Everything posted by Tee Ball Bunt Machine
-
In all seriousness - Lineup/Starters 2009.
C - Baker 1B - Cantu / G. Sanchez 2B - Uggla SS - Ramirez 3B - Cantu/ McPherson LF - Raynor/De Aza/ almost any OF not on the active roster this year. Maybe someone we get back for Jacobs & co. CF - Maybin (definite starter I think, but spot in order may depend on ST) RF - Ross Bench Everything - Amezaga OF - Hermida (if they keep him) C - Lo Duca/Treanor/Rabelo Rotation - Nolasco, JJ, A Miller, some combination of Sanchez, Volstad, Mitre and MAYBE Olsen if he can't be replaced by another LHP. SU - Ryan Tucker / Joe Nelson CP - Lindstrom Anyway, I expect that Jacobs & Hammer will be gone, I hope Hermida as well. Hopefully in return for them we can get a good corner OF bat to put into LF and either some more bullpen (can't ever have too much) or a decent Lefty SP. I don't expect any big moves for a new catcher since anyone they acquire will just be a backup for Baker, and he will have enough starts to make his backup less important. I'm hoping they can hang on to Cantu which will give them flexibility with using McPherson and Gaby Sanchez at the corners until the team is comfortable and can rely on them. I don't imagine Coghlan will be up unless they decide to get creative in trying either him, Uggla, or Hanley at 3B. I don't buy into the belief that Uggla will be traded as Coghlan hasn't been called up to get MLB playing time. Whereas I think the team clearly seems to be looking at having G Sanchez and McPherson starting next year. If the team intended to trade Uggla, you would think Coghlan would at least be on the bench right now to get some ABs at this level. I really hope Arthur Rhodes sticks around too, but I'm not sure that hope is realistic.
-
Hanley sitting again
Thank God for Maybin. It's good to not have to rush Hanley or be desperate to have him back in the lineup. Usually I think there's that conflict between the team needing him vs making sure he's ok, but with Maybin in, it's no problem.
-
2009 starters...
No Reggie Abercrombie? I think we'd have to give up too much to trade for him now. Where's Eric Reed? That's what I want to know! Get Jason Wood off 1B though, we need him in the bullpen.
-
Was Freddi's Job Saved by this last Winning Streak?
Fredi's job wasn't saved because it was never in trouble. This team was supposed to be a last place team all year and lose around 100 games. Even just the fact that we spent the better part of the first half of the season in first place meant they exceeded expectations. But even if they hadn't, even if we had lost the 90-100 games as expected and finished last, Fredi's job would be fine. Honestly, who could blame him with the starting rotation we started the year with? Who could blame him for not having a starting CF, no consistent healthy corner OF, no obvious catcher, and Jacobs at 1B after the last 2 seasons he had? I mean seriously? Does anyone think Bobby Cox is gonna get fired for how bad the Braves have done this year, and their drop off the last few years? Can you blame him for his entire rotation basically being on the DL, his best hitters either getting hurt now and again or just getting traded, etc? It's one thing to hold a manager responsible for his team's failure to perform up to expectations, but another to blame a team for losing when everyone expected the team to lose even more.
-
81st win.
ABSOLUTELY AGREE! This has been a very UNEXPECTED but, VERY SUCCESSFUL season! Lets hope Loria does NOT do what we are all expecting----dump some players rather then paying them.Because, if he keeps doing that, he will have a new, very beautiful and, VERY EMPTY retractable roof stadium! Its time to build a franchise WITH that new stadium! I wouldn't mind if he dumped Hermida. Same with Hammer, but I do like Hammer much more, there's just something to be said about a player's ability to stay healthy. And as much as I like Jacobs, I wouldn't be surprised if he ends up going too. But who knows - after this year Jake will only have had one good season, and that even with many flaws, so he may not cost too much to keep and they may just try to keep this IF together. All that said, I agree with how great it is to have clinched at minimum 500. After all the low expectations when the season started, its just amazing how this team has performed. Even if we don't make the playoffs, its been a great ride, and exciting to disprove the naysayers.
