Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

ESPN's Marlins Season Recap/Analysis

Featured Replies

Kiss 'Em Goodbye: Florida Marlins

1997. 2003. 2009? The six-year thing didn't happen -- 2010 won't, either

 

By Buster Olney, Baseball Prospectus and Insider staff

ESPN Insider

 

Baseball Prospectus' preseason PECOTA projection: 71-91, fourth place

Current record: 85-74, third place

 

The six-year theory (1997, 2003) should have gotten them another championship in 2009. It didn't. Patterns: apparently unreliable in baseball.

 

Buster Olney's take

 

What went wrong: The Marlins, like a lot of small-budget teams, try to get by with a bunch of young and unproven arms in their bullpen, and this year, that calculated gamble might have cost Florida playoff spot. Matt Lindstrom and then Leo Nunez got the opportunity to finish games for the Marlins -- and they struggled. Florida racked up 22 blown saves, tied for seventh most in the majors. Florida also struggled defensively (again), ranking in the bottom third in the majors in errors, and the Marlins had much more trouble than expected maintaining quality depth in their rotation.

 

Biggest puzzler on the drawing board: There are going to be a glut of closers on the move this winter, from free agents like Jose Valverde to possible trade bait like Kerry Wood -- and the Marlins need to figure out a way to get an established reliever to finish games. But they also have looming contractual situations with two of their best players, Josh Johnson and Dan Uggla. Johnson's agent is already banging the drum about wanting a big-money deal -- and this is the kind of dialogue that has led to the likes of Josh Beckett, A.J. Burnett, Carl Pavano, etc. heading out of South Florida. Rival executives believe this is the right time for the Marlins to decide whether they're going to sign Johnson to a multi-year deal or trade him. With Chris Coghlan now established in the majors, it may be that the Marlins will move him back to second and look to deal Uggla, who has averaged 30 homers a year over the last three seasons.

 

Baseball Prospectus' take

 

For the second year in a row, the Marlins have a record well above what would be expected given their runs scored and allowed, which are near even -- that's usually a recipe for a .500 record. The Marlins entered the season without quality players at first base or third and an unproven center fielder (Cameron Maybin). The pitching staff would hope for another good season from Ricky Nolasco, a healthy season from Josh Johnson, the blossoming of young starters Chris Volstad, Andrew Miller and Anibal Sanchez -- and the successful elevation of Matt Lindstrom to the closer's role.

 

They opened up with a stunning 11-1 record, but this was a distortion caused by a trick of scheduling; six of those games were against the Nationals at their worst, three were against a Mets team that would be one of the biggest disappointments in the league, and three were against a Braves team which had yet to restructure itself into a contender. Outside of that hot start in their first dozen games, the Marlins have gone 74-73.

 

See? A .500 team.

 

Though Hanley Ramirez had another MVP-worthy season, Maybin and Nolasco both flopped early and had to be demoted for stretches, Bonifacio was a predictable disaster, several other young pitchers imploded and Lindstrom failed. Despite these setbacks, one thing kept the Marlins from collapsing was their 29-19 record (.604) in one-run games, the best in baseball. That's not the kind of good luck that holds up from year to year. --Steven Goldman, Baseball Prospectus

 

Key stat: .299

 

Emilio Bonifacio's on-base percentage in the leadoff spot didn't quite reach .300, and it's not like he compensated by hitting for any power, slugging all of .312. Nonetheless, he was allowed to eat up plate appearances at the top of the order until the end of May, when late-developing Rookie of the Year candidate Coghlan arrived. Manager Fredi Gonzalzez dropped Bonifacio -- all the way to second, where he remained (still making outs) until Nick Johnson was acquired. Among players with over 400 plate appearances, Bonifacio has provided less offense per game than any player except Cincinnati's Willy Taveras and Texas's Chris Davis. Whatever Florida's financial constraints, giving Bonifacio such a prominent of a role was a crippling self-inflicted wound that cast a sub-replacement-level player in a key spot, hobbling an offense that needed to be at its best to overcome the shaky pitching staff. --Steven Goldman, Baseball Prospectus

 

Rumor Central

 

Trades: The Marlins aren't breaking up the core. That said, the Fish will likely try to trade Jeremy Hermida -- don't expect a bounty for the former prospect cover boy -- and also move Uggla, who will be a due a hefty arbitration raise to up to around $8 million. Oh, and Nick Johnson? Yeah, they'll be taking calls on him, too. Don't be surprised if the Giants have interest in either of the last two.

