Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins trade/FA talk

Featured Replies

Which would then make Heaney a number three, and then 4-5 is just a mishmosh of f***ery. ... Positive f***ery.

 

Well, it would give us the ability to trade yet another SP. I really don't think we'll get Rodon though.

 

I personally want Trea Turner to have a great season so we can draft him. He's a hometown kid with elite speed and a good bat who figures to stick at SS.

Well, it would give us the ability to trade yet another SP. I really don't think we'll get Rodon though.

 

I personally want Trea Turner to have a great season so we can draft him. He's a hometown kid with elite speed and a good bat who figures to stick at SS.

I'd be 100% for getting Turner, myself. His numbers are impressive. Doesn't he go to the same college Moran came from, too? Or am I remembering incorrectly?

I'd be 100% for getting Turner, myself. His numbers are impressive. Doesn't he go to the same college Moran came from, too? Or am I remembering incorrectly?

No, Moran was UNC. Turner is NC State - the same college Rodon goes to.

No, Moran was UNC. Turner is NC State - the same college Rodon goes to.

Ohhh, my bad. Wow, so the same place could have the top two picks. Has that ever happened?

I still think the draft comes down to Gatewood or Turner. I'm not buying all the Alex Jackson talk right now.

 

Right now I'd love to grab Turner. A+++ speed, decent to above average defense at SS (with the ability to play 3B and probably 2B as well), and has the potential to add some power to his repertoire.

 

Gatewood is a Stanton style high school prospect. Scouting reports have him as a guy with 30+ home run a season power as a SS, but not the best contact guy (and he's likely a meh fielder and slow baserunner). The enticing thing about Gatewood is he's coming right out of high school and has potential to gain some plate discipline, build into his frame and become an even better hitter over time.

 

But we'll all have this conversation in June. Still got months until baseball starts back up again.

We won't have to trade starting pitching for position players after we deal Stanton. You know we're trading him, and he could probably fill whatever needs we have.

Stanton's not going anywhere until NEXT offseason. And even then the Marlins will grab a couple starting pitching prospects in the deal.

I asked one of the ESPN baseball people about the Stanton thing yesterday, and he agrees with my contention that they FO is stalling until they decide to pull the trigger on a trade. It's inevitable. Why they don't just do it now is beyond me.

Agreed...Selig does not stomach Owners that are flashy and have their own pizazz

I didn't know where to put this, but I still think at some point we're gonna have to trade that starting pitching depth we have for hitters.

 

I'm not sure they have real tradeable depth in SP, right now that is. I think it is very premature to trade any starter in the organization (unless some crazy overpay happens).

 

Fernandez and Heaney are untouchable for years.

Eovaldi and Nicolino they seem to love a bit more than

Alvarez and Turner, who are probably a # 4/5 starter on a playoff team and

Flynn, Urena, Conley, DeSclafani, Koehler, and Hand are all probably relievers. Some maybe real good ones, but probably relievers. Maybe one guy here breaks through and becomes a backend starter.

 

I mean, great if they all work out and would love to be wrong (and if they do, bring on the riches in trade), but it's just very unlikely they have legitimate depth here to trade. Eovaldi blows out his arm (someone on this list will blow out their arm in 2014. It's just a numbers game unfortunately), Turner doesn't figure it out or Alvarez's lack of K's catch up to him, Urena doesn't develop a third plus pitch and ends up a high leverage reliever, Conley or Flynn ends up a loogy, Hand just doesn't make it, and Koehler in the pen, and poof. Thank god you didn't trade anybody so you still can fill out the rotation and don't have to sign Scott Feldman for $30 million. Let alone, what if Fernandez goes all Matt Harvey. It happens.

 

The depth is in all these relievers, not in the starters. They probably have two bullpens right now of guys who could crack 25 man rosters, which is pretty outstanding. Unfortunately those guys can't really be packaged for longterm hitters the Marlins need. What's Dunn getting you? Two AA versions of Dunn or a Dietrich? Not bad potential moves, but it's not like acquiring a "Yelich" or even an "Ozuna." You're getting something like Lombardozzi (whom the Tigers just got in the Fister deal) at best. That isn't getting the offense where it needs to be.

 

Maybe a situation develops where they trade some arms for bats, but in reality, the Marlins need to keep the best 5 starting pitchers period, and there needs to be at least 2 more years of evaluation on all of them to figure out the answer to that question. Plus, whoever ends up being the 6th best, is probably not getting you a "Yelich" and they need 2-3 guys like him easy. They really need to hold onto the SP for now. In fact, I think they need to take MORE starting pitching with the # 2 pick in the 2014 draft.

 

I think there is two responsible ways to fix the offense. (1) trade cishek for a longterm bat option anywhere in the infield, preferably 2B. I don't think this is unreasonable to think. (2) Loria signs a bat free agent next year that is better than Salty, probably at SS once Hecha proves he can't hit again. Throw in Moran, Marisnick, a better backup catcher/Realmuto if he works out, maybe Dietrich after a year in the minors to replace Solano/Lucas, and add a vagabond lefty killer 1B to help Jones, and now that might start looking like something if they don't blow it and trade Stanton and Yelich becomes what we hope.

 

They just aren't fixing the offense unless the dish Heaney, which is really out of the question. Eovaldi would have netted what Trumbo (sub 3WAR player) if those rumors were true, and Alvarez and Turner ain't getting that. MEH. Keep them, see what happens, and keep drafting to your strength.

  • Author

Seems like they could go ahead and do a Cishek deal really. I mean is he ever going to be more valuable? Trade deadline I guess?

 

Agreed on the pitching, let it play out for a while. I'm relieved we didn't move any pitching prospects.

and on a side note in the FA market, they're reporting that Choo turned down a 7 yr $140 milllion offer from the Yankees (Boras client). Clearly he was hoping for an offer from Loria.

I don't know why they would get 90 cents on the dollar right now, he's only going to get more expensive going forward, if you were another team seems like you'd want him now. He's entering his prime, he's the dream fantasy trade for every team out there from the sound of it, just a matter of whether the Marlins want to do it or not. But sure, point made.

 

 

 

 

says who?

 

I shouldn't have said "he doesn't seem to want to sign here." More like I don't think he want's to sign here.

Thats not true that he isn't interested in signing with us. You don't know that. He is going to get more expensive but any team trading for him knows they will have to pay him eventually. He is coming off a bad year so no chance we should trade him right now.

 

Yeah I shouldn't have said he isn't interested in signing with us. That's my opinion.

 

Part of me thinks if we did have him signed already we'd be able to get more of a return if we were to trade him. Teams would at least know what they would have to pay him. The longer we wait and the more expensive and closer to FAs he gets might make teams weary if they are just trading for a rental who's gonna walk.

This offseason in general is kind of boring. Probably the most boring one I can remember.

This offseason in general is kind of boring. Probably the most boring one I can remember.

 

You must really enjoy fire sales.

That's exactly what he meant. If there's not a fire sale, the off-season is boring. No gray area, just straight to the top.

 

You read my mind. I swear... The logic on these boards is legendary.

  • 2 weeks later...

Would six years of Seattle infielder Nick Franklin be enough to land six years of Miami outfielder Jake Marisnick? The Mariner pitching staff needs a good defensive outfielder even more than it needs a bat. Leaving Franklin out of the equation in a Marisnick trade, would the Marlins be interested in package starting with five years of 24-year-old former top propsect Jesus Montero as a righthand-hitting complement to 32-year-old Garrett Jones at first base?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.