Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. I want to disagree with Benched but I'm not sure enough he's wrong to do so. I think it will be telling how well the Brewers do over their next couple of series (and obviously how Marlins pitching fares in their next two). It's one of those chicken and egg things. We're winning because they aren't hitting, or we're winning because our pitching is shutting them down and out offense is outscoring them. The fan in me wants to go with the latter, but I'd be a liar if I said I knew definitively which it was.
  2. When Miggy switched agents to SFX (and I don't blame him) it signaled the end of his time here. He took the $150 million was happy as a pig in sh*t (all you have to do is go back and read the archived Detroit newspapers). Unfortunately he fell back on the same bad habits we more or less ignored because we loved him so - eating himself out of shape - and in Detroit third base and over to first, getting booed regularly and playing for a last place team. Every professional ballplayer will tell you it's a business first and these days his friends or an email or phone or video call away. I'm sure on one level he misses them but this is the bed he made. It's rather disingenuous to say the Marlins had the money when no one in their right mind knew they could make that kind of financial commitment going forward. There's probably less than a handful of teams in baseball that could, we all know their names. Maybe Miggy would have liked to stay here this year and next but while that may have kept his chummy club together a while longer where would that have left the Fish? With a couple of draft choices? Really. Before someone crawls down my throat for the above, please note I still carry Miggy's pic as mine and quote him as well. He was in his time as a Marlin one the greatest young talents I ever saw. I have all the respect in the world for the man, the player, but let's be real here, I doubt he sought Dave Hyde out to do this story. Hyde has had to shut up as the Marlins play better and better baseball, only coming out from under his rock when a few games didn't go the Marlins way to start his mockery and flame-throwing, and I'd bet dollars to doughnuts that another columnist without an axe to grind and better writing skills would have turned out a completely different story with the same time spent with our Miggy. Now that they're 20-14 and leading the division the only thing Hyde can come up with is a pity party for Miguel Cabrera, who probably was never looking for one when he made the mistake of answering Dave Hyde's call. As for Cantu and Cabrera this is just a snapshot, in the moment, not meant to equate two players who some might justifiably say don't belong together in the same sentence, but as of this morning Cabrera's line is .252/.342/.450 with six homeruns, 27 strikeouts and 59 total bases. Cantu is .280/.333/.480 with five homeruns, 28 strikeouts and 60 total bases. I don't know that's there's much difference in their production so far and at least Cantu is able to field his position (at least adequately) while Cabrera no longer could (less than adequately and moved to first). We lost a superstar, a mythic figure, an icon but so far we haven't lost much at the plate if at all and looking at their respective defense in 2008 may have actually improved slightly. It's a shame that Miggy was used like this by a columnist who has an axe to grind, it really is. Let's face it media scum like Hyde have no morality or pledge when it comes to truth-telling. Miggy was simply a pawn in Hyde's ongoing assault on the Marlins every chance he gets, the real reason for the piece and let's not forget that.
  3. Both Cantu and Amezaga made some terrific plays last night and to say otherwise is unfair at the very least. It would be interesting to watch the result if everyone here being held to the same standard in their workplace (whether it be educational or occupational) as is seemingly demanded from others. Cantu and Amezaga will never be confused with Brooks Robinson and Willy Mays but good play is good play regardless. I was there, I admit to not remembering exactly how the play went down other than it was hard hit and Cantu probably has made the play before (but I do know an official scorer did erase the error and awarded a hit), and if people think AA's second death-defying catch last night against the wall was a matter of him not getting a good jump you have no argument with me. He made that one look harder than need be. But the first one, the one almost universally recognized as the one or two best plays in baseball yesterday deserves better. He got a great jump on a line drive that was moving away from him, never gave up on it, and ultimately sacrificed his body to make the catch. Neither player is or will ever be superstars, or even stars, but last night both of them were significant contributors to the team's nineteenth victory of the season. I don't know what else anyone can expect from a utility infielder playing centerfield and a guy signed as a non-roster invitee whose two-run homer answered the one just plated by the Brewers. Cantu is getting better and better at third as the season progresses but if the standard is absolute unfailing perfection, I don't know any ballplayer (or anyone here for that matter) who can live up to that level of scrutiny and expectation. If that's the case let's look to determine whether the right fielder could have made more of an effort on a catchable foul ball or the catcher maybe called the wrong pitch when he "should" have known a baserunner was stealing or the shortstop not diving for a ball up the middle. Who else should we put under the microscope? Last night was a terrific game to attend, there was a lot of excitement, Badenhop's enthusiasm overflowing, a whole bunch of very good defense. This team plays as well as they did last night for the rest of the season and we'll be playing in October (it's a figure of speech, I'm not saying we will, either play this well every night or be in the playoffs).
