Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Frisaro mentions Griffey...

Featured Replies

I wouldn't mind Griffey in LF, but I can't imagine that happening for an acceptable price. He would be a (slight) all around improvement over the current in-house options.

 

As someone else said, if we're going this route, I'd rather sign Bonds, who will need more rest and play worse defense, but probably give us an OBP around or over 450 at minimum.

If Griffey wasn't still a good defensive player, no team would consider playing him in centerfield. Nonetheless during a playoff run.

 

Not sure what that's saying... The Rays threw Ben Zobrist in RF in the playoffs when he never played there in his life.

 

You're really reaching, aren't you?

 

Not as much as you by suggesting Griffey is still a good defensive outfielder

Erick senor, it is not like Hermida would be given away.

 

 

So we're trading a 24 year old OF'er who had an OPS+ of 125 as a 23 year old to get older and worse at the position? Stop thinking about the name...Griffey is not good anymore.

 

Not to mention we'd be trading away Hermida to not get max value in return b/c Hermida's coming off an off year...or better yet, he's coming off a year where he struggled to hit in a football stadium. Outside of the sh*tty stadium, Hermida had an .851 .OPS on the road. But he's terrible. :rolleyes: Lets get Griffey who's only getting older, and has had a nice history of injuries...and can barely produce average #'s nowadays playing a good portion of his games in hitters' parks.

 

Great idea.

If Hermida's off year is an issue the Marlins could package him.The Marlins have already shown in midseason that they are willing to trade Hermida, and will if they like what they get back.

 

On top of the return in a Hermida trade, the Marlins have outfield prospect options in the minors for the post Griffey era.

 

 

Hermida was in rumors...for Manny Ramirez, during a playoff run. It's a little different now, no?

 

 

The Marlins wanted to trade Hermida for only half a season of Manny Ramirez.Yeah that really shows how valuable and untouchable Hermida is.

 

I'm on the fence when it comes to keeping or trading Jeremy. But I do lean more towards trade if we can get something good in return. However, after all the previous trade talks and the benching of him last season, I would think the FO and coaches are leaning far more towards the trade idea. It would actually be more of a surprise to me if he were on the team come ST because of that.

 

As far as Junior... I pass. The way I read that article is that the team may be interested in him in a Gonzo type role and Griffey dosen't seem willing to accept that.

it would put people in the seats.

 

Griffey WILL NOT draw fans to the stadium.

 

Point in case: When he hit #600 here, we drew 16,000 people.

 

Six.Teen. Thousand. People.

 

C'mon folks, if only 16k people show up to witness a historical moment in baseball history, what makes you think they will show up to watch him roam in the outfield for 81 "normal" games?

 

I think if he were a Marlin, that 16,000 would have doubled.

 

Just me.

 

Yep. Just you. But prove me wrong by showing where signing any established name has drastically changed our attendance.

it would put people in the seats.

 

Griffey WILL NOT draw fans to the stadium.

 

Point in case: When he hit #600 here, we drew 16,000 people.

 

Six.Teen. Thousand. People.

 

C'mon folks, if only 16k people show up to witness a historical moment in baseball history, what makes you think they will show up to watch him roam in the outfield for 81 "normal" games?

 

I think if he were a Marlin, that 16,000 would have doubled.

 

Just me.

 

Why though? What past instances can you give to back up this claim?

 

We've had such stars as Pudge Rodriguez, Carlos Delgado, Mike Piazza (lol), and Hanley Ramirez and we STILL draw crap. We could resurrect Babe Ruth himself , stick a Marlins uniform on him and nobody would show up.

 

Were any of those arguably the best player in the history of the game? Were any of those players even close to reaching any major milestone in a Marlin uniform, nonetheless 600 homeruns?

 

Marlins fans have shown that they show up... when something matters. But if that thing that matters doesn't help their team, do you think they're going to show? C'mon...

 

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

I think Manny would've spiked attendance by getting us into the playoffs.

 

As for Hermida, he's not coming off of an "off-year", he has simply had an off-career. A career OPS below 800 and he's not exactly a defensive wiz either.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

I think Manny would've spiked attendance by getting us into the playoffs.

 

As for Hermida, he's not coming off of an "off-year", he has simply had an off-career. A career OPS below 800 and he's not exactly a defensive wiz either.

