Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Some Movement For Marlins, Uggla

Featured Replies

With all the complaints about Uggla's defense, it is worth noting that any replacement from within the Marlin's system will bring with him a worse glove than Uggla's.

 

Except for Ozzy maybe.

With all the complaints about Uggla's defense, it is worth noting that any replacement from within the Marlin's system will bring with him a worse glove than Uggla's.

 

Except for Ozzy maybe.

 

 

I thought Cogs was a super-duper defensive guy ? If not then we'd be crazy to take Uggla's bat out of our lineup. We would not get near the runs we do now.

With all the complaints about Uggla's defense, it is worth noting that any replacement from within the Marlin's system will bring with him a worse glove than Uggla's.

 

Except for Ozzy maybe.

 

 

 

If you're just talking about "glove," Bonifacio>>>>Uggla. Ozzie can play SS; I'm sure if he were to move over to 2B, his glove would be much better than Uggla's too. Coghlan's glove in the infield (based on scouting reports) would be better than Uggla's.

 

Uggla is not good, defensively. He just more than makes up for it with his bat.

 

I'm really not sure what the Marlins plan on doing, in the scenario that they don't keep Uggla. I highly doubt Morrison stays in LF. Dominguez is going to be the future 3B, so Coghlan's not staying at 3B long-term. Maybe they just stay with Coghlan in LF because he improved a lot statistically in 2010 out there, defensively.

 

Based on comments, it does seem like they would definitely like to be better, defensively. I still wouldn't doubt seeing Bonifacio as the everyday 2B one day. He projects to be very good there, defensively. Maybe they'll hope that Bonifacio can be the anti-Uggla. Instead of having a guy who's bat makes up for his defense, maybe the Marlins will hope that Bonifacio becomes a player who's defense/baserunning make up for his lack of offense.

Coghlan was a below average second baseman defensively in the minors. Previous reports indicated that Marlins FO did not believe he could perform as a ML Second Baseman.

 

Bonifacio is a horror with range. Check his fielding stats at second in both the majors and minors. Remember that his arm is awful and that Uggla can at least turn the DP.

lmao @ Dan Runzler

 

Seriously Erick, I am not trying to sound like a d*** here, you seem to be a really intelligent poster and very knowlegable about the game and the organization, but this is the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen. I don't know what's worse....trading Dan Uggla for Dan Runzler or trading Mike Stanton for Ozzie Guillen. You don't trade a guy who puts up that kind of production for an unproven middle reliever. You just don't. He's way way waaay more valuable than that,,,

 

 

 

Well, he's not "unproven."

 

Here's an article on his impressive minor league track record: http://bleacherrepor...arm-dan-runzler

 

 

He also threw 32.2 innings in the big leagues this year. If not for the fact that he dislocated his knee while hitting, Runzler would be on the Giants postseason roster, instead of Javier Lopez.

 

Runzler's major league stats this year were right on with what he's proven in the minor leagues. He's good, and he's good against both lefties and righties (while being better against lefties, which is a plus).

 

2010 splits

v. lefties: 10.22 K/9, 2.8 K/BB, 0.00 HR/9, 2.27 FIP, 3.26 xFIP

v. righties: 10.18 K/9, 1.53 K/BB, 0.44 HR/9, 3.67 FIP, 3.90 xFIP

 

He has the potential to be pretty dominant, and really has the potential to be a closer, if all goes well. He's not just some "filler middle reliever because we need a bullpen." He's a valuable asset who would fill an organizational need.

 

 

I also never said Uggla STRAIGHT UP for Runzler. I said Uggla for Runzler + another prospect. It sounds a whole lot more realistic than a Bumgarner/Hellickson return (I guarantee that doesn't happen; if that's what everyone's hoping for, then everyone better hope Uggla lowers his demands and signs a 3-4 year deal here). I mean, if it's so laughable, I assume you can tell us what you believe Uggla is truly worth?

 

I'm assuming people just don't know who Runzler is if you're comparing this to an Ozzie Guillen-Mike Stanton trade. (which btw, Stanton's value>>>Uggla's value)

 

He has just over 40 innings of Major League experience. That means he's unproven. And even if he does put up good numbers as a reliever for say, 50 or 60 innings a season, how valuable is that compared to a player who plays every day and hits you 30 bombs a year? There are a lot more Dan Runzlers than there are Dan Ugglas. I could see maybe trading Gaby Sanchez for Dan Runzler. Guys like that. But not Uggla. In my opinion, Uggla is worth at least one Top 50 prospect (Major-league ready) and a couple mid-level prospects.

 

I would rather see them re-sign him though. Yeah 5 years is probably too long but I look at it this way: Would you rather risk another Cabrera situation or Uggla not living up to his contract? I'll take the risk on Uggla.

