Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Some Movement For Marlins, Uggla

Featured Replies

I wonder if MLB steps in and has a say in whether or not the Marlins trade Uggla.

 

 

Why should they? It's not like we didn't offer him a fair deal.

 

Yea, but in terms of our competitiveness, losing Uggla really puts a dent into things.

 

Is there any precedent for this?

And a reasonable trade wouldn't necessarily kill our competitiveness. At worst, Uggla is maybe worth 2-3 more wins than Cogz.

MLB and/or Bud Selig have absolutely nothing to say about whether or not we sign or trade Uggla. Period.

 

However, if the rumors about him not wanting to play here are true, I can only laugh as I recall the many interviews over the last few years where he and Hanley talked about how they're "brothers" and love playing for the Marlins, who gave both of them their chance to be every-day starters.

 

If he's really not happy here, he needs to go, sooner rather than later. There's no good reason to pay anyone 10 mill+ who doesn't want to be here.

I wonder if MLB steps in and has a say in whether or not the Marlins trade Uggla.

 

 

Why should they? It's not like we didn't offer him a fair deal.

 

Yea, but in terms of our competitiveness, losing Uggla really puts a dent into things.

 

Is there any precedent for this?

And a reasonable trade wouldn't necessarily kill our competitiveness. At worst, Uggla is maybe worth 2-3 more wins than Cogz.

 

I didn't think losing 100 RBI's + 30 HR's a season needed much precedent. Perhaps Uggla is 2-3 more wins than Coghlan (which is a lot,) but who comes up to fill Coghlan's spot? How much better or worse is that player than Coghlan?

 

A reasonable trade this far into his arbitration years isn't going to net us much, really. It's one year for a guy who, by the looks of it, wants to be a free agent.

MLB and/or Bud Selig have absolutely nothing to say about whether or not we sign or trade Uggla. Period.

 

However, if the rumors about him not wanting to play here are true, I can only laugh as I recall the many interviews over the last few years where he and Hanley talked about how they're "brothers" and love playing for the Marlins, who gave both of them their chance to be every-day starters.

 

If he's really not happy here, he needs to go, sooner rather than later. There's no good reason to pay anyone 10 mill+ who doesn't want to be here.

 

 

Did you ask them? We have no way of knowing, really. I've got to think they wouldn't be very happy if this team takes a step backwards heading into a new stadium. You have to remember that while baseball is a business, the overall picture is still very important and MLB has some sort of influence on how the Marlins play going into the new ballpark.

I don't understand why Selig and co. would step in when it seems like the Marlins have done everything in the their power to offer Uggla a very fair deal. It's not like they offered him chump change. Yeah if Uggla doesn't sign and they end up trading him it might hurt the Marlins competitively but it's not like they can force him to sign especially if the speculation about his lack of desire to play in Florida is true. If Uggla doesn't want to be here and continues to price himself out of the Marlins price range there is really nothing the Marlins or Selig can do, is there?

lol, Dan turning down 4/48 deal... Clearly he doesn't want to be a Marlin

 

Whatever.. At least the Marlins will save face when/if he leaves. It's a very fair deal, specially for a 31 year old and small market team.

Did you ask them? We have no way of knowing, really.

 

I don't have to ask them. And, yes, we do have a way of knowing.

 

They have NO authority whatsoever over us or anyone else with regard to routine signings or trades and never have, EXCEPT in the circumstance where more than a million dollars in cash changes hands as part of a trade. In that case, it has to be approved by MLB. For instance:

 

The Twins also will receive $3 million in the deal, which was agreed on Wednesday night and finally approved by acting commissioner Bud Selig on Friday afternoon. Selig's approval was needed because of the cash involved.

 

http://www.startribu...s/96912659.html

 

That's 1998.

 

The Indians will also reportedly receive at least $1 million in cash from the Red Sox, which is why the deal must meet Selig's approval.

 

http://www.highbeam....2-12593029.html

 

That's 2006. The rules haven't changed since.

