November 5, 200917 yr The Red Sox have reportedly acquired Jeremy Hermida from the Marlins for left-handers Hunter Jones and Jose Alvarez. That's how far Hermida's stock had fallen with the Marlins. We still think it's ridiculous they didn't wait a few more weeks and see if something better came along. Hermida disappointed to the tune of a .259/.348/.392 line last season, but he's still just 25 and he hasn't lost the skills that made him one of baseball's best prospects a few years ago. It's tough to tell what the Red Sox will do with him, but they saw a chance to pick up a nice asset at a small price and pounced. Red Sox acquired outfielder Jeremy Hermida from the Marlins for LHP Hunter Jones and LHP Jose Alvarez. Hermida, the 11th overall pick in the 2002 draft, frustrated with the Marlins with injuries and unexceptional play in four years as a major leaguer and there was no way the team was going to pay him $3 million or so in his second year of arbitration. Still, it's a shame that they couldn't do better than a pair of generic left-handers. Hermida still has a lot of promise. He hit .296/.369/.501 in 123 games in 2007, and he's just going to be 26 next year. The Red Sox may not be content with him as a regular in the event that Jason Bay leaves, but they couldn't pass on the chance to acquire him at this price. But yea. He's never gone off. Just 2 years ago, and he's hit righties consistently. This was a great low risk move for the Red Sox. Sucks we had to part for this low, but hopefully Hunter turns into a useful reliever. You act like Hermida played at a All-Star level a couple of years ago but he didn't. His hitting also didn't make up for the fact that he is one of the worst defensive outfielders that I have EVER seen. Still, this was a good move for the Red Sox because they didn't give up anything to get him. I've seen Hunter Jones pitch and it was not pretty. You act like he's the worst player EVER. Just in, dude, he's not. He's an average player. Yes, he's a bust, but at the end of the day he's an average player. This is a great trade for Boston.
November 5, 200917 yr And it's over. I wonder who's next, though. very likely its Uggla, like 95% likely. However, that may be it for key players getting traded. Obviously some of our relievers will be gone, and we need to replace some of those bench players, but the team seems to be in tact for next year. Hopefully, they get a true 3B going into next year. Not comfortable with Gaby starting to begin next season.
November 5, 200917 yr Took way too damn long. You won't be missed here Hermida, hopefully you succeed in a lefty friendly park, but you were nothing more than a negative player in my eyes. I agree. He should've been more like Robert Andino...a positive player... Thanks for another irrelevent post Erick, always nice to know you have no sense of staying on topic. Seemed I was in the minority back at the beginning of 08 who thought Hermida would still be a below average player, when everybody else here expected him to explode immediately and become all star caliber. But yeah, lets feel sorry for getting rid of the no hustle, no role (as in, still doesn't know what type of hitter he is) player. No sorrow here, glad to finally be done with having to argue with the Hermi lovers here. What he said was relevant. How can you defend Andino, who is absolutely horrible, yet bash Hermida?
November 5, 200917 yr It wasn't relevent, actually, since Andino has no place in any sort of Hermida conversation. And people who have been on this board understand the meaning behind my Andino rants. It isn't a simple answer when it comes to Andino. It is however, a simple answer when it comes to Hermida, and it isn't very pretty. He never showed any kind of positive consistancy as a hitter, and when watching him seemed more like a detriment to the team than a player helping to win games.
November 5, 200917 yr At least this means there won't be any more idiots who say Hermida is worthless. I wonder who the scapegoat will be now?
November 5, 200917 yr At least this means there won't be any more idiots who say Hermida is worthless. I wonder who the scapegoat will be now? Pretty sure it'll be Maybin.
November 5, 200917 yr At least this means there won't be any more idiots who say Hermida is worthless. I wonder who the scapegoat will be now? Anyone who continually watches 2-0 fastballs right down the middle but will always swing at the next 2 pitches in the dirt.
November 5, 200917 yr Holly will be devastated. I was just about to say that. Someone put her on suicide watch.
November 6, 200917 yr Seems like only yesterday when we were hearing his name in the Manny rumors. Ahhh memories.
November 6, 200917 yr And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it" Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter. Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have. And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it.
November 6, 200917 yr ESPN reported this and deceivingly listed Hermida's fielding percentage and his one error this season leading Bo Sox fans to believe that Hermida is possible "defensive substitution" in the outfield. Too funny! :lol
November 6, 200917 yr The trading has begun! Hermida was given plenty of chances. Time to move on. Next up, Cantu or Uggla!
