Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2011-12 NFL Thread

Featured Replies

So they'd rather stay free agents right now than start at QB for the Dolphins?

 

Weak.

Delete

I disagree. A team will be desperate enough to take him despite his age.

Does anyone remember 29 year old old Chris Weinke from FSU? How did his NFL career workout? :mis2

 

So, because they come out at the same age, they will end up having the same career? Does talent level not matter to you?

 

Find some examples of QBs drafted at the age of 28 that have had successful NFL careers.

3-1 Tampa Bay :D

 

See you in week 7.

 

Bears have to play ATL, GB, NO, DET, TB and PHI 6 of their first 8 games.. bruuuuutal.

I disagree. A team will be desperate enough to take him despite his age.

Does anyone remember 29 year old old Chris Weinke from FSU? How did his NFL career workout? :mis2

 

So, because they come out at the same age, they will end up having the same career? Does talent level not matter to you?

 

Find some examples of QBs drafted at the age of 28 that have had successful NFL careers.

 

 

He wasn't drafted at 28, but he didn't start playing until 27 and didn't start until 29, but I think Roger Staubach worked out OK. Not that I would expect Staubach results out of anyone, but still.

unsuccessfully so far...

 

MikeBerardino

RT @JasonLaCanfora: Miami made unsuccessful attempts (at least for now) to sign David Garrard and Jake Delhomme this week

 

Why would they do it now? They (or any team for that matter) should have made attempts at Garrard as soon as he was released. Delhomme is a joke and if I were a Dolphin fan I would not want him on my team.

I disagree. A team will be desperate enough to take him despite his age.

Does anyone remember 29 year old old Chris Weinke from FSU? How did his NFL career workout? :mis2

 

So, because they come out at the same age, they will end up having the same career? Does talent level not matter to you?

 

Find some examples of QBs drafted at the age of 28 that have had successful NFL careers.

 

Why? That's a stupid exercise.

 

If Brandon Weeden isn't good, it won't be because he's 28. It'll be because he's not good. As it stands, he's very talented.

  • Author

I can understand Old Man Delhomme not wanting to come to Miami (he'd probably like to jump on board with a playoff team seeing that his career is dwindling with little time left... maybe grab a ring as a bench QB)...

 

But Garrard turning Miami down is WEAK. Sure he's not that much younger than Delhomme, but he certainly had more left in the tank and could potentially move in to Miami and take over a starting position for sure.

I can understand Old Man Delhomme not wanting to come to Miami (he'd probably like to jump on board with a playoff team seeing that his career is dwindling with little time left... maybe grab a ring as a bench QB)...

 

But Garrard turning Miami down is WEAK. Sure he's not that much younger than Delhomme, but he certainly had more left in the tank and could potentially move in to Miami and take over a starting position for sure.

 

They know Miami is a QB graveyard. All the QB's that have played here since Marino retired ended they're careers here one way or another.

I disagree. A team will be desperate enough to take him despite his age.

Does anyone remember 29 year old old Chris Weinke from FSU? How did his NFL career workout? :mis2

 

So, because they come out at the same age, they will end up having the same career? Does talent level not matter to you?

 

Find some examples of QBs drafted at the age of 28 that have had successful NFL careers.

 

Why? That's a stupid exercise.

 

If Brandon Weeden isn't good, it won't be because he's 28. It'll be because he's not good. As it stands, he's very talented.

 

But teams aren't going to take a risk on something that's essentially never happened before. Even if he's good, he you've lost 6 prime years of his career. Teams aren't going to go for that.

  • Author

6 prime years? I'd argue that a QB's best years are coming when he's 28-32.

 

That being said, you're losing out on him being able to properly develop into his best years, but you're not missing out on 6 prime years by any means. You're just starting the learning curve late. He'll peak fast.

 

I'd take him if he falls to the 3rd or 4th rounds...nothing like having too many good potential QBs in Miami.

You may not want to count Warren Moon because he was in the CFL. (I would expect that major conference NCAA is at least as good as CFL)

You evidently don't want to count Staubach because he was in Navy.

We may not want to count Kurt Warner because he was in the Arena Football League (I would expect that major conference NCAA is superior to the Arena leagues)

3-1 Tampa Bay :D

 

See you in week 7.

 

Bears have to play ATL, GB, NO, DET, TB and PHI 6 of their first 8 games.. bruuuuutal.

Wish I could go to that but I have a training course on Monday morning that I cant miss, and I would for travelling if I went down to London :(

You may not want to count Warren Moon because he was in the CFL. (I would expect that major conference NCAA is at least as good as CFL)

You evidently don't want to count Staubach because he was in Navy.

We may not want to count Kurt Warner because he was in the Arena Football League (I would expect that major conference NCAA is superior to the Arena leagues)

 

 

Three guys. Two of whom were free agents, one was the 129th player taken in the draft. And two of them were playing for years. Sweden has not been putting in the same time they were.

 

I'm not saying it's impossible he'll be good. I'm saying it would be stupid to take him in a top round. The examples of guys starting their careers late and thriving are rare. It's not worth a top investment.

If your going to argue about him dropping based off age, I can see where your coming from. I thought you were saying he's notgoing to be good because of his age.

 

We have to wait and see,I guess. Based off talent I think he's a top 10 prospect. He may not go that high but I think he could sneak in the first round if a team is desperate enough.

I think his chances of being a really good pro are pretty low due to his age, yes. The jump from college to the pros is tough. It takes time to adjust, which he doesn't have and likely won't be given due to his age. If he is going to be good, he basically has to be right away. This isn't a guy who gets to have a year or two to figure it out. He has to be good right away.

 

History is against him. If he goes to 4th round he could be good value, but if you're investing a first or second rounder, that's a big mistake in my book.

 

I wouldn't use a

 

Sage Rosenfels Experience

Yup. He's a free agent at the end of the season, so we most likely say his last game as a Dolphin last Sunday.

Wow. This puts Suck for Luck into high gear, I would think?

 

 

At this point why the hell not?... Ive gotten over the fact that the Dolphins suck and started to embrace the Suck For Luck campaign.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.