 

Considering he had a .870 OPS just one year prior, you could argue it was an off-year for him.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

I think Manny would've spiked attendance by getting us into the playoffs.

 

As for Hermida, he's not coming off of an "off-year", he has simply had an off-career. A career OPS below 800 and he's not exactly a defensive wiz either.

 

Considering he had a .870 OPS just one year prior, you could argue it was an off-year for him.

I agree, and just because he had a off season doesn't mean we should trade him for a player that is at his end of his career.

If Griffey wasn't still a good defensive player, no team would consider playing him in centerfield. Nonetheless during a playoff run.

 

By that same logic, Derek Jeter is the best defensive SS in the game. Even though he is literally the worst defensive player in the game with how much damage he does to the Yankees at such an important position.

 

Griffey was one of if not the worst RFers this past season with a -17. The last time he played CF full time, he was the worst CFer at -29. And it's been two years since then.

Love Girffey, wanted Griffey the season before we traded Cabrera and trell, but with the direction the team is headed, I think we need to stick to the youth movement.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

I think Manny would've spiked attendance by getting us into the playoffs.

 

As for Hermida, he's not coming off of an "off-year", he has simply had an off-career. A career OPS below 800 and he's not exactly a defensive wiz either.

 

Considering he had a .870 OPS just one year prior, you could argue it was an off-year for him.

And all of us who actually watched this team play in 2007 know that it was basically all the result of an absurd second half. Pre-All Star break 2007, his OPS was his typical 744. Post ASB his OPS was 956. Now if you want to sit here and expect him to be this 900+ OPS hitter that he was for 2? months, I would say that you should expect dissapointment. I will expect (far more reasonably I think) that he will generally continue to hit an OPS around 750, maybe at times close to 800, as he has the entire rest of the time he's been in the majors.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

I think Manny would've spiked attendance by getting us into the playoffs.

 

As for Hermida, he's not coming off of an "off-year", he has simply had an off-career. A career OPS below 800 and he's not exactly a defensive wiz either.

 

Considering he had a .870 OPS just one year prior, you could argue it was an off-year for him.

And all of us who actually watched this team play in 2007 know that it was basically all the result of an absurd second half. Pre-All Star break 2007, his OPS was his typical 744. Post ASB his OPS was 956. Now if you want to sit here and expect him to be this 900+ OPS hitter that he was for 2? months, I would say that you should expect dissapointment. I will expect (far more reasonably I think) that he will generally continue to hit an OPS around 750, maybe at times close to 800, as he has the entire rest of the time he's been in the majors.

 

You're hot for a week.

 

Not 3 months.

 

I think Hermida's second half in '07 demonstrated his abilities. I'm confident he will live up to what he is capable of...

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

 

That 4 infielders thing was about all they talked about on TV. I didn't see many of the games at that home stand, but the couple I did it was mentioned several times each game. Seeing we have such a TV preferred fan base.................

 

I still doubt Manny would have okayed a trade here. Just dosen't make sense. But I would still downsize that estimate to a few games.

 

You want to discuss the play off thing?? Okay. The first half of the season we were in 1st place or very near it. Even hosted a team that was tied with us for the best record in the majors. Talk was all over radio and TV how this team was in serious play off contention. We actually didn't slip out of "serious" contention til that dismal month of August, and then about half way through it. Didn't help attendance one bit. And looking at our history, even making the play offs wouldn't have helped. Until the play offs actually started. Of course then everyone you talk to would have been saying they were regulars at the ball park all season. This is a "place to be seen" type fan base. No well known player, no matter how good, is going to change that.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

 

That 4 infielders thing was about all they talked about on TV. I didn't see many of the games at that home stand, but the couple I did it was mentioned several times each game. Seeing we have such a TV preferred fan base.................

 

I still doubt Manny would have okayed a trade here. Just dosen't make sense. But I would still downsize that estimate to a few games.

 

You want to discuss the play off thing?? Okay. The first half of the season we were in 1st place or very near it. Even hosted a team that was tied with us for the best record in the majors. Talk was all over radio and TV how this team was in serious play off contention. We actually didn't slip out of "serious" contention til that dismal month of August, and then about half way through it. Didn't help attendance one bit. And looking at our history, even making the play offs wouldn't have helped. Until the play offs actually started. Of course then everyone you talk to would have been saying they were regulars at the ball park all season. This is a "place to be seen" type fan base. No well known player, no matter how good, is going to change that.