 

Money: Josh Johnson is in a weird situation. He can go to arbitration and get a hefty raise, or he can get some security by agreeing to a three- or four-year deal that would see him make north of $10 million per season. But, as Jayson Stark writes in MLB Rumor Central, "The Marlins have an organizational policy of not offering contracts longer than three years to any pitcher. They're mulling whether to make an exception for Johnson, but they're not there yet. I think it would take four years to get this done -- a deal that would buy out his final two years of arbitration and then pay him market, or near-market value, for giving up his first two years of free agency. The question is how they would value those two free-agent years. His agent has talked about getting 'CC Sabathia money.' And I can't envision the Marlins paying any pitcher $23 million a year. So it might not be a question of him 'turning down' four years at $50 million. They might not ever get that far."

 

Who 2 Watch 4:

Cameron Maybin, CF (age: 22)

 

Has Maybin finally figured something out? A perennial top prospect, Maybin's big-league trials have been consistently hampered by swing-and-miss tendencies, but he made some adjustments at Triple-A New Orleans after an early demotion, shortening his swing and focusing on contact more than power, and batting .319/.399/.463 in the process. He's looked far more comfortable at the plate during his September return to the big leagues, and 2010 could be the year where the Marlins finally get what they asked for. --Kevin Goldstein, Baseball Prospectus

 

Draft recap

 

Signed: 36 of 50 Spent: Just over $4 million

 

Hit: Chad James, LHP (No. 18 overall): James is a sturdy southpaw who ranked No. 20 on Keith Law's Top 100 and will bring three potential big-league pitches into his first pro appearance.

 

Miss: Marquise Cooper, OF (No. 97 overall): Cooper is a toolsy, athletic talent with raw baseball skills and was not on the first-day radar of most clubs. One California-based scout loved him as a later-round idea. Florida gave him $345K. --Jason A. Churchill

 

The bottom line

 

The Marlins rank last in the National League in attendance, and their approximately $37 million payroll doesn't figure to get much higher while they're waiting for their new retractable-roof stadium to open in 2012. This represents an immediate problem, because a good portion of the team is in line for raises this offseason. The resulting moves could mean a disastrous return for Bonifacio to a regular role, and maybe even more playing time for veteran journeymen like Wes Helms, while sort-of-ready prospects like first baseman Logan Morrison and outfielder Mike Stanton could be rushed to the bigs in the same way that tyro lefty Sean West was skipped past Triple-A this year. Until we know to what extent all the arbitration cases will force them to further clean house, we won't be certain of their outlook, but a leap forward into real contention seems unlikely, while a step backward looms as a real possibility. --Steven Goldman, Baseball Prospectus

 

Link (Insider needed for full article)

 

 

So as usual the stats people are raining on our parade. Not a huge surprise. However, I thought they made some good points.

Yeah Yeah Yeah and when we win 90 games again they'll say how do they do it every year with seemingly average stats.

  • Author

One thing that doesn't make sense is that the article says that we're going to be entertaining trade offers for Nick Johnson. Except that he isn't under our control for 2010. So he would be a FA.

I only have two problems with this article...

 

Firstly, our 11-1 start gets shat on again because of who we played. So what? If the Yankees went 11-1 to start the year against Baltimore and Kansas City, nobody would complain. We got lucky to have an "easy" schedule to start? Not our fault and we should be commended for taking advantage of it. Thank you very much.

 

And lastly, the rest of the recap was accurate except that they predict for us to not contend in 2010. I completely disagree. 2009 showed that we are *this* close...we make the improvements we need (such as bullpen and a reliable rotation) and we are definitely contenders in 2010. 2009 was a success overall and we are definitely setup to make a better run in 2010 with the right upgrades.

They opened up with a stunning 11-1 record, but this was a distortion caused by a trick of scheduling; six of those games were against the Nationals at their worst, three were against a Mets team that would be one of the biggest disappointments in the league, and three were against a Braves team which had yet to restructure itself into a contender. Outside of that hot start in their first dozen games, the Marlins have gone 74-73.

 

See? A .500 team.

 

This an absolutely ridiculous statement. Take out 11 of the Marlins wins and they're a .500 team. Talk about creative math

 

 

Whatever Florida's financial constraints, giving Bonifacio such a prominent of a role was a crippling self-inflicted wound that cast a sub-replacement-level player in a key spot, hobbling an offense that needed to be at its best to overcome the shaky pitching staff. --Steven Goldman, Baseball Prospectus

 

Well said, I think the FO's ego played a role in Bonifacio staying in so long. Especially considering that he wasn't even able to provide solid defense b/c he was playing out of position. The FO wanted so badly to look like they found a diamond in the rough w/ Boni and they couldn't swallow their pride expecting what we all could see, a TERRIBLE BALL PLAYER. I think a big reason for us not making the post season was this move right here

  • Author

I only have two problems with this article...

 

Firstly, our 11-1 start gets shat on again because of who we played. So what? If the Yankees went 11-1 to start the year against Baltimore and Kansas City, nobody would complain. We got lucky to have an "easy" schedule to start? Not our fault and we should be commended for taking advantage of it. Thank you very much.