 

The $1 mill cash rule is silly, but so are a lot of MLB rules. Maybe it's a hangover from days of yore, when a mill actually mattered. In any case, it didn't stop the Rangers from winding up in bankruptcy for a few days.

 

As I said, MLB has nothing to say about how we handle Uggla.

The idea of MLB stepping in is laughable. If that were the case, they may as well just shut down the Pirates and Royals by now.

First of all, the opinions of a bandwagon fanbase are completely irrelevant. The real fans will support the team regardless, and the bandwagon fans will come out as long as the team wins. In order to win, you make moves that believe help the ballclub, regardless of the player you are trading. Very few players in the big leagues reach irreplaceable status, and Dan Uggla is not one of them. I'm sure the fanbase was disheartened when the likes of Josh Beckett, Juan Pierre, etc. were traded, yet those worked out very well for the organization. The front office has to do what's best to put a winning product on the field, with the limited resources it has.

That's the attitude of a team that likes playing in front of empty seats. The Marlins have been making moves that "help the ball club" for years ... and bleeding fans all the while. Because of its history, this team needs to pay its fan favorites until they can no longer play in order to prove to fans that the goal isn't to field a AAA ball club and pocket the savings. Guys like you may have a deeper understanding of the benefits of trading Uggla for prospects, but to 90% of fans and 100% of the general population ... it just looks like another round of the Marlins shipping off its best players to avoid paying them. The fact that the Marlins are getting a new stadium is just going to make it look even worse.

 

I think I see what you're trying to get at... but I ultimately disagree...

 

You're saying we have to pay our fan favorites until they can no longer play and just ignore their productivity? So you're saying the Marlins team right now, in 2011, should have Jeff Conine, Juan Pierre, Craig Counsell, and Mike Mordecai right? Thats a shame. And of the bandwagon fans that you believe make a difference, you'd be shocked to know how many of them dont even know what a AAA ballclub is. They only care about winning, period. Erick is right. Those fans dont matter in the long run. Theyll be there when we are winning, so lets get to winning. Thats it, its that simple. Problem is, with your philosophy of pleasing those fans first, we'll never get to winning.

 

Put it this way... its like asking a 5 year old kid to choose what they want for breakfast everyday. If they choose candy every morning (which they might cause they don't understand a healthy diet), you're philosophy says we should just let them have candy every morning until their teeth fall out because its just their favorite? That's stupid. Kids are great, but they are incapable of making appropriate, educated decisions at times. In this case, the bandwagon fans are the kids. I dont care what they want because they arent all educated enough to know what they should have over what they want. That about it sums it up.

Did you ask them? We have no way of knowing, really.

 

I don't have to ask them. And, yes, we do have a way of knowing.

 

They have NO authority whatsoever over us or anyone else with regard to routine signings or trades and never have, EXCEPT in the circumstance where more than a million dollars in cash changes hands as part of a trade. In that case, it has to be approved by MLB. For instance:

 

The Twins also will receive $3 million in the deal, which was agreed on Wednesday night and finally approved by acting commissioner Bud Selig on Friday afternoon. Selig's approval was needed because of the cash involved.

 

http://www.startribu...s/96912659.html

 

That is from 1998.

 

The Indians will also reportedly receive at least $1 million in cash from the Red Sox, which is why the deal must meet Selig's approval.

 

http://www.highbeam....2-12593029.html

 

That is from 2006, and the rules haven't changed since.

 

The $1 mill cash rule is silly, but so are a lot of MLB rules. Maybe it's a hangover from days of yore, when a mill actually mattered. In any case, it didn't stop the Rangers from winding up in bankruptcy for a few days.

 

I'm not talking about legal formalities. I'm talking about a nudge from the MLB. Obviously they have no way to actually force them to do anything, but we'd be fools to say that MLB doesn't help sway clubs to take certain courses of action if its in their best interest. Perhaps I could've worded by initial thought better.

The idea of MLB stepping in is laughable. If that were the case, they may as well just shut down the Pirates and Royals by now.

