Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

5/11 Post Game

Featured Replies

Just got back from the game. I got to see the Heat finale, which was amazing.

 

The bad news was I also saw the Nunez finale. Bleh. I said before the Rollins AB that they should've IBB him to bring up Victorino with a chance at an out at any base. I know that wasn't what would've been the conventional thinking, but that is what I thought they should've done at the time. Still do.

Btw, I just saw the post at the end of the gamethread.

 

And yes, every manager brings in their closer in a tied game at home in the ninth.

 

In terms of Badenhop and his rank in our bullpen, he's one of the worst, if not the worst. He's not better than Leo Nunez, nor did I ever say he was. On the "trade Leo Nunez" thread, when I brought up the #'s over the years comparing their similar WHIP's, it was to make the point that it wouldn't be a huge downgrade to the bullpen, as a whole.

 

With that said, saying I said he's better than Nunez is just putting words in my mouth. And if Nunez is going to be your highest paid reliever...ever...he's going to pitch the 9th of an important game - especially since he's been pitching well.

 

Another thing is that the Phillies lineup is loaded with left-handed hitters. A reason why Badenhop isn't a late-game reliever is because of his troubles against left-handed hitters; Nunez, on the other hand, is capable of dominating left-handed hitters because of his changeup (which just so happened to not be good tonight).

 

I can't believe I even have to support Edwin's decision, in this case.

 

At least we can be satisfied knowing that Edwin lost with his best tonight, instead of going to his long reliever.

 

Btw, at home, you don't play to extend the game; you play to keep the game tied in the 9th to win it in the bottom half of the inning. I'm not sure how or why the "we're playing the Phillies; you have to expect a long game in this scenario" even makes sense. If you want to use that argument (which is actually terrible), it would be better served against a team like the Padres that has a dominant bullpen. In case you hadn't noticed, the Phillies had Kyle friggin' Kendrick pitching in the 8th inning tonight; their bullpen is as beatable as anyone's. The only reason why that doesn't show up in their stats is because, unlike the Marlins, the Phillies rarely ever have to use their bullpen in tight situations.

Whatever Erick. The best support you can make for your arguments is (in parenthesis, saying your opposition argument is terrible).

 

And I never said you said Burke Badenhop was better than Leo Nunez. Don't say I'm putting words into your mouth when I'm not. You definitely did however pretty much underline the fact that there wasn't much of a drop off in talent at all. And you definitely did say that Burke Badenhop was not the worst guy in the bullpen, and in the GTD you said he was the worst guy in the bullpen.

Whatever Erick. The best support you can make for your arguments is (in parenthesis, saying your opposition argument is terrible).

 

And I never said you said Burke Badenhop was better than Leo Nunez. Don't say I'm putting words into your mouth when I'm not. You definitely did however pretty much underline the fact that there wasn't much of a drop off in talent at all. And you definitely did say that Burke Badenhop was not the worst guy in the bullpen, and in the GTD you said he was the worst guy in the bullpen.

 

 

 

Really? When did I say that? You were the one who put words in my mouth on that thread, when you said something along the lines of: "Fine. Trade Leo. Let Badenhop close." as if I had ever even mentioned such a thing.

 

Badenhop's role is completely different; when I brought that up, the point was to get value for him (Nunez), let Badenhop be a long reliever, and then let someone like Hensley/Dunn close.

 

And the support for my argument is basically that you always use your best (when he's available) with the game on the line. You could bring up the argument of "saving him for a save situation," but at that point in the game, there was no more possible save situation for the home team.

 

And yes, once again, every manager does the same thing Edwin did in that situation.

Hmm...Who should I blame for this one? Tough one.

 

 

The team, same thing happened with the Dodgers, Reds and now tonights game, its just the SSDD.

Hmm...Who should I blame for this one? Tough one.

 

 

The team, same thing happened with the Dodgers, Reds and now tonights game, its just the SSDD.

 

Oh noes, 21-15 iz a horbul rekurd!

Hmm...Who should I blame for this one? Tough one.

 

 

YOURSELF! Alliterations are always angering and awful..

 

I'm not following you there buddy.

 

Notsureifserious? Your handle? :blink:

Hmm...Who should I blame for this one? Tough one.

 

 

YOURSELF! Alliterations are always angering and awful..

 

I'm not following you there buddy.

 

Notsureifserious? Your handle? :blink:

 

 

 

You lost me.

Hmm...Who should I blame for this one? Tough one.

 

 

YOURSELF! Alliterations are always angering and awful..

 

I'm not following you there buddy.

 

Notsureifserious? Your handle? :blink:

 

 

 

You lost me.

