Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

How much longer does Maybin have?

Featured Replies

Maybin has played full-time, a month has almost gone by and he's hitting below .200 for the year with 21 strikeouts and just one RBI. I know he's got potential but how much longer will he get a free pass?

 

Is there a possibility he goes down to the Minors or even replace Boner at lead-off for one more chance by the organization?

Tommy talked about the marlins probably doing something with boner and maybin if the ks continue. MAybin swings through so many pitches.

  • Author

You complain waaaaaaay to much

 

Its the 3rd week of the season

 

CHILL

 

This was not complaining, it was a real question.

 

Tommy even said today that if we keep losing the Marlins are going to have to address the situation with the K's by Boni and Maybin.

You complain waaaaaaay to much

 

Its the 3rd week of the season

 

CHILL

 

This was not complaining, it was a real question.

 

Tommy even said today that if we keep losing the Marlins are going to have to address the situation with the K's by Boni and Maybin.

 

 

Well with Maybin 1st of he changed his stance over the offseason where now hes more standing up which can result in missing the lower pitches.

2nd any mechanical issues that he's having like opening up to early should be addressed by hitting coach Jim Presley.

Bonifacio however is a mystery unsolved

  • Author

You complain waaaaaaay to much

 

Its the 3rd week of the season

 

CHILL

 

This was not complaining, it was a real question.

 

Tommy even said today that if we keep losing the Marlins are going to have to address the situation with the K's by Boni and Maybin.

 

 

Well with Maybin 1st of he changed his stance over the offseason where now hes more standing up which can result in missing the lower pitches.

2nd any mechanical issues that he's having like opening up to early should be addressed by hitting coach Jim Presley.

Bonifacio however is a mystery unsolved

 

Thanks!

 

I'd rather see Maybin start lead off for a couple of days before giving up on him.

 

Boner on the other hand might have been a one week wonder.

Bonifacio however is a mystery unsolved

 

He's like an Adam Dunn, minus the good eye. Oh, and when he hits the ball, it isn't a homerun, its a single.

Mystery solved.

The problem is, who is going to play each of these positions full-time? Carroll instead of Maybin? At least if we send Cantu over to 3rd we can have Gload playing at 1st, and just swap out Gload or Cantu out with Helms every once in awhile.

 

I'm also not sure who we would call up to play for Maybin if it wasn't Carroll. Raynor's not ready, Morrison's injured, our AAA options are the usual crap, etc.

I say move boni to the bottom of the lineup, we can still use his speed and his D has been pretty good.

Moyer looked better at the plate today than maybin has all season and better than boner since after the first week.

think of this if Bonifacio was good player do you think national will have gaving him alway their know he was not good hitter maybe soso hitter that he have alot k

boni sucks.

so he had a good first week...woopi!

he plays good defense i'll give him that.

he has speed which is awesome, but whats the point of having it when you cant reach base?

he k's way to much, doesnt walk enough.

 

like i said from the beginning, he's a bench player at best.

 

maybin, eh, he's pissing me off and maybe should be moved in the lineup.

but i still have tons of faith in him.

The problem is, who is going to play each of these positions full-time? Carroll instead of Maybin? At least if we send Cantu over to 3rd we can have Gload playing at 1st, and just swap out Gload or Cantu out with Helms every once in awhile.

 

I'm also not sure who we would call up to play for Maybin if it wasn't Carroll. Raynor's not ready, Morrison's injured, our AAA options are the usual crap, etc.

 

 

I don't think our AAA options necessarily suck. They might not be our long term option but De Aza can replace some of Boni's speed at the top of the lineup and I guarantee he'll hit better. Plus he could spell Maybin in center field. And then there's Gaby who is coming around although I'm not sure how they're gonna work him in. Heck, even Manny Mayorson has hit the ball at all levels, has a good glove and speed and can be the utility man if Boni goes down. I'd take him over Coughlin right now.

The problem is, who is going to play each of these positions full-time? Carroll instead of Maybin? At least if we send Cantu over to 3rd we can have Gload playing at 1st, and just swap out Gload or Cantu out with Helms every once in awhile.

 

I'm also not sure who we would call up to play for Maybin if it wasn't Carroll. Raynor's not ready, Morrison's injured, our AAA options are the usual crap, etc.

 

 

I don't think our AAA options necessarily suck. They might not be our long term option but De Aza can replace some of Boni's speed at the top of the lineup and I guarantee he'll hit better. Plus he could spell Maybin in center field. And then there's Gaby who is coming around although I'm not sure how they're gonna work him in. Heck, even Manny Mayorson has hit the ball at all levels, has a good glove and speed and can be the utility man if Boni goes down. I'd take him over Coughlin right now.

Mayorsons sporting a career minor league 638 OPS and his best in a full season was 786 OPS as a 25 year old without college experience in AA. His glove could be better than Coghlans at this point, but he's never earned any MLB consideration.

The season just started, no reason to give up on Maybin right now...besides I really don't see a better option at the moment.

Well the whole point in leaving ABQ was to provide us with a complete developmental system so sending Maybin, who has never seen AAA, down would probably be a really good idea. The question is how does the outfield line up without him?

Well the whole point in leaving ABQ was to provide us with a complete developmental system so sending Maybin, who has never seen AAA, down would probably be a really good idea. The question is how does the outfield line up without him?

We didn't leave the Topes, they left us.

they need to give hima real chance not batting before the pitcher

 

that is a horrid spot for a k high rookie

 

foolishness

Well the whole point in leaving ABQ was to provide us with a complete developmental system so sending Maybin, who has never seen AAA, down would probably be a really good idea. The question is how does the outfield line up without him?

We didn't leave the Topes, they left us.

Either way, we're out of there.

IMO give Carroll a shot at starting. Let him start for a week and see how he does.

IMO give Carroll a shot at starting. Let him start for a week and see how he does.

I like Carroll too but I don't like his career .387 OPS at a corner spot, nor do I think he can stay healthy as an every day guy. Maybe something like Hermida/Ross/Gload could work though.

Unfortunately for Carroll, this is about all that he is suited for, 25th man coming in for defensive reasons. If he does well PH, he'll move up the ranks. I like how Fredi rewarded him with a PH AB today after he had a great AB against lidge last night, although tonight was a horrible AB. But if he strings together a couple more good ABs, he could surpass Alfredo as spot starting OFer, move up from there.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.