October 6, 201016 yr We tried to take Tucker off the 40-man and he was claimed on waivers by the Rangers
October 7, 201016 yr The Marlins really screwed up that 2005 draft. Five picks in the first round (2 of them sandwich picks), and Chris Volstad is looking like the only one who's going to be anything.
October 7, 201016 yr Too early to give up on Sean West; He should at least be a lefty bullpen arm. He's also shown a rather large platoon split in both the majors and minors, so he probably does end up being LOOGY-ish. ugggggh minorleaguesplits is down :| but I remember he did have one!
October 7, 201016 yr When he was suspended in AAA this season and then sent to Jupiter for the rest of the year one had to figure the writing was on the wall of his days as a "Prospect" Maybe the heat in Texas will help with the condition he has.
October 7, 201016 yr Too early to give up on Sean West; He should at least be a lefty bullpen arm. He's also shown a rather large platoon split in both the majors and minors, so he probably does end up being LOOGY-ish. ugggggh minorleaguesplits is down :| but I remember he did have one! In the Majors, lefties are hitting 350 against West
October 7, 201016 yr That's a ridiculously tiny sample size, but I'm not surprised you took the opportunity to post something negative about the team.
October 10, 201016 yr Volstad is in the rotation The jury is out on West Tucker got hurt Marceaux didn't pan out Thompson became Nick Johnson That really isn't a bad draft.
October 10, 201016 yr Volstad is in the rotation The jury is out on West Tucker got hurt Marceaux didn't pan out Thompson became Nick Johnson That really isn't a bad draft. Tucker's problem isn't an injury, his entire career has been ineffective. We're talking about a minor league career K/BB of 1.77. His one "OMG AWESOME" year of 2008 was because of a pretty ERA due to a very low BABIP and HR/FB%; his K/BB that year was just 2. Tack on all the subordination issues and it's no surprise the FO let him go over others. Marceaux "didn't pan out" is putting it lightly: He was so bad he was released after four seasons, the last of which he finished with just two more strike outs than walks. Thompson became NJ, sure, but he's still posted unimpressive peripherals and, given his almost-700 IP career sample size, his high BABIPs become less "random in action" and more "He's very hittable." That is a bad draft for five first rounders. You're looking at a below average SP (Volstad) and somebody who's looking like a good LOOGY (West) for players who will contribute to the major league team. For five first round picks, that isn't good. For comp, the Red Soxs also had five first round picks that draft (And our draft position for those five picks were a lot better). They grabbed Jacoby - Above average OFer Craig Hansen - Bust Buccholz - Above average SP (Though very likely over his head this season) Jed Lowrie - average to above average MIF Michael Bowden - Jury still out but probably below average RP due to high FB tendencies. They got 3 above average players and one that the jury is still out on. We got one below average player and one that the jury is still out on. We spent 5.675m, they spent 5.017m, so there's no "Big market outspending" (We spent more because of high draft slots, though, so the two teams basically spent the same amount when taking that into consideration). Now yeah, they had a good draft. But that's five first round picks. There's going to be some busts, there's going to be below average players. i.e. even though he's a below average SP, Volstad is not a bust, he's at least contributing. 3 busts, 1 still waiting, and 1 below average SP is bad for five first round picks though. There's no prettying that picture.
October 10, 201016 yr Volstad is in the rotation The jury is out on West Tucker got hurt Marceaux didn't pan out Thompson became Nick Johnson That really isn't a bad draft. Sarcasm?