-
9/19 Post Game
The thing that makes Maybin so big the last few games is that at least for these few games he has stepped right into Hanley's spot in the order on days when Hanley needed to sit out and Maybin made sure we didn't miss a beat. Especially at such a critical time, who knows what it could have done to our streak if we had Hanley sitting out a few games without having someone like Maybin to filll his spot. I'm glad we weren't left depending on a lineup with Cody in CF, Hermida in RF, and Amezaga at SS. That lineup doesn't get it done.
-
Kevin Gregg is Concerned about his Trade Value
I haven't and don't plan to read through this thread thoroughly, but looking at somethings said, I thought I should make a few comments: #1 - Does Gregg's trade value actually affect him at all? I mean seriously, does he somehow get more money if he's traded for a better player(s)? #2 - Assuming as I do, that the answer is no, it doesn't sound selfish at all. Maybe a little egotistical to worry about his own stats, but if it's genuinely about his trade value, then what he's saying is that he wants the team to get the best return they can for him, which I would think is good for the team. #3 - Cut the guy some slack. Yeah, he blew a bunch of games this year. Maybe he was never that good as he needed to be, maybe he just wasn't right out there, but don't blast the guy like he's friggin Jorge Julio. He's just human. He wasn't gonna be our closer forever anyway, and our defense never did give him too much help.
-
John Baker
Is Hermida not up for arbitration? Everyone is assuming he'll be back. Well, he'll probably be the cheapest of the OFers, plus is the youngest with the most upside. He'll most likely be back. I'm fine with them keeping him if he's cheap, but unless he has a really good ST I think he should start the season on the bench. Honestly, he's been a lazy defender and a black hole in the lineup by and large. Just my opinion, don't jump on me about how much potential he has. If he goes next year, I won't miss him, no matter what he does there.
-
How bad would it hurt?
Considering how bad this season was supposed to go, according to the media and even most of us, no, it won't hurt that much. And I know all of us thought better of the team than did the media, who was predicting 100+ losses for us. But still, who actually thought at the beginning of the season that this team would be over 500 and within 5 games of a playoff spot into the last week of play? Who thought this team would actually be better after having lost Cabrera & Willis (not even to mention what happened to the Tigers, who were supposed to be monsters after that trade)? Whether or not we go to the playoffs, we should all be happy with this season and everyone should be looking forward to next year.
-
Maybin, Baker, Hanley...
Is there a reason why there's like a "Raynor hate parade" going on, all of the sudden? Why CAN'T he play LF? Willingham is likely gone next year...there's no guarantee of Cody Ross coming back (he's arbritation eligible). I'd be willing to bet that Raynor will at least get a chance to battle for the LF spot in Spring Training. Heck...I wouldn't even count on Hermida being back. I still don't like the idea of trading a guy with Hermida's potential (and not getting equal potential back)...but as of right now, I'm sure Fredi Gonzalez isn't very pleased with Hermida, to say the least. I will honestly be surprised if Hermida is back, even if Maybin is ready. I would sooner expect the team to keep Cody in RF, and then I think LF is the question mark. While I don't expect it, they could keep Hammer. And if not him, there's Raynor (if he's ready). On the off chance that "Mr. Glass" Alejandro De Aza actually comes in and stays healthy, why not him in LF? If one of the team's likely focuses next year will be on improving defense, how much better could they do for the OF then have 3 CF out there?
-
John Baker
Wow, I wasn't even aware that this one was up for debate. Baker has played at a very high level since he was brought up and he should absolutely be the starter in 2009. My thoughts exactly. Baker is already the starting catcher now, and considering how good a job he's doing, putting up the best OBP on the team behind Hanley, I can't really imagine why anyone would think that there was a chance of anyone else being the starting catcher in 09. Especially on this team, which rarely ever makes a big signing to address an actual need, it would be crazy to think they would finally sign someone notable to play a position where we are finally solid, at least with the starter. As for the backup catcher, I suppose I'd be fine with Treanor or Lo Duca, but I would prefer Lo Duca, just because even though he's not as good a hitter anymore, he is still much more the type of hitter to take Baker's spot in the lineup when he starts. If Treanor is the backup, then you need to reshuffle the lineup and find another #2 to move Treanor to the #8 spot. Duca can bat second though.
