Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Peter Gammons: Hanley Ramirez will win MVP

Featured Replies

Pujols is the best player in baseball right now.

It's gonna be tough for Hanley to beat him in MVP votes.

 

He might be the best hitter in baseball but not player.

 

 

How could you say that he might win a gold glove if D Lee wasen't on the Cubs

 

Yes he is good defensively but its still 1st base. 1st base can be tough but SS is the tougher position in my eyes. Han ram is good in three facets of the game. Hitting, Defense and on the base paths.

Hanley Ramirez was already better than Jose Reyes his rookie season. No need to recap Hanley's beastly sophomore season. And Jose Reyes wishes he could score as many runs as Hanley. Maybe that is why he steals so much. Btw he is not even the best base-stealer on the Mets. If you look at the SB-to-caught stealing, Beltran is better than Reyes. Every time Reyes is on base he steals second and sometimes third and still cant get in to score the runs that Hanley does. Hanley is by far the best SS in the NL, and competes with A-Rod for best in the league. I think Hanley can also give Pujols a run for his money now that he will hit in the 3 spot. As for Miggie and D-Wright, it is hard to say who is better. They are almost identical offensively. Defensively, it's a no brainer, Wright is better. And as for the Mets as a whole, WHY THE F*** DID THEY RESIGN OLI PEREZ AND NOT GO AFTER A FA --> Minaya = stupid. Beltran is gunna continue having "neck pains," "flu-like systems," and "vaginal sand" as injuries this season. Carlos Delgado is getting old but I still think he has some juice in the tank for this season. Putz and K-Rod are scary!!!! D-Wright will be nasty as usual. Jose Reyes' numbers will drop off a little from last year, except for in stolen bases because he steals bases like it's going out of style. Johan = nasty. The rest of their starting pitchers are questionable. I have never liked Pelfrey as a pitcher and John Maine has a lot of potential but never seems to buckle down.

Pujols is the best player in baseball right now.

It's gonna be tough for Hanley to beat him in MVP votes.

 

He might be the best hitter in baseball but not player.

 

 

How could you say that he might win a gold glove if D Lee wasen't on the Cubs

 

Yes he is good defensively but its still 1st base. 1st base can be tough but SS is the tougher position in my eyes. Han ram is good in three facets of the game. Hitting, Defense and on the base paths.

 

 

Well you are right but playing 1st Base vs LHB is just as bad as playing 3rd vs RHB and at 1st it's up to you to save many bad throws whcih pujols does well.

 

With Hanley tough yes his speed and Hitting are a plus but his defense has only been average at best, he keeps getting better though and will be without a doubt the best player in baseball with a little more time and pratice.

Hanley Ramirez was already better than Jose Reyes his rookie season. No need to recap Hanley's beastly sophomore season. And Jose Reyes wishes he could score as many runs as Hanley. Maybe that is why he steals so much. Btw he is not even the best base-stealer on the Mets. If you look at the SB-to-caught stealing, Beltran is better than Reyes. Every time Reyes is on base he steals second and sometimes third and still cant get in to score the runs that Hanley does. Hanley is by far the best SS in the NL, and competes with A-Rod for best in the league. I think Hanley can also give Pujols a run for his money now that he will hit in the 3 spot. As for Miggie and D-Wright, it is hard to say who is better. They are almost identical offensively. Defensively, it's a no brainer, Wright is better. And as for the Mets as a whole, WHY THE F*** DID THEY RESIGN OLI PEREZ AND NOT GO AFTER A FA --> Minaya = stupid. Beltran is gunna continue having "neck pains," "flu-like systems," and "vaginal sand" as injuries this season. Carlos Delgado is getting old but I still think he has some juice in the tank for this season. Putz and K-Rod are scary!!!! D-Wright will be nasty as usual. Jose Reyes' numbers will drop off a little from last year, except for in stolen bases because he steals bases like it's going out of style. Johan = nasty. The rest of their starting pitchers are questionable. I have never liked Pelfrey as a pitcher and John Maine has a lot of potential but never seems to buckle down.

 

Runs scored is not a good barometer of a player's value. Hanley > Reyes, though, obviously.

You guys didn't see the disclaimer? It said Peter Gammons was drunk at the time he made the prediction.

 

Mad because Hanley is twice the player Jose Reyes is?

 

yep, I clearly remember marlins fans singing the same tune about how much better cabrera was then wright and look how that turned out. Hanley won't even be a SS for that long so I don't gotta worry about comparisons between a SS and a corner player.

 

You must not be paying much attention, but even in his down year Cabrera did about the same as Wright (and in a new league, I might add).

 

Numbers (2008):

 

Cabrera: .292 37HR 127 RBI

 

Wright: .302 33HR 124RBI

 

You are a moron.

You guys didn't see the disclaimer? It said Peter Gammons was drunk at the time he made the prediction.

