Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Bour traded to Phillies.

Featured Replies

Then you have the transactions that are neither terrible or tremendous.  Most transactions are, in a vacuum, in this category.   Trading Bour for McKenzie is one of these.  Disappointing to see a familiar face go.  Certainly hurtful to our bottom third of MLB team in the current season.  Impactful to future years?  Unlikely.  It frees up a 40 man roster spot.  We don’t go to arbitration on a guy the team clearly doesn’t have in the long term plans.  There probably isn’t much more to it than that.  

 

Wont someone think of the children!!!  (I gotta get off Twitter)

 

 

Regarding that tweet... last year I prepared my kid for the fire sale by asking him/explaining to him when was the last time the Marlins won the World Series and the last time they had a winning season and I told him that "even if you love your team if they can't win then maybe it's a good idea to switch around some players and try to win with other guys." 

 

I told him this a few times over the next few weeks... the day Stanton got traded he wasn't happy but he completely understood. Gotta teach kids that trades happen and teams are always gonna shuffle the deck until the right combination comes along. 

 

 

Regarding that tweet... last year I prepared my kid for the fire sale by asking him/explaining to him when was the last time the Marlins won the World Series and the last time they had a winning season and I told him that "even if you love your team if they can't win then maybe it's a good idea to switch around some players and try to win with other guys." 

 

I told him this a few times over the next few weeks... the day Stanton got traded he wasn't happy but he completely understood. Gotta teach kids that trades happen and teams are always gonna shuffle the deck until the right combination comes along. 

 

Sounds like some members here needed a parent like you.

 

 

Regarding that tweet... last year I prepared my kid for the fire sale by asking him/explaining to him when was the last time the Marlins won the World Series and the last time they had a winning season and I told him that "even if you love your team if they can't win then maybe it's a good idea to switch around some players and try to win with other guys." 

 

I told him this a few times over the next few weeks... the day Stanton got traded he wasn't happy but he completely understood. Gotta teach kids that trades happen and teams are always gonna shuffle the deck until the right combination comes along. 

 

someone should tell that guy what an actual hard conversation with a six years old sounds like 

 

 

I think people focus on the HR derby and assume Bour was a massive fan favorite. That was a fun night, the crowd loved it. But on a day to day basis did you notice louder cheers for Bour than the other players? I didn't.

 

 

[ATTACH]2106._xfImport[/ATTACH]

 

This is not accurate, Clark Spencer should know better. 

 

Cash was included to get a player in return. The Marlins did not have to send anything. Bour could have been sent to the Phillies for literally nothing. The Phillies claimed him, they wanted him. Don't make it sound like the Marlins had to pay the Phillies to convince them to take Bour. The including of cash has zero to do with eagerness. Stop making them sound desperate to trade people. 

 

Everyone bitches that this team was so cheap to not include cash in deal after deal and the minute they do it Clark Spencer reprimands them for it with a "how dare they" tone. 

 

I like how the media can't get things right when it's their job to do so. 

 

Screenshot_20180811-095038_Chrome.thumb.jpg.4c49775372bb30a2df0a09d3fd41fd40.jpg

Class act of a guy. Will miss him, but we are in a rebuild.

 

wonder what ever happened to post previews  before submitting

 

 

Class act of a guy. Will miss him, but we are in a rebuild.

 

wonder what ever happened to post previews  before submitting

 

Good for Bour. This team has been rebuilding for 15 years now with not a single playoff appearance to show for it. I’m sure he’s excited to get out and go somewhere that has a plan and a lot of good young players.

 

 

I’m sure he’s excited to get out and go somewhere that has a plan and a lot of good young players.

 

Pretty sure the Phils plan includes non-tendering Bour next season. They have $40 mil owed to Santana next two seasons, not sure why they'd pay $5 mil for Bour to come off the bench. It's a nice short term addition for the Phils but not much beyond that.

 

 

The issue with Bour is that the arbitration process overvalues a guy that hits home runs and not much else. People keep talking about how he's under control for two more years but in arbitration (after making 3.4M this year) he'd get 5M in 2019? Probably 6-7M in 2020. If he was a free agent would someone give him USD 5-7M?

 

He's not good on defense, he's slow as balls in terms of base running. His K rate is up. He's 30 and his numbers are down across the board.

 

But on the other hand, even in a down year the guy is still sporting an .835 OPS vs R handed pitching. His career BABIP is .295 and it's .267 this year. And he's usually OK on defense. Just seems like a very unlucky/bad type of season. I think he'd be very serviceable and valuable to an AL team to play 1B/DH against RHP and bench guy. He can't stay in Philly because of Santana but if the Rockies get him, watch him put up a .850+ OPS the next two years if used the right way. I don't blame the Marlins moving him, we have no use long-term for a 30 year old stud platoon type player. The guy is coming off a 2.2 WAR season where he batted .900 in pitcher friendly Marlins Park.

 

I'm just surprised a team like COL or an AL team wasn't more interested and seemingly everyone is thinking this is him regressing and he'll just get worse and not that he's still very capable of contributing to a team, which I think he very much is.

 

 

Pretty sure the Phils plan includes non-tendering Bour next season. They have $40 mil owed to Santana next two seasons, not sure why they'd pay $5 mil for Bour to come off the bench. It's a nice short term addition for the Phils but not much beyond that.

 

Yep, but at least he gets a chance to go to the playoffs this year and see the postseason for the first time in his career.   

