Barring any unforeseen circumstances, if you had the choice of trading for a struggling Youkilis (at the time) or a 36 year old Carlos Lee, who would guys rather have at this point?...and please don't say neither. I'd like to get people's opinions on this.

Youkilis, personally. Gives you very good defense along with ability to hit.

Youk, as he's the Greek god of walks according to Fat Jonah Hill. Would have made pitchers work, I'm not so sure Lee can do that. Plus Youk provides flexibility at 3B and 1b if H2r needs rest.

Carlos Lee. He's got a better nickname.

I would rather have Youk.

I've always liked Youkilis, but I'm fine with either of them. Both can help us.

I would say maybe youkilis because he also provides good defense.

I'd take the Jewish kid.

I'd take the Jewish kid.

 

Carlos Lee is Sephardic?

Carlos Lee, because he's sexy.

Youk, better defense.

I'd take the Jewish kid.

 

Carlos Lee is Sephardic?

 

Well, he always wears a hat and has a beard....

I'd take the Jewish kid.

 

Carlos Lee is Sephardic?

 

Well, he always wears a hat and has a beard....

That would more likely make him Hasidic, but well done nonetheless.

Neither. Justin Upton is on the block. I want him. I don't even know of we have enough to get him. It would have to start with Yeilch and Fernandez, I assume. Plus the catcher in our system. Realmuto.

Where are you going to play him?

Neither. Justin Upton is on the block. I want him. I don't even know of we have enough to get him. It would have to start with Yeilch and Fernandez, I assume. Plus the catcher in our system. Realmuto.

Needs more quantity.

 

Yeah it would. Really we have no where to put him because we traded for Lee. Then we could have thrown Matt D and the pitcher in. Now we'd have to trade Lee or Lomo.