Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Will DH come to NL?

Featured Replies

I would agree with this change of mlb rule

 

1. Pitchers would no longer run the risk of getting hurt, either in the batters box or running the bases.

 

2. Pitchers should stay Pitchers.

 

3. In a clutch situation it is more advisable for a proper hitter to come to bat, not a pitcher who rarely trains as a batter, the pitcher should focus more on pitching , not hitting, this would take abit of the pressure off the pitcher.

 

I just dont see what the benefit is of the pitcher hitting in the 9 spot. If anyone is worried about the pitcher hitting another batter and not facing any penalty (ie, getting hit back in retaliation) then mlb can always up the punishment as a deterrent of NOT hitting a batter on purpose.

 

Link

 

http://sportsillustr...nav&sct=hp_nv_a

I hate this.

I enjoy the fact that managers are actually relevant in the National League.

Speculation.

 

 

I would agree with this change of mlb rule

 

1. Pitchers would no longer run the risk of getting hurt, either in the batters box or running the bases.

 

2. Pitchers should stay Pitchers.

 

 

I guess they should make a rule that doesn't allow pitchers to field their position because they can get hurt. I mean they are pitchers, not fielders, correct?

I think it will happen at some point, mainly for the reasons stated

 

Pitchers are getting more specialized each year, there would be roster accomodations to add a DH across the league which would make the union happy, the voices of people calling out "i want to see hitters hit" becomes louder and the old style managers/fans are dying off

 

I would absolutely hate it though - much prefer the NL game to the AL game

  • Author

Seems like Im the only one who likes this, by the way, I think its only an idea right now. But im surprised at how many of you hate it, I feel like the black sheep when it comes this issue.

It's not a bad thing to like it, you're a guy who likes more offense, it seems. That's perfectly fine. Just, as Erick said, "managers are actually relevant" without the DH.

I feel that this would further dumb baseball down and lead to worse and worse rule changes. All year interleague is already awful. Watering down the postseason is already awful. Do we need more awful in this awesome sport?

 

Also, a shortstop should stay a shortstop. He should concentrate on fielding his position and not have to worry about offense. Let's add a second DH. One hundred years from now, will we have nine offensive players and nine defensive players? A pitcher is a baseball player. Part of playing baseball is hitting, another part is playing the field, whether as a pitcher or a fielder. Yes, that means that I consider DHs to be half players.

Also, a shortstop should stay a shortstop. He should concentrate on fielding his position and not have to worry about offense.

 

I've heard about this in some softball leagues, called a "flex" player.

 

Not sure how "flex" you can really call that, though.

  • Author

I feel that this would further dumb baseball down and lead to worse and worse rule changes. All year interleague is already awful. Watering down the postseason is already awful. Do we need more awful in this awesome sport?

 

Also, a shortstop should stay a shortstop. He should concentrate on fielding his position and not have to worry about offense. Let's add a second DH. One hundred years from now, will we have nine offensive players and nine defensive players? A pitcher is a baseball player. Part of playing baseball is hitting, another part is playing the field, whether as a pitcher or a fielder. Yes, that means that I consider DHs to be half players.

 

I agree that interleague play has had its days, was never a fan of that.

I have mixed feelings about this. All the reasons why the NL should have it are great and valid, but there's still something about tradition. Also, the strategy of baseball is what makes it great, and I feel like that would simply take it all away.

 

On the other hand, it makes games more exciting, and it also gives more opportunity to players looking to advance to the ML level that are blocked at a position. For instance, Chris Coghlan would have a real shot at getting back into the starting lineup... a guy with no real position but a strong bat.

 

I'm on the fence and could go either way.

DL Hughley

I would agree with this change of mlb rule

 

1. Pitchers would no longer run the risk of getting hurt, either in the batters box or running the bases.

 

2. Pitchers should stay Pitchers.

 

3. In a clutch situation it is more advisable for a proper hitter to come to bat, not a pitcher who rarely trains as a batter, the pitcher should focus more on pitching , not hitting, this would take abit of the pressure off the pitcher.

 

I feel that same way, but about sh*tty hitters. We should be able to get someone like Jim Thome to hit instead of having to watch John Buck or Omar Infante go up there and swing a bat. Fielders should stay fielders.

I would agree with this change of mlb rule

 

1. Pitchers would no longer run the risk of getting hurt, either in the batters box or running the bases.

 

2. Pitchers should stay Pitchers.

 

3. In a clutch situation it is more advisable for a proper hitter to come to bat, not a pitcher who rarely trains as a batter, the pitcher should focus more on pitching , not hitting, this would take abit of the pressure off the pitcher.

 

I feel that same way, but about sh*tty hitters. We should be able to get someone like Jim Thome to hit instead of having to watch John Buck or Omar Infante go up there and swing a bat. Fielders should stay fielders.

So you're saying you enjoy watching John Buck play the field?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.