 

Mad because Hanley is twice the player Jose Reyes is?

 

yep, I clearly remember marlins fans singing the same tune about how much better cabrera was then wright and look how that turned out. Hanley won't even be a SS for that long so I don't gotta worry about comparisons between a SS and a corner player.

 

You must not be paying much attention, but even in his down year Cabrera did about the same as Wright (and in a new league, I might add).

 

Numbers (2008):

 

Cabrera: .292 37HR 127 RBI

 

Wright: .302 33HR 124RBI

 

You are a moron.

 

Cabrera's OPS: .886

Wright: .924

You guys didn't see the disclaimer? It said Peter Gammons was drunk at the time he made the prediction.

 

Mad because Hanley is twice the player Jose Reyes is?

 

yep, I clearly remember marlins fans singing the same tune about how much better cabrera was then wright and look how that turned out. Hanley won't even be a SS for that long so I don't gotta worry about comparisons between a SS and a corner player.

 

You must not be paying much attention, but even in his down year Cabrera did about the same as Wright (and in a new league, I might add).

 

Numbers (2008):

 

Cabrera: .292 37HR 127 RBI

 

Wright: .302 33HR 124RBI

 

You are a moron.

 

In fairness, Cabrera OPS+'d 130, while Wright OPS+'d 141 (and that figure is park-adjusted). And he had an OBP of .349 while Wright was at .390, with nearly identical SLG. So Wright's 2008 was quite a bit better in terms of numbers, let alone that Cabrera is in the better hitters' league.

You guys didn't see the disclaimer? It said Peter Gammons was drunk at the time he made the prediction.

 

Mad because Hanley is twice the player Jose Reyes is?

 

yep, I clearly remember marlins fans singing the same tune about how much better cabrera was then wright and look how that turned out. Hanley won't even be a SS for that long so I don't gotta worry about comparisons between a SS and a corner player.

 

You must not be paying much attention, but even in his down year Cabrera did about the same as Wright (and in a new league, I might add).

 

Numbers (2008):

 

Cabrera: .292 37HR 127 RBI

 

Wright: .302 33HR 124RBI

 

You are a moron.

 

Cabrera's OPS: .886

Wright: .924

 

Yes, I realize that. But a .924 v. an .886 hardly shows that Wright is clearly the better player. Starbrown wants to pretend that Wright is clearly better than Cabrera, and that is just plain false.

 

Career OPS:

 

Cabrera: .922

 

Wright: .922

 

 

And Cabrera's career OPS is slightly diminished slightly by the fact that he came up to the big leagues at age 20 and he's actually younger than Wright.

You guys didn't see the disclaimer? It said Peter Gammons was drunk at the time he made the prediction.

 

Mad because Hanley is twice the player Jose Reyes is?

 

yep, I clearly remember marlins fans singing the same tune about how much better cabrera was then wright and look how that turned out. Hanley won't even be a SS for that long so I don't gotta worry about comparisons between a SS and a corner player.

 

You must not be paying much attention, but even in his down year Cabrera did about the same as Wright (and in a new league, I might add).

 

Numbers (2008):

 

Cabrera: .292 37HR 127 RBI

 

Wright: .302 33HR 124RBI

 

You are a moron.

 

In fairness, Cabrera OPS+'d 130, while Wright OPS+'d 141 (and that figure is park-adjusted). And he had an OBP of .349 while Wright was at .390, with nearly identical SLG. So Wright's 2008 was quite a bit better in terms of numbers, let alone that Cabrera is in the better hitters' league.

 

Yes, but Cabrera was in a new league. His first half of the season was terrible as he was trying to adjust to the new league and new pitchers. He destroyed the leauge in the second half, hitting 26 homeruns and driving in 79 runs.

Yes, I realize that. But a .924 v. an .886 hardly shows that Wright is clearly the better player. Starbrown wants to pretend that Wright is clearly better than Cabrera, and that is just plain false.

 

Career OPS:

 

Cabrera: .922

 

Wright: .922

 

 

And Cabrera's career OPS is slightly diminished slightly by the fact that he came up to the big leagues at age 20 and he's actually younger than Wright.

Well, the biggest issue is comparing last year. Wright clearly had the better year last year, but Cabrera clearly had better years in 06 and 07, when this was an argument.

 

When we were claiming that Cabrera was better than Wright, it wasn't out of some Marlins love or Mets hate, it came from sheer fact.

Hanley isn't better then ARod or Pujols. Keep dreaming.

It depends on how you define better. Hanley is the best player in baseball to build a franchise around based on position scarcity. He obliterates all other SS in performance, and he's not even in his prime years yet. Pujols obviously is retarded, but you can easily find above average production at the position. At SS, hell no.

Hanley isn't better then ARod or Pujols. Keep dreaming.

