Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. oh please... You said you didn't understand the logic, I explained the logic, just because didn't like it doesn't mean it's not true I can think of literally dozens of "ifs"...your logic is "your" logic. Just because you think it's logical, and you're entitled to your opinion, makes it neither definitive or correct. The undeniable truth IS... Cantu doesn't make his error Helms doesn't make THAT error... that's the issue... Enjoy yourself and your fantasies...enough already. There are no undeniable truths except maybe the one on the scorer's card. You want to argue with someone, get to DS early tomorrow, look him up and I'm sure he'll give your point of view all the consideration it deserves.
  2. oh please... You said you didn't understand the logic, I explained the logic, just because didn't like it doesn't mean it's not true I can think of literally dozens of "ifs"...your logic is "your" logic. Just because you think it's logical, and you're entitled to your opinion, makes it neither definitive or correct.
  3. ...Can't wait to see him his next start. Niether can the rest of the National league now that they have some tape on him. Just bringing what he did today isn't going to be enough to survive. He needs to incrementally step up his performance or be gone. That said, all things considered he did very well.
  4. I'm not sure that I understand the logic that all four unearned runs were Cantu's fault when with two outs his error allowed ONE run to score but it was Helms subsequent error that allowed the next THREE in. Most of course loathe Cantu here and put Helms on a pedestal so the former takes the fall while the latter gets a free pass. Does Helms have a chance to make his error if Cantu makes his routine play? It's irrelevant. Helms made an error. Cost the team three unearned runs. You can play "what-if" all you want. The scorecard reflects a three run error on Helms' part.
  5. I'm not sure that I understand the logic that all four unearned runs were Cantu's fault when with two outs his error allowed ONE run to score but it was Helms subsequent error that allowed the next THREE in. Most of course loathe Cantu here and put Helms on a pedestal so the former takes the fall while the latter gets a free pass.
  6. Just stating a fact. I noted the history of the problem (3yrs on and off the DL) and the reality of the situation (back problems don't get better by themselves, there is no "cure"). If anyone thinks that's criticism they need a dictionary.
  7. ...theoretically Willingham could play catcher again... There is no theory, fantasy or LSD trip that would ever have Josh Willingham on the field as a catcher again. Three consecutive seasons with back problems (which don't get "better" they are just better "managed") should tell you that was a failed attempt at a position change.
  8. The first picture appears to be people in black shirts and white pants. The second is white shirts and black or dark shorts.
  9. Some interesting lines in last night's 'Topes game. Wolf is back. Williams still doing well. McPherson had three walks and a stolen base. De la Cruz one earned run over five. In fact Wolf, Williams and Villafuerte all with scoreless appearances.
  10. Isn't one of them represented by Scott Boras ?
  11. I dont get why more sport athletes wont date celebs or wealthy females.90% of the time it's some gold digger wife or baby mamma.These woman sure know what they are doing. Boy, you're all class. How about a "congratulations?" :thumbup
  12. They'll probably be at least one other roster spot opening up very soon so don't worry you'll probably see McPherson sooner rather than later. As for Hoover in the last two years in the Marlins organization I don't see where he's embarrassed himself, has played well when called upon, defensively and offensively. I don't think it's by accident that the Marlins protect a 32 year catcher on the 40 man roster other than they think he's worth holding onto. If the knock is his age, there's five or so guys his age or older already on the team including Matt Treanor. The guy is up for a reason, he knows what to do in game situations, he's capable of putting the bat on the ball (he's righty) and I suspect the other night when Fredi had to go to Rabelo after pinch-running for Treanor he was uncomfortable being in that position, being out of catchers, unless you want Fredo or Mike Jacobs is going back there. He's a guy with a good glove who can be there if needed. This is born out of having a catching tandem of course, instead of a solo starting catcher and backup. But we have spare outfielders, spare infielders, it might not be the worst idea in the world to carry a third catcher who can come off the bench as a pinch-hitter as your fourth or fifth infielders and outfielders are expected to do. I'm in favor of at least giving McPherson a look see sooner rather than later but this might not be the right time for any number of reasons, from health to Dean Treanor to something completely off the radar. I don't pretend to know. As a fan I'm of course I want to see him reaching his potential at the MLB level but the front office and the manager aren't pr*cks just tryin' to hold the man down, they've concluded this isn't his time.
  13. I didn't expect it either but if we were bringing up a third catcher Hoover may prove to be the right decision.
  14. Cantu, who is never going to be confused with Brooks Robinson at third, has nonetheless let his bat do his talking since moving to third spot in the lineup and doing what contact hitters do, making contact and driving in runs - twelve rbi in the last 12 games and the last five games driving in a run in each. If he stays with the team in 2009, which is the Marlins option, building up arm strength and spending the off-season taking hundreds of balls a day at third could result in very cost-effective, productive and defensively capable third baseman who can play the position until some phenom pushes him aside. He may continue to thrive in the three spot or tail off, I don't pretend to know, but does seem a) more confident at the plate hitting third, and b) appears to have a knowledge of the game to where he can make adjustments at the plate to drive a ball to right or hit a sacrifice fly when called upon to do so. (And how many times on this board over the years have we bemoaned the inability of the Fish to deliver a sac fly when needed? Plenty.) He's no one's first choice or maybe for some even their second, I'm convinced he's capable of playing the position in a way that net benefits the Marlins for the rest of this season and perhaps next. I waffle on bringing up McPherson if he isn't going to play every day, but I would like to see him perhaps called up to play back end of the interleague part of the schedule (I really think you want to play Cantu against the Rays) if for no other reason than to showcase him with July not that far off. +Edit: Since no one has commented on the above let me add if McPherson were to find his swing in MLs during some showcasing you look at a team like the Royals who (I believe) has hit less homeruns than any team in baseball, 30 to date and zero homeruns from their shortstop combo this season. So I wonder, using them as an example, if he proved capable and they acquired McPherson, could they move Gordon to shortstop to increase their homerun and scoring, an area where they are sadly lacking? Just a thought.
