August 1, 201610 yr those are all pre 2016 publications. i'd imagine castillo will be ahead of naylor on the 2017 prospect lists Well, Baseball America just came out with its mid season list and Naylor was No. 100. Castillo didn't make the list http://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/midseason-top-100-prospects/#DC4IgtTwSMATe2tk.97
August 1, 201610 yr Don't a lot of scouts basically say that Naylor is a future DH? exactly why it was so stupid to draft him. only chance he's worthwhile if he develops 30+ hr power
August 1, 201610 yr Well, Baseball America just came out with its mid season list and Naylor was No. 100. Castillo didn't make the list http://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/midseason-top-100-prospects/#DC4IgtTwSMATe2tk.97 let's see what happens with the 2017 lists
August 1, 201610 yr let's see what happens with the 2017 lists Wow, can't believe the farm system is that bad...
August 1, 201610 yr with that said Rea has a much bigger shot of ever being useful than castillo So your wish would have been to not retrade?
August 1, 201610 yr Don't a lot of scouts basically say that Naylor is a future DH? So why want him if you are a NL team? Are we now drafting for the bench/pinch hitter?
August 1, 201610 yr For what it's worth, Passan tweeted today that while Naylor is the bigger name, Castillo was the best player the Padres received.
August 1, 201610 yr with that said Rea has a much bigger shot of ever being useful than castillo agree
August 1, 201610 yr with that said Rea has a much bigger shot of ever being useful than castillo I disagree. At the very least Castillo will be a nice controllable bullpen arm. I think he has a chance to stick as a starter.
August 1, 201610 yr I think moreso than anything it shows just how bad this system is. We are way over reacting to how bad the trade is. Naylor barely cracks the top 100 overall. Just because he's the #2 in our system doesn't mean much. Cosart is worthless. And Capps is probably 60 pitches after he comes back some time NEXT YEAR from another arm injury. At least they tried to fill a hole. Not much they could do with the minimal trading pieces they have.
August 1, 201610 yr I was watching MLB Network and Joel Sherman just claimed that Rae was a big part of the deal in the Marlins eyes. According to him the Marlins new analytics department thought he was undervalued and that Benedict saw something in him that he could fix. They viewed him as a future #3 or #4 starter. I'm not an analytics guy so I'm not sure what #'s they were looking at. Brian Kenny even asked what they saw that no else did and Sherman stated that the Marlins wouldn't divulge that information. Just an interesting tidbit.
August 1, 201610 yr Did they even know how bad the injury was yet? I mean if they were that high on him...
August 1, 201610 yr I was watching MLB Network and Joel Sherman just claimed that Rae was a big part of the deal in the Marlins eyes. According to him the Marlins new analytics department thought he was undervalued and that Benedict saw something in him that he could fix. They viewed him as a future #3 or #4 starter. I'm not an analytics guy so I'm not sure what #'s they were looking at. Brian Kenny even asked what they saw that no else did and Sherman stated that the Marlins wouldn't divulge that information. Just an interesting tidbit. sounds like mechanics (benedict's speciality) more than analytics
August 1, 201610 yr Did they even know how bad the injury was yet? I mean if they were that high on him... He had an MRI today so I am guessing yes.
August 1, 201610 yr sounds like mechanics (benedict's speciality) more than analytics I agree but Sherman specifically mentioned the analytics department. Brian Kenny was confused by the comment which leads me to believe that even Mr. Analytics himself disagrees with the Marlins analytic department. I just thought it was a curious statement.
August 1, 201610 yr I agree but Sherman specifically mentioned the analytics department. Brian Kenny was confused by the comment which leads me to believe that even Mr. Analytics himself disagrees with the Marlins analytic department. I just thought it was a curious statement. lol. what a weird thing to say
August 2, 201610 yr So the Padres insist Rea was healthy Friday and that the Marlins did see his medical records and that they were clean... but they said they did the trade back because it was "in the best interests of everyone involved", which sounds kinda fishy... but the Padres mlb.com reporter says the Padres never wanted to trade Rea because of his five years of club control so he implies they did the trade back to get back the guy they never wanted to trade to begin with. So, while the Marlins have reason to want compensation for Rea's immediate injury, it sounds like the Padres did this to absolutely win the overall trade. They dump Cashner for a huge return and don't even have to lose the one guy they didn't wanna trade to begin with. It's like they spent big bucks to get something and then immediately get a rebate! Hey Mike Hill...fuck off. Amazing some of the stuff that gets said on here. We get possibly our best pitching prospect back for a guy that likely won't pitch again until 2018, and has a career ERA of almost 5, and we got the worst of the deal? I look at it as we got less screwed.
August 2, 201610 yr i was not surprise with move because could been damage pitcher their send us as soon pitch he was hurt only 4 inning pitching with us
August 2, 201610 yr I don't think the trade is made worse at all. Rea stinks. Would rather have Castillo.
August 2, 201610 yr He had an MRI today so I am guessing yes. I wouldn't assume that. The FO is that stupid.
August 2, 201610 yr Just a thought, now I really wanna win the world series this year just for the humor and entertainment I'd get when Colin Rea gets his championship ring and the rest of the Padres are like "wtf bro?"
August 2, 201610 yr Imagine you're a Padres fan who disconnected for a few days on an island vacation or a cruise. You come home today and see Padres trade for Colin Rea. You'd be confused as hell.
August 2, 201610 yr Imagine you're a Padres fan who disconnected for a few days on an island vacation or a cruise. You come home today and see Padres trade for Colin Rea. You'd be confused as hell. I haven't had internet connection for 5 days, saw we traded Colin Rea for Luis Castillo
August 2, 201610 yr I haven't had internet connection for 5 days, saw we traded Colin Rea for Luis Castillo See
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.