It depends on how you define better. Hanley is the best player in baseball to build a franchise around based on position scarcity. He obliterates all other SS in performance, and he's not even in his prime years yet. Pujols obviously is retarded, but you can easily find above average production at the position. At SS, hell no.

 

 

Well, that's true. You're not going to find anyone that gives the offensive production Hanley gives at SS.

I kinda find it hard to compare Migi and Wright nowadays because they have become completely different players. Migi is in the AL and Wright is in the NL. Migi plays 1st and DH and plays weak defense. Wright plays full time 3rd base and is stellar at defense. Cabrera only focuses on homers and rbi. Wright tries to hit for contact but also has power. Wright is a true defensive 3rd baseman and Migi is now somewhat becoming a David Ortiz type of player. They are completely different and IMO it is difficult to compare them because their playing styles are becoming completely different.

According to win Values (a metric that takes into consideration defense, position scarcity, offense, and playing time, Hanley Ramirez was behind Chase Utley and Albert Pujols last season for the most valuable player in the league--both NL and AL (3rd place overall).

 

Here's the link to see the entire list: http://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=...008&month=0

 

Hanley is still on the upward swing of the age curve, meaning he still has untapped potential. The other names around him are much older and already at their ceiling.

Just to clear it up:

 

Hanley > Reyes

 

Cabrera > Wright

 

Marlins > Mets

 

And im sorry but Hanley Ramirez is not the best baseball player in the game.

He's just not there yet with guys like a-rod and pujols still in the league.

 

And Hanley winning the MVP? Honestly, i would be very suprised, but at the same time very happy.

Hanely could win MVP if he hits 40 homeruns and steals over 30 bases, and of course hits above .300 and has an OPS of 900+.

Since his rookie campaign in 2006, Hanley has a .906 OPS. Second in the majors is Derek Jeter, down at .838 OPS. So Hanley is 70 points better than the second shortstop. Only three others also were above .800 (Tejada, Reyes, Rollins).

 

Pujols is 90 points ahead of the next best 1b in that same time frame (Howard), but there's also five with OPS's over 900, and 11 more with OPSs over 800.

 

The only other player who dominates a position is Utley, who's 100 points ahead of the next best 2b. Seven have OPSs over 800.

 

Can't really forget though that Hanley is at best an average defensive short stop but Utley and Pujols are the best fielders for their respective positions. It'd certainly be interesting to see if Utley could play shortstop. Utley is certainly going to lose a lot of value though considering the current crop of 2b (Uggla, Kinsler, and Pedroia) developed to the point of OPSing in the high .800's last year. But still, we're talking about a 2B who, in the past four years, has OPsed in the .900's and saved about 15 runs with his glove per year.

OPS isn't adjusted for ballpark, and it's a poor metric to use when there are far more robust statistics out there, like wOBA.

 

Hanley plays in an extreme pitchers park, Utley plays in an extreme hitters park.

 

SS is the second hardest position to field behind catcher.

 

When making adjustments for these two factors, Hanley is more productive than Utley.

 

Utley's value is in being a really good hitter and fielder.

 

Hanley doesn't field SS well, but he does a good enough job to be an asset at the position.

 

Right now, Pujols is probably the only player better than Hanley and Hanley is still only going to get better (he's only 25)

Hanley is amazing but come on ARod and Pujols are just another level of player even though they play corner positions which are not as valuable as SS obviously.

Hanley is a .400/.550 player as a 25 year old. He's insane. Yes, better than wright, and more valuable (and perhaps flat out better) than arod. He might be more valuable than pujols (baseball prospectus agrees.)

I used OPS because it's a lot more accessible to the public. People are going to understand a lot more the value of a .800, .900 OPS. Going by something like OPS+, it still gives the same basic result. Throw any advanced metric you want, wOBA, GPA, whatever, they're all going to give the same round about answer.

 

Considering Utley's absolute dominance at fielding second, I don't see any reason why he couldn't field short stop at at least an average rate, and likely he would be above average.

I kinda find it hard to compare Migi and Wright nowadays because they have become completely different players. Migi is in the AL and Wright is in the NL. Migi plays 1st and DH and plays weak defense. Wright plays full time 3rd base and is stellar at defense. Cabrera only focuses on homers and rbi. Wright tries to hit for contact but also has power. Wright is a true defensive 3rd baseman and Migi is now somewhat becoming a David Ortiz type of player. They are completely different and IMO it is difficult to compare them because their playing styles are becoming completely different.

 

Considering they both have .309 averages in their major league careers, I dont see how u can say Wright tries to hit for contact and exclude such a statement from ur evaluation of Miggy.

And even with how great Hanley is, the Marlins are going NO WHERE. Stuck in the bottom of the NL East.

 

You know, at times Starbrownies, you really are a ?*$!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.