Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Hermida traded to Boston

Featured Replies

  • Author

Wow, this came out of nowhere. Sure, we all knew he was going to be traded but I didn't expect him to be moved within 24 hours of the last out of the World Series.

 

I think Hermida will put up better numbers with a change of scenery. I think he will replicate his 2007 numbers in a limited role.

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

Wow, this came out of nowhere. Sure, we all knew he was going to be traded but I didn't expect him to be moved within 24 hours of the last out of the World Series.

 

I think Hermida will put up better numbers with a change of scenery. I think he will replicate his 2007 numbers in a limited role.

 

 

 

I think this shows how much the FO wanted to get rid of him. They bit on the first offer.

Well, Hermida didn't seem to have the friendliest relationship with Fredi Gonzalez and the front office.

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

It's not realistic, and I never said it was. But you stated that if he does become a consistent hitter, he will be a serviceable backup. That is not true. This is a guy who can hit .800-.850 OPS over a full year if he is consistent. But, unfortunately, he isn't consistent. That is one of his main problems. He is hot and cold.

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

It's not realistic, and I never said it was. But you stated that if he does become a consistent hitter, he will be a serviceable backup. That is not true. This is a guy who can hit .800-.850 OPS over a full year if he is consistent. But, unfortunately, he isn't consistent. That is one of his main problems. He is hot and cold.

 

 

We haven't seen a consistant season from Hermida, so how can we say diffinitively what the defintion of a "consistant" season for Hermida would be? I certainly cannot say that. It is the reason the word "potential" has been used nonstop when regarding Hermida, and that word being used so much in the past when discussing him may have always been the most frustrating part in the life story of Jeremy Hermida.

 

I'm stating my belief that he has the "potential" to become a starter again, but it is just that, an opinion at this point. We may never know what he could've become.

 

I finally see where you are coming from, the whole "serviceable backup" is a belief I have built for Hermida based off his play at the major league level. Just an observation on my part. Like I have stated multiple times in this thread, opinions will differ on what Hermida can possibly become, because there is no way we have seen how bad or good Hermida can possibly get, and we may see him hit rock bottom, superstardom, or w/e with the Red Sox considering his inconsistant past.

Finally he's gone. Won't be surprised to see him do better in BOS though.

 

I agree Maybin is the next whipping boy if he doesn't play well right away.

Jermida, I'll always remember how you never seemed sure you were supposed to chase that ball down.

 

You wrote the same thing on facebook lol.

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

It's not realistic, and I never said it was. But you stated that if he does become a consistent hitter, he will be a serviceable backup. That is not true. This is a guy who can hit .800-.850 OPS over a full year if he is consistent. But, unfortunately, he isn't consistent. That is one of his main problems. He is hot and cold.

 

 

We haven't seen a consistant season from Hermida, so how can we say diffinitively what the defintion of a "consistant" season for Hermida would be? I certainly cannot say that. Thus the reason the word "potential" has been used nonstop when regarding Hermida, and that word being used so much in the past when discussing him may have always been the most frustrating part in the life story of Jeremy Hermida.

 

Consistent is a positive word for me. Therefore, I mean it in a positive way, lol. If he can consistently have good months instead of bad months, then he would be a starter.

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

Are you trying to make fun of someone or something?

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

Are you trying to make fun of someone or something?

 

 

Are you trying to seduce me?

 

 

 

 

 

 

but seriously, what kind of f*cking question is that?

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

Are you trying to make fun of someone or something?

 

I'm sorry, but every time you post I can't help but laugh.

If he becomes the kind of "consistant" that he showed the second half of 07 and first month of this year, he would be a .900+ OPS guy and hitting in the best of the best in the major leagues. How realistic is that? He has shown that he is more of a mid .700 OPS kind of player, and a around a .780 OPS hitter against RHP, so he is serviceable as a platoon player.

 

However, as a full time starter for a contending team? A team would be held back by that kind of player. His spurts don't make up for his overall inconsistancy. We can guess all we want about where he can and will be, but in the end all we have to look back on is his past history, and aside from a half a season and the month of April and August on 09, he has been in the bottom echelan (sp?) of starting major league LFers. At this point, he seems to be no more than a serviceable backup on the Red Sox unless something drastically changes.

 

 

 

Are you trying to make fun of someone or something?

 

 

Are you trying to seduce me?

 

 

 

 

 

 

but seriously, what kind of f*cking question is that?

 

 

A legit question that has me confused. B/c you just quoted a "word" that no one else has used. And the reason no one else has used it is because you're the only one spelling it wrong...about 20 times, at least, in this thread. So really I'm not sure if you don't know how to spell the word, or if you're trying to imitate someone from the past.

Me being a Yankee fan should I be happy with this move?

 

 

Being a Yankees fan I would first and foremost be celebrating having won the World Series. Personal preference though.

 

You mean BUYING the World Series title, but that is for a different thread.

 

I guess Buster Olney didn't have all the insider info this morning on Mike and Mike. I guess the Admins should lock my thread about Buster and Hermida, because its a moot point now.

Well, Hermida didn't seem to have the friendliest relationship with Fredi Gonzalez and the front office.

 

 

Please elaborate on this.....I wasn't aware of any major problems. I knew he wasn't a favorite of the organization, because he had been a disappointment, but I have never heard of any personality clashes with Freddi or Beinfest.

I have to say that I really believe this has to be amongst the toughest trades for beinfest to make. I am sure it is very hard for him to give up on Hermida who has a world of talent but it was just inevitable. We all know we would not see Hermida in a Marlin's uniform on opening day 2010. Hermida needed a change of scenary and I am sure that most of us really wish him well I just hope we get at least something of future value for him and not just scrapheap.BTW Boston is a great place for him!

I don't think Hermida was ever going to come around in Florida. He might become a better player in Boston, but he wasn't going to do it here.

I don't think Hermida was ever going to come around in Florida. He might become a better player in Boston, but he wasn't going to do it here.

 

 

So true...

sounds like a replacement for pinto and an arm that might be ready for a badenhop-esque role in 2-3 years.

Me being a Yankee fan should I be happy with this move?

 

 

 

Are you looking for someone on this board to tell you how to feel? Do the research and then come up with your own opinion.

 

I'm always a fan of the:

 

Is Google broken? :blink:

Don't worry guys, we still have Boni (and Maybin if he doesn't smash pitching immediately).

difference between maybin and hermida is that we've had 4 years of "oh hey dont worry he'll be a superstar veryyy soon. gotta give him time". Maybin has yet to have one full year in the bigs.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.