Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2020/21 off-season

Featured Replies

4 hours ago, taiwanmarlin said:

This team needs a real catcher, just spend some money to earn the respect. 

I don't give a rat's ass about being respected by the national media. Besides even if they signed JT, the Marlins would still not be respected.

That being said, I still want them to try and sign JT to a realistic contract.

6 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

I don't give a rat's ass about being respected by the national media. Besides even if they signed JT, the Marlins would still not be respected.

That being said, I still want them to try and sign JT to a realistic contract.

Marlins: "We have signed back JT Realmuto to a six year deal worth $150M."

Media: "Wow, same old cheap Marlins underpaying a player."

Media: "Can't believe the Marlins are lying to their fanbase AGAIN."

Media: "You know they're just going to trade him in two years."

7 hours ago, taiwanmarlin said:

It would be a big risk to give Alfaro one more season, if it didn't work then what's your backup plan ? starting Wallach and use Mathis or Holaday as backup ?

It's a big risk.  But honestly, I would feel comfortable with Wallach being the starter.  All he needs to do is focus on catching. If the DH is implemented we probably won't notice his AB as often with the extra batter anyways. 

Just now, jeffreysfishfry said:

It's a big risk.  But honestly, I would feel comfortable with Wallach being the starter.  All he needs to do is focus on catching. If the DH is implemented we probably won't notice his AB as often with the extra batter anyways. 

This is also a fair point. If it's Wallach - Pitcher batting 8/9, then yes, it'd be terrible. But if it's ... let's say Rojas - Wallach 8/9 and back to ... let's say Chisholm leading off, it definitely becomes a much easier at bat to handle for Wallach if he doesn't come through.

Just now, Michael said:

This is also a fair point. If it's Wallach - Pitcher batting 8/9, then yes, it'd be terrible. But if it's ... let's say Rojas - Wallach 8/9 and back to ... let's say Chisholm leading off, it definitely becomes a much easier at bat to handle for Wallach if he doesn't come through.

That's exactly my thoughts.  A sure out from the 8th and 9th spot is like playing a 7 inning game.  With the DH Wallach is more than manageable as long as he brings his glove. 

This team had JT, Ozuna, Stanton, and Yelich but couldn’t win cause the starting staff and bullpen were crap. This team has more issues than the offense and even the offense is more than one bat away. So spending $20M-$25M per season on JT seems like a worse a idea to me than signing McCann around $9m-$10m, Rosario for $9M-$10M to give the outfield prospects a chance get their sea legs, and picking up one of these surprise non-tendered solid relievers on a discounted one year deal (in addition to any bullpen pieces they want to add anyway) 
 

Baseball isn’t like basketball where you put Lebron on a team and they get to the finals every year. Even if you gave us Mike Trout it doesn’t make us a playoff team, the talent and depth needs to be spread around the entire roster. 

1 hour ago, jeffreysfishfry said:

That's exactly my thoughts.  A sure out from the 8th and 9th spot is like playing a 7 inning game.  With the DH Wallach is more than manageable as long as he brings his glove. 

Nah man, Wallach May be better defensively than Alfaro but I wouldn’t say he’s “good” either. He’s definitely not a starting catcher on a team trying to return to the playoffs. Alfaro is more like what we saw in 2019 offensively than what we saw in 2020 and that will continue to improve as he builds his own approach at the plate and doesn’t just swing at everything.
 

And defensively, I feel like him getting “tried” the way he did by benching him for the playoffs will motivate him to work on his receiving. I honestly anticipate a different Alfaro going forward. But I’m still all for Signing Mccann for 3/27-3/30 to give Alfaro that chance to improve. If he does, you trade Mccann after the season with two years of control for some high-floor pitching prospects. If he doesn’t improve, you have Mccann for another 2 seasons. 🤷🏻‍♂️

21 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

the talent and depth needs to be spread around the entire roster. 

Ironically the Marlins made the playoffs in a season in which something else was spread around the roster.

22 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

This team has more issues than the offense and even the offense is more than one bat away. So spending $20M-$25M per season on JT seems like a worse a idea to me than signing McCann around $9m-$10m, Rosario for $9M-$10M to give the outfield prospects a chance get their sea legs, and picking up one of these surprise non-tendered solid relievers on a discounted one year deal (in addition to any bullpen pieces they want to add anyway) 

I agree with all of this.