  4. I am inclined to pass on Jones doesnt really fit into our plans. Give Carroll a shot at the very least the guy has a decent glove What's the worst that happens with Carroll? He platoons with Amezaga, puts up Ross-like numbers and after 100 ABs or so we have at least some small idea of his abilities to play everyday. Personally I'm as concerned about Willingham going forward as CF, and getting Carroll acclimated to ML pitching seems a no-brainer. In Fredi's defense, the team is winning, why mess with success? At least it's better than the alternative.
  5. For all the great numbers in McPherson's line the one not often picked up on is 40 strikeouts in less than thirty games. At some time later on a change might be justified but you'd think Cantu was hitting below the Mendoza line with Cody Ross instead of .271/.323 in a slump. As bad as Ross' BA at .164, his OBP is underwater as well at a piddling .186. In comparison (for obvious reasons recognizing they're in far different levels of development)) you have to give Maybin credit that even with his boatload of strikeouts and average in the mid-260s, his OBP is above .400. Even on his worst day with his average in freefall in Carolina he's was able to get on base at least at a .350 or so clip. I have no grudge against Ross, never had, never will, his days here are numbered if he doesn't turn it around.
  6. I'm not sure why Fredi has seemingly banished Carroll to the very end of the bench after being called up from AAA with a line (.418/.480/.896/1.376) that you would think most teams would find a spot for. Considering we're deficient at not one but two outfield positions I was surprised at his lack of playing time BUT we're winning and Gonzo's contributing and...well being a few percentage points on top of the NL East sure beats the cellar where every reporter, columnist and self-professed expert in print or the internet guaranteed we'd be. One thing that brings value to Rotoworld is their news capsules don't expire with time so if you want you can go back through a player's career and gain some insight that looking at numbers can't provide, at least from a causal standpoint you can. In looking at Jones' historical news one of the things most troubling to the Cubs was his fall off in homeruns from 27 in 2006 to 5 in 2007 with only eighty less at bats. That and he wanted out of Chicago. A common thread at Rotoworld and elsewhere questions whether he's a capable CFer any more and offensively can he be anything more than a platoon player at best? Dolphin Stadium and its cavernous CF begs the question can he still play the position? And not that it's necessarily relevant other than to provide some prospective, this fall off in production has been going on since the beginning of spring training, it didn't start last week. A lot of this has as much to do with Willingham's back as CF. Ross very well might have been gone two weeks ago were it not for the situation with Josh and is still the odd man out if the Marlins pull the trigger on this or another unannounced move. The unforeseen effect of Willingham's back is that the Marlins have lost any edge they might have had at the trading table. BTW, it might be worth noting that the same Sun-Sentinel giving credence to this Jones thing (but to be fair everyone else is out on that ledge with them) had him already signed, sealed and delivered to the Marlins last summer, getting way ahead of themselves on the story that never happened. In this case where's there's smoke there's probably fire, but you have to ask yourself if Jacque Jones is worth trading for (as in compensation going back to the Tigers and/or paying anything other than the absolute minimum) rather than letting the eight more days pass and grabbing him off the discard heap? If the Padres or someone else really wants him that badly it won't be the end of the world if we miss out. We're in first place this morning in part because Beinfest, Hill and company are right more often than they're wrong. If they pull the trigger on a trade for Jones, or they wait and try to acquire him on the open market, or they ultimately pass on him, you have to say they know what they're doing as much fun as it is second-guessing them. But in the meantime why Cody Ross continues to play while showing absolutely nothing this season and a kid who very well may have a future at a couple of positions sits at the end of the bench baffles me. For the time being I'm taking Fredi at his word that while Carroll may be on the bench currently "...but only right now" there are plans for him down the road. When that trip starts I have no idea but Fredi was quoted as saying Carroll would probably get a start in this Milwaukee series, that is if they can thaw him out in time.
