Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins deserve shot at upgrades

Featured Replies

Check Gathright OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/J...Gathright.shtml

Check Chavez OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/C/Endy-Chavez.shtml

 

Having speed doesn't make you a good leadoff hitter and Taveras doesn't exactly have a good k/bb ratio which would lead you to believe he will ever become a good leadoff hitter.

 

 

I was in favor of trading for Gathright, because the Marlins have no legitimate CF in the entire organization. If you stop and read what I wrote, you may note that I said his speed would serve him well once he gets his OBP back up.

Check Gathright OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/J...Gathright.shtml

Check Chavez OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/C/Endy-Chavez.shtml

 

Having speed doesn't make you a good leadoff hitter and Taveras doesn't exactly have a good k/bb ratio which would lead you to believe he will ever become a good leadoff hitter.

 

 

I was in favor of trading for Gathright, because the Marlins have no legitimate CF in the entire organization. If you stop and read what I wrote, you may note that I said his speed would serve him well once he gets his OBP back up.

 

Yes I read what you wrote, but looking at his career k/bb ratio, last years stats and this years stats what leads you to believe that he will have a good OBP?

 

Im sure Eric Reed speed will serve him well also if he could get his on base back up.

Check Gathright OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/J...Gathright.shtml

Check Chavez OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/C/Endy-Chavez.shtml

 

Having speed doesn't make you a good leadoff hitter and Taveras doesn't exactly have a good k/bb ratio which would lead you to believe he will ever become a good leadoff hitter.

 

 

I was in favor of trading for Gathright, because the Marlins have no legitimate CF in the entire organization. If you stop and read what I wrote, you may note that I said his speed would serve him well once he gets his OBP back up.

 

Yes I read what you wrote, but looking at his career k/bb ratio, last years stats and this years stats what leads you to believe that he will have a good OBP?

 

Im sure Eric Reed speed will serve him well also if he could get his on base back up.

They aren't exactly the same :whistle

Gathright has a minor league career OBP of .390 in 320 games, while Reed has a minor league career OBP of .347 in 371 games.

Check Gathright OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/G/J...Gathright.shtml

Check Chavez OBP http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/C/Endy-Chavez.shtml

 

Having speed doesn't make you a good leadoff hitter and Taveras doesn't exactly have a good k/bb ratio which would lead you to believe he will ever become a good leadoff hitter.

 

 

I was in favor of trading for Gathright, because the Marlins have no legitimate CF in the entire organization. If you stop and read what I wrote, you may note that I said his speed would serve him well once he gets his OBP back up.

 

Yes I read what you wrote, but looking at his career k/bb ratio, last years stats and this years stats what leads you to believe that he will have a good OBP?

 

Im sure Eric Reed speed will serve him well also if he could get his on base back up.

that's a pretty bad comp. Reed has always been all batting average with horrible plate discipline and put his numbers up all while older than Taveras. His age 22 season at AA was pretty nice. I don't know where I stand here but it's obvious you're overselling your case.

We don't need a prospect here...We need a proven guy that can help the team. Otherwise this trade is worthless and best kept for the offseason.

 

 

Identify the available CF player, on a team that is out of it, that won't cost $5,000,000+ this year, that would be a "proven guy".

 

Pierre is struggling, Hunter would cost $5,000,000+ this season, and everyone else is on a team in the mix or is not trade bait (young, under contract, cheap, etc.). Tavares would help the team now (by getting on base), AND can be on the team for years to come. The fact that he would be the team's #7 hitter says more about the fine performace of most of the Marlins, than the deficiencies of Tavares.

 

SS Ramierez

2B Uggla

1B Jacobs

3B Cabrera

LF Willingham

RF Hermida

CF Tavares

C Olivo

 

That lineup is going to score runs.

 

 

 

http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/D/C...-Denorfia.shtml

http://www.minorleaguebaseball.com/app/mil..._pbp&pid=456121

http://cincinnati.reds.mlb.com/NASApp/mlb/...layer_id=456121

 

Chris Denorfia says hi. He could be you CF for now and the future.

