Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. Saying (in absolute terms as if to make it true) someone only has two pitches and him having only two pitches are two completely different things. He has a pretty decent changeup at this point, (the fact it doesn't help someone's argument doesn't mean it's okay to just ignore its existence). Seems to me he struck out at least one batter yesterday with it and perhaps more than one. And his "retarded" curveball is spectacular, he's just seemingly afraid to use it or right now is having trouble throwing it for strikes (mechanical issue). Again, the problems are confidence (which isn't going to change by moving him to the pen) and mechanics. Now last season it's true he was pretty much two pitches, but by the end of last season and certainly this spring he has developed a major league quality changeup that frankly he doesn't feature often enough. But that's why he's back in the minors, to gain his confidence back and that using all his pitches with confidence. As for the mental part of it, the history of baseball is replete with guys who had trouble pitching at the major league level even with the best stuff. Look at Zack Greinke in 2006, look at him now. Ankiel, Dennis "Oil Can" Boyd. The idea that because he's made it to the major leagues (where everyone knows he was rushed in the first place and given a chance to redeem himself this spring) because those around him were dropping like flies from injuries doesn't mean he was or is mature enough to handle the responsibilities thrust upon him. I don't know how anyone who watches games either in person or on TV can say they haven't seen that deer in the headlights look on his face. We've seen guys literally have nervous breakdowns as young starters, develop skin irritations, alcoholism and drug abuse and worse trying to cope. Being dutch and stoic doesn't mean he's mature. I said it before, I'll say it again, just because the major leagues are ready for you doesn't mean you're ready for the major leagues. Zack Greinke is the poster boy for what can happen. So were guys like Jim Eisenreich and Jimmy Piersall but for other reasons. Personally I think Vanden Hurk would be better off if everyone would stop measuring him against his hero Burt Blyleven, it doesn't help. Greinke overcame his problems with time, I think the same will be true with Vanden Hurk. Now is not the time to tell him he is a failed starter. Now you build back his confidence in all his pitches and that he belongs at the major league level. He needs to succeed at that before suggesting a move to the pen. BTW, alot of the guys mentioned as starters turned relievers did so in the minors without ever having been a starter at the the minor league level. Tankersley, Pinto, both were converted at the minor league level. 2ensing got a Sept callup before being converted. It's rare pitchers don't begin their careers as starters so at least for me there's no merit in that argument. It's a red herring.
  2. The "turn him into a reliever" thing is that he hasn't produced as a starter, but with his K rate, he would still be good as a reliever. High K/High BB guys still work as relievers although they struggle as starters. Ideally he's a starter, but atleast we know there's a fallback option. The more concerning thing would be his HR rate. Giving up 1.65 HR/9 is going to get you blasted, starter or reliever. He's 22 years old. Besides being a reliever is more mental than anything and it's more that that drives the stats than the stats drive the reliever. I know that's hard to understand for some.
  3. The more I look at his pitch counts this early in the season, and knowing he's already had his TJ, I've come the conclusion this rush to judgement idea of making Vanden Hurk a reliever is an utterly fallacious one. His problem is not endurance, he could probably throw a hundred pitches in four days if asked. The problem is control and keeping his head straight when a problem occurs behind him or something takes out of "his" game. It doesn't matter if he's in there to handle two batters or three or four innings in long relief, the same problems will pop up, the outcome isn't just predictable, it's virtually guaranteed unless the core problems are addressed successfully. He has all the raw skills and the physicality to be a starter. The things he needs to work on are mostly between his ears and his mechanics. It would be criminal to throw away everything he has to offer in the future as a starter because of this rush to cultivate some relievers. There's plenty of them coming through the system now from Nestor to de LaCruz. Besides there's always another Todd Jones out there to pluck out of the sky. It may turn out that eventually RVH winds up in the pen but as a last resort, the Fish aren't going to give up on him as a starter until he proves unequivocally that he can't cut it and he's not at that point yet, he gets at least one more stint as a starter before any other career path is taken.
  4. It's very early yet but McPherson keeps hitting homeruns AND striking out, hopefully he can cut down on the latter. Maybin is hitting something like .460+ last time I checked and from his stats in his so far short stay in Carolina must be feasting on a steady diet of fastballs. Hopefully the word gets out and he doesn't see another one for three weeks because he's not down (or up in this case) there to hit heat, he's down there to learn what to do with breaking pitches of several descriptions. All that said, both are doing extremely well all things considered and the small sample size.
