Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins trade/FA talk

Featured Replies

Please don't sign a crappy veteran like McGehee unless it's just a minor league deal with an invitation to Spring Training. I'm not Dietrich's biggest fan or anything, but he's better than the pile of crap left in free agency. He's also a young player so we might as well give him a chance to see what he can do. Just add some low-cost pitching depth to the team and wrap up the offseason. They did more than I expected. The additions to the team are just fine and they should improve somewhat. No need to add a crappy veteran 3B who's going to add nothing to the team.

 

I think Betimet is potentially better than Dietrich is, depending on health status.

I don't know what's going on with Olt right now, but I'd much rather have him in my system than Dietrich. Olt's recent sucking might be legit, but he has a much higher ceiling than Dietrich does.

 

Wasn't it attributed to some eye problem? I remember hearing that it was corrected late last season.

I don't know what's going on with Olt right now, but I'd much rather have him in my system than Dietrich. Olt's recent sucking might be legit, but he has a much higher ceiling than Dietrich does.

 

Wasn't it attributed to some eye problem? I remember hearing that it was corrected late last season.

I think he was sucking even after it was "corrected". Just like Dan Uggla sucked because of his "eye problems" too. Dietrich has, at the very least, had SOME success in the major leagues and is coming off a very good year in Double-A. Olt has been struggling for a bit now, in the minors, with no success in the majors.

I bet the Marlins won't even attempt a Stanton extension this offseason. If I'm right, I really hope they trade him at the deadline instead of waiting like morons.

All indications are that they are once again delaying an offer until a year from now, after saying the same thing a year ago

I bet the Marlins won't even attempt a Stanton extension this offseason. If I'm right, I really hope they trade him at the deadline instead of waiting like morons.

All indications are that they are once again delaying an offer until a year from now, after saying the same thing a year ago

I wouldn't be buying a Stanton jersey any time soon, even though he is my favorite player on the team. I think they are waiting for him to have a monster season so that they can deal him. I know that is being a debbie downer, but, I'm just calling them like I see them. Just don't trade him to the Tigers, that's all I ask!

well see they just have no idea if Stanton would be willing to sign here you see. And since there's no way of ever knowing this, they're in a tough spot.

 

Then they should make him an offer and see what he says. They should offer him something like the Rays did with Longoria. If he says no, you trade him to the highest bidder.

I agree, on the one hand they claim they're building around Stanton, and yet they haven't made an effort to lock him up yet? That doesn't make sense. It also seems foolish.

well see they just have no idea if Stanton would be willing to sign here you see. And since there's no way of ever knowing this, they're in a tough spot.

 

Then they should make him an offer and see what he says. They should offer him something like the Rays did with Longoria. If he says no, you trade him to the highest bidder.

Longoria signed that contract before he had a month of service time, Stanton is arbitration eligible. That is not a good comparable on hypothetical contracts and not a deal Stanton would take. The arbitration comps are guys like J. Upton, Bruce, and especially Cargo. We're talking $80-90 land over 6 years. That comps Stanton just above the other premier outfielders, and just below the Cabrera/Pujols/Howard/Fielder class of guys who were all better than him at this respective point of their careers. You also have to do it THIS offseason, because next offseason he'll have $7 million bucks (2014 salary estimate) in his pocket already with an additional $10-12 becoming guaranteed through his pending 2015 arbitration. Basically, Stanton will have made around $20 million overall, including his 14-15 arbitration tenders, so at that point you absolutely do not sign a contract to buy out free agency years (because you already have "set for life" money) and gamble on yourself for the massive 10 year contract.

 

It's now or never before opening day if they are going to retain him beyond arbitration. And if Loria is to cheap to pony up for Stanton on 6 years right now, the smart thing to do is to trade him right now as he will not be more valuable next offseason with the looming threat of free agency and a team acquiring him immediately having to dish out a $200 million contract. Literally.