The only place they talked about the 4 infielder thing was on the Marlins own broadcast. ESPN barely mentioned it, local news and newspapers didn't even think about it.

 

And when we were in the lead at the beginning of the stadium, there was nothing on the media talking about our "serious playoff contention". It was all about how the Marlins couldn't keep the homers up and were going to fall back to Earth.

You're hot for a week.

 

Not 3 months.

 

I think Hermida's second half in '07 demonstrated his abilities. I'm confident he will live up to what he is capable of...

When it's only 3 months in a span of 3 seasons, yes, it is just getting hot. Players do get hot for more than a week or even a month. Just like some players get cold for inordinate amounts of time. I know everyone here couldn't understand that in 05 when Mike Lowell had an off year and everyone was sure he was done...What happens after another year with a 750ish OPS for Hermida? Then he's just 25? Or 26? At what point do you say that a guy who usually doesn't hit well year after year (regardless of what he may be capable of) and whose defense looks lazy needs to go? How many seasons? At what age? He's had a starting job in RF for 3 years, and look at the whole of what he's done.

Interesting theory. Let's put it to the test.

 

4 infielders going for the all time record in HRs while the team is in contention for the play offs, in the final homestand of the season, against a division rival. Can't fill your criteria much better than that. How did that work out?? Good thing there are alot of Phillies fans here and there was a Saturday night concert to attend. But Marlins fans actually at the games?? C'mon...

That 4 infielders thing wasn't played up by anyone. Also, we weren't in contention for the playoffs as much as we were longshots. That said, I don't buy that Manny would have spiked attendance for more than a few weeks.

 

That 4 infielders thing was about all they talked about on TV. I didn't see many of the games at that home stand, but the couple I did it was mentioned several times each game. Seeing we have such a TV preferred fan base.................

 

I still doubt Manny would have okayed a trade here. Just dosen't make sense. But I would still downsize that estimate to a few games.

 

You want to discuss the play off thing?? Okay. The first half of the season we were in 1st place or very near it. Even hosted a team that was tied with us for the best record in the majors. Talk was all over radio and TV how this team was in serious play off contention. We actually didn't slip out of "serious" contention til that dismal month of August, and then about half way through it. Didn't help attendance one bit. And looking at our history, even making the play offs wouldn't have helped. Until the play offs actually started. Of course then everyone you talk to would have been saying they were regulars at the ball park all season. This is a "place to be seen" type fan base. No well known player, no matter how good, is going to change that.

The only place they talked about the 4 infielder thing was on the Marlins own broadcast. ESPN barely mentioned it, local news and newspapers didn't even think about it.

 

And when we were in the lead at the beginning of the stadium, there was nothing on the media talking about our "serious playoff contention". It was all about how the Marlins couldn't keep the homers up and were going to fall back to Earth.

 

You are missing the point. Yes, it was on the Marlins own broadcast, alot. Which is where we are supposed to be drawing actual attendance from. I seriously doubt people from other parts of the country are going to flock to South Florida to watch our IFers make history just because ESPN is talking alot about them, or because the locals were heavily talking about "serious play off contenders" until the final week or two of August, and then after that saying we are still in it. We supposedly have one of the highest ranked TV audiences in the majors. That's local TV. Talking big there is supposed to intrigue the local fan base enough to actually get off their butts and make the short trip to the ball park to watch their team make history. Heavy emphasis on "supposed to." It didn't. That's what this little discussion of ours is about. People didn't show up for Griffey's historic bomb but would if it was a Marlin doing it. Well, we made some history, it was force fed to the locals that are supposed to be interested in the Marlins, and it made no difference at the gates.

You're hot for a week.

 

Not 3 months.

 

I think Hermida's second half in '07 demonstrated his abilities. I'm confident he will live up to what he is capable of...

When it's only 3 months in a span of 3 seasons, yes, it is just getting hot. Players do get hot for more than a week or even a month. Just like some players get cold for inordinate amounts of time. I know everyone here couldn't understand that in 05 when Mike Lowell had an off year and everyone was sure he was done...What happens after another year with a 750ish OPS for Hermida? Then he's just 25? Or 26? At what point do you say that a guy who usually doesn't hit well year after year (regardless of what he may be capable of) and whose defense looks lazy needs to go? How many seasons? At what age? He's had a starting job in RF for 3 years, and look at the whole of what he's done.

