaningless. That doesn't mean he doesn't deserve a spot. In fact I believe he and Miguel should be the third basemen no questions asked.

 

Wow I just realized something. We may have the best third basemen division in the league:

 

Miguel Cabrera

David Wright

Ryan Zimmerman

Chipper Jones

 

 

Wow. All four of those guys are some of the best hitters in the game right now and all are solid to above average defensively.

 

Not quite sure I get that, Wright plays in a good line-ups so his lead in RBIs and HRs don't really matter -- but Cabs is getting pitched around, so shouldn't his OBP and BA be looked in the same light? They're both tremendous players and difference between them is so small that both are deserving to play and both will. I don't think you can really complain that Wright doesn't deserve to start. Same goes for Cabs. I think I wasn't clear enough. I said I wouldn't have a problem with Wright starting. But I guess one might have read that as I would have problem with him starting. But I was just debating a real asinine point about how RBIs are rather meaningless as are the homers because Miguel doesn't have the same protection that Wright has (Respect wise). Though, the way the Marlins are hitting right now that will change.

It's official, fans should NOT be making up the All Star game. MLB Officials should be judging this again.

 

It's a COMPLETE JOKE when a has-been like Biggio (No Offence to any biggio fans) (278 BA, 342 OBP, 6 HR's 27 RBI's) is in second place of the ballot while Uggla is not even in sight :plain

I wouldn't mind if fans get to vote, but it is ridiculous that each fan gets 25 votes or something.

 

If they want the fans to vote, they should be able to go to the stadium and pick up one ballot and mail it in. One ballot per home address... you know?

 

But I still prefer that the Players and coaches, and maybe the media, should vote.

 

Stop this damn High schoolish popularity contest and let the guys putting up numbers go!

My team as of today:

 

C - Michael Barrett, Cubs

1B - Albert Pujols, Cardinals (Nomar Garciaparra, Dodgers)

2B - Dan Uggla, Marlins

SS - Edgar Renteria, Braves

3B - David Wright, Mets

LF - Matt Holliday, Rockies

CF - Carlos Beltran, Mets

RF - Bobby Abreu, Phillies

My team as of today:

 

C - Michael Barrett, Cubs

1B - Albert Pujols, Cardinals (Nomar Garciaparra, Dodgers)

2B - Dan Uggla, Marlins

SS - Edgar Renteria, Braves

3B - David Wright, Mets

LF - Matt Holliday, Rockies

CF - Carlos Beltran, Mets

RF - Bobby Abreu, Phillies

 

For me, I would replace Rent with Exkstein, he has been on a pretty good tear and has a higher BA from what I remember. Also I would swap Barret with McCann

My team as of today:

 

C - Michael Barrett, Cubs

1B - Albert Pujols, Cardinals (Nomar Garciaparra, Dodgers)

2B - Dan Uggla, Marlins

SS - Edgar Renteria, Braves

3B - David Wright, Mets

LF - Matt Holliday, Rockies

CF - Carlos Beltran, Mets

RF - Bobby Abreu, Phillies

 

 

I'm partially a Cubs fan, and while the offensive production and fighting ability they get from the catcher position is nice, Barrett's lack of any defensive ability makes me hesitate to put him on the ballot. IMO, the catcher position is about defense more than offense and Barrett is probably the worst in the league at gunning runners.

Voting through June 26

 

First Base

1. Albert Pujols, Cardinals, 2,206,409

2. Carlos Delgado, Mets, 946,093

3. Nomar Garciaparra, Dodgers, 694,489

4. Sean Casey, Pirates, 675,477

5. Lance Berkman, Astros, 665,882

 

Second Base

1. Chase Utley, Phillies, 1,236,143

2. Craig Biggio, Astros, 1,097,119

3. Jose Castillo, Pirates, 1,051,990

4. Jeff Kent, Dodgers, 483,513

5. Marcus Giles, Braves, 417,997

 

Third Base

1. David Wright, Mets, 1,386,584

2. Scott Rolen, Cardinals, 1,041,250

3. Morgan Ensberg, Astros, 687,229

4. Freddy Sanchez, Pirates, 597,249

5. Miguel Cabrera, Marlins, 561,601

 

Shortstop

1. Jose Reyes, Mets, 1,068,105

2. Jack Wilson, Pirates, 986,117

3. David Eckstein, Cardinals, 875,209

4. Edgar Renteria, Braves, 784,030

5. Jimmy Rollins, Phillies, 624,538

 

Catcher

1. Paul Lo Duca, Mets, 1,281,767

2. Mike Piazza, Padres, 880,948

3. Brad Ausmus, Astros, 724,172

4. Yadier Molina, Cardinals, 692,302

5. Brian McCann, Braves, 516,659

 

Outfield

1. Jason Bay, Pirates, 1,706,105

2. Carlos Beltran, Mets, 1,537,849

3. Alfonso Soriano, Nationals, 1,484,845

4. Ken Griffey Jr., Reds, 1,366,906

5. Andruw Jones, Braves, 1,250,129

6. Jim Edmonds, Cardinals, 863,775

7. Bobby Abreu, Phillies, 780,960

8. Carlos Lee, Brewers, 668,581

9. Barry Bonds, Giants, 639,755

10. Aaron Rowand, Phillies, 602,813

11. Adam Dunn, Reds, 479,532

12. Cliff Floyd, Mets, 461,058

13. Xavier Nady, Mets, 459,315

14. Willy Taveras, Astros, 432,914

15. Matt Holliday, Rockies, 416,230

That's a lot of Pirates.

Eventually voting will be taken away from the fans again. I look forward to that day.

 

:thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup

My team as of today:

 

C - Michael Barrett, Cubs

1B - Albert Pujols, Cardinals (Nomar Garciaparra, Dodgers)

2B - Dan Uggla, Marlins

SS - Edgar Renteria, Braves

3B - David Wright, Mets

LF - Matt Holliday, Rockies

CF - Carlos Beltran, Mets

RF - Bobby Abreu, Phillies

 

I like this list aswell. Abreu really doesn't jump out at me but at the same time I cannot think of any RF off the top of my head more deserving. That list is good and look Met fans, it even has TWO NY Met's on it. Reyes' recent surge at the plate will def land him that starting spot in my eyes.

 

The ASG is such a pathetic waste of time. If they are not going to take voting away from the fans then wipe out the All Star game and let the players take a week vacation and hang with family.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.