Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Uh-Oh Pavano

Featured Replies

The Marlins. And they have done it every year while the team has been so young. Or do you think Gonzo was brought in for his glove, arm, and bat? Even when the team said when they signed him that he was here for his veteran presence? I guess they lied. Or it's some kind of conspiracy between the team and the players union to get "old" guys a contract. Just one example, but one close to home and recent.

 

The players, FOs, and coaches all say it is important. But a few people, that have never played any type of sport at this high a level and can't put their fingers on some type of stats, say it isn't so. (That's exactly what you said, in different words. "If you can't count it, don't count on it.") The people that have earned their spots on rosters and payrolls say it is. Guess which side I am going to go with. Of course I also don't go by the theory of hiring a teenager while they still know everything.

 

We will never agree on this. Plain and simple. I can live with it.

 

Gonzo was brought in highly because a) he was affordable and b) he filled a need... the leadership thing played a secondary role. Luis Gonzalez put up a .749 OPS and was brought in to... well, replace Hammer for his annual back crap out. There's no way you can say they only got him because he was a leader, there's no way that's gonna fly. And the reason Gonzo is favored over, say, Joe Minorleaguer is because Gonzalez brings in a track record, offensively. You know, roughly, what he'll produce (by using offensive stats, omgstatnerd). Leadership is secondary... I'll say again, WHY on Earth would you bring in a guy to "groom" the young guys when he just got done spending half a year complaining about doing just that in LA and did it before THAT in Arizona?

 

(And seriously... Gonzo complaining that the young players "hitting .340, .350." weren't helping the team win games... wtf is up with that?)

 

And you're right, I don't buy into things that can't be quantified because it's too unpredictable. Did Luis Gonzalez's leadership switch to "off" when he was with Arizona between 2004-2006? How do you quantify how useful it is? Simply put, you don't. Luis Gonzalez may be the nicest guy in the world but ultimately, what good does that do when your team loses over 100 games (2004 D'Backs)?

 

I don't claim to know everything and really, that's a lame shot to take that really means nothing. But again, you're saying that these players, FO, and coaches say it's important when there are players that think a .320 OBP is a GOOD thing... when there are coaches that think sac bunts are this great thing when really, it's been proven that there are only a very small handful of situations in which they work... otherwise they're very much counter intuitive. It has nothing to do with my being a teenager, there are plenty of HIGHLY qualified individuals that agree with me... plenty of coaches (Jim Leyland, Willie Randolph... etc), plenty of GMs (Billy Beane and his followers) and so on. Don't act like I'm in some non-existent minority... (So much for ALL of them saying it... huh)

You believe what you want. You have already twisted things so far out of reality they don't matter any more. I don't even bother reading the entire gibberish. It's actually funny now. Life imitates video games. Have a nice day.

You believe what you want. You have already twisted things so far out of reality they don't matter any more. I don't even bother reading the entire gibberish. It's actually funny now. Life imitates video games. Have a nice day.

 

This is unbelievable... simply stunning, really.

 

I'm going to ignore the crap you're slinging and just attack ANOTHER one of your falsehoods...

 

 

 

Note the "leadership"... that comes straight out of, guess what, a video game! YAY VIDEO GAMES REFLECTING REAL LIFE AND BEING THE SOLE BASIS OF MY OPINIONS AND IDEAS REGARDING EVERYTHING I DISCUSS!!

 

Once you said you don't bother "reading the entire gibberish" you lose your credibility... well, you lost any with me once you started the condescending BS.

 

So lemme just sum up everything I've said before... because clearly you decided to just play this "Ah, some dumb kid" crap...

 

Leadership has its place on a team, just like any functioning group needs leadership - BUT ability to do the job is infinitely more valuable. If it came right down to it... I'd bet you a team of 13 Miguel Cabrera's and 12 *Insert Distracting Ps* would do definitively better than a team comprised of Luis Gonzalez's, Wes Helms's and a few good players (a la the Marlins, this past year).

 

This is just the same as if I ran a newspaper company - I'd rather have a staff of capable writers that get their jobs done, even if they were straight out of college, than to "make room" for a leader whose quality of work is below that of the people he is "teaching"

 

You want to twist reality, go for it...

You believe what you want. You have already twisted things so far out of reality they don't matter any more. I don't even bother reading the entire gibberish. It's actually funny now. Life imitates video games. Have a nice day.

Bob, you're my bud and all, but seriously...you need to stop that "video game" sh*t everytime someone says they don't think "veteran presence" is important but this on-base percentage is. It's insulting and ignorant.

I have to disagree with that (in bold) statement. When you watch baseball on TV, the stats that are flashed up there are BA, HR, and RBI. Same thing goes when you look up a box score. The only place where the new age stats are primarily used over age old stats are on the internet and mostly because of fantasy leagues. Most casual fans don't know what a WHIP or an OPS are. There is an argument every other day on this very board about these new age stats.

 

Also, the reason that young players aren't considered leaders is because of credibility. Until you have been around a while and have experienced it all, the highs and the lows, you won't have the credibility to be labeled a leader. Now, not all veterans are capable of being leaders, as you have stated but most leaders have alot of experience under their belts. These leaders can serve as a buffer between the young players and the coaching staff. Whether you agree with this or not, most FO's see value in it. And yes, you can point out bad FO moves, but that doesn't take away from the fact that some of the better FO's see value in this also.

