Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

MarlinsBaseball.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dunn or Abreu?

Featured Replies

I would honestly just go with our fielders that we have right now. Let Sanchez and McPherson battle out for a corner infielder spot.

 

But you have to know that Dunn is 100% to improve this team by a good margin. We might not go after him to save money, but all other things being equal, he'd be a ridiculously good addition.

I would honestly just go with our fielders that we have right now. Let Sanchez and McPherson battle out for a corner infielder spot.

 

But you have to know that Dunn is 100% to improve this team by a good margin. We might not go after him to save money, but all other things being equal, he'd be a ridiculously good addition.

 

I agree, though I just dont think signing really... anyone is realistic right now, other than our own players. So what Im saying is I would really rather just go with what we have and not plan on anything other than that.

I would honestly just go with our fielders that we have right now. Let Sanchez and McPherson battle out for a corner infielder spot.

 

But you have to know that Dunn is 100% to improve this team by a good margin. We might not go after him to save money, but all other things being equal, he'd be a ridiculously good addition.

 

I agree, though I just dont think signing really... anyone is realistic right now, other than our own players. So what Im saying is I would really rather just go with what we have and not plan on anything other than that.

 

But, but, but, but......speculation is fun(ish). We know it ain't gonna happen, but we like the high of getting our hopes up, and we deal with the crapiness (of watching him sign somewhere else) when it actually happens. :mis2

but look at his numbers in RF

 

even going by UZR

 

in 182 innings, he was at -10 in RF

in lf, he was at -10 in 980 innings, basically his career norm

 

These numbers are wrong. Where are you getting them from?

 

 

Fangraphs.

 

And what you're not understand about what I'm saying is that there is a learning curve for playing a new position. Playing RF is not the same as playing LF. Do not take into context his RF playing time last season. Just look at his career LF numbers. That's what matters.

but look at his numbers in RF

 

even going by UZR

 

in 182 innings, he was at -10 in RF

in lf, he was at -10 in 980 innings, basically his career norm

 

These numbers are wrong. Where are you getting them from?

 

 

Fangraphs.

 

And what you're not understand about what I'm saying is that there is a learning curve for playing a new position. Playing RF is not the same as playing LF. Do not take into context his RF playing time last season. Just look at his career LF numbers. That's what matters.

 

Cody Ross Career UZR:

 

LF: + .02 in 306 innings

CF: + 6.4 in 1250 innings

RF: + 2.0 in 596 innings

 

Judging by his excellent +6.4 career UZR in CF, one can safely assume he'll excel in LF where much less range is required to be outstanding there.

I was talking about Adam Dunn

 

The reason his defensive numbers were so bad last year were the 182 inn he played in RF for the d-backs.

  • Author

I think everyone citing that this is unrealistic has memory loss. I don't have a doubt in my mind that if Dunn were to be had for one-year, at $7 Million per season, that Loria would be ALL over it. No long term commitment of cash, he's in here to help this team boost to the post-season, and next year he's gone with Logan Morrison to fill in the big shoes.

I think everyone citing that this is unrealistic has memory loss. I don't have a doubt in my mind that if Dunn were to be had for one-year, at $7 Million per season, that Loria would be ALL over it. No long term commitment of cash, he's in here to help this team boost to the post-season, and next year he's gone with Logan Morrison to fill in the big shoes.

 

Except it's $7M. Wake up people. That's like 22% of the current payroll, he isn't coming up with that for a single player. To a guy like Loria, there's no such thing as "a mere" 7 million.

Why we keep talking about signing free agent, when the first thing that comes up is how much he is making, the FO don't want to spent any money and most on here are the same, i think we should stop talking about other players and get ready for the season with what we got.

we are talking about Dunn. dont matter where he is playing, when he usually hits one, it usually would go out at any stadium. plus we might actually get to see a ball reach the right field upper deck.

  • Author

I think everyone citing that this is unrealistic has memory loss. I don't have a doubt in my mind that if Dunn were to be had for one-year, at $7 Million per season, that Loria would be ALL over it. No long term commitment of cash, he's in here to help this team boost to the post-season, and next year he's gone with Logan Morrison to fill in the big shoes.

 

Except it's $7M. Wake up people. That's like 22% of the current payroll, he isn't coming up with that for a single player. To a guy like Loria, there's no such thing as "a mere" 7 million.

 

I think Loria has shown in the past when a great bargain comes along that could put this team into the post-season, and it is a short-term commitment, he will do it.

 

Left handed power hitters work so well at Dolphins Stadium. Good idea!

 

If there is any left-handed power hitter in the last decade that would see zero decline in Dolphin Stadium, it's Adam Dunn.

I think Loria has shown in the past when a great bargain comes along that could put this team into the post-season, and it is a short-term commitment, he will do it.

keep telling yourself that... maybe that was true when he was new and hopeful and trying to prove himself to the market or hoping to change the market, now he is trying to build a new stadium and offers players incentive bonuses of 25 thousand dollars on a million dollar contract.

We already have Dunn in uniform ... it just says McPherson on the back.

No, because Adam Dunn had the most walks in baseball last season.

I know (for me) Abreu is the wrong guy to be on this team and part of me feels the same way about Dunn for two reasons - money and defense. Part of me wants his bat and his OBP so I'm conflicted but in the end in my mind passing on both won't make the difference between making the playoffs or not.

  • Author

I know (for me) Abreu is the wrong guy to be on this team and part of me feels the same way about Dunn for two reasons - money and defense. Part of me wants his bat and his OBP so I'm conflicted but in the end in my mind passing on both won't make the difference between making the playoffs or not.

I agree on passing on Abreu. I'm confident he won't out produce Hermida. But Dunn would change this team dramatically.

We already have Dunn in uniform ... it just says McPherson on the back.

No, because Adam Dunn had the most walks in baseball last season.

 

 

:GASP:

 

NEVER never ever EVER put Adam Dunn and Dallas Mcpherson in the same sentence (which i just did)

Dallas couldnt hold Adam's jock strap.

Im all for getting Dunn for a year. Stick him in left and dont trade anybody, just sit one of the other three (who ever has the worse spring i guess) Adam Dunn hits like a beast. he is worth the 7 mil or whatever. he can help for the playoff push.

 

do it please!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

i would freakin flip if Dunn came to Miami.

I know (for me) Abreu is the wrong guy to be on this team and part of me feels the same way about Dunn for two reasons - money and defense. Part of me wants his bat and his OBP so I'm conflicted but in the end in my mind passing on both won't make the difference between making the playoffs or not.

I agree on passing on Abreu. I'm confident he won't out produce Hermida. But Dunn would change this team dramatically.

 

I agree with passing on Abreu as well, although I wouldn't say I'm confident that Hermida will outproduce him......still, Dunn will absolutely change this team a good bit. Sure, his defense is poor, but he wouldn't be that debilitating at first base (according to what others have reported his numbers say), and he would be replacing Gaby in the potential lineup. That's a MASSIVE upgrade.

I'll pass on Both since neither are in the point of there career to be a 4th Outfielder

I'll be happy if we get Wilkerson Anderson or Griffey.

From MLBTR:

 

Bobby Abreu may have to settle for a one or two year deal at $3MM. Cafardo lists the Angels, Mets, Braves, Dodgers, and Mariners.

 

$3m come on thats value for money!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.