-
Maybin, Baker, Hanley...
I would prefer Maybin, Gaby Sanchez, Hanley. Sanchez needs to actually perform at the MLB level (IMO) before he replaces the guy with the 2nd highest OBP on the team (among those who've had significant playing time this year), that being Baker. Honestly, someone posted a lineup in here with Baker batting 8?!?!? Just cause the guy's a catcher doesn't mean he hits like Matt Treanor or Paul Hoover. Baker belongs in the #2 spot until someone else can demonstrate better OBP ability. Now why would I think Sanchez should earn his spot and am fine with Maybin leading off? Part of it just has to do with my opinion that a good #2 hitter is harder to come by than a good leadoff hitter. Another is that the team has been trying to get Hanley into the middle of the order for a while now, and Maybin is, on top of being a big prospect and future star, the best guy to fit the leadoff hitter mold in the organization. And in the two days so far of opportunities he has had so far, he hasn't made any real mistakes. Now if Maybin comes out of ST batting 210 or something like that, then I'm ok batting him 7th or 8th until he gets it going again.
-
The reason the Marlins will beat the Astros
ummmm regardless of what happened last night to Astros, they are still the HOTTEST team in baseball but go fish They're coming off of a loss and we're on a 5 game winning streak. I'd say that makes us the hotter team. Yeah, before that loss I think they had won something like 10 in a row. And they were doing well before that too. They've had a good 2nd half. I don't know about the rest of you though, but I'm looking forward to seeing Reggie again.
-
Infield 2009
why not jacobs?? i prefer jacobs than dan uggla Because for all the crap Uggla gets about all his Ks and apparently not being a clutch hitter, he has the best OPS (and OBP) with RISP of anybody who's been with the team all year. Jacobs is about 120 behind Uggla on the OBP and SLGs a bit less too. Uggla is a better clutch hitter and a much better defender, and he plays a position where his offensive production would be more difficult to replace. As for my thoughts on the IF, main thing is to keep Hanley & Uggla there. I assume we don't keep both Jacobs and Cantu, and while I am happy ith the year Jake has put up, I'd still rather keep Cantu for the flexibility he offers. If we keep Cantu, he can either play 1B opposite McPherson in case Gaby Sanchez isn't ready or he can play 3B opposite Sanchez if McPherson cannot stay healthy. And if everyone stays healthy and produces you can trade Cantu mid-season. If they really want to get creative, I'd try Coghlan at SS opposite Uggla at 2B and see how Hanley feels about 3B. Then you've got whoever we keep between Cantu or Jacobs along with McPherson & Gaby all as 1B options. That mainly because I'm really getting tired of those botched DPs, but I wouldn't be committed to this - I understand Hanley's value at SS.
-
Is there a pitcher in MLB that can't shut the Marlins offense down
Luis Ayala
-
Miller or Olsen or Both
I'm honestly not that high on either, given the lack of consistency with both, but I'm willing to give Miller a bit more slack, all things considered. There's not a whole lot of good reason for why Olsen has failed to perform beyond the fact that he's just not that good. It was one thing when he was the #2 LHP in our rotation behind a still functional Dontrelle. Again, I would say Miller has had his moments, but then so has Olsen. And Oly has had some bad breaks, going deep into games with no run support. But at the end of the day, niether one has shown anything like the consistency we saw from JJ in 06 ( and now) or like Nolasco's dominance for the last few months. Ideally I'd still like to wait and see with both, if perhaps they can put it together, but I'm foine dumping both once they begin to cost too much.
-
Luis Gonzalez is a stud.
Hermida was benched because #1 - He hasn't been playing well lately or all season, or even for most of his ML career. #2 - The team is desperate to have decent hitter of the sort who is patient, takes pitches, and makes contact or walks, as opposed to the hard swinging K machines that make up most of our offense, in order to give the team some balance. As of now we have that from the Catcher's spot with Baker and LoDuca, and it would be kinda nice if we could get the same from Gonzo. Is this really that complicated? While I'd rather they call someone up to replace Hermida on a more permanent basis, I'm fine with this if it means Hermida will actually be getting on base when he does get an AB late in the game.
