August 31, 201610 yr We talked about the article briefly in another thread, and I agree with his points. In fairness, if you take out the #2 and #3 starting pitchers, and the #1 and #2 run producers from a team, that is a blow that most teams are not going to be able to recover from. On the other hand if you have playoff aspirations, you've got to have contingencies in place for when injuries happen (because they will) and the Marlins' contingency plan is duct tape.
August 31, 201610 yr It's a sad article to read because it says what most of knew: we needed everything to go right this season and it essentially did for 4 months(Stanton and Chen obviously underperformed). This was our year to finally make the playoffs again. There's no way we can expect so many guys to perform above their projections again in 2017. And 2018 and beyond as we know will be a train wreck.
August 31, 201610 yr On the other hand if you have playoff aspirations, you've got to have contingencies in place for when injuries happen (because they will) and the Marlins' contingency plan is duct tape. Duct tape is actually too strong. More like scotch tape.
August 31, 201610 yr There is still a shot in 2017. maybe but the braves and phillies will be better in 2017
August 31, 201610 yr I'm with squall on this one. The article was solid but a bit too damning. There's ways to get out of this.
August 31, 201610 yr I'm with squall on this one. The article was solid but a bit too damning. There's ways to get out of this. what do you propose exactly. The NL east isnt getting any easier and most likely this will be the exact same team as 2016
August 31, 201610 yr what do you propose exactly. The NL east isnt getting any easier and most likely this will be the exact same team as 2016 I'm not proposing anything, it's not my job to figure it out. The article just made it seem like the Marlins will be shit forever and I'm sure there's ways to avoid that.
August 31, 201610 yr I stated my opinion on this article previously, and I briefly went over what I'd want to do to address the problems with the team. I don't actually believe there's big problems with the lineup. I think looking at it, there is one spot that needs an immediate upgrade (shortstop) and a few others that can be done better. The biggest problem with the team is the starting pitching, regardless of what has been the problem now in August. The key moves this offseason in my own view are: 1. Re-Sign Martin Prado (I don't care if it's an overpay, I don't care if it's obvious he's due to regress. He's a steady enough player that it's worth bringing him back). 2. Sign two starting pitchers (From my view, there are three pitchers that should be given automatic rotation spots next season. They are Fernandez, Conley, and Chen. The last two should be up for grabs). 3. Trade players who are at high values (AJ Ramos, Marcell Ozuna, Derek Dietrich, Tom Koehler, potentially even Justin Bour). Use the value these players have as a means to fix the problems in the starting rotation first and foremost. Unfortunately, I don't see the Marlins being able to acquire a new shortstop given the market in free agency is putrid (Darwin Barney being the best player available). I'm not going to speculate what exactly the prospects or players we should trade for, but this would be the three areas of focus. I actually believe the bullpen is fine as currently constructed and that there are nice reinforcements available in our minor league system. When I look at the lineup, the pieces I see as "cornerstone, don't move" players are Giancarlo Stanton, J.T. Realmuto, Dee Gordon and Christian Yelich. Yelich is probably the guy I keep at all costs, while I'd listen to offers if they are ridiculously good deals. Realmuto, Gordon, and Yelich are all great value contracts that won't be free agents for a while. The rotation has nobody I see this way. Obviously Jose is a franchise guy, but he'll command $200 million+ in free agency and seemingly has no intention of re-signing. That makes him the most tradeable guy on our team. I don't see the team moving Fernandez until after the 2017 season due to a number of reasons, but he'll eventually be sent away. I don't think there's an easy fix with the team. Some questionable trades and poor drafting have left the team so devoid of depth that the only pieces we have left that have enough value to trade are on the major league roster. It's going to take some savvy moves and taking some risks that may not make the fans happy (that means trading an All-Star like Ramos, a great young player like Ozuna, or possibly even taking what you can for Fernandez now). The front office needs to think BOLD after this season. Staying the course is the wrong move, as I don't see small tweaks turning this team into an 88 win squad next season. Either that or they just have to do better in long term building.
August 31, 201610 yr I stated my opinion on this article previously, and I briefly went over what I'd want to do to address the problems with the team. I don't actually believe there's big problems with the lineup. I think looking at it, there is one spot that needs an immediate upgrade (shortstop) and a few others that can be done better. The biggest problem with the team is the starting pitching, regardless of what has been the problem now in August. The key moves this offseason in my own view are: 1. Re-Sign Martin Prado (I don't care if it's an overpay, I don't care if it's obvious he's due to regress. He's a steady enough player that it's worth bringing him back). 2. Sign two starting pitchers (From my view, there are three pitchers that should be given automatic rotation spots next season. They are Fernandez, Conley, and Chen. The last two should be up for grabs). 3. Trade players who are at high values (AJ Ramos, Marcell Ozuna, Derek Dietrich, Tom Koehler, potentially even Justin Bour). Use the value these players have as a means to fix the problems in the starting rotation first and foremost. Unfortunately, I don't see the Marlins being able to acquire a new shortstop given the market in free agency is putrid (Darwin Barney being the best player available). I'm not going to speculate what exactly the prospects or players we should trade for, but this would be the three areas of focus. I actually believe the bullpen is fine as currently constructed and that there are nice reinforcements available in our minor league system. When I look at the lineup, the pieces I see as "cornerstone, don't move" players are Giancarlo Stanton, J.T. Realmuto, Dee Gordon and Christian Yelich. Yelich is probably the guy I keep at all costs, while I'd listen to offers if they are ridiculously good deals. Realmuto, Gordon, and Yelich are all great value contracts that won't be free agents for a while. The rotation has nobody I see this way. Obviously Jose is a franchise guy, but he'll command $200 million+ in free agency and seemingly has no intention of re-signing. That makes him the most tradeable guy on our team. I don't see the team moving Fernandez until after the 2017 season due to a number of reasons, but he'll eventually be sent away. I don't think there's an easy fix with the team. Some questionable trades and poor drafting have left the team so devoid of depth that the only pieces we have left that have enough value to trade are on the major league roster. It's going to take some savvy moves and taking some risks that may not make the fans happy (that means trading an All-Star like Ramos, a great young player like Ozuna, or possibly even taking what you can for Fernandez now). The front office needs to think BOLD after this season. Staying the course is the wrong move, as I don't see small tweaks turning this team into an 88 win squad next season. Either that or they just have to do better in long term building. i agree but you know hill et all are going to blame injuries first and foremost for their downfall. they will hardly do a thing in the off season
September 1, 201610 yr i agree but you know hill et all are going to blame injuries first and foremost for their downfall. they will hardly do a thing in the off season They'll blame the injuries but I think the depth issue is obvious and they'll at least attempt to address that now that it's clearly something they can't ignore any longer.
