Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2023/24 Off-Season

Featured Replies

  • Author
18 minutes ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

What's everyones thoughts on DLC and Sanchez? Do you think they will be part of the future? 

Need to improve our outfield, it's no doubt. 

1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

 

I like how a 1.40 whip is "good" for minor league numbers lol

Just filler.

4 minutes ago, Sherman shill said:

I like how a 1.40 whip is "good" for minor league numbers lol

Just filler.

Supposedly a very high BABIP.

But yes, filler for now.

15 hours ago, UpperDeckFishTank said:

What's everyones thoughts on DLC and Sanchez? Do you think they will be part of the future? 

They are cheap, so probably.  I don't think they should be, however.

  • Author
12 hours ago, Sherman shill said:

I like how a 1.40 whip is "good" for minor league numbers lol

Just filler.

Bruce : Hey !!! it's MONEY BALL !!!!!

On 11/22/2023 at 11:18 PM, UpperDeckFishTank said:

we never heard what she said other than the reporter who mentioned Bruce hiring a new superior (Bendix) she would have and so she declined. connecting the dots you can tell she wouldn't accept the demotion and wanted a promotion. she didn't want someone above her other than bruce telling her yes and no on her moves. i dont think we will ever hear from her again, it was clearly taken as a disrespect and she wanted to move on.

 

Yes she did Sandy, and Im pretty sure as well had negotiations with Soler towards the end of this year that didn't pan out. At least there was talks tho but Soler probably earned himself a contract bruce was never going to pay.

She had plenty of time to offer extensions to a few players if she wanted.

 

On 11/24/2023 at 10:51 PM, TaiwanMarlins said:

You should know the "roller-coaster " stuff is just bad to the health. 

If you just relax and let it play out, it really doesn't affect your health....there's no need to freak out daily when something doesn't get done.

 

On 11/26/2023 at 5:45 AM, UpperDeckFishTank said:

What's everyones thoughts on DLC and Sanchez? Do you think they will be part of the future? 

Long term, no.  Unless we get other upgrades this offseason, they'll likely be here this year.

Edited by rmc523

On 11/22/2023 at 7:29 PM, UpperDeckFishTank said:

I support Bendix but the idea that Kim Ng was all of a sudden a bad GM because she focused on acquiring talent to improve the team and not on 'sustainable' is what gets me, every other GM we ever on this franchise had always traded our stars for prospects. Ng was the 1st GM we ever had that actually showed she would care more about winning than making the owner richer.

When was the last time we traded a decent player for another decent player to improve the team what it needed? Ng did that trading Lopez for Arraez. Bendix or any other GM we ever had would have traded Lopez for a bunch of worthless overrated prospects who never pan out. Ng traded some shitty prospects for quality MLB players, just the Jake Burger deal alone was worthy of praise. Bendix or any other GM we ever had would have never made those deals.

Ng was always focused on making the team better and it might move the Marlins from 30th payroll to 29th and that was unacceptable to Bruce, and so that's why I call the sudden turn on Kim Ng and the sudden unconditional love for Bendix shilling. Because it sounds like it, you have a GM who is willing to win and then people point out the flaws, but other GMs dont even want to be in the game, they are just there to make the owner money, and supporting that can be for no other reason than shilling.

The Avi deal was a miss but I would at least like to hear the reasons that deal happened, we never heard them. The Cueto deal made sense at the time, as well as the Robertson deal. You swing and you miss sometimes. Our other GMs and Bendix will never swing tho, they will just sit in the batting box hoping to take a walk so they can never get blamed for making a mistake.  That's what I like about Kim and what (SO FAR, i get it more 'time is needed') i don't like about Bendix or any other GM so far.

I guarantee you by now if Kim was here a Arraez and Luzardo extension would have been done. Nobody ever wants to talk about the Luzardo deal as well that she made trading half a meaningless season of Marte for him, that's the deal Bendix would dream of but he will never have made.

I know you're relatively new here, but most of us have been saying for years that she isn't the best GM - and most of us gave her time (a year or 2) to acclimate (see all the clock starting jokes).....but she continually made the same mistakes as year 1 in year 2 and worse, year 3 that actively hurt the team - namely in-season roster moves/lack thereof, and drafting has been terrible, and FA signings (some of the earlier ones may be attributed to Jeter).  So, it wasn't a "sudden turn" - we've all said the same things for years.  The sustainable component is in regard to bad drafting and filling the void at the bottom end by the trades for the ML players.  Just trading for ML players that decimates the farm without replacements isn't good either.

