Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Current lineup

Featured Replies

hanley himself didnt think he was ready to start in 06.............if im not mistaken lets see him play before we count him out in 08!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

definitley, sure he'll be 21 when the season starts but a certain mr.cabrera was 20 when he came up :shifty

not to keep making this retarded comparisons, but Maybin was 20 when he came up too :shifty

I dont want Uggla hitting second and Id image that Maybin wont be leading off to start the season. I think since he is still so young and not really a leadoff type guy yet, Id imagine theyd leave Hanley there for the first part of the season and see what Maybin does.

"Here is a guy that can fly," Gonzalez said. "He's your prototypical leadoff guy that can run and steal you some bases.

Linky

Soo far looks like Gonzalez is leaning towrads leading Maybin off.

Why is everyone dropping Hanley in the batting order? From what I remember he was far more superior in the lead-off spot than any other spot in the order. He actually looked uncomfortable in other spots in the order.

Why is everyone dropping Hanley in the batting order? From what I remember he was far more superior in the lead-off spot than any other spot in the order. He actually looked uncomfortable in other spots in the order.

batting first: .345/.405/.596

batting third: .297/.333/.455

 

doesn't matter though, he eventually is going to be a middle order hitter, might as well start now

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

Ricky Henderson couldn't hold Hanley's jock, slugging wise

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

Ricky Henderson couldn't hold Hanley's jock, slugging wise

 

Yeah...Rickey only once SLGed more than Hanley did last season (.562)...and that was in Rickey's prime. Hanley did it at 23, at that age, Rickey SLGed .382

 

 

Ricky also had a far superior eye and OBP skills...and 100+ SBs a season. Dude was probably the best lead off hitter ever.

 

Oh and Soriano career .327 OBP shouldn't be leading off, you can thank stupid managers for that.

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

 

Hanley hit more home runs last year than Rickey did in any single season in his career, and Henderson's high SLG was only 15 points higher than Hanley's at the age of 23.

Yeah, Hanley's pretty much the man. Over the course of many at bats that man is the man no matter where you put him in the lineup. I know I may get killed for saying this, but I thought Hanley was a better hitter than Miggy last season. In fact, I'll go so far as predict that he'll be the best all around hitter in all of baseball within 2-3 years. I just hope we buy out a few years of his arbitration at least.

Yeah, Hanley's pretty much the man. Over the course of many at bats that man is the man no matter where you put him in the lineup. I know I may get killed for saying this, but I thought Hanley was a better hitter than Miggy last season. In fact, I'll go so far as predict that he'll be the best all around hitter in all of baseball within 2-3 years. I just hope we buy out a few years of his arbitration at least.

i hope we offer him a huge 15 year deal once a stadium deal is done but i know its not going to happen

Yeah, Hanley's pretty much the man. Over the course of many at bats that man is the man no matter where you put him in the lineup. I know I may get killed for saying this, but I thought Hanley was a better hitter than Miggy last season. In fact, I'll go so far as predict that he'll be the best all around hitter in all of baseball within 2-3 years. I just hope we buy out a few years of his arbitration at least.

i hope we offer him a huge 15 year deal once a stadium deal is done but i know its not going to happen

I hope we don't offer him a 15 year deal

Yeah, Hanley's pretty much the man. Over the course of many at bats that man is the man no matter where you put him in the lineup. I know I may get killed for saying this, but I thought Hanley was a better hitter than Miggy last season. In fact, I'll go so far as predict that he'll be the best all around hitter in all of baseball within 2-3 years. I just hope we buy out a few years of his arbitration at least.

 

 

Taking posistions out of the picture, I think Cabrera had the better year...better patience at the plate, higher OBP, more power/higher SLG.

 

But when you consider what he did at the SS posistion...dude's a special player. I hate to say but what Cabrera has done so far is not legendary. It's upper-tier, but it's not legendary. I mean getting his kind of production out of a power posistion...you can name several players doing it in the bigs right now, let alone over the stands of time.

 

If Hanley can keep this up though...man. The only person I could think of would be on that level at SS would be A-Rod, and he's a 3B now anyway. I'm sure I'm missing somebody with how long baseball has been around, but how many .900+ OPS SS is there? Several .800+. But outside of A-Rod, I can't think of a .900+ guy (I mean career, not a couple-time thing like Jeter/Ripken).

How about Alfonso Soriano?

 

Yeah, it did seem that Hanley might have that Soriano-esque preference for hitting lead-off, even though his power would suggest him hitting lower in the order. Piniella tried dropping Soriano last year and it just didn't take. The reasoning was that Soriano, an excellent fastball hitter, will see more fastballs batting in the lead-off spot.

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

Ricky Henderson couldn't hold Hanley's jock, slugging wise

Ricky was a pure leadoff hitter. He had a career .401 OBP. One season he had 125 BB. In his era he hit around 20 HRs a year. Unheard of for a leadoff hitter to do that. In this era it would equal about 30 homers. I dont need to mention the SBs

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

Ricky Henderson couldn't hold Hanley's jock, slugging wise

Ricky was a pure leadoff hitter. He had a career .401 OBP. One season he had 125 BB. In his era he hit around 20 HRs a year. Unheard of for a leadoff hitter to do that. In this era it would equal about 30 homers. I dont need to mention the SBs

 

He is great because of his OBP, not because he hit homers. It's not fair to compare Rickey's power to Hanley's, because Hanley's got much more power potential.

