Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Was Freddi's Job Saved by this last Winning Streak?

Featured Replies

We Bad News Bears! This was the motto of the 2007 Florida Marlins. Loss after loss piled up, mainly because of bad pitching, which

 

caused pitching coach Rick Kranitz to be let go, and they finished off the year with a 71-91 record. Last place in the NL East, even

 

behind the Washington Nationals.

 

So as anyone in their right mind would guess, the expectations coming into the 2008 season were pretty bad. Some "experts" predicted

 

60 wins , some 70, but it didn't go any higher than that. The Marlins had the same nucleus from the previous season, so there was no

 

reason to believe that they were going to be any better. What the experts failed to realize, though, was that this was a young roster,

 

and they were going to be 1 year older this year, so they would be more mature. The team also brought in veteran leader Luis Gonzales

 

which helped in giving advice to the young players and by being a "clubhouse prescence".

 

The season started against division rivals New York Mets. Former NBA Player Mark Hendrickson was given the start, and the game did

 

not go well for the Marlins. The Mets won easily. But after that opening series, the Marlins started racking up a lot of wins, and finished

 

off May by leading the NL East by 1/2 game and with a 31-23 record. This was one of the best starts in franchise history, and though

 

some "experts" were saying it was too early to tell if the Marlins were for real, expectations were rising and some fans started thinking

 

playoffs. The Marlins spent the next 2 months battling between 1st and 2nd in the division. And by the end of July, playoffs started

 

looking like a reality.

 

But in the month of August, the Marlins started slumping, blowing leads, not scoring runs, and just losing heartbreaker after

 

heartbreaker. The Marlins went down to .500 for the first time in awhile, and they were about 10 games back in their division, and even

 

farther down in the Wild Card race. Pressure was turning on manager Freddi Gonzales, and many people, including myself, thought that

 

he might be fired at the end of the season for the late season slump.

 

But you know? These are the Marlins! Anything could happen.

 

And in the middle of September, the Marlins started a short winning streak, about 3 games, something they hadn't been able to do in

 

awhile. And to help the cause, the teams they were trailing, the Mets and Brewers started slumping. The Brewers even fired their

 

manager Ned Yost.

 

Unexpectedly, the winning streak started getting stronger, and Marlins fans and players duddenly started "scoreboard watching", and

 

after their opponents kept losing, the Marlins are now 4.5 games back in the wildcard race and 5 games back in the Division.

 

But whatever happens, with this winning streak, Freddi Gonzalez's job has probably been saved. He has brought excitement at this point

 

of the season for the first time since '05 when the Marlins were in the other end of a streak. So unless Freddi Gonzales starts cursing at

 

Jeffrey Loria from the end of the dugout, he will stay, and hopefully bring a championship to Miami this season.

 

What do you guys think?

Fredi exceeded expectations before September, we knew he was coming back regardless in 09

Fredi is here for the long term, I personally feel he is a kiss a** to the FO, exactly how they like it.

  • Author

Yeah, but you guys are saying this in the middle of a 9 game winning streak. Its the point Im trying to make. If I would've asked this 2 weeks ago, there will have been posts saying he should be fired for not handling the bullpen, etc. right.

 

And I saw some of those threads a couple of weeks ag

Fredi exceeded expectations before September, we knew he was coming back regardless in 09

 

Sometimes exceeding expectations, then going into a lowly slump like the Marlins did, and continuing that, can cost him his job. If we were to suck the entire time, no, he'd still have his job. So yes, in conclusion, I do think this winning streak, regardless of playoffs, helped Fredi keep his job.

Fredi exceeded expectations before September, we knew he was coming back regardless in 09

 

Sometimes exceeding expectations, then going into a lowly slump like the Marlins did, and continuing that, can cost him his job. If we were to suck the entire time, no, he'd still have his job. So yes, in conclusion, I do think this winning streak, regardless of playoffs, helped Fredi keep his job.

 

 

I understand that, and at times Fredi has mishandled the bullpen and taken starting pitchers out too early, but overall he has done a good job, and that is not because of the winning streak. He has kept this team in the playoff race most of the season, and u have to give a manager props for that when the team was predicted to lose 100+ games before the season

  • Author

Fredi exceeded expectations before September, we knew he was coming back regardless in 09

 

Sometimes exceeding expectations, then going into a lowly slump like the Marlins did, and continuing that, can cost him his job. If we were to suck the entire time, no, he'd still have his job. So yes, in conclusion, I do think this winning streak, regardless of playoffs, helped Fredi keep his job.

 

 

I understand that, and at times Fredi has mishandled the bullpen and taken starting pitchers out too early, but overall he has done a good job, and that is not because of the winning streak. He has kept this team in the playoff race most of the season, and u have to give a manager props for that when the team was predicted to lose 100+ games before the season

 

cough cough JOE GIRARDI cough cough

Fredi exceeded expectations before September, we knew he was coming back regardless in 09

 

Sometimes exceeding expectations, then going into a lowly slump like the Marlins did, and continuing that, can cost him his job. If we were to suck the entire time, no, he'd still have his job. So yes, in conclusion, I do think this winning streak, regardless of playoffs, helped Fredi keep his job.

