Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins listening on everyone except Sandy

Featured Replies

19 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

For my own knowledge, is:

A FV50 bat (likely CF) for Salas/prospect trade. Play now player. We like this player ala Cabrera/Meyer enthusiasm.

and

Rizzo. Let's just say he comes home.

A major overhaul with a new manager?

Fortes, Stallings
Rizzo
Jazz
Wendle, Rojas
Anderson, Williams
Bleday
FV50, Sanchez
Garcia, Soler
Midseason - Groshans, Berry, Eury, Eder, Sixto

Every pitcher is retained. All of them. And Cooper and Berti were shot out here for two more RP with options to mix and match.


I'm looking for a floor of what is deemed acceptable as I am curious.


 

I think you will see Groshans sooner than midyear 2023 though. 

Just now, Das Texan said:

I have no idea.  someone not employed by this organization currently ideally. 

So Denbo it is!

10 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Dude, 95% of the posts on this board (and most boards) are jokes, quips, one-liners.  Nobody is here for a peer-reviewed scientific study on how long a post has to be before people lose interest. 

 

Which is beyond annoying tbh. 

4 minutes ago, hovertical said:

Dude, 95% of the posts on this board (and most boards) are jokes, quips, one-liners.  Nobody is here for a peer-reviewed scientific study on how long a post has to be before people lose interest. 

You tend to ignore facts unless it's ones you've personally approved of.  I'm all good here. I come for fun banter.  It's also why I donated money to this site to keep it going. It's filled with amazing people to laugh with.

My dude, you are the one making alternative facts here with the eyeball comments and believing .400 BABIP players hold up. And when you get called out on it and lack substance to defend a stance, you go into this holier than though self serving shit and jokes, memes, and gifs*. It's a defense mechanism. Like you can literally say, oh shit DLC has a .400 BABIP. Well this isn't real. That sucks. 

I'm looking for non-shitty baseball analysis, and frankly, there is a lot of it here which I am VERY HOPEFUL is due to frustration with the team (which is VERY warranted) and better days are ahead.

I say this last piece genuinely - please let me know when I am ignoring some fact as that means something is being learned which is the goal. To note, telling me Sanchez looks bad in the field this play or that play is not ignoring something. Michael showing some actually statistics from professionals, that is something.

5 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

What Im basically saying is that I dont buy that Sanchez has really been average in CF this year defensively.  The stats I guess seem to show he has been averageish, but eyeballs say something different. 

Given that he literally cannot hit a left handed pitcher there is no way he can ever be considered to be a true cornerstone piece anyway on a side note.  Maybe he learns to hit lefties before he hits 30.  

If Marlins get an offer on him this winter for someone useful, they might be wise to move on from him and see if some other organization can instill in him the ability to hit lefties, because at this point, he is basically a part time player and you don't build around part time players.  

100%

But, he has upside (hits RHP sort of) and defense should play in a corner, so combined with lack of options, he should probably be on the team and we'll see if Burdick beats him out next summer. I suspect Bleday has a longer leash and Garcia makes $$$. And they will get a CF, even if its not the one we want/they need.

3 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

I think you will see Groshans sooner than midyear 2023 though. 

Maybe? No slugging yet and let's be real, 15 days into the season buys a year of control, and June 15th give or take buys you one less arbitration year.

We can hate it, but there is the financial aspect of this. He may be good enough to do this with. At minimum, at least mid-April.

I'm anticipating summer, but I hope you are right as that means he is great.

2 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

100%

But, he has upside (hits RHP sort of) and defense should play in a corner, so combined with lack of options, he should probably be on the team and we'll see if Burdick beats him out next summer. I suspect Bleday has a longer leash and Garcia makes $$$. And they will get a CF, even if its not the one we want/they need.

I dont even care if they get a guy who will hit .230 but provide stellar defense.

