Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
MLB Trade Rumor: Javier Vazquez for Dan Uggla
It's ridiculous on its face, the only exception being a scenario wherein it was part of a simultaneous three-way trade that netted the Fish more for Uggla than he could get being traded on his own. Not only that, the Marlins are franchise building, the ultimate goal being April 2012, and facing Uggla in a Braves uniform for the next two seasons as many times as the two teams face each other is exactly what you don't want to do as you attempt to build a bond with your new fanbase. But it doesn't go beyond Vasquez' salary, in reality you can stop there.
-
Terrific video of Mike Stanton in the bating cage
I was going to post this in "Minor League" but I thought Stanton is de facto a Marlin already (and it's pretty slow here). It's really worth watching so here it is. Notice the footwork, the lift, open stance, the stride the step towards the plate closing as he meets the ball, reminiscent of generations previous, especially the way he loads up, it will be interesting how much of it is left by the time makes it to the bigs or if they just leave him alone. http://prospectinsider.com/view/afl-video:-casey-kelly,-mike-stanton/ EDIT: I have trouble just now using the orginal link above so if you do too try this one: http://prospectinsider.com/index.php scroll down until you find the listing for the video.
-
Marlins in Jacksonville
Historically, this could be quite an exhibition and maybe worth a trip north to see just to say you saw so and so when. Think about the talent that potentially could be on the field that night and it's very interesting.
-
Here is why Dan Uggla won't be so easy to replace
I'm not going to reprint them here, this is the link: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/stats?playerId=5404 ... ...but Ross didn't set the world on fire when he first came up in 2005, in fact offensively he was atrocious in part-time play in 2005 and 2006 and it wasn't until he started a few games in 2007 here in Fla that things came together for him. We're just going to have to wait to see what Carroll develops into and until we know I'm satisfied Ross is not the worst example that could be used in fact Carroll could be better as easily as he could be worse or the same. Only time and playing time will tell. If Carroll pushes his way into the starting lineup this spring (barring injuries to Ross or someone else) it could be the quickest way to force Coghlan to the infield (see the dominoes falling) so if you want to see some other moves made and you're a Coghlan to second base guy you might want to be rooting for Carroll to blow up big next spring.
-
Here is why Dan Uggla won't be so easy to replace
How can you replace a secondbaseman that averages 30 HR and 90 RBI, its too absurd for discussion. Regardless of who the Marlins bring in his place, you will not get that type of production from any 2b, any! True they can bring in someone with a better OPB or one that strikes out less, or hits for better average, but that doesn't replace the threat that at any given time Dan could go yard, or replace his ability to help keep Hanley in line. Chris Coghlan had a higher OPS than Dan Uggla last year. Fail. Chris Coghlan had a breathtakingly successful year and no one is taking anything away from him but it's still a matter of conjecture how good a double play combination he and Hanley will make or if he can even play the position adequately. Do not read that as "he can't play the position" because that's not what I said. It's still a question mark and the organization playing him for only seven innings in one game with so many opportunities to showcase him there during the season begs the question, is he really a candidate to play 2nd base in 2010? We may not know their thinking until if and when Uggla is moved and Beinfest discusses his new strategy going forward. Comparing Coghlan's OPS to anyone on the team not named Hanley Ramirez is of course going to skew to his favor and deservedly so but might be worth mentioning that among regulars Uggla was third (taking Nick Johnson out of the equation with only just over 100 Marlins ABs). Uggla may very well be traded but one of the intangibles the team loses is the protection he provides in the lineup for the guys hitting ahead of him. Cantu in part put up the numbers he did because of the threat hitting behind him and that's not easy to replace. Dan is like so many ballplayers, imperfect, with his flaws but still an asset to any team including this one.