-
Dan Uggla
To say that Uggla is our best defensive infielder is not saying anything. And to say that he is one of the top three or four 2nd basemen in the game is ridiculous. There are like 15 regular 2Bmen with a higher BA, 7 with more RBIs, 8 or nine with better OBP, and 3 who slug better. On top of that he leads all 2Bmen in strikeouts, is tied for 3rd in errors and ranks way down in fielding percentage and range factor. And as LordMagnus alluded to , it's downright embarrassing that he (and Jacobs) are going to hit over 30 HR and have fewer than 100 RBIs. I don't hate Uggla. I just think that his value for what they will wind up paying him is low, as is Jacobs, so I would look very hard at moving him. They have fewer RBIs because our team as a whole has the 4th worst OBP in the NL. You can only drive in so many runs when you have that many chances. Sure, they've also both choked with runners on. But it ain't all that different, they K and hit HRs whether they have runners on or not. Why is not then embarassing that Hanley will probably do the same, and not just because he's a leadoff hitter, but because he bats like 200 with RISP? Uggla gets this reputation as some sort of choke artist, but they guy also has a 405 OBP with RISP even in the midst of this slump. I guess though more to my point, you can pick out stats here and there, especially as his numbers are weighed down by over a month of slumping, but lets either compare it at the end of the season or look at his career numbers, and how many 2B have been putting up those numbers for the last 3 years? And even if you think it doesn't say much, he is the best defender amongst our starting IF. A better defender than Coghlan, and a way better hitter than any other in-house option at 2B. And if he's really so bad among 2B, then maybe he won't command so much money after all. But I still think there are reasons why he went to the all star game ahead of so many of those 2B with higher avgs and more RBIs and higher OBPs, and its not that Uggla plays is a big market with a lot of press. PS. Uggla has the highest OBP with RISP on the entire team (not counting the recently added catchers). Is that really the player you want to dump off?
-
Dan Uggla
To say that Uggla is our best defensive infielder is not saying anything. And to say that he is one of the top three or four 2nd basemen in the game is ridiculous. There are like 15 regular 2Bmen with a higher BA, 7 with more RBIs, 8 or nine with better OBP, and 3 who slug better. On top of that he leads all 2Bmen in strikeouts, is tied for 3rd in errors and ranks way down in fielding percentage and range factor. And as LordMagnus alluded to , it's downright embarrassing that he (and Jacobs) are going to hit over 30 HR and have fewer than 100 RBIs. I don't hate Uggla. I just think that his value for what they will wind up paying him is low, as is Jacobs, so I would look very hard at moving him. They have fewer RBIs because our team as a whole has the 4th worst OBP in the NL. You can only drive in so many runs when you have that many chances. Sure, they've also both choked with runners on. But it ain't all that different, they K and hit HRs whether they have runners on or not. Why is not then embarassing that Hanley will probably do the same, and not just because he's a leadoff hitter, but because he bats like 200 with RISP? Uggla gets this reputation as some sort of choke artist, but they guy also has a 405 OBP with RISP even in the midst of this slump. I guess though more to my point, you can pick out stats here and there, especially as his numbers are weighed down by over a month of slumping, but lets either compare it at the end of the season or look at his career numbers, and how many 2B have been putting up those numbers for the last 3 years? And even if you think it doesn't say much, he is the best defender amongst our starting IF. A better defender than Coghlan, and a way better hitter than any other in-house option at 2B. And if he's really so bad among 2B, then maybe he won't command so much money after all. But I still think there are reasons why he went to the all star game ahead of so many of those 2B with higher avgs and more RBIs and higher OBPs, and its not that Uggla plays is a big market with a lot of press. PS. Uggla has the highest OBP with RISP on the entire team (not counting the recently added catchers). Is that really the player you want to dump off?
-
8/27 Post Game
Why not? Uggla was 2-3 with a walk and he scored 3 runs (the entire margin of victory BTW), including of course the HR and a 2B. I still voted for JJ, cause it doesn't beat the CG, but I considered voting for Uggla.