 

With Griffey,Dunn,Kearns, and Freel there is just no room in the major for Deno. He is definately MLB ready, and could step in and be your everyday CF.

 

 

This guy looks pretty good to me. I like that he hits a lot of 2Bs and draws a lot of walks.

I do not see Taveras as a markable difference compared with a Cody Ross or Jeremy Hermida in CF. I think he'd be a good pickup either way (for our future)...All I'm saying is that if we make a move at the trade deadline, it will be for a vet (or at least someone with a couple years)

Reed

 

 

With Choo or whatever his name is coming up for Seattle and them desperately needing pitching, he'd come cheaper than Taveras, imo.

I'd prefer a CF with some pop over these guys who are all speed and nothing else. I love the way the top of our order is (with Uggla) and a 7th-8th hitter that couldn't drive in runs would hurt our linup more than it would help.

But first, the Marlins should step up their search for an upgrade in center field, where their production ranks 13th in the league and they recently passed on Joey Gathright after an earlier flirtation.

Interesting, then, that he'd suggest Pierre, considering that the Cubs are last in the league in production at center field.

 

And let's not speak anything of Pierre's arm and his knack for giving baserunners the extra base.

I'd prefer a CF with some pop over these guys who are all speed and nothing else. I love the way the top of our order is (with Uggla) and a 7th-8th hitter that couldn't drive in runs would hurt our linup more than it would help.

 

sounds like Chris Young to me! :hat

A few comments.

 

First, this is Berardino whose jihad against all things Fish continues. Anyone who takes this column at face value is making a mistake.

 

The play in right center in the first inning last night that seems to have spurred MB into penning this column was not an issue of competence, it was borne almost soley from a wicked setting sun being directly in the eyes of both defenders. Yes, Hermida should have fielded that ball, and yes he should have taken charge on the play, but I submit that were Hermida to move to center more or less permenantly, plays like this (and had that same play happened two innings later we wouldn't be talking about it because one of them would have caught it) won't happen again.

 

Do I believe Hermida can be an everyday ceneterfielder? Yes.

 

Would I like to see Denorfia or Crawford out there every night? Yes, for different reasons.

 

But do not ignore the fact that this column exists for the sole reason of embarrassing Jeffrey Loria and does so by ignoring that this is still a sub-.500 team and almost twice as far behind in the wildcard than its 2003 counterparts with eight teams to climb over and a slew of games against the Mets (love them or hate them but they are the best team in baseball right now and will be throughout the rest of the season) coming up.

 

It's one thing to be three and a half back with a group or more or less mature players used to the daily grind of a 162 game season, it's a completely different thing to be doing it with a club populated with rookies who may or may not have the endurance to be competing come September. Especially the pitchers who have fueled the recent and dramatic improvement in the team.

 

No one has been more in favor of acquiring talent to make a run than me. I am unabashedly in the Carl Crawford camp for obvious reasons (protection for Miggy) and don't believe others here are accurately assessing what it would take to land him. But at the same time, realistically, I liked what I saw last night at PPS with Hermida in CF and Ross (my god what bat speed the guy has!) in right.

 

I could live with this for some time, "some time" being defined as, as long as Ross continues to hit.

 

Berardino brings up Borchard who seems to be at his best coming off the bench and made it a point to query him yesterday. One can just hear Berardino asking Joe as he strikes a match and then yells "FIRE!!!", "How come you aren't the starting centerfielder?" as he does best to create descension in the clubhouse.

 

Thanks Mike.

 

Would Dontrelle be overjoyed to be reunited with his soulmate Pierre? Without a doubt? Would his work ethic and love of the game be infectious among the baby Fish? For sure.

 

But do we need him, really need him? Is he the guy who puts the team over the top?

 

No.

 

I love you JP, but no.