 

So why can't Hermida have been cold all of last year? Why was Lowell just really cold but actually a good player?

I know everyone is saying he's had 3 full seasons, but one of those "full" seasons included 300 AB as a 22-year-old.

He'll be 25 to start this season; many players have not even come to the bigs yet by 25.

So, yes, 2007 could've been an incredible hot streak far above and beyond his ability; but, 2008 could easily have been a cold streak, way below his ability.

To trade a player, still under team control at age 24, while his value is probably the lowest it's ever been is silly.

2005 21 CAR SOU AA FLA 118 386 77 113 29 2 18 63 111 89 .293 .457 .518 .975 23 2 92%

 

http://minors.baseball-reference.com/players.cgi?pid=6515

 

Maybe he was just insanely hot that year, too, but I'm willing to take one more years worth of chances. Remember, any prospect you might get for him could just as easily be a "bust" like Jeremy.

 

FWIW, what happened to those stolen bases? He had a ton and at a very high percentage throughout the minors.

Hermida's problems are of his own making but not necessarily in his control.

 

The fear that if we traded him he might return a player who ultimately failed too is a red herring.

 

The fear that if we traded him and he blossomed into the player everyone expected we would have seller's remorse is something every team has to weigh every time they make a trade. It isn't exclusive to this situation.

 

If the Marlins are going to make a run in 2009 you have to honestly ask yourself are you willing to allow Hermida to flounder again and hold back that effort just so he has one more opportunity? The answer has to be no.

 

If he can produce he should be here, if he can't then the franchise can't wait any longer. Age has nothing to do with it. Nothing at all. Nor at this point does anything he did in the minors matter. The MB website is littered with thousands of posts about minor league players who were touted as having tremendous major league potential and eventually were proven to be AAAA players.

 

To me it's in the hands of the front office. They know what they are doing. I live with whatever their decision is because i know it will be more informed than any I can make.

 

No one here is against Hermida succeeding or hoping he fails. What I think we all share is a desire to be playing in October again and if that means a few of our current players wind up being thrown under bus, regardless of age, pedigree, potential or anything else, so be it.

To me it's in the hands of the front office. They know what they are doing. I live with whatever their decision is because i know it will be more informed than any I can make.

 

I hate this kind of talk. So no matter what happens, it's the right move because the people in the front office may (or may not) be more informed than us?

You're hot for a week.

 

Not 3 months.

 

I think Hermida's second half in '07 demonstrated his abilities. I'm confident he will live up to what he is capable of...

When it's only 3 months in a span of 3 seasons, yes, it is just getting hot. Players do get hot for more than a week or even a month. Just like some players get cold for inordinate amounts of time. I know everyone here couldn't understand that in 05 when Mike Lowell had an off year and everyone was sure he was done...What happens after another year with a 750ish OPS for Hermida? Then he's just 25? Or 26? At what point do you say that a guy who usually doesn't hit well year after year (regardless of what he may be capable of) and whose defense looks lazy needs to go? How many seasons? At what age? He's had a starting job in RF for 3 years, and look at the whole of what he's done.

 

So why can't Hermida have been cold all of last year? Why was Lowell just really cold but actually a good player?

I know everyone is saying he's had 3 full seasons, but one of those "full" seasons included 300 AB as a 22-year-old.

He'll be 25 to start this season; many players have not even come to the bigs yet by 25.

So, yes, 2007 could've been an incredible hot streak far above and beyond his ability; but, 2008 could easily have been a cold streak, way below his ability.

To trade a player, still under team control at age 24, while his value is probably the lowest it's ever been is silly.

2005 21 CAR SOU AA FLA 118 386 77 113 29 2 18 63 111 89 .293 .457 .518 .975 23 2 92%

 

http://minors.baseball-reference.com/players.cgi?pid=6515

 

Maybe he was just insanely hot that year, too, but I'm willing to take one more years worth of chances. Remember, any prospect you might get for him could just as easily be a "bust" like Jeremy.

 

FWIW, what happened to those stolen bases? He had a ton and at a very high percentage throughout the minors.