September 1, 201610 yr They'll blame the injuries but I think the depth issue is obvious and they'll at least attempt to address that now that it's clearly something they can't ignore any longer. I don't think they can address that in one offseason unless if they make some major changes (like trading Stanton).
September 1, 201610 yr Author I don't think they can address that in one offseason unless if they make some major changes (like trading Stanton). Why is it everyone mentions trading stanton. It's as if everyone forgot he has a no trade clause.
September 1, 201610 yr Why is it everyone mentions trading stanton. It's as if everyone forgot he has a no trade clause. Doesn't mean he won't accept a trade.
September 1, 201610 yr 1. Trading stanton would hurt the team. 2. I don't trust Hill to trade stanton. Well, you said we should go "all out." I'm not even sure if we could realistically do that this offseason, but even if we could...would you trust Mike Hill in that process?
September 1, 201610 yr I'd rather him make mistakes adding than subtracting for value in a trade. They're equally as damaging to the franchise. Also, the team has also been much better recently in making trades than they have been with free agent signings. The free agent signings have been awful. I wouldn't want Hill signing a bunch of free agents.
September 1, 201610 yr Cashner. Capps. Hill couldn't trade a hologram slammer for burgerking pogs. I'd rather him sign FAs, if it doesn't work, pull a 2012 like they did before. 2017 is really the last realistic chance for this team. Gotta go for it. Can we at least let Capps pitch a game for SD before labeling that deal as the worst move ever? Of course, there have been some bad deals, but good trades are also a reason why we survived until now. The Prado/Phelps for Eovaldi deal looks like an absolute win. Cishek for Barraclough looks good. Hill's free agent signings on the other hand have been an absolute disaster. It's actually the biggest problem with the franchise. They sign guys coming off career years or guys with declining peripherals. They overpay and then they're forced to trade them for 3 A ball players while still having to pay the majority of the contract. I'd rather they just make trades and make minor moves in free agency. As of now, I'm waiting for them to trade Wei-Yin Chen to the Dodgers for a couple of guys we've never heard of as we pay at least a good 50% of the remaining contract. It's what they do best.
September 1, 201610 yr Dating back to the opening of the stadium, if you look at our free agent signings, I would venture to say that we've gotten the worst value in free agency out of all teams and it isn't even close. I don't even remember the last good free agent signing. I guess it would be Mark Buehrle who was pretty unspectacular.
September 1, 201610 yr Author Doesn't mean he won't accept a trade. Doesn't mean he will either. So, you can't count on that.
September 1, 201610 yr They aren't in a position to trade away players. They need to add and replace. ASG, current core of players, fairly weak nl east. They can't start positioning for 2019 and beyond. It's possible to sell and add at the same time to remain competitive.
September 1, 201610 yr When have they signed any free agent of note since 2012? Chen who seemingly got injured on the first day of the season. John Buck? Jarrod Saltalamacchia? Also, isn't the upcoming free agent class pretty weak?
September 1, 201610 yr Come to think of it, the Buck signing had already happened. Either way, another terrible free agent signing.
September 1, 201610 yr Doesn't mean he will either. So, you can't count on that. He would probably accept a trade to the Dodgers.
September 1, 201610 yr Free agents I remember the team signing following the 2012 debacle are Salty, Morse, Chen, Ichiro, Polanco, Olivo, Pierre, Marmol, Wolf, Jones, McGehee, and Don Kelly. The real notable names in that list to talk about are Salty, Morse, Chen, Ichiro, Jones, and McGehee. I'd say McGehee and Ichiro have been success stories for this franchise, signed for cheap and have been important contributors. Salty, Morse, Chen, and Jones are guys we gave our real free agency money to and have seen fail spectacularly. Chen is too early to decide but the other three just didn't do their jobs. To be completely honest, there aren't enough "real" free agent signings to form a real opinion of Hill's ability to sign free agents. I agreed with signing Salty, Morse, and Chen at the time that they joined. All were reasonable contracts that simply backfired. I don't remember too many if any egregiously bad signings that have hurt the team's cap long term yet (although Stanton will get there). It's interesting how the Marlins "big" free agent signings the last four years would be considered middle of the line moves for just about every other franchise. Looking back it just shows even more how little resources Hill and the front office are given to work with. A few bad draft picks, which is what has happened, and suddenly the team has no depth because of an ownership unwilling to give his team a fair chance.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.