 

And lastly, the rest of the recap was accurate except that they predict for us to not contend in 2010. I completely disagree. 2009 showed that we are *this* close...we make the improvements we need (such as bullpen and a reliable rotation) and we are definitely contenders in 2010. 2009 was a success overall and we are definitely setup to make a better run in 2010 with the right upgrades.

 

The main reason they think that we are going to move backwards in 2010 is because Uggla's gone, N. Johnson might be gone, we still have no closer, and we also might lose another bat, possibly.

 

In summary the article is also correct that we didn't do better because of the following reasons:

-Inconsistent starting pitching

-No true closer

-Bonifacio taking up so many ABs with that INCREDIBLE .299 OBP, which is just horrible.

 

Those are pretty much what killed us this year. Otherwise we are in the playoffs now.

Having Coghlan batting leadoff for a whole season next year is already a vast improvement over what happened this season with Bonifacio.

I only have two problems with this article...

 

Firstly, our 11-1 start gets shat on again because of who we played. So what? If the Yankees went 11-1 to start the year against Baltimore and Kansas City, nobody would complain. We got lucky to have an "easy" schedule to start? Not our fault and we should be commended for taking advantage of it. Thank you very much.

 

And lastly, the rest of the recap was accurate except that they predict for us to not contend in 2010. I completely disagree. 2009 showed that we are *this* close...we make the improvements we need (such as bullpen and a reliable rotation) and we are definitely contenders in 2010. 2009 was a success overall and we are definitely setup to make a better run in 2010 with the right upgrades.

 

The main reason they think that we are going to move backwards in 2010 is because Uggla's gone, N. Johnson might be gone, we still have no closer, and we also might lose another bat, possibly.

 

In summary the article is also correct that we didn't do better because of the following reasons:

-Inconsistent starting pitching

-No true closer

-Bonifacio taking up so many ABs with that INCREDIBLE .299 OBP, which is just horrible.

 

Those are pretty much what killed us this year. Otherwise we are in the playoffs now.

 

 

I disagree. I think there's a good chance that we're a 90-win team next year.

 

Catcher- Baker is all but guaranteed to be back next season, and I think Paulino also has a good chance of sticking around for 2010. Considering we get a mid-high .700 OPS between the two, we're in pretty good shape there.

 

First- The position is still a question mark for next season. Yeah, we'll be without NJ, but he only played 32 games for us this season, so him not being here at all next year won't be that much of a difference. If we have, let's say, Gaby Sanchez playing first, then the offense that Sanchez brings will be a downgrade, but if he can play league average defense, that will be an improvement over what NJ has done this season, so he could be almost as good. We could also see Morrison up during the middle of the season.

 

Second- Coghlan's BABIP will drop, which means his OPS will drop, but if he can still maintain at least a high-700 OPS with average defense at second base, he would probably be a slightly worse Dan Uggla. In fact, he may even be better than that considering he is a much better contact hitter than Uggla.

 

Third- If I had to guess, and for the sake of argument, I'll put Cantu at third for 2010. He should put up around another .800 OPS season, so no upgrade, but no downgrade there.

 

Short- Hanley's numbers could decrease, but if they do, it probably won't be by that much. He also has room for improvement on defense.

 

Left- Cody has a good chance of playing LF next year. He can put up an OPS somewhat near Coghlan's 2009 OPS. He also brings much better defense though, so if anything, it will be an improvement in LF.

 

Center- Maybin is a player that is really too hard to project. He can be both great and terrible offensively, and the same can be said for his defense. He could be worse than Cody was this year, or he could be better, I really just don't know.

 

Right- Carroll would be my best guess to play RF in '10. Hermida might be better on offense than Carroll, but the defensive upgrade would be HUGE. It's never a bad thing to have one of the best defensive right fielders in the game playing for your team, even if the offense is below average. Regardless, he will probably be an upgrade over Hermida.

 

Starters- This is where I see a huge upgrade over this season. We're probably keeping all of our pitchers from this year, and with all of them either still very young or at least relatively young, we should see them all improve. The two which I expect to see performing much better are Nolasco and Volstad, since they have been very unlucky this year. Amazingly, Volstad has the highest HR/FB% in the MLB, and Nolasco is .003 points away from having the highest BABIP in the MLB. Needless to say, I expect solid season from both of them next year, with Nolasco's ERA falling somewhere in between 3.5-4, and Volstad with an ERA from 4-4.5, with both having the ability to be even better than that. Johnson should continue to dominate, while whoever the other two starters are (Sanchez, West?) should at least be decent in 2010, if not better.