 

So, as with any Berardino column, let the reader beware. Would we hardcore fans love to see an emerging star centerfielder out there tonight, or Carl Crawford switching uniforms in the sixth inning? Absolutely. But one thing is for sure. The one guy who cares less about the Marlins making the playoffs is Mike Berardino.

 

A leopard doesn't change it's spots.

Torii Hunter as a Marlin, I can see it now........ :evil

 

 

 

 

I just got tingling in my loins over that one,

 

:o

 

But I think that would be too good to be true.

 

Could you imagine Torii patrolling the outfield?

 

 

That would be so sweet.

I just read this in the paper this morning and was going to post it. Great article :thumbup .

 

 

Torii Hunter as a Marlin, I can see it now........ :evil

 

I just got tingling in my loins over that one,

:o

But I think that would be too good to be true.

Could you imagine Torii patrolling the outfield?

That would be so sweet.

 

I am just curious. How much would Torii be?

baldelli would be lovely, of course most likely a dream

 

so would crawford, what about one of the young dodger OF's we could perhaps swipe one for one of our young pitcher prospects?

 

I just read this in the paper this morning and was going to post it. Great article :thumbup .

 

 

Torii Hunter as a Marlin, I can see it now........ :evil

 

I just got tingling in my loins over that one,

:o

But I think that would be too good to be true.

Could you imagine Torii patrolling the outfield?

That would be so sweet.

 

I am just curious. How much would Torii be?

 

 

2 A level prospects most likely. Plus he is having an off year and really isnt as good as people make him out to be. Plus the twins are surging so I doubt they move him.

Realistically I'd be very hesistant to make a trade. Sure we are having a great run and I think we have a very good team and a very promising future, but we are still learning about our rookies an about our future. Our winning is basically due to our outstanding pitching, BUT I am still cautious about holdindg onto all our pitching prospects because as the saying goes: "Pitching wins Championships." I want to keep all our pitchers because some pitchers that are doing well now can tank or get injured later remember Vargas and K-Mart. Also much of our pitchers sucess can be atributed to MLB batters never having seen them before. That is why it is important to hold onto them so MLB tems can face them repeatedly and if that pitcher continues to have success THEN you have a keeper. I'd be hesitant to throw away our pitching prospects for a CF that in all likelihood won't take us to the playoffs. Let Amegaza play center, he is more than capable and a better leadoff man anyways IMO.And drop Hanley down to 7th to take pressure off of him and I think he is better suited to be in a position to drive in RBIs.

 

Amegaza CF

Uggla 2nd

Jacobs 1st

Cabrera 3rd

Willingham LF

Hermida RF

Ramirez SS

Olivo C

A few comments.

 

First, this is Berardino whose jihad against all things Fish continues. Anyone who takes this column at face value is making a mistake.

 

The play in right center in the first inning last night that seems to have spurred MB into penning this column was not an issue of competence, it was borne almost soley from a wicked setting sun being directly in the eyes of both defenders. Yes, Hermida should have fielded that ball, and yes he should have taken charge on the play, but I submit that were Hermida to move to center more or less permenantly, plays like this (and had that same play happened two innings later we wouldn't be talking about it because one of them would have caught it) won't happen again.

 

Do I believe Hermida can be an everyday ceneterfielder? Yes.

 

Would I like to see Denorfia or Crawford out there every night? Yes, for different reasons.

 

But do not ignore the fact that this column exists for the sole reason of embarrassing Jeffrey Loria and does so by ignoring that this is still a sub-.500 team and almost twice as far behind in the wildcard than its 2003 counterparts with eight teams to climb over and a slew of games against the Mets (love them or hate them but they are the best team in baseball right now and will be throughout the rest of the season) coming up.

 

It's one thing to be three and a half back with a group or more or less mature players used to the daily grind of a 162 game season, it's a completely different thing to be doing it with a club populated with rookies who may or may not have the endurance to be competing come September. Especially the pitchers who have fueled the recent and dramatic improvement in the team.

