Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins Unlikely to Move Uggla, Ross

Featured Replies

  • Author

Cantu needs to be gone before the 31st regardless of being a buyer or a seller.

 

 

No doubt about that and it's better for us that teams like the Giants and Rockies are interested and the Rangers are pretty much desperate for him.

It's probably more of the fact that they're not convinced Coghlan can play 3B...at least not immediately.

Morrison would easily outproduce Cantu.

 

I think that's probably true (though, really, Cantu can't play 3B either).

 

Cantu is terrible at third, but his play has more to do with a lack of ability than familiarity with the position. I would think that Coghlan would have just as much ability, but I still remember 2006 where the whole infield was making rookie mistakes and constant head-scratching plays. And I remember last year where Bonifacio did the same thing, even though he's actually a versatile and decent defensive player. Having a guy who isn't comfortable at the position is going to result in a lot of costly mistakes that may be both worse and more numerous than what even Cantu is making.

You've got a point, as CC was originally a 3B but hasn't regularly played it since '06 (he did play some games at 3B in '09 and '08).

 

That's the smart way to think about it, but that's not how this team thinks about it. Going back as far as Miggie this team has put guys at 3B who hadn't played 3B regularly for a while (or ever).

 

Miggie hadn't played 3B for a couple years until he was put there at the end of '05 when Lowell got injured. Cantu hadn't played 3B regularly ever before we put him there, though he played some games there in 2004 and 1 game in 2007. Bonifacio had never played 3B until we put him there (unless he played some in Winter League, 2003 would probably have the most information there, though 2003 always said that most of the games he played there was in the OF).

 

So why, with the first guy since Lowell who is a natural 3B, are we suddenly afraid to put him there because he hasn't played it regularly for a few years?

 

Chris Coghlan isn't a natural third basemen though. He was drafted as a third basemen, but was moved to second rather early on. He looks more like a second basemen, and there is no way he has a third base arm. On top of that, he was an error machine at third base in the minors, except for last year where he got into a few games at third and only made one error. But even in 2008, in 10 games at third he made 5 errors, while he was vastly better at second. He's got experience at third, but is still not what I would call a natural.

 

Cabrera actually was a natural third basemen early in his career. His weight issues did not creep up until later, dictating the move to first. Other than that, he had the tools to play third, while I can't say if Coghlan does or not.

I'm one who's not ready to throw in the towel, and I've been a Cantu fan for some time, but I'm ready to trade Cantu and try someone else at third. Thing is, I'd go with Helms to start with. His defense is probably as good as any of the other choices, maybe better. I've heard that his average as a starter this year is pretty good and he has been taking walks lately. If that doesn't hold up, then there are still all those other options that have been mentioned.

Cantu needs to be gone before the 31st regardless of being a buyer or a seller.

 

 

No doubt about that and it's better for us that teams like the Giants and Rockies are interested and the Rangers are pretty much desperate for him.

 

 

I don't see how trading Cantu would be entering seller mode. If anything wed probably get some pen help from the trade and having Logan play would help us.

Sure some people who have very little knowledge about the Marlins might call it selling but all you have to do is look at Cantu's number's.

It's probably more of the fact that they're not convinced Coghlan can play 3B...at least not immediately.

Morrison would easily outproduce Cantu.

 

I think that's probably true (though, really, Cantu can't play 3B either).

 

Cantu is terrible at third, but his play has more to do with a lack of ability than familiarity with the position. I would think that Coghlan would have just as much ability, but I still remember 2006 where the whole infield was making rookie mistakes and constant head-scratching plays. And I remember last year where Bonifacio did the same thing, even though he's actually a versatile and decent defensive player. Having a guy who isn't comfortable at the position is going to result in a lot of costly mistakes that may be both worse and more numerous than what even Cantu is making.

You've got a point, as CC was originally a 3B but hasn't regularly played it since '06 (he did play some games at 3B in '09 and '08).

 

That's the smart way to think about it, but that's not how this team thinks about it. Going back as far as Miggie this team has put guys at 3B who hadn't played 3B regularly for a while (or ever).

 

Miggie hadn't played 3B for a couple years until he was put there at the end of '05 when Lowell got injured. Cantu hadn't played 3B regularly ever before we put him there, though he played some games there in 2004 and 1 game in 2007. Bonifacio had never played 3B until we put him there (unless he played some in Winter League, 2003 would probably have the most information there, though 2003 always said that most of the games he played there was in the OF).

 

So why, with the first guy since Lowell who is a natural 3B, are we suddenly afraid to put him there because he hasn't played it regularly for a few years?