They might want to give the Yankees a call this winter to inquire about Harrison Bader if his foot is healthy as an example (though he has worked himself up to a .250ish hitter)

1 minute ago, MarlinsLou said:

Maybe? No slugging yet and let's be real, 15 days into the season buys a year of control, and June 15th give or take buys you one less arbitration year.

We can hate it, but there is the financial aspect of this. He may be good enough to do this with. At minimum, at least mid-April.

I'm anticipating summer, but I hope you are right as that means he is great.

I think you'll see him late April, after some 'seasoning' 

Because they will be too cheap to acquire someone to allow him more time and I also think guys like Anderson will not be back.  

A new manager will want to deploy Wendle properly (i.e play him all over), so they will need a 3b. 

3 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

I think you'll see him late April, after some 'seasoning' 

Because they will be too cheap to acquire someone to allow him more time and I also think guys like Anderson will not be back.  

A new manager will want to deploy Wendle properly (i.e play him all over), so they will need a 3b. 

I can see them doing this:

Jazz
Wendle, Rojas
Berti/Anderson, Williams (who is kind of alright!)

Groshans is next up and frankly, someone is getting hurt so he will get time.

Berti/Anderson is traded for a RP.

This is honestly a lot of flexibility and not a bad idea if they do something big in CF, and presumably maybe get a better 1B as not sure where else you can upgrade offensively unless you get like Danny Janson and have a really elite C platoon, ditching Stallings.

They have options. We'll see.

15 hours ago, MarlinsLou said:

What? I gave up on this team before you and everyone else besides Das. Just so you know.

They are losing no players. None of them are losing any perceivable value for who they are. Pablo is very valuable. Everyone else not so much. Flyer prospects, FV45 low ends at best (like what Wendle was traded for). None of this moves the needle whether they move or don't. No goalpost is being moved. 

This is making a mountain out of a mole hole complaining about deadline trades. She didn't not trade W. Contreras. THAT'S a real problem. 

This is a little annoying, but it's not a big deal. If they go this offseason and don't get a major CF, that's a big deal.

Agree with Lou 100%

10 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

I can see them doing this:

Jazz
Wendle, Rojas
Berti/Anderson, Williams (who is kind of alright!)

Groshans is next up and frankly, someone is getting hurt so he will get time.

Berti/Anderson is traded for a RP.

This is honestly a lot of flexibility and not a bad idea if they do something big in CF, and presumably maybe get a better 1B as not sure where else you can upgrade offensively unless you get like Danny Janson and have a really elite C platoon, ditching Stallings.

They have options. We'll see.

I trust that you will see Fortes as the everyday catcher next year which may not be a bad idea.  I need to look at his advanced metrics a bit more but I like what I see from him in general at this point so they may not need to really focus on acquiring a catcher.  

Diaz is a guy who I think he is who he is at this point.  Thats a spot they really should look to upgrade. 

3 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

I trust that you will see Fortes as the everyday catcher next year which may not be a bad idea.  I need to look at his advanced metrics a bit more but I like what I see from him in general at this point so they may not need to really focus on acquiring a catcher.  

Diaz is a guy who I think he is who he is at this point.  Thats a spot they really should look to upgrade. 

Fortes should have a 100 game/62 game heavy split with Stallings... or they can radically get another catcher and maybe that guy also dabbles as a DH (or 1B). I'm honestly fine with Fortes/Stallings (anticipate some sort of defensive rebound with Stallings). Fortes is a real gem maybe. He has earned a long shot. I think the slugging drops and he may just be a high .600 OPS bat, but that is also pretty fine as he isn't a defensive liability (so says the experts anyways). I think they may have done it again ala Nola-Barnes-Realmuto. Found a catcher who is going to have some real value for years. Fingers crossed. Hopefully at worst he gets them to Mack who is good whenever he can play.