 

First things first - ESPN broadcasts (while not the primary broadcast of baseball games) do show OBP and show splits by pitch count. Also, in regards to most box scores, box scores should reflect the individual games performances, ergo it's less important to show OBP/SLG etc... so, they can maintain the old format and retain functionality.

 

Leadership credibility is a myth. Leaders are leaders, regardless. I've been on teams and in organizations where younger, less experienced peers have emerged as leaders because it's a natural talent... no different than being able to hit a 100mph serve, or being able to crunch numbers efficiently and quickly, throw a football a mile ... etc. You gotta remember, these players have played baseball probably most of their lives... they've all seen highs and lows and have won championships at varying levels.

 

Again, just because most FO's see value in something doesn't mean it's value, it's just a "conventional knowledge" that it's valuable. I'm not debating it has some value, but it's certainly very low on the talent totem pole. Remember... Speed and defense just had us trade Hammer/Olsen for Amezaga 2.0 and two relatively unknown prospects... one of which is currently injured.

 

Also, I'd like you show me a "better FO" that stresses value in "veteran leadership" and I'll show you a team with good players that happened to sign good player that is also a leader.

 

 

When I say watch on TV I am speaking about the actual game. When a player comes to the plate they show BA, HR, and RBI's. As for the box scores, whatever the reason is, they are what they are. I think we can agree that the new age stats are being used more frequently by analysts, but they still aren't used by the majority of fans especially the casual fans.

 

As for the whole leadership debate I don't think our opinions are too far off. I would never put experience or leadership over talent. I think what we are talking about in this case with Pavano is comparable talents. When you compare Pavano to Badenhop, or Trahern there seems to be comparable talent. Pavano is not the same because of injuries, and the other two are untested, but in the end all three of them project to be back or the rotation or bullpen arms. Now the question is does Pavano's experience help the rest of the staff, and if so is that more important this season than to develop Badenhop and Trahern.

 

Now if the debate were whether to sign Pavano and put him in the rotation at the expense of Miller, or Sanchez, I would be totally against it because both Miller and Sanchez are superior talents over Pavano. Even in this case with Pavano over Badenhop and Trahern, as I have already stated, I would choose the younger guys for one reason. If one of these kids does develop, then you have them cheap for the next several years as where Pavano would be a one year rental. With the Marlins economic situation that would be the better route in my opinion. However, I do see the merit in having a pitcher such as Pavano because of what he could bring to the rest of the staff.

 

* Note ( I used Badenhop and Trahern for example purposes only)

  • 3 weeks later...

LAS VEGAS -- Add the Marlins to the list of teams interested in free-agent pitcher Carl Pavano. Pavano's agent, Tom O'Connell, is scheduled to meet with Florida officials late Tuesday afternoon at the Winter Meetings.

 

"The Marlins are very much in the mix," O'Connell said before the meeting.

 

The Red Sox also have shown a high level of interest in the 32-year-old right-hander. About a half-dozen teams are considering Pavano, who pitched for Florida from 2002-04.

 

Pavano's best season was when he pitched for Florida. In 2004, he went 18-8 with a 3.00 ERA.

 

Following that season, Pavano signed with the Yankees, where he endured four injury-plagued seasons. In 2008, he was 4-2 with a 5.77 ERA.

 

Prior to the Winter Meetings, the Marlins had limited conversations with Pavano. But interest picked up in the past two days.

 

 

http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/news/articl...sp&c_id=fla

  • 4 weeks later...
  • Author

According to ESPN's Buster Olney, the Indians are in serious discussions with free agent starter Carl Pavano. Pavano will visit Cleveland soon and a deal could be wrapped up quickly. We'll have to see if Pavano can come close to the $2MM guaranteed Mike Hampton received from the Astros.

According to ESPN's Buster Olney, the Indians are in serious discussions with free agent starter Carl Pavano. Pavano will visit Cleveland soon and a deal could be wrapped up quickly. We'll have to see if Pavano can come close to the $2MM guaranteed Mike Hampton received from the Astros.

 

poop.

Pavano signed (or will sign) with the Indians:

 

Free-agent right-hander Carl Pavano, a subject of ridicule during his tenure with the Yankees, is on the verge of finding a new home.

 

Pavano has reached preliminary agreement on a one-year, $1.5 million agreement with the Indians, according to major-league sources.

 

The deal, pending a physical, also includes $5.3 million in incentive bonuses based on the number of games Pavano starts and his innings pitched.

 

Pavano underwent a physical in Cleveland on Tuesday, sources said, and if all goes well, his deal will be announced Wednesday.

 

The Indians are looking for stability in their rotation beyond their top two starters, left-hander Cliff Lee and righty Fausto Carmona.

 

Pavano, 32, made only 26 starts in his four seasons with the Yankees, suffering a variety of injuries. He went 4-2 with a 5.77 ERA last season after returning from elbow surgery in August.

 

News of the Indians' interest in Pavano was first reported by ESPN.

 

http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/9039172...tive-laden-deal

Their goes our chance to get him. Teams are always willing to throw guaranteed money at players like Pavano, wish him the best.

Good base price, Absolutely bonkers insane incentives. No way they let him trigger that.

No, but I doubt he'll get close to earning them.

Good base price, Absolutely bonkers insane incentives. No way they let him trigger that.

 

While Im not saying anything for or against the signing... (it has its pros and cons) what kind of pitcher would you expect to get for 5.3, Lou?

 

I mean... on the off chance he actually "earns" the 5.3M... the Indians still look great here

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.