Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Papelbon

Featured Replies

Love the bashing of the bullpen a few weeks ago and now bashing when they inquire on an arm. Yeah he's pricy but you can't have too many arms when you're trying to make a run

 

​The bullpen actually looks much better now than it did a few weeks ago though. That should be taken into consideration. 

 

 

​I'm not supportive of this trade idea by any means but who is really intriguing in the minors other than Kolek and Nicolino?

 

​A deal for Chapman would, at the very least, require one of those two going to Cincinnati. No thanks. This team's issue at this point isn't the bullpen. 

 

 

There's no chance we would part with Ozuna or Yelich for Chapman. And anyone who thinks Papelbon is as dominant as chapman is kidding themselves 

 

 

There's no chance we would part with Ozuna or Yelich for Chapman. And anyone who thinks Papelbon is as dominant as chapman is kidding themselves 

 

Obviously, Chapman is a better bet long-term and 100 mph is always nice, but check out their #'s this year.

 

Valuing one way more than the other makes no sense unless if there are plans to convert Chapman to SP or something.

 

Trading what's left of the farm system for Chapman would be classic Marlins.

 

 

Could chapman actually be in the rotation?

 

He was a starter in Cuba and the conversion has been discussed on multiple occasions since he came to the States, but it's never happened. For what it's worth, he's said that likes to close.

 

 

Why not trade one of Cishek or Ramos in the same deal for Chapman- that should bing the prospect price down if they want players who can contribute. If they only want prospects it's a different story 

 

 

I would not include Kolek, for example, in a deal for a reliever. 

 

For what it's worth, Papelbon is every bit as dominant as Chapman these days, but everyone hates him. I absolutely do not want Papelbon either for other reasons, but I find the hatred of him kind of weird. 

 

I would not deal Kolek for Chapman, either, and I don't even think the Marlins would consider that.

 

As far as Papelbon, he is seven years older than Chapman and is making $26 million between this year and next year. Plus, he is kind of an asshat.

 

 

I would trade Kolek for Chapman in a heartbeat if it only meant giving up a few more non top prospects on top of Kolek.  I would also try to transition over time Chapman to a starting role. That being said I'm not sure about his contract so that would obviously play a role in the decision as well.  He obviously signed a major league deal out of cuba so I'm not sure how many years is left on that.  Kolek looks pretty bad for a number 2 pick so far.

 

 

​Key words are "so far".  He's 19, I don't dump a 19 year old top draft pick this fast for a reliever

 

The thing with Kolek is they took Kolek before Rodon which makes the pick look especially terrible "so far"

 

 

The only players I would want to pursue are ones that would make this team better in the second half AND BEYOND.  

 

On a fantasy/wishful thinking/ daydreaming note, I would love to pry Goldy from D-Backs.  Could you imagine 3-4-5-6 of Yelich, Beast, Goldy, Ozuna? 

 

 

The only players I would want to pursue are ones that would make this team better in the second half AND BEYOND.  

 

On a fantasy/wishful thinking/ daydreaming note, I would love to pry Goldy from D-Backs.  Could you imagine 3-4-5-6 of Yelich, Beast, Goldy, Ozuna? 

 

​We'd probably have to give up Yelich and Ozuna for Goldschmidt.

 

 

I agree Wittgren is at least worth trying out.

 

These are all short term fixes to a team that needs long term solutions.

 

​yes, and Grant Dayton is another if they need a guy who's effective against lefties.

 

I don't think the pen is in terrible shape at all.  No way on Pap.  Particularly if Cishek gets it together, but even if he doesn't we'll have an extra arm or two from Phelps and Company who'll be pushed out of the rotation, so there's extra arms to pick from.

 

 

​We'd probably have to give up Yelich and Ozuna for Goldschmidt.

 

​I know... but someone like that would really impact the line-up...i can dream I guess

 

 

​I know... but someone like that would really impact the line-up...i can dream I guess

 

​While dropping two people that already really impact the lineup [both positive and negative].

 

I'd love Goldschmidt, too, especially considering he's a good defender as also, but, still.

 

That or we trade Kolek, Nicolino, Wittgren, Urena, and a PTBNL which turns out to be Naylor after the season :lol  

 

 

​While dropping two people that already really impact the lineup [both positive and negative].

 

I'd love Goldschmidt, too, especially considering he's a good defender as also, but, still.

 

That or we trade Kolek, Nicolino, Wittgren, Urena, and a PTBNL which turns out to be Naylor after the season :lol  

 

For Goldschmidt, all of those guys can go.

 

 

​Key words are "so far".  He's 19, I don't dump a 19 year old top draft pick this fast for a reliever

 

​for a certain reliever who has thrown 106 at a point and has history as a starter.  sign me up.

 

 

​We also trade a Fan to be Named Right the Fuck Now.

 

And that fan is fish14.

 

​No Marlins Man? Vince will be pissed

 

 

​Seeing as he wouldn't be a starter here, that part is meaningless.

 

​being that this is a hypothetical scenario that wouldn't happen anyway, all of this is meaningless.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.