54 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

This team had JT, Ozuna, Stanton, and Yelich but couldn’t win cause the starting staff and bullpen were crap. This team has more issues than the offense and even the offense is more than one bat away. So spending $20M-$25M per season on JT seems like a worse a idea to me than signing McCann around $9m-$10m, Rosario for $9M-$10M to give the outfield prospects a chance get their sea legs, and picking up one of these surprise non-tendered solid relievers on a discounted one year deal (in addition to any bullpen pieces they want to add anyway) 
 

Baseball isn’t like basketball where you put Lebron on a team and they get to the finals every year. Even if you gave us Mike Trout it doesn’t make us a playoff team, the talent and depth needs to be spread around the entire roster. 

Fair point, hard to argue this but I still want JT anyway.

23 minutes ago, SonOfJack said:

Fair point, hard to argue this but I still want JT anyway.

Kind of like I know Taco Bell is gonna kill me but I’ve made peace with that reality.

5 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Kind of like I know Taco Bell is gonna kill me but I’ve made peace with that reality.

I did last night and am on poop #3

Just now, Iowa said:

I did last night and am on poop #3

Silver lining: they did their part in keeping you regular...Constipation is a silent killer. 

  • Author
2 hours ago, SonOfJack said:

Fair point, hard to argue this but I still want JT anyway.

Miami Marlins is a qualified MLB team, they have the every right to sign any MLB FA they want, you know what I mean. 

11 minutes ago, taiwanmarlin said:

Miami Marlins is a qualified MLB team, they have the every right to sign any MLB FA they want, you know what I mean. 

I'm going to do research later and verify if this is true. I'll get back to you on my findings.

  • Author

https://www.mlb.com/marlins/news/marlins-inbox-lewin-diaz-first-base-starter

"Alfaro struggled in 2020, but most likely will start off the season as a candidate to play regularly. If he struggles, then the team may explore other options."

If you don't acquire a catcher in the off-season and you start the regular season with Alfaro your No.1 catcher and he struggles then you have no other options to explore …

  • Author

https://www.mlb.com/marlins/news/marlins-gm-kim-ng-gives-offseason-update

""Last year, Alfaro probably wasn’t where we had hoped he would be,” Ng said. “But I think that we were very fortunate having Wallach to pick up some of the slack.

“I would say at this point we’re hoping both will come into Spring Training ready to go, and we’ll make decisions then.”"

Just find it, it seems this team have zero interest to replace Alfaro with other options …

1 hour ago, taiwanmarlin said:

https://www.mlb.com/marlins/news/marlins-gm-kim-ng-gives-offseason-update

""Last year, Alfaro probably wasn’t where we had hoped he would be,” Ng said. “But I think that we were very fortunate having Wallach to pick up some of the slack.

“I would say at this point we’re hoping both will come into Spring Training ready to go, and we’ll make decisions then.”"

Just find it, it seems this team have zero interest to replace Alfaro with other options …

"Aflaro had a disappointing year and we intend to significantly upgrade the catcher position," said Marlins GM taiwanmarlin. "To all the agents and GMs out there listening, we're desperate. So give us only your highest and worst offers."

 

7 hours ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Nah man, Wallach May be better defensively than Alfaro but I wouldn’t say he’s “good” either. He’s definitely not a starting catcher on a team trying to return to the playoffs. Alfaro is more like what we saw in 2019 offensively than what we saw in 2020 and that will continue to improve as he builds his own approach at the plate and doesn’t just swing at everything.
 

And defensively, I feel like him getting “tried” the way he did by benching him for the playoffs will motivate him to work on his receiving. I honestly anticipate a different Alfaro going forward. But I’m still all for Signing Mccann for 3/27-3/30 to give Alfaro that chance to improve. If he does, you trade Mccann after the season with two years of control for some high-floor pitching prospects. If he doesn’t improve, you have Mccann for another 2 seasons. 🤷🏻‍♂️

You're not really giving Wallach the same respect in terms of player development as you are with Alfaro.  You don't think Wallach can improve at the plate, only Alfaro?  

Let's not shrug the importance of manning that position either.  I believe Wallach and Cervelli both had wins over losses.  Alfaro nearly sunk this team the last 3 weeks.  I think he had 8-10 starts losing all but 1.   When you see glaring issues in a player with no major positives and has all the potential, the problem is probably internal.  To me, that will cause inconsistency.  