November 6, 200917 yr And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it" Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter. Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have. And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it. You get attacked because you always exxagerate when it comes to Hermida. A serviceable backup? If he becomes consistent, he is a starter on a contending team. No doubt.
November 6, 200917 yr Me being a Yankee fan should I be happy with this move? Are you looking for someone on this board to tell you how to feel? Do the research and then come up with your own opinion.
November 6, 200917 yr And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it" Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter. Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have. And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it. You get attacked because you always exxagerate when it comes to Hermida. A serviceable backup? If he becomes consistent, he is a starter on a contending team. No doubt. His consistancy dates to a half of the 2007 season and a month in 2009, how exactly should anyone bank on him ever becoming consistant. He has been a hell of a lot more consistantly bad than he has been good. And I don't believe I exagerate when it comes to Hermida, because he has shown what he is. He ended the season becoming basically the backup to Brett Carroll, having some platoon opportunities. So to call him a serviceable backup, yeah, he certainly can be that MAYBE, but to ever become a starter, he never showed he can sustain any kind of production to become that. There's a reason people rely on talking about potential to discuss what Hermida is, because he has very little to no production on the field to say anything good about. It's a small risk for the Red Sox, and it could work out bad, but he was never going to succeed as a Marlin, and I don't think he can be anything more than a career backup from now on (or a starter for a REALLY bad team).
November 6, 200917 yr Me being a Yankee fan should I be happy with this move? Being a Yankees fan I would first and foremost be celebrating having won the World Series. Personal preference though.
November 6, 200917 yr http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/index.php/boston-acquires-hermida (from Fangraphs.com) Jeremy Hermida seemed destined for the land of non-tenders as late as a week ago, but not any longer as the Boston Red Sox have acquired the corner outfielder via trade. Hermida is formerly a top prospect with nearly 2,000 plate appearances in the bigs. Over that time his bat has played slightly above average (a .336 wOBA) while his defense has left much to be desired. The story with Hermida has been his lack of power. Since 2007 – when he first broke onto the scene as a true regular – his ISO has slipped in each season. From .205 to .157 down to .133, the soon-to-be 26-year-old was going the wrong way, even drawing some comparisons to former wunderkind-to-bust Ben Grieve. Fenway park is more receptive to offense – putting it lightly – which should raise Hermida’s offensive production without so much as a true increase in talent. Barring something unforeseen – like Boston not addressing the left field spot further – Hermida figures to be a bench player for them in 2010 and potentially beyond. Assuming he actually starts next season in Boston and isn’t flipped for something else through the off-season. For their efforts to move Hermida, Florida receives a pair of arms. Lefties Hunter Jones and Jose Alvarez. Jones features impressive minor league numbers but has velocity that averages about 87 miles per hour. He’s a fastball/slider guy and 12 innings is far too small of a sample size to say one way or the other, but if his contact rate continues to be around 87% don’t look for him to sit down nearly 10 batters per nine like he did in the minors. He’s better against lefties, as you would expect. I know next-to-nothing about Alvarez. He was as tarter in the system with unimpressive strikeout rates which somehow dipped to 4 per nine after switching to relief and heading to High-A.
November 6, 200917 yr And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it" Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter. Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have. And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it. You get attacked because you always exxagerate when it comes to Hermida. A serviceable backup? If he becomes consistent, he is a starter on a contending team. No doubt. His consistancy dates to a half of the 2007 season and a month in 2009, how exactly should anyone bank on him ever becoming consistant. He has been a hell of a lot more consistantly bad than he has been good. And I don't believe I exagerate when it comes to Hermida, because he has shown what he is. He ended the season becoming basically the backup to Brett Carroll, having some platoon opportunities. So to call him a serviceable backup, yeah, he certainly can be that MAYBE, but to ever become a starter, he never showed he can sustain any kind of production to become that. There's a reason people rely on talking about potential to discuss what Hermida is, because he has very little to no production on the field to say anything good about. It's a small risk for the Red Sox, and it could work out bad, but he was never going to succeed as a Marlin, and I don't think he can be anything more than a career backup from now on (or a starter for a REALLY bad team). Hermida can hit. We know that. You know that. If he can consistently hit, he will be a starter. Not for Boston, because of Bay and Drew, but for some team he can be. That is what I meant. Hermida ended the season injured. Not on the bench. You see what I mean by exaggerating? Which is why I said if he can stay consistent, he will be a starter. His problem is he is hot and cold. One month, he'll OPS .900+, another he'll OPS .600. If he can stay consistent, he will be a starter.
