Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2023/24 Off-Season

Featured Replies

Anyways, it's November and Bendix has been here less than a month, so let's actually wait and see what he does.

Or should we bother waiting? Since it's already known and a given fact that he will do nothing and just try and make Bruce more money?

Also we should entirely forget the fact that Bruce wanted to keep Kim and she left on her own. FOR A GOOD REASON, mind you, but it was still her decision and not Bruce's.

 

I'm not sure anyone has flat out said Kim was a bad GM. Simply that she, like many other GMs, had flaws. Drafting? Not good. Free agent signings? Not good. Trades? That's where she succeeded. Fantastic mind for trades, as was pointed out. Arraez for Pablo - it's so far a win-win! That was a great trade.

 

Every other GM traded the stars for prospects because ... well, ya know, outside of the 1997 dismantling, the team wasn't all that good prior to the teardown. The 2005 team probably could have used another year together, but is what it is. That being said, this was something the owners told the GM to do, and you know what happens if the GM says to the owner, "I'm not going to do what you're telling me to do?" Welllll they're not the team's GM much longer.

 

Don't think anyone has completely turned on Kim or fully thrown undying support to Bendix yet. But we know what Kim did and could do, and we know where Bendix is coming from and the success that was had there, with him playing a pretty reasonable role.

 

Let's. See. What. Happens.

 

 

Also format longer posts like this, it's really hard to read a 20 sentence block of text.

Now that I'm thinking about it, in three years here, did Kim give ANYONE an extension?

Berti, maybe? That's the only one I can think about.

Edit - even then, Berti is still under the arbitration umbrella through 2025. lol

1 minute ago, Michael said:

Now that I'm thinking about it, in three years here, did Kim give ANYONE an extension?

Berti, maybe? That's the only one I can think about.

She gave me one m8

OK she extended Sandy, forgot about that one. Right before the lockout.

 

BUT STILL.

 

Actually Jeter was still here so that may have been him. lol

1 hour ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

I support Bendix but the idea that Kim Ng was all of a sudden a bad GM because she focused on acquiring talent to improve the team and not on 'sustainable' is what gets me, every other GM we ever on this franchise had always traded our stars for prospects. Ng was the 1st GM we ever had that actually showed she would care more about winning than making the owner richer. When was the last time we traded a decent player for another decent player to improve the team what it needed? Ng did that trading Lopez for Arraez. Bendix or any other GM we ever had would have traded Lopez for a bunch of worthless overrated prospects who never pan out. Ng traded some shitty prospects for quality MLB players, just the Jake Burger deal alone was worthy of praise. Bendix or any other GM we ever had would have never made those deals. Ng was always focused on making the team better and it might move the Marlins from 30th payroll to 29th and that was unacceptable to Bruce, and so that's why I call the sudden turn on Kim Ng and the sudden unconditional love for Bendix shilling. Because it sounds like it, you have a GM who is willing to win and then people point out the flaws, but other GMs dont even want to be in the game, they are just there to make the owner money, and supporting that can be for no other reason than shilling. The Avi deal was a miss but I would at least like to hear the reasons that deal happened, we never heard them. The Cueto deal made sense at the time, as well as the Robertson deal. You swing and you miss sometimes. Our other GMs and Bendix will never swing tho, they will just sit in the batting box hoping to take a walk so they can never get blamed for making a mistake. That's what I like about Kim and what (SO FAR, i get it more 'time is needed') i don't like about Bendix or any other GM so far. I guarantee you by now if Kim was here a Arraez and Luzardo extension would have been done. Nobody ever wants to talk about the Luzardo deal as well that she made trading half a meaningless season of Marte for him, that's the deal Bendix would dream of but he will never have made.

Do we still need a CF?

  • Author
2 hours ago, Michael said:

Bruce wanted to keep Kim and she left on her own. FOR A GOOD REASON, mind you, but it was still her decision and not Bruce's.

It's what Bruce said but what's Kim said ?

Reality though is that if the Marlins and especially Bruce Sherman wants to change the actual narrative and not have fans/media/et al feel that the Bendix move is all about trying to win without spending money...

 

They really need to extend Luzardo and Arraez.

 

otherwise, its going the perception of Bruce Sherman being a cheap fuck is just going to continue, especially if there is no semi significant spending to upgrade the roster.

 

Does this have to happen now?  No.

Does it need to really happen beore the end of Week 1 of Spring Training?  Probably

By Opening Day? Definitely.