 

Chris Coghlan isn't a natural third basemen though. He was drafted as a third basemen, but was moved to second rather early on. He looks more like a second basemen, and there is no way he has a third base arm. On top of that, he was an error machine at third base in the minors, except for last year where he got into a few games at third and only made one error. But even in 2008, in 10 games at third he made 5 errors, while he was vastly better at second. He's got experience at third, but is still not what I would call a natural.

 

Cabrera actually was a natural third basemen early in his career. His weight issues did not creep up until later, dictating the move to first. Other than that, he had the tools to play third, while I can't say if Coghlan does or not.

He was moved to 3B, not because of his arm (he's been sniping people out at 2B from LF) or his range, it was because his bat didn't project at the corner, which is almost ironic considering he's playing LF now.

 

He did make a nice amount of errors in '08 but was a bit better (though not great) when we first got him and he was playing 3B regularly.

 

Oh, and Miggie was a natural SS who got to big for the position, so he was moved to 3B halfway before the year we called him up.

  • Author

As of now it looks like Cantu will be traded, Helms and Boni, probably Murphy aswell will get the rest of the season playing 3rd and Logan will remain in the minors until September with Cogs in 3rd.

The F.O. seems to not want to rush Coghlan into the 3rd base job and want him to get an offseason and spring training of work before officially moving back to the infield.

 

Next year I see Coghlan at 3rd, Uggla back at 2nd and Logan Morrison in LF.

I'd love to see Donnie Murphy get some starts if we're not going to move CC to 3rd/logan to LF. And this isn't just because of the walk offs, I've been interested in him since the start of the season, guy has been killing the ball in the minors for several years and is in his power prime.

 

Does suck though because he's another right handed low walk/high strikeout/high power guy, and we already have plenty of those.

He was moved to 3B, not because of his arm (he's been sniping people out at 2B from LF) or his range, it was because his bat didn't project at the corner, which is almost ironic considering he's playing LF now.

 

He did make a nice amount of errors in '08 but was a bit better (though not great) when we first got him and he was playing 3B regularly.

 

Oh, and Miggie was a natural SS who got to big for the position, so he was moved to 3B halfway before the year we called him up.

 

 

I do remember the SS bit, but there are so many players who come into the pros as SS's but will be shifted at some point in the minors that its hard to qualify guys as natural SS's unless they broke into the majors like that. Even Josh Willingham was a SS at one time; many of the younger players are simply because the guys who make it to the majors, even if they aren't good enough to play major league SS, were probably still more athletic or at least coordinated than most of the guys they would have been playing with as amateurs.

I'd love to see Donnie Murphy get some starts if we're not going to move CC to 3rd/logan to LF. And this isn't just because of the walk offs, I've been interested in him since the start of the season, guy has been killing the ball in the minors for several years and is in his power prime.

 

Does suck though because he's another right handed low walk/high strikeout/high power guy, and we already have plenty of those.

 

 

Sad thing with Donnie Murphy is, his numbers for his age were always prospect numbers, especially for an infielder. But he struggled in his major league chances, and once guys get past a certain age teams have a hard time giving them a chance at legitimate at-bats (not necessarily even starting at-bats) because hitters are always labeled 4A players if they can't hit in the majors before a certain age. Teams are very quick to accept the certainty of mediocrity from offensive players over the uncertainty of a guy who is not a proven player nor even a genuine prospect anymore.

 

Pitching is different because the dominoes fall quickly, and teams can hardly ever find competent guys to take all the innings that needed to be pitched at the major league level. A talented arm will almost always land in the major leagues at some point, and all he needs are ten good innings to prove that he can get it done. A minor league journeyman can have good performance in 10 at-bats, yet still be shipped to AAA in favor of experienced, mediocre players.

 

The worst thing is a journeyman 1st basemen. Any guy who sticks around the upper levels for years at first can usually swing the bat pretty well, but most teams would rather switch any number of guys on their current roster to first than give a guy labeled "4A" another chance at it, even if he's hitting .330 and slugging 30+ homers in the minors.

I think the problem is that the Marlins are apparently refusing to truly enter seller mode. They are afraid to put Coghlan, Helms, or Bonifacio at third base everyday because it might not help them down the stretch.

 

If you are of my mindset and think that the Marlins should throw in the towel, I think the Marlins should deal Cantu no questions asked. I'm fine with keeping Ross and Uggla, but if the Rangers are actively seeking Cantu, the Marlins should move him without hesitation.

 

 

I don't think it's anything as drastic as throwing in the towel, more like just facing reality. They are not going to come out on top in this division with a crap bullpen, sloppy defense,and unreliable starters(aside from JJ).

It's probably more of the fact that they're not convinced Coghlan can play 3B...at least not immediately.

Morrison would easily outproduce Cantu.