 

Relievers- This is the hardest part to predict, since a bullpen can change dramatically every season. If we can put together just an average bullpen, then we would be in the same area as we were in 2009.

 

To recap:

 

Upgrades- Left, Right, SP

Same- Catcher, Second, Third, Short, RP

Downgrades- First

Unknown- Center

 

Which means that we should be a better team, in my opinion.

While I expect Coghlans BABIP to drop, I still expect him to be a .800 OPS AB. So, we lose out on power, but gain OBP.

I only have two problems with this article...

 

Firstly, our 11-1 start gets shat on again because of who we played. So what? If the Yankees went 11-1 to start the year against Baltimore and Kansas City, nobody would complain. We got lucky to have an "easy" schedule to start? Not our fault and we should be commended for taking advantage of it. Thank you very much.

 

And lastly, the rest of the recap was accurate except that they predict for us to not contend in 2010. I completely disagree. 2009 showed that we are *this* close...we make the improvements we need (such as bullpen and a reliable rotation) and we are definitely contenders in 2010. 2009 was a success overall and we are definitely setup to make a better run in 2010 with the right upgrades.

 

The main reason they think that we are going to move backwards in 2010 is because Uggla's gone, N. Johnson might be gone, we still have no closer, and we also might lose another bat, possibly.

 

In summary the article is also correct that we didn't do better because of the following reasons:

-Inconsistent starting pitching

-No true closer

-Bonifacio taking up so many ABs with that INCREDIBLE .299 OBP, which is just horrible.

 

Those are pretty much what killed us this year. Otherwise we are in the playoffs now.

 

 

I disagree. I think there's a good chance that we're a 90-win team next year.

 

Catcher- Baker is all but guaranteed to be back next season, and I think Paulino also has a good chance of sticking around for 2010. Considering we get a mid-high .700 OPS between the two, we're in pretty good shape there.

 

First- The position is still a question mark for next season. Yeah, we'll be without NJ, but he only played 32 games for us this season, so him not being here at all next year won't be that much of a difference. If we have, let's say, Gaby Sanchez playing first, then the offense that Sanchez brings will be a downgrade, but if he can play league average defense, that will be an improvement over what NJ has done this season, so he could be almost as good. We could also see Morrison up during the middle of the season.

 

Second- Coghlan's BABIP will drop, which means his OPS will drop, but if he can still maintain at least a high-700 OPS with average defense at second base, he would probably be a slightly worse Dan Uggla. In fact, he may even be better than that considering he is a much better contact hitter than Uggla.

 

Third- If I had to guess, and for the sake of argument, I'll put Cantu at third for 2010. He should put up around another .800 OPS season, so no upgrade, but no downgrade there.

 

Short- Hanley's numbers could decrease, but if they do, it probably won't be by that much. He also has room for improvement on defense.

 

Left- Cody has a good chance of playing LF next year. He can put up an OPS somewhat near Coghlan's 2009 OPS. He also brings much better defense though, so if anything, it will be an improvement in LF.

 

Center- Maybin is a player that is really too hard to project. He can be both great and terrible offensively, and the same can be said for his defense. He could be worse than Cody was this year, or he could be better, I really just don't know.

 

Right- Carroll would be my best guess to play RF in '10. Hermida might be better on offense than Carroll, but the defensive upgrade would be HUGE. It's never a bad thing to have one of the best defensive right fielders in the game playing for your team, even if the offense is below average. Regardless, he will probably be an upgrade over Hermida.

 

Starters- This is where I see a huge upgrade over this season. We're probably keeping all of our pitchers from this year, and with all of them either still very young or at least relatively young, we should see them all improve. The two which I expect to see performing much better are Nolasco and Volstad, since they have been very unlucky this year. Amazingly, Volstad has the highest HR/FB% in the MLB, and Nolasco is .003 points away from having the highest BABIP in the MLB. Needless to say, I expect solid season from both of them next year, with Nolasco's ERA falling somewhere in between 3.5-4, and Volstad with an ERA from 4-4.5, with both having the ability to be even better than that. Johnson should continue to dominate, while whoever the other two starters are (Sanchez, West?) should at least be decent in 2010, if not better.

 

Relievers- This is the hardest part to predict, since a bullpen can change dramatically every season. If we can put together just an average bullpen, then we would be in the same area as we were in 2009.

 

To recap:

 

Upgrades- Left, Right, SP

Same- Catcher, Second, Third, Short, RP

Downgrades- First

Unknown- Center

 

Which means that we should be a better team, in my opinion.

 

I think Nolasco will be #2 and more like 3-3.5 and Volstad will be #3 and more like 3.5-4.0 but this is a great post from you. .

I do agree with this article in some respects. We all know about the Bonifacio debacle, starting pitching woes and poor defense (despite the speed and defence mantra from the FO). However, I do take a few exceptions.