-
Marlins hire St. Claire
Even if it was only for a sliver of time Harvey was our Nolan Ryan, Bob Gibson kind of overpowering and intimidating guy and I would love to see that instilled in our pitching prospects (which is not to say I know anything about his coaching abilities)coming up through the system. I watch our young guys and this is purely my own thing but I seldom except for Ricky who exudes it and Josh sometimes, see that intimidating "I'm the guy who's goin' get you out" demeanor (not just facial expressions but body language as well) rather you see the "politeness" of a Sean West or RVH. The "attitude" has to be matched up with ability of course but sometimes believing in your abilities is a step in the right direction when it comes to competing at the major league level. I agree to an extent, but don't you think that Harvey would be better suited for the bullpen coach position? Have their been any rumored candidates yet for this job? I've only heard Harvey's name for pitching coach. Honestly Pengie, I don't know what he's good or not good at but his approach to getting the job done when he was a playing is what I was commenting on. I'd like to see more of that introduced to kids sooner rather than later throughout the system but if he's capable of being the guy in the bullpen I have no problem whatsoever with him coaching there. He might be the first autograph I sought out in twenty-five years if he was out there.
-
Marlins hire St. Claire
Even if it was only for a sliver of time Harvey was our Nolan Ryan, Bob Gibson kind of overpowering and intimidating guy and I would love to see that instilled in our pitching prospects (which is not to say I know anything about his coaching abilities)coming up through the system. I watch our young guys and this is purely my own thing but I seldom except for Ricky who exudes it and Josh sometimes, see that intimidating "I'm the guy who's goin' get you out" demeanor (not just facial expressions but body language as well) rather you see the "politeness" of a Sean West or RVH. The "attitude" has to be matched up with ability of course but sometimes believing in your abilities is a step in the right direction when it comes to competing at the major league level.
-
Marlins hire St. Claire
I admit it, I have no idea what to expect from him going forward. The guy wasn't a coach at this level for nearly seven years for nothing and anyone who's played any competitive team sport understands no matter how good your coaches and management is, meltdowns like we saw in Washington are going to happen, especially when the talent was as thin as it was there in 2009. Could someone else have held them together better, longer, I suppose Mr. Perfect is out there somewhere but I really don't know how to assign blame for what happened. We'll find out pretty quickly.
-
Free Agents in the Marlins price range
Facing the fact that the Marlins aren't going to spend money this winter it looks like these are the kind of guys that might sign with them: Frank Catalanotto, Tony Clark (HASN'T HIT HIS WEIGHT SINCE 2006, LOOK UP AGING NO-BAT DH/1ST BASEMEN IN THE DICTIONARY, THERE HE IS), Eric Hinske (BANGHEAD), Doug Mientkiewicz(BLOWN SHOULDER, DNP 2009, 4 homers in six years, ANOTHER AGING FIRST BASEMAN, CAN"T PLAY THIRD ANY MORE, 5TH OUTFIELDER), Kevin Millar (SCAB, .223/.311), Chad Tracy (.237/.306 FIRST BASE), Jerry Hairston (GEE WE SURE NEED ANOTHER AGING UTILITY GUY), Bobby Crosby (THAT .225/.295 LINE SHOULD A BIG HELP TO THE FISH), Tony Pena (THAT .098/.195 LINE in 2009, .169/.189 in 2008, .267/.284 in 2007 REALLY MAKES MY TOES TINGLE) Joe Crede (BONIFACIO PUT UP BETTER NUMBERS AT THIRD THIS SEASON), Troy Glaus (THAT'S WHAT NEED AT THIRD, A SURGICALLY REPAIRED THROWING SHOULDER WITH NO RANGE), Rocco Baldelli, Brian Giles (MAYBE WE COULD KEEP MAYBIN DOWN IN THE MINORS AGAIN AND GO WITH GILES IN THE OUTFIELD. MAYBE. LOL), Gary Sheffield (I LOVE YOU BUT NO), --- I GIVE UP ---Xavier Nady and Jason Giambi (OMG). From the pitching side of things: Joaquin Benoit, Elmer Dessens, Kelvim Escobar (ANOTHER BAD SHOULDER, HAS NOT RESPONDED TO REHAB POST SURGERY BUT STILL CASHING IN TO THE TUNE OF $10 MILLION IN 2009) and Justin Speier. Depending on who leaves I think that Chad Tracy, Troy Glaus or Brian Giles would be good fits. Escobar and Benoit seem like the kind of pitchers the Marlins like to roll the dice with. I have a feeling that Escobar will probably be out of the Marlins' price range but maybe not. Seriously I appreciate the effort with starting new threads when it's DOA around here but this is really, really stretching it. Good try though. There might be someone here that matches up with the Fish but it's hard to see where.