I agree, we need a catcher. Maybe we can pony up for McCann (cue SOJ).  I'm not saying Wallach is "good" I never did, and like you said one player doesn't  guarantee anything.  That's why I'm saying Wallach is manageable right now. 

 

Edited by jeffreysfishfry

1 hour ago, Photo-Realistic Billy said:

"Aflaro had a disappointing year and we intend to significantly upgrade the catcher position," said Marlins GM taiwanmarlin. "To all the agents and GMs out there listening, we're desperate. So give us only your highest and worst offers."

It's like carrying a briefcase handcuffed to your wrist.  Nothing to see here folks. 

48 minutes ago, jeffreysfishfry said:

 

You're not really giving Wallach the same respect in terms of player development as you are with Alfaro.  You don't think Wallach can improve at the plate, only Alfaro?  

Let's not shrug the importance of manning that position either.  I believe Wallach and Cervelli both had wins over losses.  Alfaro nearly sunk this team the last 3 weeks.  I think he had 8-10 starts losing all but 1.   When you see glaring issues in a player with no major positives and has all the potential, the problem is probably internal.  To me, that will cause inconsistency.  

I agree, we need a catcher. Maybe we can pony up for McCann (cue SOJ).  I'm not saying Wallach is "good" I never did, and like you said one player doesn't  guarantee anything.  That's why I'm saying Wallach is manageable right now. 

 

Wallach Is what he is at this point, he’s a backup catcher that didn’t hit in the minors either (I see a Matt Treanor ceiling there). Alfaro was a bat-first guy in the minors so that tool should revert back closer to what we saw in 2018/2019. And on the defensive side Alfaro is much better than Wallach as far as pop time and arm strength (top 10 in pop time and top 3 in arm strength) which when the robot umps come will be MUCH more important than pitch framing (which had Wallach slightly better than Alfaro but still only in the 16th percentile so he was actually pretty bad too)
 

last year was also a very hard year to judge him on because I feel like the staff just lost their rhythm when they switched to a new receiver (especially with Pablo) The comfort/trust wasn’t there and he wasn’t vocal like Cervelli. But I think with another offseason of getting familiarized with the staff and working on his receiving he’ll be fine.
 

I just think we don’t gain anything from having Wallach as a starter delaying any possible progress from Jorge. Either get a better catcher that can help Jorge progress, or let him get at it and get him back to the 2+ war catcher he was and more than likely still is.

Edited by marlinsmaniac

23 hours ago, mystikol87 said:

Good point about Covid revenue loss — perhaps it hurt the Marlins less than most other teams 😜

#hiddenbenefits

You'd think that, but revenue sharing was also suspended, which hurt us.

12 minutes ago, marlinsmaniac said:

Wallach Is what he is at this point, he’s a backup catcher that didn’t hit in the minors either (I see a Matt Treanor ceiling there). Alfaro was a bat-first guy in the minors so that tool should revert back closer to what we saw in 2018/2019. And on the defensive side Alfaro is much better than Wallach as far as pop time and arm strength (top 10 in pop time and top 3 in arm strength) which when the robot umps come will be MUCH more important than pitch framing (which had Wallach slightly better than Alfaro but still only in the 16th percentile so he was actually pretty bad too)
 

last year was also a very hard year to judge him on because I feel like the staff just lost their rhythm when they switched to a new receiver (especially with Pablo) The comfort/trust wasn’t there and he wasn’t vocal like Cervelli. But I think with another offseason of getting familiarized with the staff and working on his receiving he’ll be fine.
 

I just think we don’t gain anything from having Wallach as a starter delaying any possible progress from Jorge. Either get a better catcher that can help Jorge progress, or let him get at it and get him back to the 2+ war catcher he was and more than likely still is.

Alfaro's issue seemed to be pitch calling and leadership. Once he improves on those, he'll be fine. I was on his case all this season for hardly ever going out to the mound to calm his pitcher. Can't imagine he talked much to them in the dugout between innings either.

He very clearly has a stronger arm (that and pop time are pretty connected so it's really just one category) so I'll agree framing won't matter at all if we get robo umps. Although I honestly can't imagine that we do, cause imagine having to change them every batter? Yeesh.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.