 

1) You know what he's capable of doing

2) He has proven people wrong every year

3) Why not reward a guy who has been so vital to your organization the past few years?

 

Give the man the money he deserves

Coghlan was a below average second baseman defensively in the minors. Previous reports indicated that Marlins FO did not believe he could perform as a ML Second Baseman.

 

Bonifacio is a horror with range. Check his fielding stats at second in both the majors and minors. Remember that his arm is awful and that Uggla can at least turn the DP.

 

 

 

No he's not.

Bonifacio was actually viewed as the best defensive infielder in the Diamondbacks organization back when he was a prospect, and his natural position was/is 2B.

May I ask which defensive statistic you're looking at to come up with that conclusion?

 

Bonifacio has only played a grand total of 436.1 innings at 2B in the Major Leagues, btw. That's not a good sample.

In my opinion, Uggla is worth at least one Top 50 prospect (Major-league ready) and a couple mid-level prospects.

 

I would rather see them re-sign him though. Yeah 5 years is probably too long but I look at it this way: Would you rather risk another Cabrera situation or Uggla not living up to his contract? I'll take the risk on Uggla.

 

3) Why not reward a guy who has been so vital to your organization the past few years?

 

 

 

 

Just going to answer what I quoted here.

 

In my opinion, he's not quite worth that much. Really though, Runzler was the 4th best prospect in the Giants organization at the beginning of the year, and he's Major League ready. To put things in perspective, Buster Posey and Madison Bumgarner were the first two guys on the list. Basically, he was the #4 prospect this year for an organization that had a very good farm system.

 

Runzler + a mid-level prospect or two is pretty much the type of deal I'd see us getting for Uggla.

 

2010 was a very nice year for Uggla; in my opinion, however, the player he is likely to be for the rest of his career is what he did in the 2009 season, which is a dropoff from his 2010 season.

 

As for your second sentence, you're comparing apples to oranges. Miguel Cabrera>>>>>Dan Uggla. It won't hurt the organization as much to lose a 30 year old Uggla than it did to lose a 24 year old Miguel Cabrera, who's the best right-handed hitter in baseball not named Albert Pujols. Cabrera is a player you can build around, much like Hanley & Stanton. Dan Uggla doesn't quite reach that level.

 

As for your question #3, my answer is simple. You don't give contracts out (especially with the Marlins budget) based on past performance. You give contracts based on what you believe the player will give you in the upcoming years. We're not in position to give Uggla a "thank you for what you did; here's your reward" contract like what the Yankees are about to do with Jeter without thinking about the upcoming years. It could hurt this organization even more to give Uggla a 5 year contract and not have it pan out (which is a definite possibility).

 

This team has given out two long-term contracts.

1. Hanley Ramirez (Star player. Best at his position. In his prime.)

2. Josh Johnson (Ace. One of the best pitchers in baseball. In his prime.)

 

Dan Uggla doesn't really fit that caliber of player, nor will he be in his prime throughout his contract. When you give a 5 year contract out, years 4 & 5 are just as important as years 1 & 2. Will Uggla be anything more than a DH by the time he reaches the ages of 33? 34? 35?

Coghlan was a below average second baseman defensively in the minors. Previous reports indicated that Marlins FO did not believe he could perform as a ML Second Baseman.

 

Bonifacio is a horror with range. Check his fielding stats at second in both the majors and minors. Remember that his arm is awful and that Uggla can at least turn the DP.

 

 

 

No he's not.

Bonifacio was actually viewed as the best defensive infielder in the Diamondbacks organization back when he was a prospect, and his natural position was/is 2B.

May I ask which defensive statistic you're looking at to come up with that conclusion?

 

Bonifacio has only played a grand total of 436.1 innings at 2B in the Major Leagues, btw. That's not a good sample.

 

EB made at least 20 errors in every full year in the minors, mostly at 2B.

 

And in those 436 ML innings, he made nine errors at 2B.

 

There is no evidence that Boni is even an average ML Second Baseman, other that he is fast and fits preconconceived notions of his role.

Coghlan was a below average second baseman defensively in the minors. Previous reports indicated that Marlins FO did not believe he could perform as a ML Second Baseman.

 

Bonifacio is a horror with range. Check his fielding stats at second in both the majors and minors. Remember that his arm is awful and that Uggla can at least turn the DP.

 

 

 

No he's not.

Bonifacio was actually viewed as the best defensive infielder in the Diamondbacks organization back when he was a prospect, and his natural position was/is 2B.

May I ask which defensive statistic you're looking at to come up with that conclusion?

 

Bonifacio has only played a grand total of 436.1 innings at 2B in the Major Leagues, btw. That's not a good sample.

 

EB made at least 20 errors in every full year in the minors, mostly at 2B.

 

And in those 436 ML innings, he made nine errors at 2B.

 

There is no evidence that Boni is even an average ML Second Baseman, other that he is fast and fits preconconceived notions of his role.