  5. As I understand it Amezaga's value hitting eigth is in providing protection for the six and seven hitters and his working counts and patience. He's not hitting there because there's no other place for him, he's there because they want him there.
  6. For what it's worth not every 22 year old ready to pitch in major leagues just because the opportunity presents itself. Hopefully he has a chance to collect himself and a find a way to make that great stuff he has in his arsenal work for him on a consistent. He's got three pitches in his repertoire he just needs the confidence and the ability to locate them at will. Sometimes it just seems he loses his focus from one pitch the next, my assumption is his confidence is still shot from last year's major league experience. Let's see if he can go down and dominate for a few months, I think that's what he needs, to feel like King Kong again the way he did in the Hawaiian League in 2006 that put him on the fast track, perhaps too fast a track looking back on it.
  7. Good to see at least for today, Hermida is able to master A level pitching. I was getting worried there for a minute considering he had gone 1 - 7 before today's start. St, Lucie used four pitchers today. Their ERAs 12.00, 9.00, 4.50, 10.80. I wouldn't draw too much of a conclusion from his performance today.
  8. Now, back to my original question, does someone else see someone else taking over at third, especially now that Helms is aboard? There's too many scenarios that could play themselves out to say definitively. Cantu gets hot or falls apart, Helms stays the player we saw in Philly or returns to his 2006 level, McPherson get's it all together after fifty games in AAA, or fillintheblank...you know, too many things can happen. Until I see and indication otherwise I'll take Beinfest at his word that the move was made to incrementally improve pinch-hitting, backup at first and third and an improvement overall coming off the bench.
  9. That was the luckiest I've ever seen someone pitch. D-Train pitched 5 sh*tty innings and managed to luck his way into not giving up a hit. He didn't strike out a single batter, every single batter just hit the ball to the wrong spot. He ended throwing more than 90 pitches, with 50% being balls. He walked SEVEN BATTERS! His line might be better than Miller's, but Miller pitched better than Willis. He was just rediculously lucky. I was going to not mention his performance today, but it was ugly for Willis and Detroit has to be banging their collective heads against a wall moaning thirty-million-dollars, thirty-million-dollars..." Just 'cause i love the guy so (and he's in the AL) I really hope he turns it around by if he flames out the Tigers essentially wind up paying $193 million for Cabrera.
  10. * Slaps balls * lmao
  11. This was one of the most exciting games I've gone to in quite a while, and not just because there's been no baseball since September. So when is Jack McKeon coming back? (j/k)
  12. While i know it means nothing and is indicative of even less, it sure has a ring to it. "Your first place Florida Marlins"
  13. We were offering Scott Nestor (RP spec) That was a million years ago. The Phils took money and got no one in exchange.
  14. I've got nothing strong against Wes Helms (after all, I was a bit upset to see him go after 2006), but why is everyone here so excited to see him back? His 2007 was rather abysmal. Because he's an upgrade over Jason Wood. It's an incremental step and their salaries will be just about a wash. And because we beat the Braves to him. It was the right move on a number of levels.
  15. Marlins say Hermida is still not 100 percent Posted on Sat, Apr. 05, 2008 By CLARK SPENCER It could be several more days before Jeremy Hermida is removed from the disabled list and installed in right field. That's because the Marlins aren't convinced the right fielder is 100 percent recovered from a strained left hamstring. "It's not there yet," Marlins manager Fredi Gonzalez said Saturday. "He's not confident enough yet to turn it loose." Hermida was eligible to come off the DL on Saturday. But Gonzalez said the decision was made to give the Hermida extra time to get back to full strength. As a result, Hermida was scheduled to play just five innings today for Single A Jupiter and would go nine innings on Sunday for the Hammerheads before a decision is made. Gonzalez said Hermida could join the Marlins in Washington early in the week or wait until the team gets to Houston later in the week.
  16. Normally I wouldn't want to take the bat out of Uggla's hands but the third baseman was playing behind the bag and staying close in of double play. The last thing they were thinking about was Uggla bunting. But it's always easy to look at things in hindsight and admittedly as I was sitting there bunting was the last thing on my mind.
  17. I'd trade Uggla for Ian Stewart and platoon Amezaga/Andino at 2B. I don't find this unrealistic considering the Rockies don't have anything at 2B anywhere in their organization. Hopefully this will happen in June or July. Nice staying on subject there Lou. Your obsession with trading Uggla has reached Spike-like levels, it's a freakin' sickness with you friend.