 

1) Since when is Cantu not considered a quality corner IF? He might not be a superstar, but he's put up two very solid seasons with the fish, and is better than any of the options we've had (though to be fair to Gaby, he hasn't been given the opportunity to prove that one way or the other).

 

2) I'm not as worried about our closers as everyone else seems to be. Yes, we lead the NL in BS's and Nunez lead the team in that category. However, do you know who was tied for second? Kiko and Pinto with 4, and along w/ Meyer, they were the core of our BP this year. 8 different players recorded a blown save, and our two main closes recorded less than half of those. Personally, I think Nunez was just overwhelmed this year with the responsibility thrown on him and Lindstrom I don't believe has fully recovered from his early season injuries. Given an offseason to physically recover (Lindstrom) and mentally prepare (Nunez), I think they'll be both be in much better places next season. I'm not sure a closer committee is the best thing, but at the same time, both players are fiercly competitive, so perhaps having the other breathe down their necks will keep them honest.

 

3) To me, the overall BP is the main concern. When you have that mainly players recording a blown save, there's a problem with consistency and depth. Marlins relievers accounted for almost 40% of our losses, which to me is pretty remarkable considering how inconsistent our SP was outside of JJ. Outside of the fore-mentioned core of Kiko, Pinto, Sanches and Meyer, our BP was a bunch of unproven youngsters and has-beens that should nerver have been on our roster (Ayala, Penn). Donnelly looks like he might have recovered his hold form, but I'm not sure he'll return.

 

Hopefully we'll actually retain our core for next season, isntead of once again scouring baseball for reclemation projects. I can't help but think what this season would have been like had we just given the modest (And deserved) raises Nelson and Waechter were requesting.

While I expect Coghlans BABIP to drop, I still expect him to be a .800 OPS AB. So, we lose out on power, but gain OBP.

 

 

Which is why I said that he could be nearly as good as Uggla has been for us the past few years, providing that he at least plays average defense at second.

I do agree with this article in some respects. We all know about the Bonifacio debacle, starting pitching woes and poor defense (despite the speed and defence mantra from the FO). However, I do take a few exceptions.

 

1) Since when is Cantu not considered a quality corner IF? He might not be a superstar, but he's put up two very solid seasons with the fish, and is better than any of the options we've had (though to be fair to Gaby, he hasn't been given the opportunity to prove that one way or the other).

 

2) I'm not as worried about our closers as everyone else seems to be. Yes, we lead the NL in BS's and Nunez lead the team in that category. However, do you know who was tied for second? Kiko and Pinto with 4, and along w/ Meyer, they were the core of our BP this year. 8 different players recorded a blown save, and our two main closes recorded less than half of those. Personally, I think Nunez was just overwhelmed this year with the responsibility thrown on him and Lindstrom I don't believe has fully recovered from his early season injuries. Given an offseason to physically recover (Lindstrom) and mentally prepare (Nunez), I think they'll be both be in much better places next season. I'm not sure a closer committee is the best thing, but at the same time, both players are fiercly competitive, so perhaps having the other breathe down their necks will keep them honest.

 

3) To me, the overall BP is the main concern. When you have that mainly players recording a blown save, there's a problem with consistency and depth. Marlins relievers accounted for almost 40% of our losses, which to me is pretty remarkable considering how inconsistent our SP was outside of JJ. Outside of the fore-mentioned core of Kiko, Pinto, Sanches and Meyer, our BP was a bunch of unproven youngsters and has-beens that should nerver have been on our roster (Ayala, Penn). Donnelly looks like he might have recovered his hold form, but I'm not sure he'll return.

 

Hopefully we'll actually retain our core for next season, isntead of once again scouring baseball for reclemation projects. I can't help but think what this season would have been like had we just given the modest (And deserved) raises Nelson and Waechter were requesting.

 

 

Calero is a free agent. He's gone. And his raise will be more than either Nelson's or Waechter's would have been. And how can you claim that they deserved the raises? They were solid last season, so maybe that's what you mean. But both have followed it up with poor 2009s. Waechter threw 5 IP the entire season. And Joe Nelson was lucky to have a 4.02 ERA, considering he walked nearly as many batters as Pinto (6 BB/9) and struckout fewer guys than last year (10 K/9 in 2008, 8 K/9 in 2009). So I'm quite happy we aren't paying either of those guys what they wanted......and that's not even mentioning the way it seemed like Nelson and his agent played us....

 

That said, I wish we had the payroll to keep Kiko. Sanches will stay (and probably regress); Meyer will stay; Pinto will stay; Badenhop will stay; at least one of Nunez/Lindstrom will stay; and the other 2 spots will be some combo of FA pickups, RVH/Miller/Sanchez (I hope they put Miller in AAA if he can't make the rotation); and maybe some guys from within the organization who are deemed worthy of a shot as the 6th/7th RP arm.

