Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
5/16 Postgame
What was great about last night was we won, and we got to watch JP put on a show, both in the outfield and offensively. Brings back fond memories, was a good object lesson for EB and we still walked out happy.
-
What Happened To Alfredo?
Yes he did.
-
Is It Time To Start Thinking Of Firing Fredi Gonzalez
...I love that he demoted Carroll as well who got maybe 1 game start if any As Rabb said above the front office makes that call, but yes Fredi did bend a little and gave Carroll a start before his exile. I wonder if that came from above as well because when you go thirty+ games without giving a player a start it should be obvious Fredi would have gone 130 if he had his druthers.
-
General Cameron Maybin Discussion
lol...truly funny.
-
"Kid" who caught Chris' first career HR
I suspect what is at work here is another unwritten "rule" of baseball that teams, after years of going through this, probably have established some broad guidelines as to what is fair compensation in these situations. Otherwise, just like free agency or a wildly extravagant '90s George Steinbrenner player offer, once team X starts giving in to these demands, gives up two bats and a ball and tickets etc. that becomes the norm everywhere - until the next guy demands and gets MORE. It becomes a vicious cycle. The fallacy in these "negotiations" (because they aren't really negotiations, this is a courtesy) is that Happy thought he was in charge because he had possession of the baseball and therefore could set whatever terms "he" thought were "fair". He wasn't. MLB/Brewers ultimately were as they control stadium access and for whatever reason they chose to employ (he bumped an usher, he was behaving in a dangerous or boisterous manner, you name it) could simply ban him from all future games. In negotiating parlance they had their finger on the trigger on their side of the table. Ultimately, if this piece of theater were to play itself out to it's conclusion, Happy would be left with two choices, keep the ball and banishment or behave in an acceptable manner and be rewarded with some "fair and reasonable" compensation. Luckily for all concerned it didn't have to go there. This kind of stuff happens all the time and while it does look that Coghlan could have behaved more appropriately, no one is perfect, his motivation became deeply personal and emotionally charged in his desire to reward his mother with this trophy, he should be forgiven for a moment of perhaps bad taste *(photo and comments)*. For Happy, perhaps his lesson will never be learned as witnessed by his blog post, he still doesn't seem to comprehend what actually transpired.
-
General Cameron Maybin Discussion
It's just amazing the impunity with which people make stuff up and pass it off as fact or truth.
-
The Marlins need an outfielder
I have to say I'm not a big Adam Dunn fan and when his name was thrown around this winter/spring I wasn't particularly interested, not at all, but I have to say, weak defense or no, those numbers he's putting up in Washington are exactly what the Marlins have needed the last two dozen games this season. It's hard to ignore a .310/.444/.638/1.082 line and what it would mean to our team. Woulda, coulda, shoulda...what can you do? $20 million for two years, having to be frugal to play to their constituency (City of Miami & MDC, and now the bond community), it's understandable why he's there not here, or someone like him, but I really hope the real Cody Ross rises from the dead and catches fire, because we need more than we're getting from our regular corner outfielders.
-
General Cameron Maybin Discussion
Hopefully they'll cure him of CRD (Cody Ross Disease, humongously long swing) so when he comes back he has the bat control and pitch recognition he needs to stay in the bigs for fifteen years. I honestly could care less (within reasonable bounds) what his numbers look like in the minors as long as he's working on the right things and getting the right mentoring.
-
Sheffield's ESPN report
Didn't Sheffield just recently say that if he's elected to Cooperstown he's going in as a Marlin?
- Hanley leading off
-
Henry Owens
Jim Fleming spoke well of him not too long ago. I suspect all is forgiven. ''He looked good in spring,'' Marlins executive Jim Fleming said. ''He should be a factor'' this summer.
-
Proctor to undergo Tommy John surgery
I can't speak to Hanley and his LT contract but otherwise the Marlins do not buy insurance to cover player contracts and certainly not in the case of someone like Scott Proctor, no team would. What's the exposure, one year $750k? Not practical unless you want to commit $1.3 million to him instead of 750. Baseball disability insurance usually covers two-three years max of a player's contract and only a set %, the higher the % the higher the cost. No one insures a player for one year, especially a guy coming off injury. The Marlins have talked about it a number of times publicly and if you think about it, it makes sense. The next time Samson or Beinfest or Hill are on the radio, and they are on weekly, call in and ask. The Marlins are, for all intents and purposes devoid of contracts they would seek protection from. This is not like key man insurance, you are hedging not having to pay off a portion of an extended contract obligation.