 

 

Yeah its pointless. I think this just comes from the misinterpretation of what happened last year when MLB said the Fish had to spend more and suddenly JJ got a significant contract. MLB did not say "You must give JJ a contract."

 

MLB can not dictate to a team who to sign and anything like that. There are so many future problems that can arise from this but I wont get into it. Its laughable. End of story.

I'm talking about a nudge from the MLB.

 

There's no such thing. People seem to have some inflated impression of MLB/Selig's influence. It's near zero.

 

Owners do what they want. Remember Charlie Finley.

So, does no one else remember that Uggla/Ramirez interview where Dan says to Hanley "You make me better" and the Hanley says "No, you make me better," and then they argue about who makes who better?

 

And go on to gush about how wonderful it is to play with each other and for the Marlins? And how they're "brothers?"

 

Ah, what a difference 50 million, give or take, makes.

I wonder if MLB steps in and has a say in whether or not the Marlins trade Uggla.

 

 

Why should they? It's not like we didn't offer him a fair deal.

 

Yea, but in terms of our competitiveness, losing Uggla really puts a dent into things.

 

Is there any precedent for this?

And a reasonable trade wouldn't necessarily kill our competitiveness. At worst, Uggla is maybe worth 2-3 more wins than Cogz.

 

I didn't think losing 100 RBI's + 30 HR's a season needed much precedent. Perhaps Uggla is 2-3 more wins than Coghlan (which is a lot,) but who comes up to fill Coghlan's spot? How much better or worse is that player than Coghlan?

 

A reasonable trade this far into his arbitration years isn't going to net us much, really. It's one year for a guy who, by the looks of it, wants to be a free agent.

 

I was referring to precedent for them stepping in.

I agree w/LordM that if MLB did that, the Pirates would be in deep doodoo :lol

Uggla, Marlins at an impasse

 

Club persistent after second baseman rejects four-year offer

MIAMI -- If a long-term deal is not reached, Dan Uggla's long-range tenure with the Marlins may be in jeopardy.

 

MLB.com has confirmed that the power-hitting second baseman has rejected a four-year, $48 million extension.

 

Ken Rosenthal of FOXSports.com initially reported that Uggla was turning down one of the largest offers in Marlins history. The story added that the team was "stunned" by the rejection.

 

MLB.com has learned that the Marlins may seriously consider trading the 30-year-old if a multiyear contract isn't worked out. According to a source familiar with the negotiations, Florida has been led to believe that Uggla would rather play for another club.

 

A second source added that both sides are still talking and that negotiations are ongoing, so it is premature to suggest that a long-term deal won't eventually be reached.

 

Uggla's agent, Terry Bross of Gaylord Sports Management, said Monday that Uggla's preference is to stay with the Marlins.

 

"Dan is not angling to get out of Florida," said Bross, who did not give specifics on negotiations.

 

Uggla, 30, has one more season of arbitration eligibility remaining. He made $7.8 million in 2010.

 

If a multiyear contract isn't worked out, the Marlins may opt to sign Uggla to a one-year deal in 2011 and keep him the entire season. The team could then be in position to receive Draft pick compensation if he moves on as a free agent.

 

A more realistic choice could be to seek a trade for Uggla either before Spring Training 2011 or by the non-waiver Trade Deadline next July 31.

 

Uggla, the Marlins' all-time home run leader with 154, is coming off his best season. The slugger belted 33 homers and drove in 105 runs, to go along with a .287 batting average.

 

Retaining their gritty second baseman has been a high priority for the Marlins since last July, when negotiations initially began.

 

Uggla has been hitting home runs at a historic rate for a player at his position, with a Major League record of four seasons of 30 or more. Also, Uggla's power numbers stack up with free-agent outfielder Jayson Werth, most recently of the Philadelphia Phillies, who is looking for a bigger contract than the relatively comparable Uggla.

 

If Uggla re-ups for four years, it would in effect be a three-year extension in addition to his 2011 season. Uggla would then be 34 years old when he became a free agent, and he might be more inclined to wait until next season is over to cash in on a longer-term deal.