  7. I see what you're talking about...sheesh you go out of town for a while...it wasn't the LAST four games which i assumed because i wasn't here, it was four games from 19th-22nd...I see what you mean. what throws you off is he was hitting .263 before that streak, but in the immortal words of ex-wives everywhere, and the favorite words they love to hear "you were right and I was wrong". lolol
  8. I'm too lazy to go back through a list of FAs but I also didn't mean in the 500k cheap we got Cantu on, and upwards of 5m, where cheap because argumentative. as far as the math goes In that 4 game hot streak, he has 10 h in 17ab. his year totals are 29h and 94 ab. (29-10)/(94-17) = 19/77 = .2467... (so round up to .247). He was a MONSTER in those 4 games, but just as you say, we're at such a short part in the season that stats get skewed easily. Outside of those 4 games, where he just absolutely crushed the ball, he has not been very good. He's had good games, yes, but also a lot of not so good. There has to be something wrong in the math because since April 10th his average was never down to .247 and look at his average for the last ten days on his bio page. he was hitting ...let me go look...maybe I'm wrong but...
  9. I do believe they are stretching out Waetcher for an eventual slot in the rotation whether they make trade a move or not.
  10. 1) There were a TON of cheap CF options this past offseason. Hell Lofton is still available although I doubt he'd come here. 2) It's extremely unlikely Cody keeps up at this pace and at the very least should put up a good OPS against LHP 3) Carroll would put up roughtly a low .700 OPS, being fair. Based of the past few years, and optimistic OPS for Cantu would be mid to high .700 OPS. And the main difference then would be that Cantu is one of the worst defensive IFers in the game, whereas Brett is an above average defender. It'll likely increase our OF defense aswell...I'm unsure if Carroll will have as much range as Alfredo, but at the very least you're looking at a huge difference at arms to make it at worst push. Cantu had a big 4 game hot streak. You can't take those numbers away from him, you can remove any player's "good" games to make him look bad, but we're at such a small sample size at this point in the season that it also greatly skews his numbers. Outside of those 4 games, including tonights game, he has a .247/.318/.377/.695 line, and I think that's more along the lines he'll be. And again, his defense has been as bad as advertised, not just with his range but his bad arm. 1) Who exactly were these "cheap" centerfielders? For the record, the words "cheap" and "Lofton" shouldn't be used in the same sentence. And I like Kenny Lofton. 2) It's unlikely Cody is a member of the team in a week or ten days unless he absolutely blows up. His days are numbered. The only thing that saves him is an injury to a starter. 3) Stating what Carroll will or won't do is 100% fantasy. 4) Your assessment of Cantu's month is 100% wrong, I'm going to chalk it up to bad math because I know you well enough that you wouldn't purposely make stuff up just to further a good character assassination as some others might. Maybe you were looking someone else's numbers or you looked in the wrong column, but previous to Cantu's "four game hit streak", he wasn't hitting .247 for the season, here's his BA (I didn't bother to write all the additional OBP etc stats down): april 11 263 12 267 13 265 15 255 16 273 17 263 19 295 20 308 21 314 22 338 23 325 25 309 26 294 27 289 29 309 Each of these came from the MLB scorecard page, end of each game. I didn't start until the eleventh because before that the numbers fluctuate so wildly they aren't representative of anything. Two weeks ago Cameron Maybin was batting (from memory) .474, and so many wanted him called up, he's hitting .214 after his last game. I also didn't bother accumulating the other stats but obviously if he wasn't hitting .247 five days ago (actually .325) I have to assume the OBP of .318 has to be way off as well as the rest of the line. According to the MLB Player's Page he's hit .359 for his last ten games. As for his arm, I haven't seen anything close to a problem in that department to call his arm "bad" but I guess if you see what you want to see (and I was out of town for three days and missed last night's game so if he made some huge error I admit to not seeing it). He has made some defensive miscues to be sure but at the same time he hasn't been a total embarrassment there either. I remember watching him the other night unable to field a ball cleanly but smart enough to use his body to keep the ball in front of him and eventually throw the runner out at first. This is not Brooks Robinson at third base but considering the circumstances he's done a reasonably good job defensively. And the range argument, I have no idea where that comes from. None at all. Not in 2008. We've all seen him make plays on the foul side of the bag, rush bunts and grounders, move to his left pretty darn well. Absolutely he makes more errors than you want from an MLB third baseman but this is a guy who was never a third baseman, and had played a grand total of one (1) game there since 2006 (a total of 62 in 2005). I looked at his three basic defensive stats and he's in the middle of the pack on one and towards the bottom in the other two, but again if you have actually seen the guy play this season you can't call his defense "bad". It's wrong and unfair. There are guys in each category you'd love having play here. I think you have to look at the totality of the package and for what we're paying the offensive dividend we're getting his weaknesses are outweighed by his shortcomings.