-
Dan Uggla
hey, if I had a say I would have Andino start, but that is just me. I have been a big fan of Andino's since he came over. He is a huge upgrade defensively at 2nd and has shown he does not belong in the minors, he is a starter in my eyes. He's not a huge upgrade defensively, mainly on account of the fact that #1 - he's a SS, not a 2B #2 - Uggla's not that bad defensively to begin with And much more important, in the realm of things that actually are huge, Andino would be a huge offensive downgrade.
-
Dan Uggla
hey, if I had a say I would have Andino start, but that is just me. I have been a big fan of Andino's since he came over. He is a huge upgrade defensively at 2nd and has shown he does not belong in the minors, he is a starter in my eyes. He's not a huge upgrade defensively, mainly on account of the fact that #1 - he's a SS, not a 2B #2 - Uggla's not that bad defensively to begin with And much more important, in the realm of things that actually are huge, Andino would be a huge offensive downgrade.
-
Dan Uggla
yep, Cody is a guy i would like to keep, mainly because we are a HORRIBLE defensive team and he has been one of the few bright spots there. Hermida needs to actually show me he can do something ALL season not just the 2nd half. If he can't get rid of him after the 09 season. Uggz will be gone soon, he will be asking for a lot, and management has groomed Couglen, he is ready, Jacobs is replaceable also, Gaby Sanchez is close to ready, but until then we can move Cantu to first and see what McPhearson can do. Coughlan has twice as many errors as Uggla so far this season, and you think he's ready to pick up the slack of playing in our IF? I'm not saying that he is ready defensively, I just think that he brings something to this team that Uggla doesn't, he is a contact hitter. He will have a high batting average and could turn out to be another Luis Castillo but worse defensively. Couglan may need another year to correct some problems. And then you lose what Uggla is and you add another bad glove to the IF. I'm still amazed by how our fanbase is in such a hurry to trade away the team leaders in RBIs. As for how Coghlan is offensively, his minor league numbers look to me a bit similar to Jeremy Hermida. Now I'm not consigning him to the same fate, I'm just saying that good minor league offensive numbers don't guarantee major league performance. Before people even want to try replacing an All-Star run producer like Uggla with a player who is a defensive downgrade, I'd like to see how he hits in the bigs.
-
Dan Uggla
yep, Cody is a guy i would like to keep, mainly because we are a HORRIBLE defensive team and he has been one of the few bright spots there. Hermida needs to actually show me he can do something ALL season not just the 2nd half. If he can't get rid of him after the 09 season. Uggz will be gone soon, he will be asking for a lot, and management has groomed Couglen, he is ready, Jacobs is replaceable also, Gaby Sanchez is close to ready, but until then we can move Cantu to first and see what McPhearson can do. Coughlan has twice as many errors as Uggla so far this season, and you think he's ready to pick up the slack of playing in our IF? I'm not saying that he is ready defensively, I just think that he brings something to this team that Uggla doesn't, he is a contact hitter. He will have a high batting average and could turn out to be another Luis Castillo but worse defensively. Couglan may need another year to correct some problems. And then you lose what Uggla is and you add another bad glove to the IF. I'm still amazed by how our fanbase is in such a hurry to trade away the team leaders in RBIs. As for how Coghlan is offensively, his minor league numbers look to me a bit similar to Jeremy Hermida. Now I'm not consigning him to the same fate, I'm just saying that good minor league offensive numbers don't guarantee major league performance. Before people even want to try replacing an All-Star run producer like Uggla with a player who is a defensive downgrade, I'd like to see how he hits in the bigs.
-
Dan Uggla
yep, Cody is a guy i would like to keep, mainly because we are a HORRIBLE defensive team and he has been one of the few bright spots there. Hermida needs to actually show me he can do something ALL season not just the 2nd half. If he can't get rid of him after the 09 season. Uggz will be gone soon, he will be asking for a lot, and management has groomed Couglen, he is ready, Jacobs is replaceable also, Gaby Sanchez is close to ready, but until then we can move Cantu to first and see what McPhearson can do. Coughlan has twice as many errors as Uggla so far this season, and you think he's ready to pick up the slack of playing in our IF?