I'm not sure how Bruce wanting to improve an area of weakness of Kim's is somehow a bad thing??  Did he handle it the best way by wanting to put someone above her?  Probably not, but at the end of the day, he is trying to improve the team rather than standing pat and hoping things improve.

We also have given her credit where credit is due - Sandy extension, trades that worked out (Marte, Arraez, Burger, Bell, etc), so to act like we've only said she's flat out terrible is incorrect.

Also, the team has been terrible for what?  15 years.....we've literally not been in a position to buy at the deadline (absent stupid attempts under Loria).....acting like Kim is the only one to have balls to do competitive trades when the team's other GMs haven't been in positions to do such trades?  Railing on phantom GM not in Kim's position saying they wouldn't do what Kim did is funny.

I don't fault her for the Cueto signing (though in Marlins fashion, it did have collapse written on it given his age and good year last year), nor the Robertson trade - that was another (like Stallings) that was good on paper.

"Unconditional love" is an extremely strong tone.  I'd term it as hopeful optimism, given the success of the Rays organization, and hopefulness that that consistent success can carry over here.

The Rays trade players all the time (both in the buy and sell direction), so not sure where you're coming from with this Bendix or other GMs would never have done some of these trades?

Also, complaining about Bendix not making big trades yet?  The guy has been on the job 2 weeks.  He has to evaluate what's here and what to do.  STL is really the only team to have made multiple moves so far, and even those have been meh moves.

Kim had plenty of time to offer extensions for those players if she wanted to - if anything, she was notorious for taking way too long to "evaluate" - we've been arguing for extensions for Arraez/Luzardo for some time, and there's been zero reports of extension talks.

4 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

We also have given her credit where credit is due - Sandy extension

I think Jeter was still calling all the shots at this time, so it may not have been her.

It did occur during her tenure, though, so I'm willing to give her credit for it.

 

4 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

Kim had plenty of time to offer extensions for those players if she wanted to - if anything, she was notorious for taking way too long to "evaluate" - we've been arguing for extensions for Arraez/Luzardo for some time, and there's been zero reports of extension talks.

I find it hilarious that this poster says both of them would have been extended already if Kim was still here when, as you state, there hasn't been a peep about it. She had Luzardo for 2.5 years and Arraez for a full season, never started extension talks.

13 minutes ago, Michael said:

I think Jeter was still calling all the shots at this time, so it may not have been her.

It did occur during her tenure, though, so I'm willing to give her credit for it.

 

I find it hilarious that this poster says both of them would have been extended already if Kim was still here when, as you state, there hasn't been a peep about it. She had Luzardo for 2.5 years and Arraez for a full season, never started extension talks.

Yup, it's hard to give full credit or blame for moves made while Jeter was here - the Marte/Luzardo trade could've been Jeter or Kim.  Same on the signings and other trades.

 

Right?  Can't have it both ways.  As I stated, we often discussed how long she would take to "evaluate" the market either for signings or trades.

15 minutes ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

 

Wonder what the trade could be. I assume trading another pitcher, maybe Cabrera for another position player. I know Skip doesn't have Cabrera as high as other teams cuz of the walks, even sending him down to the minors. Tho Scott had the same problem till this past year, thankfully Skip never lived thru a Scott walking meltdown.  Everyone knows Cabrera has great potential, with more control he can be unstoppable. If Tanner Scott can do it, why not Cabrera?

8 hours ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

 

That's just Mish getting the feeling a trade is more likely than big spending, not news. And I'm the Mish shill here! Gotta learn to read whats news and whats speculation and hunches. 

19 minutes ago, Das Texan said:

I like how Mish doesnt even know if he is going to the Winter Meetings as well as if they arent next week and every serious beat writer will be there.

Wait....oh ya. 

This is a good post.

  • Author

It seems I would never feel satisfied with Marlins off-season moves (because they never spend big ) but it also seems I would be a Marlins fan forever (because I just can't rooting for other teams genuinely).

1 minute ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

It seems I would never feel satisfied with Marlins off-season moves (because they never spend big ) but it also seems I would be a Marlins fan forever (because I just can't rooting for other teams genuinely).

You could try!

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.