  11. from the Miami Herald: The Marlins return home with 15 victories, matching a franchise-high for April. They think they can continue the magic. ''Why not?'' Ramirez said. ``Absolutely. We don't have to show nobody. They're going to find out. ``We don't care what other people say, what other people think about us. I don't care if people feel surprised. ``All I care about is how hard we play.'' The naysayers think this kind of talk means nothing. Frankly I think you have to be blind or dead to not see it. Who wants to tell Hanley that he's wrong? In a twisted sort of way perhaps the snubs early on in this run by the media local and national, and the ridicule right to and including opening day may have really brought this team together. I can't say definitively who istarted it or even what it is, but these guys have that f*** you attitude down. Hanley is not embarrassed to proclaim himself King Fish. All hail the King :notworthy http://www.miamiherald.com/589/story/512044.html
  12. He's going to make a lot in arbitration next year. At least $3 mil, more if he keeps hitting. That is not young and cheap (for the Marlins). If they are somehow contending, they will simply hold him through the season, and trade him in the offseason. I agree with Eric. If they can get anything for Cantu at the deadline, they will pretty much do it. And that will be one successful as hell FA signing, and big ups to Beinfest for finding an adequate 3B stopgap for 4 months of the season, that brings us back something in the end. Lou I'm honestly confused trying to figure out your macro position on trading at the July deadline. Maybe I'm just reading the above wrong - it seems like you are saying two different things although I doubt you it - are you saying regardless of whether (big IF) they are contending or not to trade away Cantu (and from your previous posts up to 10-12 other players) OR are you saying IF they are contending to wait until the off-season to trade Cantu and others? I assume you don't think they will be contending by the end of June (which is a valid supposition) and in that case trade him away. Is that right?
  13. Wow how quickly things can change. That's April for you.
  14. Lecturing anyone about intelligence isn't your strong suit so don't go there. What you are is a classic dogmatist. I'm still trying to figure what taking walks has to do with making contact since by definition he's laying off pitches out of the strike zone that he shouldn't be swinging at. This strike outs/putting the ball in play argument that has gone on here for three, four years, after a while it does getting boring and the answer is there is no answer. Those who believe one way can point to their facts and figures, people on the other side the same. But you know what you're probably right I could have not mentioned it, I'm just fed up with these never-ending arguments. As for Cantu he is making great contact this season even when he makes outs. Striking out 100 times sounds like a big number and nothing to be proud of, but the truth is if he only strikes out 100 times in 2008 he'll have a helluva year. In today's game it's hardly out of the norm. In fact the list of premier players with over 100 strikeouts last season would make quite a lineup. I don't know that's a benchmark that makes any sense these days unless you want to indict Cabrera, Wright, Soriano, D Lee, Willingham and Hermida in 2/3 of a season, A-Rod. The list is almost endless. There's Ryan Howard's 199 SOs or BJ Upton or Granderson, Tulowitzki, etc. etc. etc. Collectively guys who struck out a hundred times or more last season looks like a who's who of major league stars. But I'm really hoping you're right and all he does is strike out 100 times this season. That would be really great! Are you lecturing me about the unimportance of strikeouts? I had no qualms with him striking out, it's your assertion that he is making good contact that I was arguing with. He is, arguably, making less contact than he has at any point in his career. This is all I was saying, no need to get your chest all puffed out and angry. I know since Swifty left you don't have anyone to have cat fights with, but please don't pick me. And really, if you want to compare Cantu to any of those guys, you are out of your f***ing mind. 100 Ks is still probably higher than average, so if you want to say he's making good contact, he isn't. The only thing Cantu has in common with anyone you listed is he might strike out 100 times, and he's a professional baseball player. Seems to me you're the one looking for a fight (and playing the victim) over some tiny thing you could have let pass especially since I said you were probably right about it in the first place. But that shoudn't surprise anyone. So let's recap, I agree I didn't need to bring one thing up and I took your 100 strikeout number as legitimate, only making the point an awful lot of established major leaguers do far worse each season, using names people would recognize to make the point but that's not enough for you, you have to go on and say I'm out of my "f*cking mind" and I'm looking for a catfight and I'm equating Cantu with them, which I never did. It was about the number in today's game among agressive-style hitters. Read what I wrote. You pass opinion off as fact all the time (that's the definition of a dogmatist and frankly have a right to your opinion) and then go out off if anyone disagrees with ridicule and name-calling. It has been your style since the day you arrived on the scene. You and Swift deserve each other. The modus operandi is the same. You're not an idiot, I don't treat you like one either. You might want to brush up on the hubris thing and let someone else have an opinion of their own without a lecture and name-calling, or passing fiction off as fact.