-
BBA places Coghlan 4th in their ROY voting
It's rookie of the year, meaning that what happened prior to those two months is significant, as well. I understand children always have to be right because, well, because children always have to be right. lol That said I never postulated that Coghlan should be or would be picked over McCutchen or anyone else, please show me where I said that or for that matter that the last two+ months of the season are more important than any other period, or the season as a whole, because I don't think that's what I said. If I wanted to make that argument I would have. The words I used didn't appear by accident. I picked them on purpose. As for Coghlan, my point was and is simply that he's "in the running" (my EXACT words) because he put on a show in the last two months+ of the season (that every Marlins fan might enjoy taking a moment after a sometimes frustrating season to enjoy) or as I put it originally, "...to bring a smile your face...it's a thing of beauty". And it was. http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/stats/individual_player_gamebygamelog.jsp?c_id=fla&playerID=458085&statType=1
-
BBA places Coghlan 4th in their ROY voting
I don't know what the BBWA members will use as their criteria but if you want to see a comparison worth noting between the two players being discussed, compare their gamelogs for August and Sept/Oct. The thing that leaps out at you is the number and frequency of multi-hit games that Coghlan racked up. He's in the running because of one thing -- he's a freakin' hit machine. You can try and reference some stat that's more or less representative just look at the succession of hits the guy put up. The gamelog for each player tells the story. And nothing above takes anything away from McCutchen who had a fabulous year as well. But just to bring a smile your face take three minutes and check out Coghlan's August on gamelog, it's a thing of beauty.
-
De Aza Claimed by White Sox
I'm not arguing that (in fact I'm not arguing at all) De Aza is some phenom or anything special but if memory serves didn't he make the Opening Day roster with the Marlins at least once and I think it was twice so regardless of what some may think the professionals within the organization who evaluate players for a living thought he was not without the talent to play at the major league level. That said, one could also posit that those same people allowed his departure, so while I don't think it's the end of the world that he's gone to Chicago, we never had a chance to see what he was capable of with a full season under his belt. Again not drawing any comparison but if one were to look at Chris Coghlan's first month or so in the bigs and used that as a snapshot of what kind of player he was, in hindsight it be a tragically flawed assessment. Spike and others above may be right he never plays an inning but you never know who gets traded, who gets injured, etc. and what happens if he's in the right place at the right time. Dan Uggla would be an aging utility player scratching out a living in AA ball right now if the Diamondbacks still had him under their control so personally I hope the guy nothing but the best and hope he earns (operative word) a spot on the White Sox roster in 2010.
-
Gary Sheffield?
Why is it necessary to look at a player one dimensionally? The question isn't about his mouth (euphemistically speaking) or his bat or glove, it's about weighing the relative value of the player as a contributing member of a team. Who would argue Wes Helms or Brett Carroll didn't contribute last season, the question if it's in the context of a secondary right hand bat who would contribute the most in 2010 as a whole if there was only one slot to fill? I didn't see enough of Sheffield last season to really decide so I'll leave it others but it needs to be in the context of team contribution first and the player as he is today - not five or ten years ago - second. As for his "mouth" we'll all *say* a lot of things we'd prefer to have never said and I would guess Sheffield is no different.
-
BBA places Coghlan 4th in their ROY voting
Can't handle stats=facts... Most stats are not facts, except for the most empirical ones - X hits in Y plate appearances as an example, those based on what actually happened in a game or a season or by a player or a team - but beyond those, once one number in a formula is postulated, stats are supposition and last time I looked supposition and fact are not easily confused.
-
Perry Hill Available
Not to say Perry Hill couldn't help just about anyone be a better infielder but (putting aside Hanley for a moment) it really depends on how the Marlins set about assembling their 2010 infield and who those players are to determine exactly how important Hill would be in Miami. Whether he's a necessity or a luxury remains to be seen until Beinfest and Hill start making their moves. We also don't know if there are underlying factors - family or others - that may be shaping Hill's decision.
-
Perry Hill Available
(Lol Pengie...ever the contrarian :brigginbounce ) I thought the operative portion was. "...and his departure was not unexpected. Hill has expressed unhappiness that the team traded three-fourths of the infield during the season...", my assumption being the Marlins knew this when they made their coaching moves. I'm not saying he's headed back here because it may have to do with other factors, but the single best chance for Ramirez to truly mature into the game's premier shortstop would be for him to spend the next few years under Perry.