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

Ricky Henderson couldn't hold Hanley's jock, slugging wise

Ricky was a pure leadoff hitter. He had a career .401 OBP. One season he had 125 BB. In his era he hit around 20 HRs a year. Unheard of for a leadoff hitter to do that. In this era it would equal about 30 homers. I dont need to mention the SBs

 

He is great because of his OBP, not because he hit homers. It's not fair to compare Rickey's power to Hanley's, because Hanley's got much more power potential.

 

It's not fair to compare the two, period. They're two completely different players.

 

Hanley should and will hit third next season. The only way he doesn't is if this happened:

 

1. Ramirez

2. Maybin

3. Hermida

4. Jacobs

5. Uggla

6. Willingham

7. 3B

8. C

9. P

 

BUT, I'd much rather have...

 

1. Maybin

2. Hermida

3. Ramirez

4. Jacobs

5. Uggla

6. Willingham

7. 3B

8. C

9. P

 

Almost everyone is in their natural position in the batting order, or at least in a spot that they can excell. Maybin, much like Hanley two years ago, is looking like a lead-off major leage guy. Two years down the road, nobody knows, but for now. Hermida can hit anywhere from 2-6 in the lineup without a problem, but he'd be most deadly at either 2-3. Ramirez is just simply your prototypical 3-hole guy. Hits for average, power, speed, drive in runs. Jacobs, idk what's going to happen. BUT, I think with the three guys in front of him and a 30-homer guy behind him, he's going to have a lot of success. Batting him clean-up also breaks up the lefites. Uggla needs to have a hitter behind him for some protection, and with his power he's a perfect fit at the 5. I don't know if he's going to be as dangerous of a threat out of the 2 though, because those fastballs won't be coming in the wheelhouse as often. Willingham is Willingham; you know you're getting .275+, 20+ HR, 80-100 RBI, .370+ OBP. As solid as it gets. Hopefully that front six is good enough that the back 3 don't really matter... But I'd really like to see Jorge Cantu in that 7-spot.

Why, Rickey Henderson never hit anywhere else besides lead-off!

Ricky Henderson couldn't hold Hanley's jock, slugging wise

Ricky was a pure leadoff hitter. He had a career .401 OBP. One season he had 125 BB. In his era he hit around 20 HRs a year. Unheard of for a leadoff hitter to do that. In this era it would equal about 30 homers. I dont need to mention the SBs

 

He is great because of his OBP, not because he hit homers. It's not fair to compare Rickey's power to Hanley's, because Hanley's got much more power potential.

 

It's not fair to compare the two, period. They're two completely different players.

 

Hanley should and will hit third next season. The only way he doesn't is if this happened:

 

1. Ramirez

2. Maybin

3. Hermida

4. Jacobs

5. Uggla

6. Willingham

7. 3B

8. C

9. P

 

BUT, I'd much rather have...

 

1. Maybin

2. Hermida

3. Ramirez

4. Jacobs

5. Uggla

6. Willingham

7. 3B

8. C

9. P

 

Almost everyone is in their natural position in the batting order, or at least in a spot that they can excell. Maybin, much like Hanley two years ago, is looking like a lead-off major leage guy. Two years down the road, nobody knows, but for now. Hermida can hit anywhere from 2-6 in the lineup without a problem, but he'd be most deadly at either 2-3. Ramirez is just simply your prototypical 3-hole guy. Hits for average, power, speed, drive in runs. Jacobs, idk what's going to happen. BUT, I think with the three guys in front of him and a 30-homer guy behind him, he's going to have a lot of success. Batting him clean-up also breaks up the lefites. Uggla needs to have a hitter behind him for some protection, and with his power he's a perfect fit at the 5. I don't know if he's going to be as dangerous of a threat out of the 2 though, because those fastballs won't be coming in the wheelhouse as often. Willingham is Willingham; you know you're getting .275+, 20+ HR, 80-100 RBI, .370+ OBP. As solid as it gets. Hopefully that front six is good enough that the back 3 don't really matter... But I'd really like to see Jorge Cantu in that 7-spot.

Jacobs batting cleanup? Bleh. That job needs to go to Hammer.

BUT, I'd much rather have...

 

1. Maybin

I think Maybin should be in AA/AAA for the first half of 2008 to not set off his service time. Starting him from April 1, he hits arbitration in 2011. Starting him from July 1, he does not hit arbitration until 2012 and it tac's on an extra year until free agency where we'd have him in 2014. Why do we need Maybin for 3 months to make him more expensive sooner? He absolutely needs to play and get plopped at the top of the order, but we need to be patient and wait just a little bit longer.

 

I'd hope an end of the year lineup is this.

 

Maybin

Hanley

Hermida

Willingham

Then who really cares, as those 4 are the ones who make sense longterm.

I know Hammer is extremely popular here and has some extraordinary offensive stats but I wonder if he's long for this team in a starting capacity. I am not saying "the guy is going to get traded" or "I want to trade the guy" I just think he is someone who, to the right team is a piece that might marry up with a high pitching prospect to get something of value we want in return.

 

I think his value would increase were he playing first base ala Boone last season (multi-positional) although I still think if Jacobs stays healthy and can succeed in developing a more compact swing he can be a big rbi guy on this team.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.