 

I think that's probably true (though, really, Cantu can't play 3B either).

 

Cantu is terrible at third, but his play has more to do with a lack of ability than familiarity with the position. I would think that Coghlan would have just as much ability, but I still remember 2006 where the whole infield was making rookie mistakes and constant head-scratching plays. And I remember last year where Bonifacio did the same thing, even though he's actually a versatile and decent defensive player. Having a guy who isn't comfortable at the position is going to result in a lot of costly mistakes that may be both worse and more numerous than what even Cantu is making.

 

You also have to remember that that uncomfortable feeling in the field will quite often be refelected in his at bats.

 

I can think of no reason, while in a run for the play offs, that you move an OFer (a soph OFer) to a new position at 3B and bring up a rookie 1B that is just learning LF. The possible downside far outweighs the remote possible upside. IOW, it's too much of a gamble. Might as well stand pat.

 

If Cantu is traded....

 

Leave Logan where he is. He still needs the every day ABs and more time at the new position. Maybe a call up in Sept to get his feet wet. Stick Helms at 3B and call up Luna for the bench. Of course this is all dependent on a trade involving Cantu, which we have no idea what we get in return. For all we know they could be working out a multi team trade involving more of our players that brings us a missing piece besides pitching help. We do have a couple of "extra" players we could throw in that wouldn't have a negative affect on what is happening on the field right now.

 

We have less than a week left of wait and see. So let's wait and see what the FO has in mind.

Can we please stop putting Logan Morrison and Hector Luna in the same sentence? Luna is a career journeyman bench player, while Morrison is a top 20 prospect in baseball, right now. There's a difference. It's not silly to suggest that Morrison would succeed at the major league level. He's more like Coghlan/Gaby in terms of his approach at the plate, and we've seen how those guys have been successful in their rookie years. He should be called up. If anything, he should be called up for the sake that he's a good left-handed bat, and we currently only have one of those in our lineup. This lineup, and team in general, is very unbalanced in terms of righty-lefty.

 

 

 

That's the only good argument for bringing him up. But not good enough. I would think if a Cantu trade is going to happen that is one area they are looking for in return.

 

Everyone keeps talking like Cantu is the only one to be moved. I just doubt that is the case.

It's probably more of the fact that they're not convinced Coghlan can play 3B...at least not immediately.

Morrison would easily outproduce Cantu.

 

I think that's probably true (though, really, Cantu can't play 3B either).

 

Cantu is terrible at third, but his play has more to do with a lack of ability than familiarity with the position. I would think that Coghlan would have just as much ability, but I still remember 2006 where the whole infield was making rookie mistakes and constant head-scratching plays. And I remember last year where Bonifacio did the same thing, even though he's actually a versatile and decent defensive player. Having a guy who isn't comfortable at the position is going to result in a lot of costly mistakes that may be both worse and more numerous than what even Cantu is making.

You've got a point, as CC was originally a 3B but hasn't regularly played it since '06 (he did play some games at 3B in '09 and '08).

 

That's the smart way to think about it, but that's not how this team thinks about it. Going back as far as Miggie this team has put guys at 3B who hadn't played 3B regularly for a while (or ever).

 

Miggie hadn't played 3B for a couple years until he was put there at the end of '05 when Lowell got injured. Cantu hadn't played 3B regularly ever before we put him there, though he played some games there in 2004 and 1 game in 2007. Bonifacio had never played 3B until we put him there (unless he played some in Winter League, 2003 would probably have the most information there, though 2003 always said that most of the games he played there was in the OF).

 

So why, with the first guy since Lowell who is a natural 3B, are we suddenly afraid to put him there because he hasn't played it regularly for a few years?

 

Chris Coghlan isn't a natural third basemen though. He was drafted as a third basemen, but was moved to second rather early on. He looks more like a second basemen, and there is no way he has a third base arm. On top of that, he was an error machine at third base in the minors, except for last year where he got into a few games at third and only made one error. But even in 2008, in 10 games at third he made 5 errors, while he was vastly better at second. He's got experience at third, but is still not what I would call a natural.

 

Cabrera actually was a natural third basemen early in his career. His weight issues did not creep up until later, dictating the move to first. Other than that, he had the tools to play third, while I can't say if Coghlan does or not.

 

Not really. Miggy was never a good 3B. His weight issues were under control in Detroit when they saw he couldn't handle the position better than what they had and moved him to 1B a couple weeks into his first season there. I was in Lakeland that ST and saw him. He was looking pretty good physically.

Seriously. Morrison's got Scott Hatteberg written all over him.

