Fish of the Year

[Admin]

Who gets it?

 

 

[pollythewog]

dont think a vote is needed brah

 

 

[Admin]

dont think a vote is needed brah

 

I know but its a formality.

 

 

[SilverBullet]

Cashner?

 

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

 

 

[Admin]

Cashner?

 

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

 

 

@Michael, trash needs to be taken out please

 

 

[Admin]

Chris Paddack

 

 

[fanofthefish]

There is a little room for discussion, Yelich had a 5.1 WAR to Jose's 4.7 which really isn't arguable, factoring an everyday player against someone that plays every five days and then having to  dismiss the passing of Jose and also if given the option I would have split my vote between the two, but since I can't  I gotta go with Yelly.

 

 

[SilverBullet]

Yeah ill say jose for obvious reasons but Yelich is probably the real mvp. Jose had several bad starts sprinkled in this year.

 

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

 

 

[pollythewog]

There is a little room for discussion, Yelich had a 5.1 WAR to Jose's 4.7 which really isn't arguable, factoring an everyday player against someone that plays every five days and then having to  dismiss the passing of Jose and also if given the option I would have split my vote between the two, but since I can't  I gotta go with Yelly.

 

if you go by FG WAR (imo is the best) is 6.2 jose to yelich 4.0. Jose in a landslide either way

 

 

[pollythewog]

jose had the 5th highest k% in mlb history. Yelcih is an above average OFerr. It's really not close

 

 

[FloridaMarlinsForever]

Martin Prado

 

 

[Admin]

Maybe the poll is more than a formality!

 

 

[pollythewog]

there is an arguable case, terrible tragedy aside, that jose could get the Cy. to think prado or yelich had a better year than him  is really...silly

 

 

[Admin]

there is an arguable case, terrible tragedy aside, that jose could get the Cy. to think prado or yelich had a better year than him is really...silly

 

I fully agree. It is a shame that people will say he only won cause he died if he wins it. He really did have a superb season.

 

 

[pollythewog]

I fully agree. It is a shame that people will say he only won cause he died if he wins it. He really did have a superb season.

 

6.2 WAR is all i need to see

 

 

[pollythewog]

Maybe the poll is more than a formality!

 

if i have to ill make 25 fake accounts to make sure jose wins

 

 

[CyggyMarlin]

No contest.  This is your guy.

 

[ATTACH]1189._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

[Admin]

^Lies

 

 

[Admin]

if you go by FG WAR (imo is the best) is 6.2 jose to yelich 4.0. Jose in a landslide either way

 

I'm not a fan of their WAR for pitchers.

 

 

[SixYearItch]

Hate to say anything negative in regard to Jose but he did disappoint on the road. As an everyday guy who kept the team afloat with Prado, I'd have to give Best Fish to Yellie.

 

 

[pollythewog]

Hate to say anything negative in regard to Jose but he did disappoint on the road. As an everyday guy who kept the team afloat with Prado, I'd have to give Best Fish to Yellie.

 

And Yelich was pretty disappointing at home (.774 ops) and against lefties (.720 ops) if you wanna play the split game

 

 

[CoastieMike]

Jose is Fish of the Century. End of story. 

 

 

[el_gmac]

it was between Jose and Martin, have to go with Jose, he had an awesome season, Prado was very close to get my vote

 

 

[dim]

If Stanton played like his 2012 self all the time, him and Yelich would be such a force to reckon with in the lineup. 

 

Jose Fernandez was the team's best player this year, and I'm honestly not factoring for the tragedy. Him and Yelich were clearly ahead of the rest of the team, and Jose gets the nod for the simple fact that he was keeping a starting rotation that is otherwise bottom 3 in baseball without him afloat in a playoff race. 

 

The starting rotation next season is going to be rough next season and honestly the next three or four years until they start hitting on draft picks (Dillon Peters being the one minor league arm I think could become a regular starter).

 

 

[bmg42]

This is a trick question, right? Outside of Adam Conley when he was healthy, we had exactly one SP we could count on all year. Jose pitched 29 times, and we won 18 of those games. And if Mathis and Hech were playing, he probably could have hit seventh. You can talk about WAR for a pitcher vs. a hitter, or how hitters are more valuable than starters, but on this team a replacement starter was worse than your average fill-in. Yelich was terrific, as was Ozuna in he first half. But at not-quite full strength Jose was clearly our best player.