 

 

That has nothing to do with range.

Bonifacio makes more errors because he gets to some balls that other 2B aren't able to get to.

 

This happens all the time. Some of the best defensive infielders make a lot of errors. Errors don't indicate how good/bad a player is, defensively.

Boni has range.

 

Doesn't catch ground balls well.

 

Terrible arm, weak and inaccurate.

 

He's fast and showed some improvement with plate discipline last year.

 

A useful utility player and better in the OF than the INF.

 

But no more than that

i feel like Erick has never actually watched a baseball game. he just researches the f*** out of every minor league stat available to make arguments.

  • Author

i feel like Erick has never actually watched a baseball game. he just researches the f*** out of every minor league stat available to make arguments.

 

So you think Boni has bad range? And does that thought come from watching him play a lot of 2B?

i feel like Erick has never actually watched a baseball game. he just researches the f*** out of every minor league stat available to make arguments.

 

So you think Boni has bad range? And does that thought come from watching him play a lot of 2B?

he's fast. he can't field well.

i feel like Erick has never actually watched a baseball game. he just researches the f*** out of every minor league stat available to make arguments.

 

So you think Boni has bad range? And does that thought come from watching him play a lot of 2B?

he's fast. he can't field well.

 

 

No need to question this. The great poptart said it. He's watched every single baseball game Bonifacio has ever played, and knows more than all statistics/scouting reports.

 

I hope Admin Beinfest gets fired one day because I just feel we'd be a lot better with the great poptart at GM. He could enlighten me, and the rest of us really with his superior knowledge.

So now you want to trade Dan Uggla for a #5 starter?

i feel like Erick has never actually watched a baseball game. he just researches the f*** out of every minor league stat available to make arguments.

 

So you think Boni has bad range? And does that thought come from watching him play a lot of 2B?

he's fast. he can't field well.

 

 

No need to question this. The great poptart said it. He's watched every single baseball game Bonifacio has ever played, and knows more than all statistics/scouting reports.

 

I hope Admin Beinfest gets fired one day because I just feel we'd be a lot better with the great poptart at GM. He could enlighten me, and the rest of us really with his superior knowledge.

mmmm... great poptart :drool

So now you want to trade Dan Uggla for a #5 starter?

 

 

 

No. His potential is better than that. It just shows that he can be thought of as a guy who's capable of starting, as well. Possibly another C.J. Wilson situation there. Walk rate has been kinda high like Wilson, but very good stuff/difficult to hit like Wilson.

 

A #5 starter for the Giants is like saying potential #2-3 for just about anyone else. The Giants have, arguably, the best pitching staff in baseball.

Doesn't catch ground balls well.

 

Terrible arm, weak and inaccurate.

 

 

 

 

 

What the hell does "doesn't catch ground balls well" mean? I mean, I know what it means, but it's never something you really hear with major league baseball players. Why? Because it's untrue. Most of the time, when a major league player is in position to field a routine groundball, it gets done.

 

You're basing all of this on errors, which is silly.

 

Do you think Ryan Zimmerman is a bad defensive 3B? I mean...he makes a lot of errors. I guess he shouldn't play the position because due to the errors statistic, it must mean that he "doesn't catch ground balls well." Right? :rolleyes:

 

As for what you said about his arm, just stop. Bonifacio might not have the best arm in the world, but it's certainly at least average, if not above average. You must have not seen some of the throws he made from the outfield last year. Actually, to sum it up, Bonifacio has experience playing in RF (both in Winter Ball, and some in the Major Leagues). Most guys who are capable of playing RF don't have "weak and inaccurate" arms. Try some other better adjectives. Weak is a good adjective to describe the way he hits; his defense? Not "weak," at all.

By the way, for those who think Runzler is "just a 30-50 inning reliever," maybe you'd feel differently about the guy if you go on mlbtraderumors. The Giants have their great top 4 of Lincecum, Cain, Sanchez, and Bumgarner heading into next year. Receiving consideration to be the #5 starter? Dan Runzler.

 

http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2010/11/giants-dont-intend-to-trade-zito.html

 

 

You seem to be really stuck on getting this guy. But I don't think Uggla is traded. So maybe come up with another trade to get him.

Wait, is Erick defending Bonifacio?

 

 

Dogs and Cats are living together in sin!

So now you want to trade Dan Uggla for a #5 starter?

 

 

 

No. His potential is better than that. It just shows that he can be thought of as a guy who's capable of starting, as well. Possibly another C.J. Wilson situation there. Walk rate has been kinda high like Wilson, but very good stuff/difficult to hit like Wilson.

 

A #5 starter for the Giants is like saying potential #2-3 for just about anyone else. The Giants have, arguably, the best pitching staff in baseball.

 

Throw in their AAA pitching coach as well then.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.