 

No one has been more in favor of acquiring talent to make a run than me. I am unabashedly in the Carl Crawford camp for obvious reasons (protection for Miggy) and don't believe others here are accurately assessing what it would take to land him. But at the same time, realistically, I liked what I saw last night at PPS with Hermida in CF and Ross (my god what bat speed the guy has!) in right.

 

I could live with this for some time, "some time" being defined as, as long as Ross continues to hit.

 

Berardino brings up Borchard who seems to be at his best coming off the bench and made it a point to query him yesterday. One can just hear Berardino asking Joe as he strikes a match and then yells "FIRE!!!", "How come you aren't the starting centerfielder?" as he does best to create descension in the clubhouse.

 

Thanks Mike.

 

Would Dontrelle be overjoyed to be reunited with his soulmate Pierre? Without a doubt? Would his work ethic and love of the game be infectious among the baby Fish? For sure.

 

But do we need him, really need him? Is he the guy who puts the team over the top?

 

No.

 

I love you JP, but no.

 

So, as with any Berardino column, let the reader beware. Would we hardcore fans love to see an emerging star centerfielder out there tonight, or Carl Crawford switching uniforms in the sixth inning? Absolutely. But one thing is for sure. The one guy who cares less about the Marlins making the playoffs is Mike Berardino.

 

A leopard doesn't change it's spots.

 

 

I was reading the posts on this topic and waiting for someone to point out the above. Damn, it is 100% on the mark. Berardino is critical of every move made and critical of every suggestion that he has that is not acted on. I guess we all want to believe that the media and MB in particular feels like us-that we want the Fish to succeed on and off the field. But bring back JP-help. Love his work ethic but now that he can't hit consistently only adds to how little he would bring. I just remember the pain in the gut I would get watching runners move up from first to second on routine fly balls. Remember, Cabrera did that to him this year. Yes, and that was when he was at his heaviest, running like Godzilla with his 245 pounds.

Tavarez is not having an off-season; not unless you're just looking at batting average (.267 compared to .291 last year). His OBP (.321 compared to .325 last year) is nearly identical, as are many of his numbers. In fact, some of his stats look even better this year than they did last year. Specifically, look at his walks, strikeouts, and extra base hits.

 

Tavarez in 2005: 25 BBs, 103 Ks (4.12 ratio).

Tavarez in 2006: 18 BBs, 43 Ks (2.39 ratio).

 

Tavarez in 2005: 592 ABs, 172 hits, 20 extra base hits (1 XB hit every 30 ABs, 1 XB hit every 9 hits)

Tavarez in 2006: 255 ABs, 68 hits, 12 XB hits (1 XB hit every 21 ABs, 1 XB hit every 6 hits).

 

Can you still honestly say that he has regressed just because of a slight dip in batting average? He Ks less, walks more, and has more power. 'Nuff said.

 

I'd definitely deal one of our minor league arms for him.

Tavares isn't the kind of upgrade we want.

 

Hunter fits the bill by playing better D than tavarez and making it so that our weakest position in the lineup is catcher.

 

Imagine Torii hitting infront of miguel. You saw what it did to Jacobs season. Man, I think I just wet myself.

 

Minnesota is 11 back in a very tough division. 9 back of second place and the wildcard. (though they are 9-1 in their last 10).

 

Hunter is in the last year of his contract. He has a no-trade clause to 5 teams but the Marlins aren't one of them. (he had the red sox and cubs on the list but said that he would waive the no trade clause if they wanted him this season)- His 3 other no's are Toronto, Detrioit and Tampa.

 

I dont know if they twins one pitching or hitting. But besides Liriano and Santana, aren't they getting a little old in the rotation?

 

If the twins are out of it. And the Fish are within a couple of games at the all-star break. I wouldn't mind seeing torii in teal, even if its just as a rental. I bet he would be a HOT commodity though and would cost a pretty arm. Either one of the big three or Anibal

  • Author

How much better than our Ross/ Amezaga combination does the potential center fielder have to be, how much is Loria willing to spend, and who would we have to give up?