  15. yeah we did you know I find this funny that gameday is ahead of radio considering during spring trainng you could wait 10 minutes for an updates. plus they have really really improved on gameday, it's really quite impressive.
  16. Lecturing anyone about intelligence isn't your strong suit so don't go there. What you are is a classic dogmatist. I'm still trying to figure what taking walks has to do with making contact since by definition he's laying off pitches out of the strike zone that he shouldn't be swinging at. This strike outs/putting the ball in play argument that has gone on here for three, four years, after a while it does getting boring and the answer is there is no answer. Those who believe one way can point to their facts and figures, people on the other side the same. But you know what you're probably right I could have not mentioned it, I'm just fed up with these never-ending arguments. As for Cantu he is making great contact this season even when he makes outs. Striking out 100 times sounds like a big number and nothing to be proud of, but the truth is if he only strikes out 100 times in 2008 he'll have a helluva year. In today's game it's hardly out of the norm. In fact the list of premier players with over 100 strikeouts last season would make quite a lineup. I don't know that's a benchmark that makes any sense these days unless you want to indict Cabrera, Wright, Soriano, D Lee, Willingham and Hermida in 2/3 of a season, A-Rod. The list is almost endless. There's Ryan Howard's 199 SOs or BJ Upton or Granderson, Tulowitzki, etc. etc. etc. Collectively guys who struck out a hundred times or more last season looks like a who's who of major league stars. But I'm really hoping you're right and all he does is strike out 100 times this season. That would be really great!
  17. adjusted for at bats cantu is one hit behind hanley %-wise. cantu- 25/77 obp .381 hanley 30/90 .obp .406 the guy is making great contact and on a team like this that's added value. of course now comes the debate about strikeouts and putting the ball in play :banghead Then why say things? I'll make sure to check with you next time.
  18. adjusted for at bats cantu is one hit behind hanley %-wise. cantu- 25/77 obp .381 hanley 30/90 .obp .406 the guy is making great contact and on a team like this that's added value. of course now comes the debate about strikeouts and putting the ball in play :banghead
  19. he's talking about mcpherson
  20. here's Mcpherson's milb page the guy has struck out *ALMOST*HALF his at bats and he still has an OBP of .424 and and 1.128 OPS http://web.minorleaguebaseball.com/milb/st...&pid=425774 *Oops
  21. So Maybin has lost 200 points off his BA in 10 days...gotta love these early season stat swings. Dallas McPherson's line is 2-5, a homerun, three batted in and THREE strikeouts...to which I say wow...where do you put him?...seven homeruns already?...what do you do with one of the best contact hitters on the team in Jorge Cantu? Congrats to the other Dallas (Trahern) for getting his season started with 5 inning, 1 earned run.
  22. He gets a fair number of walks as well which leads me to believe he's learning the strike zone better and needs to work hitting breaking balls. I've listened to a couple of games in the last week and his defense is pretty good and getting better all the time. I have little fear he won't eventually be as advertised, but it's going to take time.
  23. I think he actually means for trying to take out Hanley on a double play when he slid at him NOWHERE near the bag. With both Jacobs AND Hanley last night, and then again tonight.
  24. And next time Diaz is up, knock him on his butt.
  25. Ross needs to see the bench for a while I don't know that Ross will be with the team that much longer.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.