 

 

Yep, but at least he gets a chance to go to the playoffs this year and see the postseason for the first time in his career.   

 

How could this be his first time seeing the postseason, has he never owned a TV?

 

 

And a small group of people will be overly optimistic about every single transaction

 

if i could give this 2 up votes I'd do so = )  one for each of them

 

 

And a small group of people will be overly optimistic about every single transaction

 

point to the people who have been overly optimistic about this trade please with quotes. I am having difficulty locating them.

 

 

No one has answered my question if they think Bour will actually be any good in 2020 or after. 

 

I do think there's a better chance of Bour being better in 2020+ than Mills ever contributing anything to the current or future teams.  I think both chances are slim but I do believe Bour will contribute far more in the short term and has a better chance in the long-term over Mills. After sitting here and looking at this trade, which again really isn't some watershed moment, but seems almost like some ruse to make people think "oh look, they're trying harder than Loria - at least they got SOMEBODY back". 

 

I think what's lost in all of this is that they didn't HAVE TO get rid of Bour.  I mentioned this earlier but he's one of those guys that will be worth more to Miami than anything that they could get back for him.  Getting Mills back does nothing for Miami and judging by his body of work I highly doubt it'll ever do anything for Miami.  Sure, he may get his cup o' coffee in the bigs when the rosters expand or in an emergency call up later on but Bour would have been more useful to the team even if it meant hanging onto him and seeing if he increases his value.  Nobody was going to give anything up for him of use and they wasted 450k on this move just to dupe some of you into thinking "omg, they're really trying. this is so different than with Loria who would have just let him go!"

 

 

Had the Marlins not traded Bour before Aug. 31, he would have been a non-tender candidate, as his $3.4 million salary in his first year eligible for arbitration was expected to jump to more than $5 million. So rather than risk not getting anything for the 30-year-old first baseman, Miami made the move.

 

MLB.com

 

 

I've been very critical of Jeter since he decided to dismantle last years outfield.  You know, #FuckJeter ! LOL

 

With that, I will say that I've come to believe that Jeter and company want to win in the long run. I believe they are being sincere. Of course, Jeter and company answer to their investors and at the same time they have to make money.  However, I think building a winner is their main focus.

 

This trade could turn out to be pointless but the bottom line is that they were willing to include money in a deal and that was very refreshing.  By the way that money is meaningless of any real consequences.  It was just half of Bour's remaining contract this season.  It doesn't effect our finances next season.

 

Bour will help the Phillies in the short run and Mills should help us in the long run even if its out of the pen. Those of you that have written Mills off before ever seeing the kid throw a pitch are just being foolish.  You can't possibly know enough about this kid to come to that conclusion.  I'll take the Marlins FO (who did their due diligence and are actual scouts) opinion over (and I say this with love) wanna be GM's.  

 

Again, whether this move pays off is not as important as the Marlins FO showing that they are changing from the cheapskate ways of the old regime. It was a baseball move and that's what I want to see.

 

#FuckJeterAnyway

 

 

I've been very critical of Jeter since he decided to dismantle last years outfield.  You know, #FuckJeter ! LOL

 

With that, I will say that I've come to believe that Jeter and company want to win in the long run. I believe they are being sincere. Of course, Jeter and company answer to their investors and at the same time they have to make money.  However, I think building a winner is their main focus.

 

This trade could turn out to be pointless but the bottom line is that they were willing to include money in a deal and that was very refreshing.  By the way that money is meaningless of any real consequences.  It was just half of Bour's remaining contract this season.  It doesn't effect our finances next season.

 

Bour will help the Phillies in the short run and Mills should help us in the long run even if its out of the pen. Those of you that have written Mills off before ever seeing the kid throw a pitch are just being foolish.  You can't possibly know enough about this kid to come to that conclusion.  I'll take the Marlins FO (who did their due diligence and are actual scouts) opinion over (and I say this with love) wanna be GM's.  

 

Again, whether this move pays off is not as important as the Marlins FO showing that they are changing from the cheapskate ways of the old regime. It was a baseball move and that's what I want to see.

 

#FuckJeterAnyway

 

I wanna make jokes but honestly just glad you're analyzing things and not just sticking to one stance without reason. Not everything is as cut and dry as people think. 

 

 

I've been very critical of Jeter since he decided to dismantle last years outfield.  You know, #FuckJeter ! LOL

 

With that, I will say that I've come to believe that Jeter and company want to win in the long run. I believe they are being sincere. Of course, Jeter and company answer to their investors and at the same time they have to make money.  However, I think building a winner is their main focus.

 

This trade could turn out to be pointless but the bottom line is that they were willing to include money in a deal and that was very refreshing.  By the way that money is meaningless of any real consequences.  It was just half of Bour's remaining contract this season.  It doesn't effect our finances next season.

 

Bour will help the Phillies in the short run and Mills should help us in the long run even if its out of the pen. Those of you that have written Mills off before ever seeing the kid throw a pitch are just being foolish.  You can't possibly know enough about this kid to come to that conclusion.  I'll take the Marlins FO (who did their due diligence and are actual scouts) opinion over (and I say this with love) wanna be GM's.  

 

Again, whether this move pays off is not as important as the Marlins FO showing that they are changing from the cheapskate ways of the old regime. It was a baseball move and that's what I want to see.

 

#FuckJeterAnyway

 

Thank you, this is how it is done. Well said.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.