The problem is that to believe that 2008 was a cold streak, you have to believe that so was the rest of his MLB career, so all of 2006 and the first half of 2007. You can complain about the sample size in 2006 and that it's not a fair comparison, but I think if anything it's also idicative of the problem he has as far as durability. I also think it's disingenuous to want to disregard a sample size of 300+ ABs while your only evidence that he is "that good" is a span of 256 ABs after the ASB in 2007 where Hermida had a 956 OPS.

 

If you want to compare him to Mike Lowell? Ok, Mike Lowell had an OPS over 800 the 3 years before 2005, 4 of the 5 years before that, and it was over 860 in the last two (2003 & 2004). Just look at his career numbers and you see that 2005 is the year that didn't fit, it wasn't that he had "overperformed" or simply been hot for the last 5 years. Mike Lowell also had the added factor of being a Gold Glove defender, whereas Hermida is...well...not.

 

Please don't make an excuse out of his age. Everyone though he was ready in 2006, and he wasn't. Maybe he will be great when he's 29 or 30, I don't know. But I don't have any confidence that he will be ready next season and I imagine the FO shares that feeling.

 

Again, if 2008 was a cold streak then so was 2006 and the first half of 2007 (where he maintained a 744 OPS). So it's not just as easy to believe that, at least not for me.

 

It's also not silly to trade a young player when his trade value is lowest if you only expect it to get lower. And while you may be willing to take a chance, I don't think now is the time for second and third chances. This team had nine blown saves and finished about 8 games back of the WS champions. This team should expect to compete next year, and if you're playing to win, you can't afford to just commit to give a guy who keeps dissapointing another chance when you have options that are possibly better.

 

And for your question on his SB numbers, I would guess that he became a less inclined to run (or the coaching staff less inclined to send him) after he's been on and off the DL since 2006 started.

It's much easier to steal bases in the minors and many times the catchers are instructed to not even throw down. That and pitchers are so inclined to work on their stuff, they rarely hold baserunners on.

That's why you keep Hermida, Willingham, Ross, and Maybin and let them fight for playing time. It also provides a strong bench option.

You're hot for a week.

 

Not 3 months.

 

I think Hermida's second half in '07 demonstrated his abilities. I'm confident he will live up to what he is capable of...

When it's only 3 months in a span of 3 seasons, yes, it is just getting hot. Players do get hot for more than a week or even a month. Just like some players get cold for inordinate amounts of time. I know everyone here couldn't understand that in 05 when Mike Lowell had an off year and everyone was sure he was done...What happens after another year with a 750ish OPS for Hermida? Then he's just 25? Or 26? At what point do you say that a guy who usually doesn't hit well year after year (regardless of what he may be capable of) and whose defense looks lazy needs to go? How many seasons? At what age? He's had a starting job in RF for 3 years, and look at the whole of what he's done.

 

So why can't Hermida have been cold all of last year? Why was Lowell just really cold but actually a good player?

I know everyone is saying he's had 3 full seasons, but one of those "full" seasons included 300 AB as a 22-year-old.

He'll be 25 to start this season; many players have not even come to the bigs yet by 25.

So, yes, 2007 could've been an incredible hot streak far above and beyond his ability; but, 2008 could easily have been a cold streak, way below his ability.

To trade a player, still under team control at age 24, while his value is probably the lowest it's ever been is silly.

2005 21 CAR SOU AA FLA 118 386 77 113 29 2 18 63 111 89 .293 .457 .518 .975 23 2 92%

 

http://minors.baseball-reference.com/players.cgi?pid=6515

 

Maybe he was just insanely hot that year, too, but I'm willing to take one more years worth of chances. Remember, any prospect you might get for him could just as easily be a "bust" like Jeremy.

 

FWIW, what happened to those stolen bases? He had a ton and at a very high percentage throughout the minors.

The problem is that to believe that 2008 was a cold streak, you have to believe that so was the rest of his MLB career, so all of 2006 and the first half of 2007. You can complain about the sample size in 2006 and that it's not a fair comparison, but I think if anything it's also idicative of the problem he has as far as durability. I also think it's disingenuous to want to disregard a sample size of 300+ ABs while your only evidence that he is "that good" is a span of 256 ABs after the ASB in 2007 where Hermida had a 956 OPS.