I agree on Diaz... which is why I think Rizzo is going to be the main FA target. Cheaper than Nimmo/Swanson in annual contract and years.... they can trade Cooper/Lewin for relievers. Local pull. Big name. I mean it's an upgrade, but it's not in itself moving the needle unless the CF is a monster. Monster

8 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

Fortes should have a 100 game/62 game heavy split with Stallings... or they can radically get another catcher and maybe that guy also dabbles as a DH (or 1B). I'm honestly fine with Fortes/Stallings (anticipate some sort of defensive rebound with Stallings). Fortes is a real gem maybe. He has earned a long shot. I think the slugging drops and he may just be a high .600 OPS bat, but that is also pretty fine as he isn't a defensive liability (so says the experts anyways). I think they may have done it again ala Nola-Barnes-Realmuto. Found a catcher who is going to have some real value for years. Fingers crossed. Hopefully at worst he gets them to Mack who is good whenever he can play.

I agree on Diaz... which is why I think Rizzo is going to be the main FA target. Cheaper than Nimmo/Swanson in annual contract and years.... they can trade Cooper/Lewin for relievers. Local pull. Big name. I mean it's an upgrade, but it's not in itself moving the needle unless the CF is a monster. Monster

If the Marlins go into 2023 with a Fortes/Stallings duo at catcher you take that and are ok with it.  

You want guys that are at worst average in terms of game calling with your pitching as your strength.  I think both of these can and will do that.

Hats off to Nick Fortes for basically earning this based on his play. 

1 minute ago, SonOfJack said:

Would he be willing to take a 12 mil AAV though? That's been Sherman's ceiling in free agency.

He'd be walking away from $16, so no. But I think they'd give him 3/$50 with an opt out. I'm not saying this is the smartest idea, I'm saying this may be their budget range and he's still pretty good. Local guy to be the "leader."

They can easily fit this into $85m (cheap enough overall?) if they jettison Cooper, Lewin, Berti, Anderson, Floro, Hernandez, Scott, Okert, and get a CC CF.

The replacements there are Rizzo himself, Williams, Groshans, CC CF from likely mega trade, and four club controlled relievers, which is likely Neidert, trade return Cooper, trade return Anderson, and trade return Berti.... or maybe someone like Nardi breaks through. Basically, they have everyone already and they can trade those people and focus on RP..... Fortes/Stallings, Rizzo, Jazz, Wendle/Rojas, Wendle/Groshans, Bleday/Sanchez, new CF, Garcia/Sanchez, Soler, all pitchers. Credit Hovertical for short post here*

The team works if the CF is great, and Rogers/Garrett/Luzardo/Cabrera bring the heat. Eury/Eder/Sixto make it interesting later.

48 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

My dude, you are the one making alternative facts here with the eyeball comments and believing .400 BABIP players hold up. And when you get called out on it and lack substance to defend a stance, you go into this holier than though self serving shit and jokes, memes, and gifs*. It's a defense mechanism. Like you can literally say, oh shit DLC has a .400 BABIP. Well this isn't real. That sucks. 

 

What exactly am I need of defending myself from? It's a message board dude. And not once did I ever say that that average would hold up.  What I did say was that Don should play the hot hand instead of sitting a guy who was getting nearly every hit ball to drop.  That's all I said.  I simply said he was worth playing to see if he could turn into a solid player because Soler was really bad and the offense he did provide came in situations when it just didn't matter anymore.  You're really reading something and taking it to an extreme and turning it into something that was simply not said. 

Another recent example of this was you wanting to know why people were upset we didn't trade Pablo.  Nary a single person said they were upset Pablo wasn't moved - yet there you were telling us that's what we were doing.  You just really take the smallest of nuggets and run with them and turn them into something that never existed in the first place.  I don't get it unless you just like to have someone to yell at and try to flex on?  I think that's YOUR defensive mechanism - just keep shouting and attempting to belittle the other person as much as you can by saying they don't know as much as "the experts". 