-
Henry Owens
Owens is pitching in extended spring training right now and may do so for 34 games. The final 16 games of his suspension will be at whatever minor league level the Marlins assign him to.
-
It may be time to look into getting another Starting Pitcher
If you like Cliff Lee he and his contract are tailor-made for the playoff or bust 2009 Marlins with (moreorless) $5 million left on this season's contract and a $1 million buyout next.
-
Coghlan
Morrison is injured. I was wondering when someone would realize this. Maybe wrong, but I think the vagueness is because more moves are ahead.
-
Coghlan
Well, that's part of the puzzle solved.
-
5/7 Post Game
I know what the feedback is going to be on this and I'm going to get a ration of sh*t for it and be accused of hating on the guy but I wouldn't be surprised if a) Maybin does go down, b) Hermida is traded to a team who needs a high OBP guy for a starting pitcher, Bonifacio moves to the outfield and Coghlan comes up and plays third base. Before someone says EB can't play the outfield he's been doing it for three years in the DWL. He's probably got 1000+ innings under his belt. Why is Maybin going down? Who are we replacing him with? This only makes the team worse. I mean, I don't see a team giving us a stud pitcher for Hermida, right now. Who are possible candidates you're thinking of? Erick, think in big terms...I'm not saying to do it...I'm just crystal-balling...it's just a thought. No more, no less.
-
5/7 Post Game
I know what the feedback is going to be on this and I'm going to get a ration of sh*t for it and be accused of hating on the guy but I wouldn't be surprised if a) Maybin does go down, b) Hermida is traded to a team who needs a high OBP guy for a starting pitcher, Bonifacio moves to the outfield and Coghlan comes up and plays third base. Before someone says EB can't play the outfield he's been doing it for three years in the DWL. He's probably got 1000+ innings under his belt.
-
Coghlan
why do people always suggesting calling people up and puttign them in a different postion? people have said call up morrison and put him in the outfield when hes a first baseman and now people are saying call up chris when the marlins are commited to having him play second. why do people always do this. I don't know that the Marlins "are" committed to playing him at second so much as they "were". This season he's playing a lot of third base (and much better than the last couple of times he was tried there) and with Gaby out he's going to see even more playing time there until he ultimately gets a call. His big problem at 2nd was around the bag and if moving to third diminishes that as an issue all the better. As for Morrison and other players being mentioned as "out of position" in theoretical callups, usually those ideas came from outside this messageboard either by Marlins decision-makers (FO, etc.) or beat reporters who one would think got the idea from speaking to someone with the club or a scout or talent evaluator. I've mentioned Morrison for example as a outfielder, but only because it appeared in print beforehand from a credible source. edit: let me correct myself...just for the heck of it I went back and checked where CC has played the last week and it's back at 2nd base, so maybe the 3rd base experiment is over or they figured out what they needed to know.
-
Amezaga
PWG, this is I think perhaps your best post I've ever read. I can live without some of the tone and absolutism but nonetheless this is a great post. The only thing that I feel you might rethink is the line, "...And still, you can go back to that 200 runs recorded stat, and... it's still ultimately meaningless..." I would suggest that if ballplayers themselves and those in the game (GMs, scouts, managers and coaches etc.) have used this simple standard - actually it's 100/100 but that is irrelevant - (and I'm not applying it to Hermida or anyone else) for as long as I can remember, and probably before, regardless of what empirical evidence you can accumulate all of which is valid, can't there be room in how you view the game to accept that it is a standard within the game (among those in the game, Uggla as a case in point) and will be for years to come? Your well thought out points and this simple standard do not have to be mutually exclusive. Understand, like we all do, the game has its own shorthand and this is one of them. It isn't meant to invalidate anything else. These things can live in peaceful harmony. It's like the 200 hit threshold. It's meaningless too considering all the variables that can affect it, but it's used everyday... Great post though, nice job.