November 6, 200917 yr glad he is gone...boston, just getting over the nightmare that was mark bellhorn, will now have to deal with someone who watches even more good pitches go right by
November 6, 200917 yr Jermida, I'll always remember how you never seemed sure you were supposed to chase that ball down.
November 6, 200917 yr And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it" Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter. Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have. And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it. You get attacked because you always exxagerate when it comes to Hermida. A serviceable backup? If he becomes consistent, he is a starter on a contending team. No doubt. His consistancy dates to a half of the 2007 season and a month in 2009, how exactly should anyone bank on him ever becoming consistant. He has been a hell of a lot more consistantly bad than he has been good. And I don't believe I exagerate when it comes to Hermida, because he has shown what he is. He ended the season becoming basically the backup to Brett Carroll, having some platoon opportunities. So to call him a serviceable backup, yeah, he certainly can be that MAYBE, but to ever become a starter, he never showed he can sustain any kind of production to become that. There's a reason people rely on talking about potential to discuss what Hermida is, because he has very little to no production on the field to say anything good about. It's a small risk for the Red Sox, and it could work out bad, but he was never going to succeed as a Marlin, and I don't think he can be anything more than a career backup from now on (or a starter for a REALLY bad team). Hermida can hit. We know that. You know that. If he can consistently hit, he will be a starter. Not for Boston, because of Bay and Drew, but for some team he can be. That is what I meant. Hermida ended the season injured. Not on the bench. You see what I mean by exaggerating? Which is why I said if he can stay consistent, he will be a starter. His problem is he is hot and cold. One month, he'll OPS .900+, another he'll OPS .600. If he can stay consistent, he will be a starter. I honestly believe that the injury was made to be worse than it really was. My opinion on the matter was that the team wanted to find a way to give Maybin some work the rest of the season, so Hermida's wrist injury gave them the excuse to get him in. And I think that a 1 week injury early on in the season became a 1 month injury because of the emergence of Maybin. And we are pretty much stating the same thing, however you believe that he can become consistant at some point , I believe it just isn't going to happen. People have been waiting way too long for him to get it all together. The scouts obviously missed something key when scouting him back in the minors that teams caught onto. Either that or the Marlins did a horrible job in the way they managed him through his time in the majors. I remember Pressley tweaking his mindset at the plate (which eventually led to his 100 K season), I think that could be a big part. But my ultimate feelings are that Hermida is damaged goods.
November 6, 200917 yr And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it" Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter. Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have. And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it. You get attacked because you always exxagerate when it comes to Hermida. A serviceable backup? If he becomes consistent, he is a starter on a contending team. No doubt. His consistancy dates to a half of the 2007 season and a month in 2009, how exactly should anyone bank on him ever becoming consistant. He has been a hell of a lot more consistantly bad than he has been good. And I don't believe I exagerate when it comes to Hermida, because he has shown what he is. He ended the season becoming basically the backup to Brett Carroll, having some platoon opportunities. So to call him a serviceable backup, yeah, he certainly can be that MAYBE, but to ever become a starter, he never showed he can sustain any kind of production to become that. There's a reason people rely on talking about potential to discuss what Hermida is, because he has very little to no production on the field to say anything good about. It's a small risk for the Red Sox, and it could work out bad, but he was never going to succeed as a Marlin, and I don't think he can be anything more than a career backup from now on (or a starter for a REALLY bad team). Hermida can hit. We know that. You know that. If he can consistently hit, he will be a starter. Not for Boston, because of Bay and Drew, but for some team he can be. That is what I meant. Hermida ended the season injured. Not on the bench. You see what I mean by exaggerating? Which is why I said if he can stay consistent, he will be a starter. His problem is he is hot and cold. One month, he'll OPS .900+, another he'll OPS .600. If he can stay consistent, he will be a starter. I honestly believe that the injury was made to be worse than it really was. My opinion on the matter was that the team wanted to find a way to give Maybin some work the rest of the season, so Hermida's wrist injury gave them the excuse to get him in. And I think that a 1 week injury early on in the season became a 1 month injury because of the emergence of Maybin. And we are pretty much stating the same thing, however you believe that he can become consistant at some point, I believe it just isn't going to happen. People have been waiting way too long for him to get it all together. The scouts obviously missed something key when scouting him back in the minors that teams caught onto. No, they didn't make it as an excuse. He had an .855 OPS in the month of August. There was no reason to sit him. Never said that. You said he will be a serviceable backup if he can become consistent. I'm arguing against that. If he can finally become a consistent hitter, he will be a starter.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.