 

 

Wow That is just crazy to say that! I am surprised you even remember that name...Logan does appear to be coasting a bit but he still appears to be a very disciplined hitter. We just havent been seeing many 3 hits days but his OBP is still sky high

Seriously, if the Rangers are making an aggressive push to land Cantu then now is the time to deal him.

Seriously. Morrison's got Scott Hatteberg written all over him.

 

 

Wow That is just crazy to say that! I am surprised you even remember that name...Logan does appear to be coasting a bit but he still appears to be a very disciplined hitter. We just havent been seeing many 3 hits days but his OBP is still sky high

 

I agree with you Eddie. If Morrison turns out to be another Scott Hatteberg that would be a disaster for the Marlins. They can't afford for him to be another Jeremy Hermida or Scott Hatteberg. I think his upside is much higher than those two stiffs.

  • Author

Seriously. Morrison's got Scott Hatteberg written all over him.

 

 

Wow That is just crazy to say that! I am surprised you even remember that name...Logan does appear to be coasting a bit but he still appears to be a very disciplined hitter. We just havent been seeing many 3 hits days but his OBP is still sky high

 

I agree with you Eddie. If Morrison turns out to be another Scott Hatteberg that would be a disaster for the Marlins. They can't afford for him to be another Jeremy Hermida or Scott Hatteberg. I think his upside is much higher than those two stiffs.

 

Hatteberg was and probably will always be a better hitter then Hermida, I think what they mean is even if he doesn't live up to potential, he could still be a solid contributor with High OBP like Hatterberg was.

Seriously. Morrison's got Scott Hatteberg written all over him.

 

 

Wow That is just crazy to say that! I am surprised you even remember that name...Logan does appear to be coasting a bit but he still appears to be a very disciplined hitter. We just havent been seeing many 3 hits days but his OBP is still sky high

 

I agree with you Eddie. If Morrison turns out to be another Scott Hatteberg that would be a disaster for the Marlins. They can't afford for him to be another Jeremy Hermida or Scott Hatteberg. I think his upside is much higher than those two stiffs.

 

Hatteberg was and probably will always be a better hitter then Hermida, I think what they mean is even if he doesn't live up to potential, he could still be a solid contributor with High OBP like Hatterberg was.

 

Hatteberg really wasn't that great for a first basemen. He worked on AL teams because with the DH they don't need the all around production from a first basemen that a national league team needs.

 

Hermida has left me a little bit leery of discipline in the minor leagues. His biggest problem was that he was all too willing to never swing, he's go up there looking for a walk and seemed to be afraid to swing when he wasn't doing well. Consequently, he looked at way too many pitches including called strike threes.

I think you guys missed Dim's point.

 

The discussion was about Logan Morrison coming to the big leagues, and how he'd be right away. I think that's actually a good comparison for the short-term this year.

 

Hatteberg was an underrated player. I think Dim is just saying that Morrison, like Hatteberg, should be a guy who even if he doesn't put up the power numbers right away, will be a Scott Hatteberg. Which is a good thing. A consistent, .OBP guy.

 

Hatteberg had a career .361 .OBP with more walks than strikeouts in his big league career. The guy was just undervalued/underrated. That's not a knock on Morrison.

 

If Morrison becomes Scott Hatteberg with some more power, I'd be thrilled.

If he becomes John Olerud (Hatteburg with more power) I would be very happy.

 

 

If you compare Logan Morrison's minor league track record to John Olderud's, there are absolutely no similarities.

 

But that's because John Olerud had no minor league track record.

I hope they aren't keeping guys in some misguided thinking that this team can contend. Even after playing very well last week, they gained virtually no ground, anywhere.

I hope they aren't keeping guys in some misguided thinking that this team can contend. Even after playing very well last week, they gained virtually no ground, anywhere.

 

 

We're 6.5 games out of the wildcard and we've got the leaders in a 4 game series. I would like to see this team maximise future output by at least getting something in return for Cantu, but unless we tank in this SF series we are still in it and if we do beat them, we'll have put together quite a run.

I hope they aren't keeping guys in some misguided thinking that this team can contend. Even after playing very well last week, they gained virtually no ground, anywhere.

 

 

We're 6.5 games out of the wildcard and we've got the leaders in a 4 game series. I would like to see this team maximise future output by at least getting something in return for Cantu, but unless we tank in this SF series we are still in it and if we do beat them, we'll have put together quite a run.

 

 

We also went from 10.5 games to 8 games out in our division which I believe is significant. If we beat SF GIANTS who are .5 out of the wildcard then it shows we can compete. And if we lose, well we can play spoiler in our division. It's been a lot of fun in past years ruining Mets chances. :notworthy We have 9 with Atlanta who I hear is 18-17 in the DIVISION, 5 more with the Mets, and 9 with the Phillies.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.