Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Hermida traded to Boston

Featured Replies

Maybin should at least play good defense, run bases well, ect ect.

 

Hermida didn't do anything right the past two years

This is basically Hermida for nada, and I expect him to prosper in Boston. I have some hope for Alvarez, but Jones is too old to be that guy.

difference between maybin and hermida is that we've had 4 years of "oh hey dont worry he'll be a superstar veryyy soon. gotta give him time". Maybin has yet to have one full year in the bigs.

 

I remember hearing the Hermida stuff as early as 2006, and a bunch in the first half of 2007.

This quote literally made my day

 

"He hasn't fulfilled his potential yet," Epstein said of the former top prospect. "We acquired him today to see if he can fulfill that potential."

Is he even going to start?

 

I doubt it, but they'll find him 350-400 PA against mostly right handed pitching and he'll probably just magically be awesome with a change of environment, and especially that ballpark.

 

I would think it all depends on if they re-sign FA Jason Bay. I see no reason why they wouldn't, but ya never know.

The Red Sox have reportedly acquired Jeremy Hermida from the Marlins for left-handers Hunter Jones and Jose Alvarez.

That's how far Hermida's stock had fallen with the Marlins. We still think it's ridiculous they didn't wait a few more weeks and see if something better came along. Hermida disappointed to the tune of a .259/.348/.392 line last season, but he's still just 25 and he hasn't lost the skills that made him one of baseball's best prospects a few years ago. It's tough to tell what the Red Sox will do with him, but they saw a chance to pick up a nice asset at a small price and pounced.

 

Red Sox acquired outfielder Jeremy Hermida from the Marlins for LHP Hunter Jones and LHP Jose Alvarez.

Hermida, the 11th overall pick in the 2002 draft, frustrated with the Marlins with injuries and unexceptional play in four years as a major leaguer and there was no way the team was going to pay him $3 million or so in his second year of arbitration. Still, it's a shame that they couldn't do better than a pair of generic left-handers. Hermida still has a lot of promise. He hit .296/.369/.501 in 123 games in 2007, and he's just going to be 26 next year. The Red Sox may not be content with him as a regular in the event that Jason Bay leaves, but they couldn't pass on the chance to acquire him at this price.

 

But yea. He's never gone off. Just 2 years ago, and he's hit righties consistently. This was a great low risk move for the Red Sox. Sucks we had to part for this low, but hopefully Hunter turns into a useful reliever.

 

You act like Hermida played at a All-Star level a couple of years ago but he didn't. His hitting also didn't make up for the fact that he is one of the worst defensive outfielders that I have EVER seen. Still, this was a good move for the Red Sox because they didn't give up anything to get him. I've seen Hunter Jones pitch and it was not pretty.

 

Gotta disagree with that. When he wanted to he was pretty good out there. Problem was that he didn't want to very often. He was a lazy fielder and a lazy hitter most of his time here.

Thank you, thank you, thank you.

I'm ecstatic to get his lazy arse out of here. If there's one thing that ticks me off more than anything it's a lazy player.

Go ahead Jeremy. Get off your $%# and pack your bags. Off you go.

My apologies if it turns out that he really has some mental disorder, which I've always suspected.

this sucks hermida was one of my favorite players =( i hope he does great in boston. i always cheer for former marlin players and boston has a few of them.

And after reading some posts on the Red Sox board, the major point people seem to mention is "Worth what we gave up" and "Potential is worth it"

 

 

Fine, you want to live on neverending potential, fine. I won't deny his road stats are fine, but we have all watched Hermida the last few years. Yes, a part of his failures was the Marlins park, but watching him since he was called up, he hasn't shown much of all in any kind of improvement since 2007. He had a good April in 09, but that was it. He hasn't shown any kind of consistancy as a hitter.

 

Once he shows any kind of consistancy, then call him a "serviceable backup", but it is VERY VERY slim that he ever becomes a starter for any kind of contender ever again. I think if the Red Sox were planning to let Jason Bay go, they'd have a better backup plan than Hermida, especially with the kind of resources they have.

 

And I expect to get attack, as it always seems to happen, in this Hermida discussion. Have at it.

 

Really, a trade like this boils down to money. The Red Sox can afford to spend $3-4 million in 2010 and hope that he lives up to his potential. For the Marlins, that's impossible with a payroll like ours. We have to let him go if we want to have any chance to keep some of our more important guys.

I hated him here, but like i said countless times during the year, he will be a pretty good platoon DH type player. If he gets his ab's i could see him putting up a .280 15 hr's 60 rbi year in limited playing time.

 

Cant wwait till he misplays a ball in rf though, want to see how he reacts

Found this Article on the trade...

 

http://mlb.fanhouse.com/2009/11/09/hermida-could-pay-off-big-for-red-sox/?ncid=txtlnkusspor00000002

 

 

Hermida Could Pay Off Big for Red Sox

 

 

In Advanced Scouting, MLB FanHouse's professional talent evaluator breaks down offseason moves from a scouting perspective.

 

It hasn't taken long for the Hot Stove to get heated up as we roll past the World Series. Some key players have already been locked up and some high upside trades have already gone down. What do these moves mean for each club involved and how will the players dealt respond to their new homes? Just as significant, how important will the prospects dealt turn out to be?

 

From Mark Teahen headed to Chicago, to the Carlos Gomez for J.J. Hardy swap, to Bobby Abreu's new deal with the Angels, each move had a distinct impact. Perhaps the most interesting of these, however, was Jeremy Hermida being shipped to Boston. For the price of a pair of young lefties, the Red Sox took a gamble that may prove very worthy.