I'll say this despite Mystikol kinda pointing it out already.

 

Joe Nelson, the career minor leaguer, didn't even make it into August as a Major Leaguer, I think it's safe to say we made the right decision not giving in to his demands.

 

Doug Waechter, with his history of injuries, got DLed twice and injured three times this season including tearing his labrum for a second time. I think it's safe to say we made the right decision not giving in to his demands.

I'll say this despite Mystikol kinda pointing it out already.

 

Joe Nelson, the career minor leaguer, didn't even make it into August as a Major Leaguer, I think it's safe to say we made the right decision not giving in to his demands.

 

Doug Waechter, with his history of injuries, got DLed twice and injured three times this season including tearing his labrum for a second time. I think it's safe to say we made the right decision not giving in to his demands.

 

 

And we followed that up with making the wrong decision by signing Scott Proctor...

They opened up with a stunning 11-1 record, but this was a distortion caused by a trick of scheduling; six of those games were against the Nationals at their worst, three were against a Mets team that would be one of the biggest disappointments in the league, and three were against a Braves team which had yet to restructure itself into a contender. Outside of that hot start in their first dozen games, the Marlins have gone 74-73.

 

See? A .500 team.

 

This an absolutely ridiculous statement. Take out 11 of the Marlins wins and they're a .500 team. Talk about creative math

 

 

Whatever Florida's financial constraints, giving Bonifacio such a prominent of a role was a crippling self-inflicted wound that cast a sub-replacement-level player in a key spot, hobbling an offense that needed to be at its best to overcome the shaky pitching staff. --Steven Goldman, Baseball Prospectus

 

Well said, I think the FO's ego played a role in Bonifacio staying in so long. Especially considering that he wasn't even able to provide solid defense b/c he was playing out of position. The FO wanted so badly to look like they found a diamond in the rough w/ Boni and they couldn't swallow their pride expecting what we all could see, a TERRIBLE BALL PLAYER. I think a big reason for us not making the post season was this move right here

 

think this way why did natinal gave him in trade that fast because he was not good player if he was good he be still on team of national

And this is why when you trade Uggla, Hermida, and Cantu this offseason, you target exclusively pitching. Starter, Reliever. Doesn't matter. As much young pitching as you can get.

 

Stopgap 3B with something. Call up the obvious kids for everywhere else. Just trade for pitching pitching pitching and see what sticks.

  • Author

And this is why when you trade Uggla, Hermida, and Cantu this offseason, you target exclusively pitching. Starter, Reliever. Doesn't matter. As much young pitching as you can get.

 

Stopgap 3B with something. Call up the obvious kids for everywhere else. Just trade for pitching pitching pitching and see what sticks.

 

That makes no sense. We don't have anyone besides Cantu that can step in at 3rd, unless you really think that Gaby Sanchez can produce. My guess is that he would make up for just under half of Cantu's offense. We can't afford that kind of offensive loss on top of Uggla almost certainly leaving. Our system is not as deep as it was, because we have been relying on it far too much. The only people that can play 3rd base are still a few years away.

 

We can probably get a decent reliever or starter in exchange for Uggla, but I don't know if the FO wants to go in that direction.

 

This is what our offense looks like for next year, assuming that both Uggla and Hermida are gone:

 

C: Baker/Paulino

1B: Either G. Sanchez or Morrison, if he's ready

2B: Possibly Bonifacio (eww)

SS: Hanley

3B: Cantu

RF: Ross

CF: Maybin

LF: Coghlan

 

I don't see much power in that lineup beyond Hanley, Cantu, and Ross. The other problem is that Hanley's power numbers have taken a hit lately, while his average is up.

 

I know a recent PBP article said that it's pretty likely now that Coghlan will actually stay out there in left field, and not come into the infield as I originally thought. The only problem with this is that we don't have an infielder except for Bonifacio who can step in at second besides Coghlan. We do have outfielders like Carroll, who improved greatly this year, who could play in left or right.

My guess is that he would make up for just under half of Cantu's offense.

 

 

You think Gaby can only put up a .550 OPS?

 

I mean, quick RC math

 

.345(OBP) * .441(SLG) * 635(PA) = 96 runs for cantu this season

 

.250 * .300 * 635 = 47 runs

 

our offense is fine, really. People put too much of an emphasis on having a yankee line up. I mean, we're replacing a .600 OPS from 3b. if bonifacio is starting again, yeah, sure, our offense will take a hit.

And this is why when you trade Uggla, Hermida, and Cantu this offseason, you target exclusively pitching. Starter, Reliever. Doesn't matter. As much young pitching as you can get.