October 10, 201016 yr Volstad is in the rotation The jury is out on West Tucker got hurt Marceaux didn't pan out Thompson became Nick Johnson That really isn't a bad draft. Sarcasm? A bit, but now that we've been compared to the most successful draft I feel compelled to be contrary. In the 2005 draft we acquired 2 starting position players (1 perhaps being trade bait for pitching), a #4 starter (if he doesn't get better) and a LOOGY (if he doesn't get better) and a backup Catcher
October 11, 201016 yr Volstad is in the rotation The jury is out on West Tucker got hurt Marceaux didn't pan out Thompson became Nick Johnson That really isn't a bad draft. Tucker's problem isn't an injury, his entire career has been ineffective. We're talking about a minor league career K/BB of 1.77. His one "OMG AWESOME" year of 2008 was because of a pretty ERA due to a very low BABIP and HR/FB%; his K/BB that year was just 2. Tack on all the subordination issues and it's no surprise the FO let him go over others. Marceaux "didn't pan out" is putting it lightly: He was so bad he was released after four seasons, the last of which he finished with just two more strike outs than walks. Thompson became NJ, sure, but he's still posted unimpressive peripherals and, given his almost-700 IP career sample size, his high BABIPs become less "random in action" and more "He's very hittable." That is a bad draft for five first rounders. You're looking at a below average SP (Volstad) and somebody who's looking like a good LOOGY (West) for players who will contribute to the major league team. For five first round picks, that isn't good. For comp, the Red Soxs also had five first round picks that draft (And our draft position for those five picks were a lot better). They grabbed Jacoby - Above average OFer Craig Hansen - Bust Buccholz - Above average SP (Though very likely over his head this season) Jed Lowrie - average to above average MIF Michael Bowden - Jury still out but probably below average RP due to high FB tendencies. They got 3 above average players and one that the jury is still out on. We got one below average player and one that the jury is still out on. We spent 5.675m, they spent 5.017m, so there's no "Big market outspending" (We spent more because of high draft slots, though, so the two teams basically spent the same amount when taking that into consideration). Now yeah, they had a good draft. But that's five first round picks. There's going to be some busts, there's going to be below average players. i.e. even though he's a below average SP, Volstad is not a bust, he's at least contributing. 3 busts, 1 still waiting, and 1 below average SP is bad for five first round picks though. There's no prettying that picture. And those aren't his only 1st round misses......Allison, Skipworth, and the 3 busts from 2005. Yet people still slurp on Beinfest. I don't get it, I think we can do a lot better than Beinfest.
October 11, 201016 yr blaming Beinfest for Allison is pretty silly. And for the 2005 draft, they did get Gaby Sanchez fwiw... But no question the #1 picks from 2005 were a disappointing lot.
October 11, 201016 yr blaming Beinfest for Allison is pretty silly. And for the 2005 draft, they did get Gaby Sanchez fwiw... But no question the #1 picks from 2005 were a disappointing lot. Yeah, we just had a drafted-and-developed player win ROTY last year, and three in the running this year; Now isn't exactly the time to be bashing the FO's drafting ability. The 2005 first round is a big X on Beinfest resume but it does not represent everything as a whole.
October 11, 201016 yr blaming Beinfest for Allison is pretty silly. And for the 2005 draft, they did get Gaby Sanchez fwiw... But no question the #1 picks from 2005 were a disappointing lot. Volstad, Sanchez, and Morrison. 1979 was a terrible draft for the San Francisco 49ers, they only had their 3rd and 10th round picks pan out.
October 11, 201016 yr Too early to give up on Sean West; He should at least be a lefty bullpen arm. He's also shown a rather large platoon split in both the majors and minors, so he probably does end up being LOOGY-ish. ugggggh minorleaguesplits is down :| but I remember he did have one! That reminds me... wasn't he accused of being out of shape and overweight, that supposedly led to an injury this season?