 

There was a time when Jeremy Hermida was a can't-miss outfielder, considered pretty much unanimously to be one of the top prospects in all of baseball. For the former Marlin, those days were many setbacks ago. But make no mistake, there was good reason he was held in such high regard on his way up through the minor leagues. The raw power potential is still very much there and he has the skills that any scout points to with excitement.

 

On the other hand, the story of a player with physical skills that doesn't pan out has been retold many a time. So, did Boston get the player who never reaches that high ceiling or one it can help turn the corner?

 

There's no clear answer here, but it's safe to say that Boston has a good track record with left-handed hitters in recent years. Giving a guy like Hermida something to shoot for with that inviting Green Monster in left field will be fascinating to watch. It could very well put him in a better frame of mind at the plate. If they can get him confident in his ability to drive the ball to the opposite field, he could still blossom into the .300-hitting, 20-homer bat scouts envisioned a few years ago.

 

Considering his contract, his injury trouble and his failure thus far to reach his potential, Hermida is most definitely a gamble for the Red Sox. That only leaves the issue of the players that Boston sent to Florida in return.

 

First, there is lefty reliever Hunter Jones. With a fastball hovering around 86-88 mph, Jones is not a guy who figures to ever be a key setup man in a major league bullpen. If he's going to have a career, it's going to have to be against left-handed hitters. He relies heavily on his sweeping breaking ball and has shown he can have some success against tough lefty bats, but all things considered, this isn't a player Boston fans need to be concerned about dealing for a high-upside player like Hermida.

 

Jose Alvarez, the second and even lesser known of the two lefty arms Boston sent to the Marlins, also does not profile as a savior in this deal for Florida. After scouting him back in spring training, my impression of Alvarez was not an uncommon one. This isn't a pitcher with standout skills or projectability. There are some things to like about the 20-year-old southpaw, who finished the season at advanced Single-A, but he is not going to wow anyone with his raw stuff.

 

He's a feel pitcher with plus command of his pitches, and that control is going to need to remain for him if he's going to have success at higher levels. His fastball sits at 86-89 mph and he relies heavily on his two average secondary pitches. He has confidence in his changeup and has proved he could locate his 74-77 mph breaking ball against lefties.

 

The main concern with Alvarez is his over-aggressiveness in the zone. He gets too much plate when he's ahead in the count for a pitcher with less-than-electric stuff. Overall, there is enough there for him to have a role in a big-league bullpen, but given his smallish frame and current stuff there isn't a lot of upside.

 

If there is gamble for Boston in picking up Jeremy Hermida, it is not because it gave up high upside talent to get him. Clearly this was about dumping salary from the Marlins' perspective, and that is the positive they must take from this, because the talent they received doesn't come close to equaling Hermida's upside.

 

It appears We didn't really get much at all for Hermida by consensus I guess addition by subtraction

Whenever I read definitive statements by bloggers regardless of their "expertise" or seniority the first thing I do is take a look for myself.

 

It "should" be interesting to see what Hermida does in Fenway with the Green Monster looming in left. Except this oft-repeated (at least for the last few days) observation might have some crediblity if the author(s) bothered to see how many homeruns Hermida actually hit to the opposite field in 2009 and as far as I can tell checking all the stadiums in the NL east and about six or so more NL stadiums where I know the Marlins had series, Hermida appears to have exactly zero homeruns in 2009 to left. If I missed one, my bad.

 

This is exactly the same as "Hanley really wasn't that good" in 2006 when the Fenway faithful tried to convince themselves that King Theo the Great had plundered another mark. Here's what I know, Hermida was a dead man walking with this team since the late summer 2008 when Fredi benched him. 2009 for whatever reason or excuse people want to conjure up was just deja vu all over again if you get my drift.

 

I would guess, and that's exactly what it is, there's a 25% chance Hermida gets cut before the arbitration deadline and probably double that that he's not on the BoSox Opening Day roster, maybe higher depending on who Theo signs or re-signs. Let's face it in a world where literally a hundred new faces will be in spring training in 2010 looking to grab a roster spot at the expense of a chronic "underachiever" (another popular phrase these days) or the wealth of free agents who will be scrounging around for work promising every GM their agent can corner twice as much output for half of what they made last season, Hermida's true value is pretty low in this highly competitively market especially since he's guaranteed a raise in arbitration.

 

If he were worth more we would have gotten more. It's that simple. Two or three or four GMs would have been recharging their Blackberries every few hours just to make sure they didn't miss that all important Hermida call. Since no one has reported anything to the contrary we are left with one thing - there was no "market" for Hermida and we got what we could.

 

The Marlins were left with two choices - get something or non-tender him and get nothing. They chose the former. And no matter how declarative someone in the blogosphere presents himself, the fact is they have no idea what they are talking about anymore than any of us do so I wouldn't get my panties in a twist worrying about what's posted in the Red Sox-centric world of Fanhouse or Bleacher Report or SOSH. 93% of the Red Sox faithful/internet experts didn't know Jose Alvarez existed before he was moved in this deal and now they are out by the scores guaranteeing he'll never see a major league mound because King Theo would never let talent get away.

 

As for the Green Monster and Hermida, one last thought, as a Fenway rat I can't tell you how many ballplayers came and went thinking their salvation was only 310 ft away. Bucky F'ing Dent got lucky, most of them didn't. Could be the worst thing that could happen to a guy like Hermida if he starts letting it get inside his head because he's a pull hitter and he ought to concentrate on what he does best not start shooting for an impossible target. But first he has to make the team and that's not a lock. Not in 2010.

Where does Boston's AAA affiliate play?

 

 

McCoy Stadium in Pawtucket, RI.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.