-
Marlins pitching coach search
He (Rosenthal) has been mentioned in other articles, just not this one.
-
Marlins pitching coach search
Dick Pole is a perfect example of why I willingly resigned from the Red Sox Nation before there was a Red Sox Nation when I moved here in 1992. I guess from the success he's had as a pitching coach he is the prototypical "those you can, do, those who cannot, teach" school of life. Whether he is a quality pitching coach prospect I can't say, and I can give him a pass because of the freak occurrence in his onfield career but my memory of him generally was one of resignation on days he was due to pitch. I'm not sure if his unceremonious departure from Cincinnati was a good or bad thing but I wouldn't want to be the pitching coach in Great American Ballpark so who knows? edit: However much of a long shot it is and how good at, or ready for the position he would be, it would thrill me no end to see Bryan Harvey in a Marlins uniform again. I've long held that his performance in 1993 was the single greatest achievement in the franchise's history given the circumstances and his contribution to that team. I will never forget watching him out there night after night carrying an otherwise horrendous team to respectability and finishing five games ahead of the Mets.
-
ESPN 30 for 30 Steve Bartman:Catching Hell
It seems Alou will say whatever whoever is asking seems to want to hear. His comments about not being able to catch the ball could not have been clearer, that is until questioned about his statement on same, then his answer is 180 degrees in the other direction. It's gotten to the point where he is the last person one would go to for an expert opinion. But that's not surprising considering his primary motivation appears to be self-preservation.
-
Andrew Miller headed to AFL
So are the AFL Mesa Solar Sox playing in jupiter anytime or anywhere in FLA or no? no.
-
Andrew Miller headed to AFL
Without reading every post, here or other threads, has it been mentioned that Bo Porter will be managing one of the teams in the AFL? Nice showcase.
-
Scott Proctor and Dave Davidson released.
I thought Trahern was outrighted to NOLA not let go. Besides he's recovering from TJ so I suspect the reason he could be removed from the 40 man without fear was it's doubtful someone would risk their roster spot on him. Admittedly the likelihood he returns and brings value to the trade is tenuous, but enough players have come back that it's at *least* worth not shutting the door on the possibility he can still be productive.
-
Scott Proctor and Dave Davidson released.
Firesale !!!!! I can see the headlines tomorrow.
-
Wiley and Fox Out
I never got the thing about wanting the owners to spend even if it meant they lose money they lose money = they lose ownership cuz they no longer have money this continues = no more major league baseball we as fans = some how profit? Well, generally this is right. I will add, though, that this is not the owners' only sources of revenue. And I've heard that sometimes they love the team and want to win so badly that they'll take a bit of a loss on the total operation of the team. And theoretically, even if the current owners couldn't afford the teams anymore, there could be new people to take their places, but maybe the values of the teams would go down, but that's contingent on several things. Years ago (perhaps decades is the more correct word)costs were a fraction of what they are now and tax rates were much much higher (which meant in some circumstances either spending or giving it to the IRS). Because taxes were much more regressive than they are now, one could conceivably be paying 70% above a certain number in combined state and federal taxes, might be willing to lose a few dollars to bring down his effective to say 60%, and make money by to offset the "loss" by lowering his overall tax rate. But the modern owner, having almost surely seen his fortune diminish in today's market is loathe to lose a dime. The Wilpons invested gazillions with Bernie Madoff, money gone forever, others have seen the value of their corporate ownerships or or investments beat up. It looks like next season we finally may give up the mantle of lowest payroll team in baseball to at least one team, and conceivably a couple because certainly it looks like Pittsburgh will claim the crown.
-
Wiley and Fox Out
Understand the deals on the new stadium and the adjoining parking garages are separate entities, the latter is City owned and the Marlins contractually already committed to renting every parking space for every game for thirty+ years. there won't be any 10,000 fan games, at least not on paper because by the time the place opens they'll have the equivalent of 20,000+ season tickets sold for the rest of the decade. And the concessions will belong to them, at least the lion's share although they will probably roll the concessions into a management package and put it out to bid, guaranteeing them a predictable income stream while taking a piece off the top on anything over a set level. the only thing that would drive down ticket sales to 10,000 a night would be a complete world-wide financial meltdown and if that happens attendance at baseball games will be the last thing you or I will be worrying about.