 

FOXSports.com also suggested that Uggla might be interested in playing for the Yankees, Red Sox or Phillies, but those three teams are set at second base, with three of the best players in the game in Robinson Cano, Dustin Pedroia and Chase Utley, respectively. The site wrote that Uggla might be willing to switch positions to third base or the outfield to accommodate one of those perennial contenders after next year.

 

A year ago, the Marlins pursued trade talks for Uggla, but his market was limited at that time.

 

On the free-agent market, the Mets would be one of the few teams that could afford to take on a $12 million second baseman.

 

Joe Frisaro is a reporter for MLB.com. Follow him on Twitter @JoeFrisaro. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.

I'm talking about a nudge from the MLB.

 

There's no such thing. People seem to have some inflated impression of MLB/Selig's influence. It's near zero.

 

Owners do what they want. Remember Charlie Finley.

 

So you believe that the MLB doesn't have the ability to express a wish to a major league ballclub, and that the ballclub would never have a reason to listen and possibly comply? The statement that MLB made regarding the Marlins and the Pirates spending is a perfect example. Before some of you start raging and saying that it had no effect on signing JJ, I'm going to say that that's not what I'm arguing here. I'm arguing that the MLB''s wishes aren't totally irrelevant for a team that used the MLB's help to secure their ballpark and who has already verbally agreed to raise payroll modestly until the inauguration of the new ballpark. You're telling me that the MLB has absolutely no influence?

 

I still maintain that certain actions like, for example, the Mets series in PR last year are favors that teams and the MLB exchange.

First of all, the opinions of a bandwagon fanbase are completely irrelevant. The real fans will support the team regardless, and the bandwagon fans will come out as long as the team wins. In order to win, you make moves that believe help the ballclub, regardless of the player you are trading. Very few players in the big leagues reach irreplaceable status, and Dan Uggla is not one of them. I'm sure the fanbase was disheartened when the likes of Josh Beckett, Juan Pierre, etc. were traded, yet those worked out very well for the organization. The front office has to do what's best to put a winning product on the field, with the limited resources it has.

That's the attitude of a team that likes playing in front of empty seats. The Marlins have been making moves that "help the ball club" for years ... and bleeding fans all the while. Because of its history, this team needs to pay its fan favorites until they can no longer play in order to prove to fans that the goal isn't to field a AAA ball club and pocket the savings. Guys like you may have a deeper understanding of the benefits of trading Uggla for prospects, but to 90% of fans and 100% of the general population ... it just looks like another round of the Marlins shipping off its best players to avoid paying them. The fact that the Marlins are getting a new stadium is just going to make it look even worse.

 

 

Sorry...but you're wrong. The Marlins don't need to keep certain players because the fans like them. Those "fans" don't understand the business aspect of the sport. The Marlins will do what they feel is best to win in a cost efficient way (because not every team is the Yankees), just like every team does. Every team goes about their business the same way. Try to field a winning team with what you have to work with. You win...the fans will come.

 

Losing Dan Uggla isn't going to hurt this club for years. Dan Uggla is not Miguel Cabrera. For what it's worth, losing Miguel Cabrera is not what set this franchise back; losing Miguel Cabrera and getting close to no production from the players we received in that trade is what hurt the franchise.

 

Losing players doesn't hurt you if you replace them the right way.

 

But if the Marlins did, indeed, use your strategy, Juan Pierre would still be here (one of the worst contracts in baseball...if I might add, no Ricky Nolasco), declining Josh Beckett would still be here (and if I might add...no Hanley Ramirez/Anibal Sanchez), Jorge Cantu would still be here (probably doesn't even belong in the big leagues anymore), Cody Ross would've been treated like a franchise player, etc., etc., etc. We'd be worse. Organizations don't pay attention to what fans think. They don't need to.