 

There is your timeline.  Tick tock. (On Bruce Sherman)

6 minutes ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

It's what Bruce said but what's Kim said ?

we never heard what she said other than the reporter who mentioned Bruce hiring a new superior (Bendix) she would have and so she declined. connecting the dots you can tell she wouldn't accept the demotion and wanted a promotion. she didn't want someone above her other than bruce telling her yes and no on her moves. i dont think we will ever hear from her again, it was clearly taken as a disrespect and she wanted to move on.

 

2 hours ago, Michael said:

OK she extended Sandy, forgot about that one. Right before the lockout.

 

BUT STILL.

 

Actually Jeter was still here so that may have been him. lol

Yes she did Sandy, and Im pretty sure as well had negotiations with Soler towards the end of this year that didn't pan out. At least there was talks tho but Soler probably earned himself a contract bruce was never going to pay.

1 hour ago, Sherman shill said:

Do we still need a CF?

tbh i think Jazz proved he is not only an ok center fielder, but can be a great one. he continues to improve at center fielder. maybe the injury curse turns around. he's had some freak accidents (the foot, shouldnt happen again) and some other wear and tear injuries (back and oblique and hamstring issues). but i think obviously a 4rth outfielder who can play great at CF is necessary, someone like Hampson or Davis both who are gone now. but no i dont think we need a center fielder i know Jazz is our guy and he's improving still at CF, i think he can be an allstar there and even be a gold glove caliber player there. if u remember toward the end of the year he was making amazing plays routinely.

  • Author
15 hours ago, Michael said:

Anyways, it's November and Bendix has been here less than a month, so let's actually wait and see what he does.

If I can make a time travel for ten minutes once a year, I would travel through time to the opening day to know all the moves that made in the off-season so I don't need to waste lots of time to check it daily. 

1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

If I can make a time travel for ten minutes once a year, I would travel through time to the opening day to know all the moves that made in the off-season so I don't need to waste lots of time to check it daily. 

That's fair. While you're there, though, check some stock prices.

  • Author
4 hours ago, Michael said:

That's fair. While you're there, though, check some stock prices.

It's for only ten minutes so I don't think I can do that. 

Edited by TaiwanMarlins

1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

It's for only ten minutes so I don't think I can do that. 

You can screenshot the roster page and also like the price of 25 stocks in 10 minutes and bring the info back.

  • Author
23 minutes ago, Michael said:

You can screenshot the roster page and also like the price of 25 stocks in 10 minutes and bring the info back.

And use the money that earned from the stocks to sign Ohtani. 

1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

And use the money that earned from the stocks to sign Ohtani. 

Yes, just send it to me and I'll make sure that gets done.

On 11/23/2023 at 11:44 AM, TaiwanMarlins said:

If I can make a time travel for ten minutes once a year, I would travel through time to the opening day to know all the moves that made in the off-season so I don't need to waste lots of time to check it daily. 

This kills the roller-coaster of the offseason. I wouldn't do this if I had the chance. 

1 hour ago, SilverBullet said:

This kills the roller-coaster of the offseason. I wouldn't do this if I had the chance. 

Do the stocks thing I said then.

  • Author
2 hours ago, SilverBullet said:

This kills the roller-coaster of the offseason. I wouldn't do this if I had the chance. 

You should know the "roller-coaster " stuff is just bad to the health. 

  • Author

"Marlins: Miami is among the best fits for Jimenez, as evidenced by their interest in his services at this year’s trade deadline. With righty slugger Jorge Soler having departed the club in favor of free agency, the addition of Jimenez would fill the void left by Soler at a price point not far above the $12MM AAV Soler would’ve been on the books for in 2024 had he not opted out of his deal. In exchange, the Sox could look to add one of Miami’s many young infielders without a clear path to playing time such as Jacob Amaya, Jordan Groshans, or Xavier Edwards."

Edited by TaiwanMarlins

6 hours ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

"Marlins: Miami is among the best fits for Jimenez, as evidenced by their interest in his services at this year’s trade deadline. With righty slugger Jorge Soler having departed the club in favor of free agency, the addition of Jimenez would fill the void left by Soler at a price point not far above the $12MM AAV Soler would’ve been on the books for in 2024 had he not opted out of his deal. In exchange, the Sox could look to add one of Miami’s many young infielders without a clear path to playing time such as Jacob Amaya, Jordan Groshans, or Xavier Edwards."

Sign me up for Eloy. The guy resurrected, anything is possible after that.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.