 

Stopgap 3B with something. Call up the obvious kids for everywhere else. Just trade for pitching pitching pitching and see what sticks.

 

That makes no sense. We don't have anyone besides Cantu that can step in at 3rd, unless you really think that Gaby Sanchez can produce. My guess is that he would make up for just under half of Cantu's offense. We can't afford that kind of offensive loss on top of Uggla almost certainly leaving. Our system is not as deep as it was, because we have been relying on it far too much. The only people that can play 3rd base are still a few years away.

 

We can probably get a decent reliever or starter in exchange for Uggla, but I don't know if the FO wants to go in that direction.

 

This is what our offense looks like for next year, assuming that both Uggla and Hermida are gone:

 

C: Baker/Paulino

1B: Either G. Sanchez or Morrison, if he's ready

2B: Possibly Bonifacio (eww)

SS: Hanley

3B: Cantu

RF: Ross

CF: Maybin

LF: Coghlan

 

I don't see much power in that lineup beyond Hanley, Cantu, and Ross. The other problem is that Hanley's power numbers have taken a hit lately, while his average is up.

 

I know a recent PBP article said that it's pretty likely now that Coghlan will actually stay out there in left field, and not come into the infield as I originally thought. The only problem with this is that we don't have an infielder except for Bonifacio who can step in at second besides Coghlan. We do have outfielders like Carroll, who improved greatly this year, who could play in left or right.

 

You really don't see the big picture. It make sense if payroll is $37 million. For $40, they could keep Cantu. This is a big difference in payroll. I'd LOVE to keep Cantu, but if we're playing the hypothetical game at $37 million, there is no way we can afford a $5.5-6 million Cantu in 2010 unless we exchange him for Ross, and then look for other OF options. Which really could happen, as the moderate $1-2 million free agents may have more value in the OF than at 3B.

 

C John Baker $415,000

1B Gaby Sanchez $405,000

2B Chris Coghlan $410,000

3B Some kind of 3B

SS Hanley Ramirez $7,000,000

LF Brett Carroll $405,000

CF Cameron Maybin $405,000

RF Cody Ross $4,250,000

B Emilio Bonifacio $415,000

B Wes Helms $950,000

B Ronny Paulino $880,000

B Veteran 1B/LF $1,000,000

B Jai/De Aza/Raynor $405,000

 

SP Josh Johnson $5,500,000

SP Ricky Nolasco $4,250,000

SP Andrew Miller $2,000,000

SP Chris Volstad $415,000

SP Anibal Sanchez $1,000,000

RP Matt Lindstrom $1,600,000

RP Reynel Pinto $850,000

RP Dan Meyer $415,000

RP Rick Vanden Hurk $415,000

RP Brian Sanches $415,000

RP Burke Badenhop $415,000

RP Tim Wood $405,000

 

$34,620,000

 

You basically have $2.5 to find a 3B at $37. Cantu can stay for $40. That's the team. Also notice West is in AAA with this team, which could impact the pen if they want to make one of the starters a reliever to just get your 12 best arms in the bigs at whatever slot.

 

Best Case scenario, is a $40 million payroll and insert Cantu above. But to say a Cantu less team makes no sense is not looking at what is really going on.

 

Also, Baker/Paulino have produced the 7th best slugging for catchers this year, Coghlan at 2B would tie for 7th at 2B. I think it's foolish to think that team has no power besides Hanley and Ross. These guys are no slouches even if they don't have 30 HR pop like Dan. Maybin, Gaby, BC, and probably Morrison in the summer, would all be able to add at least as much pop as Hermida, N. Johnson, Cantu, and Bonifacio - a combined 32 HR over 1750 PA.

 

I'm telling you. Offense isn't the problem. It's PITCHING. PITCHING. and MORE PITCHING. All trades need to bring back near exclusive pitching, even if we have a cheap veteran/helms/bonifacio year at 3B in 2010.

Further on this retarded power argument

 

Uggla, Cantu, Hermida, Bonifacio, and N. Johnson hit 63 HR. Eyeballing it, this is like a .410 slugging percentage combined. That is basically 4 starters on the field where we average 16 HR/.410 slugging. Holy crap, stop the presses!

 

I do not think this is a big deal to replace. Losing Uggla will hurt 1 lineup spot, and yes keeping him and improving elsewhere would produce an even better team, but if those guys cost.... literally $20 million, and we can replace everyone with .270/.340/.410 hitters, which is not asking a lot from Maybin, Gaby, BC, and whoever else, offense is literally not changing at all. Marlins are 5th in the NL in runs. A worst case scenario is dropping to average, and that's still a winning team if the PITCHING comes together.

 

PITCHING PITCHING PITCHING

 

Trade for nothing else.