 

Personally, I think 6/$90 removes all distaste out of Stanton's mouth. He'd be stupid to not "willing" sign that from a business perspective. Gets paid and still a free agent in his prime. And if his level of spite is irrational and doesn't take it? Trade him to Seattle for their entire system and be done with it.

 

And saying that, they should give Fernandez a better "Matt Moore" contract right now. They already messed up his service time (if they had kept him in the minors in April, they would have gained a full year of service time in 2019. Really short sighted move) by calling him up on opening day last year, but maybe they can help mitigate that mistake with a real 6 year contract with an option or two on the back.

Trading Stanton wouldn't be so bad. We've got holes that need to be filled. I just hope they do one or the other soon...

I agree on Stanton and Fernandez, but I don't see either happening

 

Me neither. Stanton will be gone in 2 seasons and when he outright states he will not negotiate a new contract until free agency, they'll get 50% of what they could get for him right now. But hey, having Stanton for 2 non-contending years in 2014-2015 is worth that lower trade value right? These guys suck.

I agree on Stanton and Fernandez, but I don't see either happening

 

Me neither. Stanton will be gone in 2 seasons and when he outright states he will not negotiate a new contract until free agency, they'll get 50% of what they could get for him right now. But hey, having Stanton for 2 non-contending years in 2014-2015 is worth that lower trade value right? These guys suck.

I agree with you on this stuff Lou. I just hope that the Marlins' front office and scouting department do a good job of evaluating other teams' talent if they deal Stanton. Another thing, I would not deal him to the Tigers no matter what they gave the Marlins back. Burke Badenhop, Dallas Trahern, Frankie De La Cruz, Cameron Maybin, Andrew Miller, Mike Rabelo, Rob Brantly, JacobTurner and Brian Flynn for Miguel Cabrera, Dontrelle Willis, Anibal Sanchez and Omar Infante! Nice return for the Fish! LOL!

I agree on Stanton and Fernandez, but I don't see either happening

 

Me neither. Stanton will be gone in 2 seasons and when he outright states he will not negotiate a new contract until free agency, they'll get 50% of what they could get for him right now. But hey, having Stanton for 2 non-contending years in 2014-2015 is worth that lower trade value right? These guys suck.

I agree with you on this stuff Lou. I just hope that the Marlins' front office and scouting department do a good job of evaluating other teams' talent if they deal Stanton. Another thing, I would not deal him to the Tigers no matter what they gave the Marlins back. Burke Badenhop, Dallas Trahern, Frankie De La Cruz, Cameron Maybin, Andrew Miller, Mike Rabelo, Rob Brantly, JacobTurner and Brian Flynn for Miguel Cabrera, Dontrelle Willis, Anibal Sanchez and Omar Infante! Nice return for the Fish! LOL!

I agree with you on the Cabrera trade but it's way too early to call the Anibal Sanchez trade a bad deal. Jacob Turner (whom the majority on this board wanted from DET) had a decent season and is still very young. Brian Flynn also looks promising from what he has done in the minors thus far. I also have some hope that Brantly can figure things out in the minors. I know he gets a bum rap on here , not that it wasn't warranted, but he is still a young catcher that had a bad season on a terrible team. When you consider what we have in the minors, and that Mathis is our backup C , we'd better hope that he pans out to be at least a decent backup. So, it's too soon to call on the Sanchez deal in my opinion.

I agree on Stanton and Fernandez, but I don't see either happening

 

Me neither. Stanton will be gone in 2 seasons and when he outright states he will not negotiate a new contract until free agency, they'll get 50% of what they could get for him right now. But hey, having Stanton for 2 non-contending years in 2014-2015 is worth that lower trade value right? These guys suck.

I agree with you on this stuff Lou. I just hope that the Marlins' front office and scouting department do a good job of evaluating other teams' talent if they deal Stanton. Another thing, I would not deal him to the Tigers no matter what they gave the Marlins back. Burke Badenhop, Dallas Trahern, Frankie De La Cruz, Cameron Maybin, Andrew Miller, Mike Rabelo, Rob Brantly, JacobTurner and Brian Flynn for Miguel Cabrera, Dontrelle Willis, Anibal Sanchez and Omar Infante! Nice return for the Fish! LOL!