Personally, I prefer to use both stats AND the "eye test" which is also why teams still have extensive scouting departments.  A stat sheet can tell you that a player is performing poorly at the plate but it can't tell you that it's because his swing his a peculiar hitch in it necessarily.  A stat sheet can tell you that a player is adequately playing a position but it doesn't tell you that they can drastically improve with some better initial positioning or what's separating them from being great. 

But you go right on feeling 100% confident that you're right if that's what you need to get you through the day man. 

3 minutes ago, hovertical said:

What exactly am I need of defending myself from? It's a message board dude. And not once did I ever say that that average would hold up.  What I did say was that Don should play the hot hand instead of sitting a guy who was getting nearly every hit ball to drop.  That's all I said.  I simply said he was worth playing to see if he could turn into a solid player because Soler was really bad and the offense he did provide came in situations when it just didn't matter anymore.  You're really reading something and taking it to an extreme and turning it into something that was simply not said. 

Another recent example of this was you wanting to know why people were upset we didn't trade Pablo.  Nary a single person said they were upset Pablo wasn't moved - yet there you were telling us that's what we were doing.  You just really take the smallest of nuggets and run with them and turn them into something that never existed in the first place.  I don't get it unless you just like to have someone to yell at and try to flex on?  I think that's YOUR defensive mechanism - just keep shouting and attempting to belittle the other person as much as you can by saying they don't know as much as "the experts". 

Personally, I prefer to use both stats AND the "eye test" which is also why teams still have extensive scouting departments.  A stat sheet can tell you that a player is performing poorly at the plate but it can't tell you that it's because his swing his a peculiar hitch in it necessarily.  A stat sheet can tell you that a player is adequately playing a position but it doesn't tell you that they can drastically improve with some better initial positioning or what's separating them from being great. 

But you go right on feeling 100% confident that you're right if that's what you need to get you through the day man. 

No, you defended him harder and this is a revisionist history. As for Pablo, many comments made this was a golden opportunity lost (it's not) and Kim doesn't know what she's doing. And how could she not do anything. Ignoring they can do it in the offseason. It is boiled over frustration because they suck.

The last line is you. Hope you understand that. 

2 minutes ago, MarlinsLou said:

No, you defended him harder and this is a revisionist history. As for Pablo, many comments made this was a golden opportunity lost (it's not) and Kim doesn't know what she's doing. And how could she not do anything. Ignoring they can do it in the offseason. It is boiled over frustration because they suck.

The last line is you. Hope you understand that. 

I truly you find help with whatever it is that drives your burning need  for validation on a message board.  Seriously man. No message board is worth getting that wound up over.  I hope whatever happened to you in real life to turn you into this person heals over time. 

1 hour ago, MarlinsLou said:

Not sure I agree here. There was enthusiasm, and frankly, I agree to disagree he should have even been given a leash as the dumpster fire was clearly evident on the horizon. I suspect we can blame Kim again here for not even getting a MILB CF of note. Sorry Quinn and Hamilton. I've been saying this for months, all roads lead back to CF failure here. All of them.

I remember that debate, and I'm pretty sure the consensus was only that they ought to play the hot hand while hot, instead of a guy having a great game, and then he's benched the next day.

 

1 hour ago, Das Texan said:

The manager is done, he has basically more or less admitted to as much with recent comments.

Perfect time for an extension, in Marlins FO speak.

1 hour ago, hovertical said:

who would be your front-runner for manager if you were given the choice?

At this point, a pet rock would probably be better.

1 hour ago, MarlinsLou said:

I can see them doing this:

Jazz
Wendle, Rojas
Berti/Anderson, Williams (who is kind of alright!)

Groshans is next up and frankly, someone is getting hurt so he will get time.

Berti/Anderson is traded for a RP.

This is honestly a lot of flexibility and not a bad idea if they do something big in CF, and presumably maybe get a better 1B as not sure where else you can upgrade offensively unless you get like Danny Janson and have a really elite C platoon, ditching Stallings.

They have options. We'll see.

Ha.  Kim will bring Placido Polanco out of retirement for 4 weeks before calling anyone up.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.