Starters- This is where I see a huge upgrade over this season. We're probably keeping all of our pitchers from this year, and with all of them either still very young or at least relatively young, we should see them all improve. The two which I expect to see performing much better are Nolasco and Volstad, since they have been very unlucky this year. Amazingly, Volstad has the highest HR/FB% in the MLB, and Nolasco is .003 points away from having the highest BABIP in the MLB. Needless to say, I expect solid season from both of them next year, with Nolasco's ERA falling somewhere in between 3.5-4, and Volstad with an ERA from 4-4.5, with both having the ability to be even better than that. Johnson should continue to dominate, while whoever the other two starters are (Sanchez, West?) should at least be decent in 2010, if not better.

 

Relievers- This is the hardest part to predict, since a bullpen can change dramatically every season. If we can put together just an average bullpen, then we would be in the same area as we were in 2009.

 

To recap:

 

Upgrades- Left, Right, SP

Same- Catcher, Second, Third, Short, RP

Downgrades- First

Unknown- Center

 

Which means that we should be a better team, in my opinion.

 

 

I'd put our starters under "Unknown" as well. We could've said the same thing at the beginning of this year about how Volstad would be good and that is not what he's shown. And what makes you think Anibal will be better? You just don't know what to expect from these guys. Nolasco looks legit but even he has faltered.

 

Our rotation is JJ, Nolasco, hopeforthebest, hopeforthebest, hopeforthebest

 

Closer is non existent.

 

If we don't keep JJ we're gonna be hurting.

  • Author

We have JJ for the next two seasons. But it's going to cost us more in arbitration in the fall of 2010 most likely, than it would to sign him to a 3-4 year deal, which would go from 2010-2014 or so.

 

Look, I understand that pitching is really important. But we have the starting depth at this point. As long as we hang onto those guys they should improve. Anibal was injured this year, along with Ricky (who struggled as well). I have no confidence in Andrew Miller at all, but hopefully he'll surprise me. Not sure what to do with Volstad. He really took a major step backwards this season. But this was his first full MLB season. So hopefully he can fix his issues in Spring Training and have a better year. I doubt that we'll have as many rotation issues in 2010 as we did in 2009 (knock on wood).

 

So again, I'm not as concerned with the starting staff as much as I am with the bullpen (still) and the offense. Already we're setting up to repeat what we did in 2009, where we decided to roll the dice with two unproven players (Maybin and Bonifacio). First base is going to be a gamble again, with either Gaby Sanchez or Logan Morrison getting the job. We could have an even less clear situation at 3rd if Cantu isn't signed.

Starters- This is where I see a huge upgrade over this season. We're probably keeping all of our pitchers from this year, and with all of them either still very young or at least relatively young, we should see them all improve. The two which I expect to see performing much better are Nolasco and Volstad, since they have been very unlucky this year. Amazingly, Volstad has the highest HR/FB% in the MLB, and Nolasco is .003 points away from having the highest BABIP in the MLB. Needless to say, I expect solid season from both of them next year, with Nolasco's ERA falling somewhere in between 3.5-4, and Volstad with an ERA from 4-4.5, with both having the ability to be even better than that. Johnson should continue to dominate, while whoever the other two starters are (Sanchez, West?) should at least be decent in 2010, if not better.

 

Relievers- This is the hardest part to predict, since a bullpen can change dramatically every season. If we can put together just an average bullpen, then we would be in the same area as we were in 2009.

 

To recap:

 

Upgrades- Left, Right, SP

Same- Catcher, Second, Third, Short, RP

Downgrades- First

Unknown- Center

 

Which means that we should be a better team, in my opinion.

 

 

I'd put our starters under "Unknown" as well. We could've said the same thing at the beginning of this year about how Volstad would be good and that is not what he's shown. And what makes you think Anibal will be better? You just don't know what to expect from these guys. Nolasco looks legit but even he has faltered.

 

Our rotation is JJ, Nolasco, hopeforthebest, hopeforthebest, hopeforthebest

 

Closer is non existent.

 

If we don't keep JJ we're gonna be hurting.

 

 

I never said that our starters were unknown, I said our releivers were unknown. Our rotation can be one of the better ones, maybe even a top five rotation in the NL next season. I don't think any realistic people thought that Volstad would come in and have that sub-3 ERA he had last season. A 3.9 HR/FB% is nearly impossible to maintain, so we knew that was going to come up. It just came up a lot higher than most people would have expected it to. Anibal, assuming that he remains healthy throughout 2010 (which is a big IF), should make a decent back-end of the rotation starter.

 

Our rotation is far from just two starters. If we can get another 3-ERA season from JJ, around a 3.5 from Nolasco, ERAs in the high-threes from Volstad, and low-mid fours from both Sanchez/West/whoever the last two starters are, then we will be in very good shape, pending that there are no major injuries.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.