I agree with you on the Cabrera trade but it's way too early to call the Anibal Sanchez trade a bad deal. Jacob Turner (whom the majority on this board wanted from DET) had a decent season and is still very young. Brian Flynn also looks promising from what he has done in the minors thus far. I also have some hope that Brantly can figure things out in the minors. I know he gets a bum rap on here , not that it wasn't warranted, but he is still a young catcher that had a bad season on a terrible team. When you consider what we have in the minors, and that Mathis is our backup C , we'd better hope that he pans out to be at least a decent backup. So, it's too soon to call on the Sanchez deal in my opinion.

I agree with you Rydawg that it's a little too early to close the book on the Sanchez/Infante deal. Both of those guys are still really good though and they helped the Tigers get back to the World Series. Turner or Flynn could still be good starting pitchers, but Brantly is a waste....as he is Mike Rabelo part two. The Cabrera trade was a joke though! I just don't want the Marlins to deal with the Tigers anymore! There are 28 other teams the Fish can trade with and I'm sure they all have some nice young prospects on them.

  • Author

well see they just have no idea if Stanton would be willing to sign here you see. And since there's no way of ever knowing this, they're in a tough spot.

 

Then they should make him an offer and see what he says. They should offer him something like the Rays did with Longoria. If he says no, you trade him to the highest bidder.of course that's what they should do - I was joking. all they have to do is offer. If he turns his nose up, hey they're off the hook and go find the best package in the world. It is lunacy to do what they're currently doing, which is nothing. It's a waste - Stanton becomes less & less valuable in deals (yes still king's ransom stuff but the point remains...) He does us no good here for the next year or two if they're just going to turn around and deal him when he's a FA - like Lou said, the 4 or 5 wins he gives you on a bad team in 2014 is accomplishing something? Whatever it is, just get it done already so the team can move forward.

  • Author

You also have to do it THIS offseason, because next offseason he'll have $7 million bucks (2014 salary estimate) in his pocket already with an additional $10-12 becoming guaranteed through his pending 2015 arbitration. Basically, Stanton will have made around $20 million overall, including his 14-15 arbitration tenders, so at that point you absolutely do not sign a contract to buy out free agency years (because you already have "set for life" money) and gamble on yourself for the massive 10 year contract.

 

Agree - that's the point where he's no longer foolish to turn down a contract (or at least less foolish). It's now or never. And they'll probably just punt again.

Loria keeping payroll low in order to sell the team for max value when his penalty drops.

One can only hope that it's bought by a pencil-pushing nerd that likes advanced stats.

Loria keeping payroll low in order to sell the team for max value when his penalty drops.

One can only hope that it's bought by a pencil-pushing nerd that likes advanced stats.

 

Or NOT!! How about someone the genuinely loves baseball and is willing to spend money on it.

Loria keeping payroll low in order to sell the team for max value when his penalty drops.

One can only hope that it's bought by a pencil-pushing nerd that likes advanced stats.

 

Or NOT!! How about someone the genuinely loves baseball and is willing to spend money on it.Uhhh... those 2 aren't mutually exclusive

Loria keeping payroll low in order to sell the team for max value when his penalty drops.

One can only hope that it's bought by a pencil-pushing nerd that likes advanced stats.

 

Or NOT!! How about someone the genuinely loves baseball and is willing to spend money on it.

Mark Cuban? One only dream! no way he comes to the same city as Micky!

Loria keeping payroll low in order to sell the team for max value when his penalty drops.

One can only hope that it's bought by a pencil-pushing nerd that likes advanced stats.

 

Or NOT!! How about someone the genuinely loves baseball and is willing to spend money on it.

Mark Cuban? One only dream! no way he comes to the same city as Micky!

Cuban would kill to own any MLB team. Anytime there's a team for sale, he's in on them. I would love to have Cuban here.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.