  18. 2003: I believe that if Helms clears waivers and is released, the new team that signs him would get him for the prorated minimum while the Phillies would pay his original deal. That's what I thought too Admin, but when I looked at his contract on Cots and saw there's an option for 2009 attached, I wondered if that played a part in decision-making by the various teams who potentially might have some interest? But yeah, usually it works the way you outlined. Now that I think of it - Damion Easley - had that big long term contract with the Tigers when they cut him and the Fish picked him up and it seems to me the Marlins only paid him the minimum for two years he was here.
  19. After I posed the question and later posted my anser it dawned on the problem regarding Helms, not just for he Marlins, but generally, is the $750,000 2009 contract buy-out and who is responsible for it. I would assume this is why no one is going to sign him before he is officially let go, so the Phillies are on the hook for the whole conntract. I believe if another team signs him after that, they offer him a second contract good for just 2008 and the original one remains the Phillies obligation. If I'm wrong someone correct me.
  20. Were it me, I think when Hermida comes back, now or later, he obviously replaces Carroll, especially since Gonzalez has shown himself to be a capable substitute in either outfield corner position, and if Helms is available at the minimum, he's a smart replacement for Jason Wood, as sorry as I'll be to see the guy go. Since what you'd essentially be doing is trading major league minimum for major league minimum Helms' numbers over the last three years have to give the edge to him. What does complicate it is the only legitimate centerfielders (by that I mean players who can play the position) are Amezaga and Ross which may be too thin. Trying to think outside the box, it might be time for Andino to take a crash course in centerfield if he wants to stick in the bigs as a super-utility player. he certainly has the speed and hands, he has a good arm, so as remote as it is, that would be a possibility too. Alfredo after all made the transition. For me it comes down to who is is more valuable to the team, Carroll or Andino and I think the latter. Others of course may disagree.
  21. Q: With Hermida coming back, how would you rearrange the roster keeping in mind a 25 man limit and the possibility of Helms being picked up or acquired (or not acquired as may be your choice) ? Jason Wood, Robert Andino, Brett Carroll, Wes Helms - who goes? who stays? Andino took outfield practice this spring, Carroll can play the infield, Wood and Helms are known quantities. There is no wrong answer. I have my own opinion, but that can wait until later. Q: With Luis Gonzalez off to a torrid start (BA/ OBP/ SLG/ OPS) .400/.500/.900/1.40 with a homer and a double in ten at bats, and Brett Carroll backing him up defensively do we really want to rush Hermida and possibly risk another injury or do we move him to AA or AAA for some closer to MLB at bats and continue his rehab until Gonzalez cools off knowing it's a long season? Q: Are you even interested in Wes Helms if he's available for the minimum ($390k) or the minimum and a PTBL type if we are competing with the Dodgers and Braves for his services? Helms three year line in a total of 688 at bats is .288/.345/462/.807. He's played LF, 1B, 3B during that period.
  22. This is the closest to drunk posting I've ever seen M2003 i had my shoulder scoped today, i'm on meds and typing with one hand
  23. a couple of days ago uggla was hitting .375 and ramirez .200. one guy goes 3-5 the other 0-5 (although he didn't strike out once and that to me shows signs of improvement) and the numbers flip-flop. it is way too early in the season to be drawing conclusions about starter. one guy hit them where they were the where thet weren't. look at cantu he's being the crap out of the ball and has absoluely nothing to show for it stats-wise.. it all comes out in the wash after about 100 at bats but until then all you can do is watch for indicators like hitting for contact.
  24. I enjoyed the game immensely. Great D, a lot of guys who aren't getting hits making really good contact, came back from a deficit, Olsen's ERA my look high after tonight but pitched a heck of a game, I love watching the vulture work and interesting didn't. Jacobs, aside from his communications problem olsen continues to look goos at first ans keeps hitting drives which they've been trying get him to do for two years. god i hate the manatees, and everyone knew between jacobs, willingham and cantu this game was not going beyond nine. robert andino looks like a major league ballplayer but also carroll's play tonight was big. just an awesome play. but so was uggla's dp. with wes helms cut and maybe available in a few days for virtually nothing, is this the end of the road for jason wood? so who's still unhappy we picked up luis gonzalez and thinks signing him was a mistake? how long before fredi starts pinch-hitting olsen? amezaga is in a zone the way he's playing a walk is as good as a hit. except for treanor twice, no strikeouts tonight. how nasty is taylor tankersley when he's on his game? just random thoughts.
  25. 2006 .339 2007 .326 Is that a big decline?

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.