 

 

I understand that, and at times Fredi has mishandled the bullpen and taken starting pitchers out too early, but overall he has done a good job, and that is not because of the winning streak. He has kept this team in the playoff race most of the season, and u have to give a manager props for that when the team was predicted to lose 100+ games before the season

 

cough cough JOE GIRARDI cough cough

 

 

Girardi did a good job with day to day managing, he just overworked the starting pitchers, leading to that HORRIBLE 2007 season, now that everyone is healthy, Fredi has actually done well wit the starting pitchers, he still needs to work on managing the bullpen, but other than that he has done a great job

  • Author

Fredi exceeded expectations before September, we knew he was coming back regardless in 09

 

Sometimes exceeding expectations, then going into a lowly slump like the Marlins did, and continuing that, can cost him his job. If we were to suck the entire time, no, he'd still have his job. So yes, in conclusion, I do think this winning streak, regardless of playoffs, helped Fredi keep his job.

 

 

I understand that, and at times Fredi has mishandled the bullpen and taken starting pitchers out too early, but overall he has done a good job, and that is not because of the winning streak. He has kept this team in the playoff race most of the season, and u have to give a manager props for that when the team was predicted to lose 100+ games before the season

 

cough cough JOE GIRARDI cough cough

 

 

Girardi did a good job with day to day managing, he just overworked the starting pitchers, leading to that HORRIBLE 2007 season, now that everyone is healthy, Fredi has actually done well wit the starting pitchers, he still needs to work on managing the bullpen, but other than that he has done a great job

And how many games have we lost because of that?

Sometimes exceeding expectations, then going into a lowly slump like the Marlins did, and continuing that, can cost him his job. If we were to suck the entire time, no, he'd still have his job. So yes, in conclusion, I do think this winning streak, regardless of playoffs, helped Fredi keep his job.

 

 

I understand that, and at times Fredi has mishandled the bullpen and taken starting pitchers out too early, but overall he has done a good job, and that is not because of the winning streak. He has kept this team in the playoff race most of the season, and u have to give a manager props for that when the team was predicted to lose 100+ games before the season

 

cough cough JOE GIRARDI cough cough

 

 

Girardi did a good job with day to day managing, he just overworked the starting pitchers, leading to that HORRIBLE 2007 season, now that everyone is healthy, Fredi has actually done well wit the starting pitchers, he still needs to work on managing the bullpen, but other than that he has done a great job

And how many games have we lost because of that?

 

 

Not his fault he didn't have anybody else in the bullpen who could close out games at the time

I see the point of this topic... but I completely disagree with it.

 

I don't think Fredi's job was in any serious danger. He's well liked by most including the front office... and even without this amazing hot streak, this year was a relative success for Fredi and the ballclub as a whole...

 

A strong finish definitely looks nice, but even without it, the 08 Marlins definitely exceeded expectations

  • Author

I see the point of this topic... but I completely disagree with it.

 

I don't think Fredi's job was in any serious danger. He's well liked by most including the front office... and even without this amazing hot streak, this year was a relative success for Fredi and the ballclub as a whole...

 

A strong finish definitely looks nice, but even without it, the 08 Marlins definitely exceeded expectations

 

But as previously said in this topic, making a bad last impression could be disastrous for him, since that will be what they remember when they make the decision. And if we would've continued our slumping, then he wouldn't have completed our expectations at the halfway point of the season.

I am the most critical one here of Fredi at least the most vocal, I felt that he wasn't gonna be fired anyway even though he is a very mediocre manager and I don't see him as the person to lead this team to the next level. He will manage the Marlins next year and maybe beyond. He doesn't make waves and is low key yes man. I feel he would be better served working in the scouting and development department but for now he is our manager with or without the winning streak. I guess the barometer would really be if the Marlins will extend him a longterm contract with large amount of zeros. I for some reason do not see that happening

He was never going to lose his job. He's managed this club very well and we could have lost 90 games and he would still be here next year.

 

Also, Girardi was tossed because Loria hated him, not because he was bad. Sure, we found out later that he kinda sucks at handling a young pitching staff, but that had nothing to do with his firing.

The post is too long, I didn't bother reading it.

 

 

u do relize that if there weren't spaces in between that is a little over a paragraph, right?

Fredi's job wasn't saved because it was never in trouble. This team was supposed to be a last place team all year and lose around 100 games. Even just the fact that we spent the better part of the first half of the season in first place meant they exceeded expectations. But even if they hadn't, even if we had lost the 90-100 games as expected and finished last, Fredi's job would be fine. Honestly, who could blame him with the starting rotation we started the year with? Who could blame him for not having a starting CF, no consistent healthy corner OF, no obvious catcher, and Jacobs at 1B after the last 2 seasons he had?

 

I mean seriously? Does anyone think Bobby Cox is gonna get fired for how bad the Braves have done this year, and their drop off the last few years? Can you blame him for his entire rotation basically being on the DL, his best hitters either getting hurt now and again or just getting traded, etc? It's one thing to hold a manager responsible for his team's failure to perform up to expectations, but another to blame a team for losing when everyone expected the team to lose even more.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.