July 31, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. you really are selling hermida short. did you even watch the cubs series?
July 31, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. What about Hermida's 2nd half #'s last year? Is that a reflection of talent? How about waiting till a player reaches his prime before calling him a bust?
August 1, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. What about Hermida's 2nd half #'s last year? Is that a reflection of talent? How about waiting till a player reaches his prime before calling him a bust? i am very happy you get to keep your sig :notworthy
August 1, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. What about 21 in the big leagues who was 5th among right fielders in MLB in OPS two years later as a 23 year old, which was his first full season?
August 1, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. What about Hermida's 2nd half #'s last year? Is that a reflection of talent? How about waiting till a player reaches his prime before calling him a bust? Where did I call Hermida a bust? WTF? I'm saying, the reason he's in the majors at age 24 is because we have no one else to go out there while he develops. My concern with Hermida is that if he does develop and enter his prime we won't be able to afford him anyhow because of how early he started.
August 1, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. What about Hermida's 2nd half #'s last year? Is that a reflection of talent? How about waiting till a player reaches his prime before calling him a bust? i am very happy you get to keep your sig :notworthy and im very glad im about to change my sig to a Hermida one... and then let you repeat that hahaha :thumbup
August 1, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. Only an ignorant person would call a 24 year old, already in the big leagues a bust. :whistle Being 24 and being in the big leagues isn't a reflection of talent, its a reflection of our needing someone cheap and affordable to play right field. What about Hermida's 2nd half #'s last year? Is that a reflection of talent? How about waiting till a player reaches his prime before calling him a bust? Where did I call Hermida a bust? WTF? I'm saying, the reason he's in the majors at age 24 is because we have no one else to go out there while he develops. My concern with Hermida is that if he does develop and enter his prime we won't be able to afford him anyhow because of how early he started. You DID NOT call him a bust. The person I was responding to called him a bust. That's the main reason I responded.
August 1, 200818 yr Marlins - 11 Rockies - 1 I think the Fish are glad Manny didn't come to Florida, I know I am. How about Anibal!
August 1, 200818 yr At the end of the day I'm more than quite alright with this. I did get caught up in the excitement of it and Manny does bring excitement to the plate. It had people buzzing big time about the Marlins and that's always good to see. Still, I didn't want to see the Fish give up too much for a rental or cause disruption to a team that clearly seems to have a tight comfort level even if that rental was Manny. What I am disappointed about is that we didn't upgrade they way I would have liked. I also hope this doesn't create any kind of negative backlash or buzz-kill for the Marlins.
August 1, 200818 yr Thank god Jeremy is still a Marlin. Waste of a perfectally good future for our team.
August 1, 200818 yr Thank god Jeremy is still a Marlin. Waste of a perfectally good future for our team. Thank God we didn't trade Jeremy, Tucker, AND Stanton. I wanted to :banghead when I saw that rumor. Then I realized Beinfest wasn't that stupid. Btw, 3 hits for Jeremy tonight? It's the 2nd half...could it be Jeremy being Jeremy? :blink:
August 1, 200818 yr Thank god Jeremy is still a Marlin. Waste of a perfectally good future for our team. Thank God we didn't trade Jeremy, Tucker, AND Stanton. I wanted to :banghead when I saw that rumor. Then I realized Beinfest wasn't that stupid. Btw, 3 hits for Jeremy tonight? It's the 2nd half...could it be Jeremy being Jeremy? :blink: Ermmm its Hermy being Hermy. As per Tommy Hutton. Apparently.
August 1, 200818 yr As much as I love the BoSox, I didn't want Manny here. I just felt it wouldn't be the same.
August 1, 200818 yr I love it. May I use it as my Facebook picture? Oh wait, I already did. I lost A LOT of sleep over the possibility of this happening. Deep down I was hoping, but unsure, that Beinfest would "get it" about their chemistry and not pull the trigger in an attempt to garner support for the ballpark. I've never really been against any of the trades made at the deadline in past years we were "in it" -- but this one just rubbed me the wrong way. And it was sickening how the fickle South Florida sports media was salivating over this. It was almost as infuriating as the national sports media pointing out that the Marlins' ERA is near the bottom of the league, totally clueless that the rotation now is completely different to that of the season's start. I was so glad when Rich and Tommy brought that up because I definitely noticed it on Mike and Mike after a sleepless night. For the record, I finally got some sleep -- just a few hours, though.
August 1, 200818 yr YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! But it's not for any of those reasons. We didn't need Manny and I feel we were giving up too much. Giving up what exactly ? A bust 1st rounder ? We'd have a chance to get 2 1st round picks in next years draft when Manny deserted us after the season. The Marlins would have made a statement to their players that they are serious, instead the players now know that this front office will never be about winning, but just about being as cheap as they can. How about management saying that they believe in the team that we currently have, and there was no need to add Manny to it. This game is as much about chemistry as it is skill, and you can see the tightness this team has with one another. To break that up could of been nearly as devastating as having a weaker defensive outfield with Ramirez. We already lead the league in homers, we average almost 5 runs a game, there was no need for Manny and his antics in LF, regardless if it brought more people to the game or not. We are going to either sink or swim with this group of players, and I wouldnt have it any other way.
August 1, 200818 yr at first i liked the idea of manny coming to the marlins but when i saw we were losing hermida, tucker and stanton i was praying for the deal to fall through we dont need manny - we have slugged our way into contention to make the playoffs we needed pitching - and that has arrived in the form of JJ, anibal, volstad and to a lesser extent rhodes disappointed we never got a catcher but i still like the way our team is set up to finish the season
August 1, 200818 yr I'm pleased. I loathe Manny and his whole act. Go knock over some clubhouse attendents in L.A.
August 1, 200818 yr I'm pleased. I loathe Manny and his whole act. Go knock over some clubhouse attendents in L.A. I have to agree with that as well. My main reason against this trade, to be honest, was that Manny makes Hermida look like Charlie Hustle out on the field.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.