You: AnonymousAnomaly

AnonymousAnomaly : Totally alliteration.

Oh I see, he doesn't like my name...

 

 

I actually think your name is clever. You seem like an unnecessarily tense fellow; this isn't the first time you appear to have gotten annoyed with what was pretty clearly a joke. I'm just joking around - I promise.

Most of the time I am messing around also, like this time. But sometimes people like to be smart asses to me and I'm a smart ass back. And also thats the problem with forums, sometimes its hard to pick up if someones being a douche or messing around. But like you, I am usually messing around.

I came out of this series feeling like we were a starting pitcher and a big bat short of playing at the same level as the Phillies. I know we don't have Logan back yet, but having to start Helms is painful (What is the team record this year when Aunty Wes starts a game?)...and trying not to dump on Javy much with his family issues, but he is a liability... The fact that we may be a player or two away is encouraging considering what we may do by July deadline of who we target on the FA market this offseason going into the new stadium.

What is the team record this year when Aunty Wes starts a game?

 

Not that it means much, but we're 2-5 when he starts:

 

4-07 WSH L 3-5

4-10 HOU L 1-7

4-17 PHI L 2-3

4-26 LAD W 4-2

4-29 CIN W 7-6

5-07 WSH L 2-5

5-11 PHI L 3-5

 

Fortunately, he only starts a little less than one in 5 games.

 

We're 8-7 in the other games he's appeared in.

 

So, in games not graced with a "professional" Helms appearance of any kind, we're 11-3.

 

I'd say that placing much faith in those numbers would constitute being fooled by randomness, but in the case of Helms it's really quite well within the realm of realistic possibility that those numbers, or something close to them will hold up for the entire year.

 

He's struck out 13 times in 39 PAs. 2 BB. 2 RBI. OPS < .600. 2 errors in 18 chances (not including 5-11, I don't recall whether he had a chance or two or not yesterday but it doesn't matter, a 10% error rate is ridiculous.) With few exceptions, he's a liability if he does anything other than sit on the bench and mentally prepare for his "professional" at-bats wherein he manages to strike out 1/3rd of the time and accomplishes nothing other than looking pitiful almost 80% of the time.

 

Perhaps he'll conclude that he's taking up a roster spot for absolutely no good reason and decide to forego his current contract and ask for a new contract coaching somewhere in the Marlins system for a few years. Or, better yet, the FO decides they can't tolerate this crap any longer and DFAs him.

 

It would be good practice for the Vazquez DFA, which is surely coming within 5-10 starts, barring a miracle recovery.

What is the team record this year when Aunty Wes starts a game?

 

Not that it means much, but we're 2-5 when he starts:

 

4-07 WSH L 3-5

4-10 HOU L 1-7

4-17 PHI L 2-3

4-26 LAD W 4-2

4-29 CIN W 7-6

5-07 WSH L 2-5

5-11 PHI L 3-5

 

Fortunately, he only starts a little less than one in 5 games.

 

We're 8-7 in the other games he's appeared in.

 

So, in games not graced with a "professional" Helms appearance of any kind, we're 11-3.

 

I'd say that placing much faith in those numbers would constitute being fooled by randomness, but in the case of Helms it's really quite well within the realm of realistic possibility that those numbers, or something close to them will hold up for the entire year.

 

He's struck out 13 times in 39 PAs. 2 BB. 2 RBI. OPS < .600. 2 errors in 18 chances (not including 5-11, I don't recall whether he had a chance or two or not yesterday but it doesn't matter, a 10% error rate is ridiculous.) With few exceptions, he's a liability if he does anything other than sit on the bench and mentally prepare for his "professional" at-bats wherein he manages to strike out 1/3rd of the time and accomplishes nothing other than looking pitiful almost 80% of the time.

 

Perhaps he'll conclude that he's taking up a roster spot for absolutely no good reason and decide to forego his current contract and ask for a new contract coaching somewhere in the Marlins system for a few years. Or, better yet, the FO decides they can't tolerate this crap any longer and DFAs him.

 

It would be good practice for the Vazquez DFA, which is surely coming within 5-10 starts, barring a miracle recovery.

 

I joked about that in my post (on the first page of this thread) about Wes Helms starting so we lost. It seems like when he starts we lose. Hey he did have a hit today (the fact that's a big deal is somewhat ridiculous...). I'd rather have Dobbs start than Helms any day though

One day after the loss, and i have decided that in the grand scheme of things we are probably going to be .500 versus the phills. 1 sweep will counteract this loss, and another one will counteract the 1 of three versus the nats, if we can manage that then we'll be fine long term.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.