 

If you want to compare him to Mike Lowell? Ok, Mike Lowell had an OPS over 800 the 3 years before 2005, 4 of the 5 years before that, and it was over 860 in the last two (2003 & 2004). Just look at his career numbers and you see that 2005 is the year that didn't fit, it wasn't that he had "overperformed" or simply been hot for the last 5 years. Mike Lowell also had the added factor of being a Gold Glove defender, whereas Hermida is...well...not.

 

Please don't make an excuse out of his age. Everyone though he was ready in 2006, and he wasn't. Maybe he will be great when he's 29 or 30, I don't know. But I don't have any confidence that he will be ready next season and I imagine the FO shares that feeling.

 

Again, if 2008 was a cold streak then so was 2006 and the first half of 2007 (where he maintained a 744 OPS). So it's not just as easy to believe that, at least not for me.

 

It's also not silly to trade a young player when his trade value is lowest if you only expect it to get lower. And while you may be willing to take a chance, I don't think now is the time for second and third chances. This team had nine blown saves and finished about 8 games back of the WS champions. This team should expect to compete next year, and if you're playing to win, you can't afford to just commit to give a guy who keeps dissapointing another chance when you have options that are possibly better.

 

And for your question on his SB numbers, I would guess that he became a less inclined to run (or the coaching staff less inclined to send him) after he's been on and off the DL since 2006 started.

 

I agree that durability is a problem of Hermida's; Hammer certainly has durability problems, as well.

With that comment about him not being ready, you proved my point. He wasn't ready at age 22. They rushed him to the bigs, and so I don't think it's fair to count a rough year for a 22-year old against ML pitching against the kid.

I think it's much more fair to look at 2007 & 2008 to judge his realistic performance.

I wasn't trying to compare him to Mike Lowell overall, just using your point that people can be either hot or cold for extended periods.

In my mind, he only disappointed one time, last year. But I suppose we just have to agree to disagree on that point. But if you really want to compare, Mike Lowell only had 15 ML AB's before age 25.

 

The only thing complicating the decision (in my mind) as to whether or not to keep him is the pay raise he's about to get.

 

Otherwise:

-If you sell low (trade now), and he continues to suck (so he has no trade value) --> small gain

-If you sell low (trade now), and he becomes decent --> small loss

-If you sell low (trade now), and he reaches expectation --> large-loss

-If you hold, and he continues to suck --> small-medium loss

-If you hold, and he becomes decent --> small-medium gain

-If you hold, and he reaches expectation --> large gain

 

Now, I recognize the hole in this logic: this is looking a the value of the single player, and not how he affects the club as a whole. And, I certainly agree that the club should contend this year, and it'd be tough to swallow another season from Hermida like 2008.

But, I don't think we can sign a FA replacement for any cheaper that we can expect to produce much better; the MiLB replacement options are even more unproven and with less talent.

And worst case scenario, I think a platoon in left could be interesting:

Willingham career OPS vs LHP: .844

Hermida OPS vs. RHP: .794

Yes, Willingham's career OPS vs RHP is higher than Jeremy's, but I think in the end, he's worth holding for another year. Given my assumption, the worst-case scenario if we hold is a small-medium loss, where we risk a large loss if we move him. However, if we trade him there is no way to realize a large gain, but if we hold there is that chance.

 

Obviously, the way you weight these probabilities largely affects the Expected Values of the various circumstances - but I still think the chance he explodes (and possibly explodes soon) is pretty decent.

 

Oh, and if he sucks, we can certainly play Hammer every day. Hermida's value won't drop much farther, IMO, if he struggles in the first half 2008.

To me it's in the hands of the front office. They know what they are doing. I live with whatever their decision is because i know it will be more informed than any I can make.

 

I hate this kind of talk. So no matter what happens, it's the right move because the people in the front office may (or may not) be more informed than us?

 

Actually, he didn't say "right move." He did say they know better because they are more informed than we are. I agree with that. In every aspect. I don't know what his attitude is off the field, what is being offered to us in trade, or if the coaches are seeing things in practices that we don't see in actual games. "Right move" could be a combination of many things. He's been looking pretty lazy out there. Lackadaisical may be a better word. We have no idea if that benching added to an attitude (if he had one) or it helped cure one. Maybe "right move" means getting a potential club house cancer off the team before he infects a bad attitude towards other players. Or maybe he has just shown the coaching staff he isn't all he was cracked up to be at this level. In any case, I would trust the FO to make the right choice when it comes to the team over what anyone here says. Because they are more informed than anyone here.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.