Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

What to do with Jake!

Featured Replies

So McPhearson is tearing up the minor leagues with 25 homer in the year and hitting near 300. Why not give him a shot and move Cantu over to first, I don't think he can be any worst than Mike "swing at anything" Jacobs.

 

Besides he hit the most meaningless home run of the year yesterday... there should be some punishment for that lol.

So McPhearson is tearing up the minor leagues with 25 homer in the year and hitting near 300. Why not give him a shot and move Cantu over to first, I don't think he can be any worst than Mike "swing at anything" Jacobs.

 

Besides he hit the most meaningless home run of the year yesterday... there should be some punishment for that lol.

We had another first baseman who used to do the same, except he could really field his position. Then he left us-Derrick Lee

So McPhearson is tearing up the minor leagues with 25 homer in the year and hitting near 300. Why not give him a shot and move Cantu over to first, I don't think he can be any worst than Mike "swing at anything" Jacobs.

 

Besides he hit the most meaningless home run of the year yesterday... there should be some punishment for that lol.

We had another first baseman who used to do the same, except he could really field his position. Then he left us-Derrick Lee

Atleast D-Lee knew how to take a walk.

Move Jake for another bullpen arm.

He is worth more then a bullpen arm.

 

Especially with that worthless first pitch swing and killer average...

 

Move Cantu to 1st, bring up Dallas to 3rd and trade Jacobs for whatever can be had for him

OMG does there HAVE to be a thread about Jacobs poor play EVERY day?

 

What if he has a day where he saves about 6-8 runs some how with his defense and provides 3 or 4 offensively?

What are you going to say then? He's the best player the Marlins have ever had?

 

Come on guys, enough of it.

OMG does there HAVE to be a thread about Jacobs poor play EVERY day?

 

What if he has a day where he saves about 6-8 runs some how with his defense and provides 3 or 4 offensively?

What are you going to say then? He's the best player the Marlins have ever had?

 

Come on guys, enough of it.

 

Honestly

Jacobs is having a pretty good year despite the 240 ba

18 hrs is like 3rd in the NL

He plays decent defensively not bad but nothing special

Swinging at the first pitch- hes agressive somtimes its not a good thing but he ends up making contact and drives in runs which is why he should bat 4th

he has mad power to all fields off leftys and rightys

and hes all or nothing so try it while hammers getting back to form

 

 

wat about cantu

he scrubs it up at 3b no 1 complains

he hits weak popups with no out men on 1st nd 3rd a freakin groundout scores a danm run

 

good lineup

 

Hanley

Hermida

Uggla

Jacobs

Hammer

Cantu

Cody Ross

Catcher

Pitcher

 

or how bout tring pitcher catcher 8 - 9

anything to score runs

Move Jake for another bullpen arm.

He is worth more then a bullpen arm.

 

 

He's likely worth less than an average bullpen arm.

 

When taking into considering both his offense and his defense, he's likely the worst starting 1st baseman in the majors for the third year running.

 

I really had hope for him this year with the power he had been showing, but it look like it went to his head and that's all he's been trying to do. The first pitch pop up swing for the fences but pop it up in the infield pisses me off beyond belief. The guy's patience at the plate has gone to completely sh*t. his BB% has dropped every single year since 2005, his K% has risen every year. Hell he used to walk a pretty good amount (9.1% in 2005, 8.8% in 2006) but it's gone to completely sh*t now (dropped to 6.8% last year and 4.6% this year). His BB/K used to be a good-enough 0.45, now it's an anemic .19. He has completely deteriated in his offensive game.

 

Cantu at first and McPherson at third should improve the infield defene by quite a lot (and our infield defense is going to start becoming a lot more important soon once Volstad is up). Not that they'd be gold glovers at those posistions, but rather the normal defense is just so bad at those posistions (Extremely small sample size but Canu's defense at 1st has still been below average, but that's still a lot better than, but that's still a lot better than competing for worst fielding 3rd with mike lamb).

 

Well, that's also thinking back surgery hasn't completely killed McPherson's defense at third. You certainly have to expect a drop off (which would still be quite a bit above Cantu's defense, as Mcpherson was about an average 3B before), but hopefully it's not a huge drop off.

Move Jake for another bullpen arm.

He is worth more then a bullpen arm.

 

Especially with that worthless first pitch swing and killer average...

 

Move Cantu to 1st, bring up Dallas to 3rd and trade Jacobs for whatever can be had for him

 

minor league success does not always lead to major league success

joe borchard tour up the PCL last year

but did he do well in the majors?

no.

In regards to Jacobs' value it has everything to do with how big a need he fills for a contending or rebuilding team and very little to do with a specific need we're trying to fill.

Honestly I like McPherson, but AAA is AAA. De La Cruz did well in AAA, but he sucks in the majors. Maybe in September for McPherson, or if an injury occurs somewhere.

OMG does there HAVE to be a thread about Jacobs poor play EVERY day?

 

What if he has a day where he saves about 6-8 runs some how with his defense and provides 3 or 4 offensively?

What are you going to say then? He's the best player the Marlins have ever had?

 

Come on guys, enough of it.

 

Isn't that the main part of a forum, to discuss things. I might not agree with getting rid of Jake, but that's the whole point of these threads is to throw stuff out there regardless of their redundancy

Honestly I like McPherson, but AAA is AAA. De La Cruz did well in AAA, but he sucks in the majors. Maybe in September for McPherson, or if an injury occurs somewhere.

 

De la cruz doens't suck. He's a rookie so we have to give him sometime to get used to the mlb competition.

Honestly I like McPherson, but AAA is AAA. De La Cruz did well in AAA, but he sucks in the majors. Maybe in September for McPherson, or if an injury occurs somewhere.

 

De la cruz doens't suck. He's a rookie so we have to give him sometime to get used to the mlb competition.

 

C'mon he does suck, there are much better options in the minors than him (Volstad,Thompson,Hernandez).

Honestly I like McPherson, but AAA is AAA. De La Cruz did well in AAA, but he sucks in the majors. Maybe in September for McPherson, or if an injury occurs somewhere.

 

De la cruz doens't suck. He's a rookie so we have to give him sometime to get used to the mlb competition.

 

C'mon he does suck, there are much better options in the minors than him (Volstad,Thompson,Hernandez).

 

Thompson and Hernandez have both stunk this year.

Nope Mcfearson is are best option

call down andino

call up mcfearson

 

Even if it was a good idea, Andino can't go down (at the earliest) until Amezaga is 100%.

I have been petitioning for McPhearson to be called up for a month and a half, finally some other people are starting to think the same way,

Nope Mcfearson is are best option

call down andino

call up mcfearson

 

Even if it was a good idea, Andino can't go down (at the earliest) until Amezaga is 100%.

Double yeah.

McPherson just hit his 27th homerun and sixth straight game in which he homered. He's hit safely in 10 of his last eleven games. His sts line is off the charts.

 

BTW, for those who think it's just another mile high altitude shot in the PCL, it was hit in Iowa. Elevation 817 ft. About the same as Turner Field in Atlanta.

 

I understand completely roster spotrs don't grow on trees and there are lots of pieces to the puzzle that GMs and their staffs try to put together, so at least for now I'm enjoying following the guy every night and cheering him on. I think what he is doing is a tremendous accomplishment (considering the back story or not) and great baseball. I'm really enjoying it. :brigginbounce

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.