October 11, 201016 yr And those aren't his only 1st round misses......Allison, Skipworth, and the 3 busts from 2005. Yet people still slurp on Beinfest. I don't get it, I think we can do a lot better than Beinfest. Beinfest has never had much success in the first round historically. Really the only bright spot is Dominguez who, of course, is a promising prospect but is ultimately unproven. Volstad is nothing spectacular. Tankersley has had success as a lefty specialist but you want something a little more valuable than that in a first round pick, although I guess it's better than a bust alltogether. Jury is still out on guys like Skipworth, James, and Yellich. The rest are basically busts. Hermida, Allison (obviously not Beinfest's fault), Thompson, Marceaux, Tucker, Sinkbeil. Fortunately he makes up for it by finding talent in other rounds and trading for good young players, though the Cabrera trade is looking like a failure of epic proportions and may ultimately set this franchise back. That's the hard part about being GM of the Marlins, there is not much room for error. You can't get away with trading an elite player like Cabrera and getting nothing out of it.
October 11, 201016 yr And those aren't his only 1st round misses......Allison, Skipworth, and the 3 busts from 2005. Yet people still slurp on Beinfest. I don't get it, I think we can do a lot better than Beinfest. Beinfest has never had much success in the first round historically. Really the only bright spot is Dominguez who, of course, is a promising prospect but is ultimately unproven. Volstad is nothing spectacular. Tankersley has had success as a lefty specialist but you want something a little more valuable than that in a first round pick, although I guess it's better than a bust alltogether. Jury is still out on guys like Skipworth, James, and Yellich. The rest are basically busts. Hermida, Allison (obviously not Beinfest's fault), Thompson, Marceaux, Tucker, Sinkbeil. Fortunately he makes up for it by finding talent in other rounds and trading for good young players, though the Cabrera trade is looking like a failure of epic proportions and may ultimately set this franchise back. That's the hard part about being GM of the Marlins, there is not much room for error. You can't get away with trading an elite player like Cabrera and getting nothing out of it. Chris Carpenter was nothing spectacular either after 4 years with an ERA over 5. Volstad is 4.47 now. He will be fine it takes pitchers longer to develop so its too early yet. Impossible to say about Dominguez at this point. So far a great fielder and no bat. Same with Skipworth
October 11, 201016 yr And those aren't his only 1st round misses......Allison, Skipworth, and the 3 busts from 2005. Yet people still slurp on Beinfest. I don't get it, I think we can do a lot better than Beinfest. Beinfest has never had much success in the first round historically. Really the only bright spot is Dominguez who, of course, is a promising prospect but is ultimately unproven. Volstad is nothing spectacular. Tankersley has had success as a lefty specialist but you want something a little more valuable than that in a first round pick, although I guess it's better than a bust alltogether. Jury is still out on guys like Skipworth, James, and Yellich. The rest are basically busts. Hermida, Allison (obviously not Beinfest's fault), Thompson, Marceaux, Tucker, Sinkbeil. Fortunately he makes up for it by finding talent in other rounds and trading for good young players, though the Cabrera trade is looking like a failure of epic proportions and may ultimately set this franchise back. That's the hard part about being GM of the Marlins, there is not much room for error. You can't get away with trading an elite player like Cabrera and getting nothing out of it. Chris Carpenter was nothing spectacular either after 4 years with an ERA over 5. Volstad is 4.47 now. He will be fine it takes pitchers longer to develop so its too early yet. Impossible to say about Dominguez at this point. So far a great fielder and no bat. Same with Skipworth Carpenter became an ace because of new pitch thanks to Dave Duncan. Guys who make jumps like that are almost always because 1) new pitch or 2) new mechanics. And if it were that easy, every person would be an ace. I mean, Volstad just added a slider this year, and it's done jack.
December 13, 201015 yr Tucker outrighted by Texas. Embarrassing collapse for that guy. He's still got time, but, man. http://trsullivan.mlblogs.com/archives/2010/12/rangers_sign_matt_treanor.html
December 13, 201015 yr Tucker 's career has come apart at the seams He needs to reinvent himself with a new pitch of some sort also needs to find himself on the mound delivey-wise
December 14, 201015 yr Ha, I remember going to Tucker's MLB debut (think it was against the Reds, the day before Griffey hit his 600th) He, along with the bullpen, struck out enough guys to get me a free pizza. He's OK in my book.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.