 

I think these are the key questions.

 

Ross is hitting very well. He can play RF and Hermida can play CF.

When Uggla comes back, Amezaga can play CF when a left handed bat is needed.

 

Would we be better off getting more help for the bullpen? ( although lately they have been impressive)

 

I have a feeling that there will be NO moves unless we get ridiculously close to the wild card lead by the trading deadline. If this is the case, who knows what will happen then!

 

This season is turning out to be much more enjoyable than anyone had ever imagined!

Identify the available CF player, on a team that is out of it, that won't cost $5,000,000+ this year, that would be a "proven guy".

 

Pierre is struggling, Hunter would cost $5,000,000+ this season, and everyone else is on a team in the mix or is not trade bait (young, under contract, cheap, etc.). Tavares would help the team now (by getting on base), AND can be on the team for years to come. The fact that he would be the team's #7 hitter says more about the fine performace of most of the Marlins, than the deficiencies of Tavares.

 

By the time the All Star Break comes, Hunter would cost less than $5mil for the rest of the year

the toronto blue jays have a kid named tony miller in AA ball that plays center and is hitting 333 w a 524 OBP 2-2b 5-RBI 2-SB. he was playing horrible for colorados AAA affiliate but was moved to toronto's AA and has obviously found new life.

 

and

 

they have a solid RHP mid. rel. in vinnie chulk who's been up and down this season, in AAA he's got a 2.74 3-1 1-save in 13 appearances, 23-inn, 30/10 K/BB ratio. vinnie started off the year horrible but had a 1.80 ERA in 5 June appearances before being sent down, including a june k/bb of 4/0.

the toronto blue jays have a kid named tony miller in AA ball that plays center and is hitting 333 w a 524 OBP 2-2b 5-RBI 2-SB. he was playing horrible for colorados AAA affiliate but was moved to toronto's AA and has obviously found new life.

 

and

 

they have a solid RHP mid. rel. in vinnie chulk who's been up and down this season, in AAA he's got a 2.74 3-1 1-save in 13 appearances, 23-inn, 30/10 K/BB ratio. vinnie started off the year horrible but had a 1.80 ERA in 5 June appearances before being sent down, including a june k/bb of 4/0.

 

no reason to get unproven players

We are in such a great position to acquire a cornerstone OF, preferably a natural CF. We need that one last missing player to make our offense complete. We would be improved by a natural leadoff type or someone to bat lower in the lineup w/ presumably 30HR power. Our front office needs to simply decide if it wants to pull the trigger now or in the offseason. Acting now would obviously help in any possible wild card run. Waiting for the offseason would presumably give us more time/options to find the "perfect" player.

 

We have so much pitching depth that we are completely dealing from a positon of strength. We can offer Dontrelle or we can offer two big time prospects/young guns. Either/OR should allow us to acquire a Carl Crawford/Chris Young/Curtis Granderson type player. I'm not saying those 3 specifically but either someone young but experienced like Crawford (signed to a great deal) or someone who is the CF equivalent to our staple of great young pitchers- Nolasco, Johnson, Anibel, Olsen etc.

 

I would prefer us to keep Dontrelle and trade 1 or 2 of our young studs. We know what we have in Dontrelle. While no guarantee, his arm has shown the strength to hold up over the last 3 years. But as ridiculous as it is to say this, we have so much pitching that we could afford to trade Dontrelle and still be solid for years to come.

 

If your the Dodgers/Diamonbacks/Angels/Rays...how could you pass up the chance to add Dontrelle or two great young (and cheap) legit starting pitchers. We don't need to press with any one team. There are alot of good OF prospects/young players out there. And practically every team desperately needs pitching if they are going to have a chance to win anything. And we are the only team that has a surplus of good pitchers to deal who aren't immediately free agents. This is an awesome time to be a Fish fan. We are great now (maybe a slight overstatement) and our future only looks to get better. I trust Admin B to do the right thing. Be it in the next two months or in the offseason.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.