First of all, the opinions of a bandwagon fanbase are completely irrelevant. The real fans will support the team regardless, and the bandwagon fans will come out as long as the team wins. In order to win, you make moves that believe help the ballclub, regardless of the player you are trading. Very few players in the big leagues reach irreplaceable status, and Dan Uggla is not one of them. I'm sure the fanbase was disheartened when the likes of Josh Beckett, Juan Pierre, etc. were traded, yet those worked out very well for the organization. The front office has to do what's best to put a winning product on the field, with the limited resources it has.

That's the attitude of a team that likes playing in front of empty seats. The Marlins have been making moves that "help the ball club" for years ... and bleeding fans all the while. Because of its history, this team needs to pay its fan favorites until they can no longer play in order to prove to fans that the goal isn't to field a AAA ball club and pocket the savings. Guys like you may have a deeper understanding of the benefits of trading Uggla for prospects, but to 90% of fans and 100% of the general population ... it just looks like another round of the Marlins shipping off its best players to avoid paying them. The fact that the Marlins are getting a new stadium is just going to make it look even worse.

 

 

Sorry...but you're wrong. The Marlins don't need to keep certain players because the fans like them. Those "fans" don't understand the business aspect of the sport. The Marlins will do what they feel is best to win in a cost efficient way (because not every team is the Yankees), just like every team does. Every team goes about their business the same way. Try to field a winning team with what you have to work with. You win...the fans will come.

 

Losing Dan Uggla isn't going to hurt this club for years. Dan Uggla is not Miguel Cabrera. For what it's worth, losing Miguel Cabrera is not what set this franchise back; losing Miguel Cabrera and getting close to no production from the players we received in that trade is what hurt the franchise.

 

Losing players doesn't hurt you if you replace them the right way.

 

But if the Marlins did, indeed, use your strategy, Juan Pierre would still be here (one of the worst contracts in baseball...if I might add, no Ricky Nolasco), declining Josh Beckett would still be here (and if I might add...no Hanley Ramirez/Anibal Sanchez), Jorge Cantu would still be here (probably doesn't even belong in the big leagues anymore), Cody Ross would've been treated like a franchise player, etc., etc., etc. We'd be worse. Organizations don't pay attention to what fans think. They don't need to.

 

Amen.

 

Sorry, I just realllly disagreed with what he said and I'm totally with Erick here. I'm not a fan of bandwagon fans who think they know it all. If youre a bandwagon fan, understand your place and don't say a word when it comes to long term decisions made by the ballclub.

So, does no one else remember that Uggla/Ramirez interview where Dan says to Hanley "You make me better" and the Hanley says "No, you make me better," and then they argue about who makes who better?

 

And go on to gush about how wonderful it is to play with each other and for the Marlins? And how they're "brothers?"

 

Ah, what a difference 50 million, give or take, makes.

 

 

I agree but I'm still holding out hope that this is just a misinterpretation from the media. How in the world did this side of Uggla come out of nowhere??? I gotta believe we are reading this story wrong and Dan will accept this offer or similar soon and then he'll give an interview shooting down the reports of him angling the team. It just doesnt make sense and doesnt line up to the Dan Uggla we know. I could be dead wrong of course, but this out of left field seems so absurd, Im not buying it yet.

So, does no one else remember that Uggla/Ramirez interview where Dan says to Hanley "You make me better" and the Hanley says "No, you make me better," and then they argue about who makes who better?

 

And go on to gush about how wonderful it is to play with each other and for the Marlins? And how they're "brothers?"

 

Ah, what a difference 50 million, give or take, makes.

 

 

I agree but I'm still holding out hope that this is just a misinterpretation from the media. How in the world did this side of Uggla come out of nowhere??? I gotta believe we are reading this story wrong and Dan will accept this offer or similar soon and then he'll give an interview shooting down the reports of him angling the team. It just doesnt make sense and doesnt line up to the Dan Uggla we know. I could be dead wrong of course, but this out of left field seems so absurd, Im not buying it yet.

 

 

There was speculation that Cody had been trying to convince him to not sign with Florida and sign with the Giants after next year.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.