-
Miller placed on 15 day DL
Good attitude. Change is never easy and changing something he's probably been doing since high school in order to get his career on track, regardless of the setbacks, is laudable.
-
Amezaga
For you, he'd have to have a year up there with NL MVP Albert Pujols, who only had 216 Runs+RBI. That makes it sound like a combined two hundred runs/RBIs is almost a mythical number which it isn't. I stopped counting in the high teens (phone call, lost count) the number of players. Some interesting names on the list. Going through it the Mets (boo) have so many players on that list you almost can't imagine them not winning the division by twenty games...shows to go ya...but it is an interesting list nonetheless. Here's the link, it's on RBI now, click on "runs" and you can see the guys who did from the other side, more runs than RBIs. http://mlb.mlb.com/stats/historical/player...;sortByStat=RBI As for it being a necessary benchmark for Hermida to achieve, I think it's pretty lofty and if I say unattainable someone will take it as bashing him which isn't my intention. I think Rabb is more right than Bob on this one, he doesn't need to get there (or "very close") to prove his worth to the club but if you take Bob's point more broadly Hermida this season is going to be valued (for 2010) by his bat with greater scrutiny than past years, if for no other reason than for arbitration decision-making purposes.
-
Amezaga
Just a few clarifications. I was speaking of at least 2010, not 2009. I only mentioned Coghlan as an outfielder because at some point this off-season, I believe a Marlins executive (it's posted here somewhere) or a beat reporter who spoke with someone in the organization, or whatever it was, suggested it was a possibility because his bat speaks for him and his defense was considered somewhat problematic (and no that doesn't mean I'm calling him a crappy infielder or denigrating him, he's better with the bat than the glove). And even opining if A happened than one of the consequences could be B. And if it happens in 2010 or 11 or 12 is for me irrelevant. As for walks vs hits it really is a matter of what the expectation is of the player determined by his place in the lineup. Perhaps an argument is being made Hermida should lead off or hit higher in order because he gets on base so frequently. It is a legitimate consideration. But if he's going to hit in a spot where players who are expected to drive in runs occupy, and he is merely getting on base with a walk, while that represents one more potential run to be scored by the next guy, it's not the same.
-
Taylor, Badenhop and Penn???
Taylor, while not lights out yesterday, pitched a lot better than in his first start. He may never be an ace, but considering he would be pitching out of the 5 spot, he is servicable. And may continue to improve. I am more concerned about Miller than any other pitcher on the staff, starter or relief. And temporarily at that. I'm not sure what the expectations are here for a fill-in fifth starter but I'll take two or three more starts like yesterday from the guy and not complain at all. As for Miller, I really wish we had some honest background or insight into what is happening with him physically and mentally. I keep hoping it's just time with him, he'll mature into someone ala Randy Johnson (that does not mean he'll be Randy Johnson), tall, intimidating and focused - the one thing he doesn't seem to possess right now - and just for me I'm willing to give him this season and maybe next before rethinking my aspirations for him.
-
Amezaga
As Tommy pointed out yesterday the complaint regarding Hermida is not that he isn't getting on base, but really how he is and the lack of production he brings to the team. Walks are great but in his mind JH should be driving in more runs, that's what he's paid to do. I think to some extent it's a valid complaint and its impossible to ignore the batting slump he's going through, having gone hitless five of his last seven games, his average falling nearly 50 points in the interim. But everyone goes through dry spells so I guess all we can do is hope he starts showing some of that aggressiveness at the plate we saw earlier in the season. Hanley's coming back, Maybin and Bonifacio are showing improvement, if Cody and Hermida can start hitting with some frequency, and Uggla who seems to hit the ball right at someone so many times, we can have as good a May as we did April. I do think the only current outfielder we'll see in 2010 is Maybin and it's only a matter of time before Hanley joins him. Cody and Hermida are expendable if that happens (assuming either Stanton or Morrison, or even Coghlan steps up this summer). Both players though hold their destinies in their hands, they both can play themselves onto or off the team by the trade deadline.