  15. This is not about Badenhop per se, but I have been wondering for weeks if the organization made the right personnel move in hiring Mark Wiley for a second go-around with the Fish? I see pitchers collectively and individually making the same mistakes over and over. Yes I understand the coach is not out throwing the ball but I ask whatever happened to their early 2008 mantra about first pitch strikes? Why do so many have so much trouble getting that third out after getting two with ease? Guys with sinker balls and other breaking pitches should be pitching to contact much more than they are. That phrase "pitching to contact" is not some new term, it has been part of the game's lexicon for at least one decade and maybe two. And of course there's the walks issue. I do wonder. I wonder whether like in 2003 when we jettisoned one manager for acquire another, it might be time for a change? Wiley has had his share of successes this season but I would question if overall the FO, with two months under their collective belts maybe think they should have looked harder at an open field of candidates rather than handing the guy for all intents and purposes the job in mid-2007. The fly in the ointment, real or imagined, is that pitchers especially, have a unique relationship with their coach and any re-evaluation that may lead to changing horses will probably have to wait until the off-season. But so far I would give Wiley a C- for his inability to train his staff to do the three things he himself said were important as the season began.
  16. Boy I have to disagree with the notion that Rabelo 2008 is worse defensively than Olivo 2007. I don't know that it's possible. Rabelo was the goat last night, to be sure. At the end of the game there was a shot of the dugout with him sitting there alone. You could almost see him revisiting the consequences of his play just moments before. But let's not forget there were men on base in the first place that were not of his doing. In the end a number of people hopefully learned or took something away from last night and Rabelo is right near the top of that list.
  17. The payroll numbers and length of commitment seem an immediate deal-killer but beyond that let's see if we can get Jacque Jones hitting first before we think about any other outside the organization reclamation projects.
  18. The thing that absolutely baffles me is that Gregg's vision is so screwed up that he can't see the catcher's regular signals, who now have to give hand signals on their chest to call a pitch and he's still being counted on in the same role. This does not seem to me to be what you're looking for in the ninth inning trying to close out a game. Maybe just maybe Gregg ought to be coming in the seventh at least until his vision issue is corrected, as the first reliever and use Lindstrom/Pinto/Kensing to setup and let Waechter and Nelson close out games. Just trying to think outside the box.
  19. Thinking in terms of the upcoming interleague schedule, depending on what the FO sees as the respective futures for Cantu and McPherson (who by now they must have reams of scouting reports on), to showcase both by finding playing time for the pair between 3B and DH - as GMs throughout baseball start talking about potential matchups as next month approaches - wouldn't be the worst thing to do. I would think as tradebait Cantu and McPherson have more value than a John Gall so spotlighting the pair, especially McPherson, who really is an unknown quantity right now at the MLB level potentially increases interest and his trade value which is a good thing. Of course he has to deliver.
  20. After being humiliated on national television the night before at Fenway 25-8, Mike Lowell's late inning homerun that turned around the next night's game 10-9 has to be part of 2003 season lore. Ultimately we lost the series 1-2 but the come from behind win on Saturday was a steppingstone in their 2003 run.
  21. I mean, obviously it's an opinion, but I don't buy into all of the warm fuzzies that he is extolling as to why Harvey is The Greatest Pitcher in Marlins History. He had a nice season as a reliever on a bad team. First of all the title of the thread is "Best Marlins Pitcher of All Time", not as you've tried to redefine it as "The Greatest Pitcher in Marlins History". And here's what I posted " Until I see a pitcher have a greater impact on a season for me it will always be Bryan Harvey." It took until 2004, a team populated with players like Lowell, Cabrera, Burnett, Beckett, Penny, Castillo and all the holdovers from 2003 for Armando Bentitez to best Harvey's saves record. Eleven years. Armando secured 56% of the team's victories that season. In 1993 Harvey, carrying a 1.70 ERA and striking out 73 over 69 innings of work with only 13 walks, secured 72% of the team's wins. You know how many other games were saved by Marlins pitchers in 1993? Three. Let me repeat that, three. That is what I call an impact player and that is why I believe he was one of the "Best Marlins Pitcher(s) of All Time". I personally don't think it's possible to pick one not just because in so many cases the situations were different, but the word "best" is not one you'll ever get a consensus meaning on. It's hard to for example ignore Beckett's fall 2003 performance. To me he deserves a "Best" as well. And there have been others. Part of being "best" at least for me, is being there and delivering when your team needed you to. And that's something Harvey and Beckett share in common. I will say, no other Marlins pitcher under consideration ever had to pitch with the ineptitude that surrounded him when he went out there to as I said, carry this team on his back, because without him without a doubt this team could have lost 120+ games. GarbageMan recounts, even at ten years old he understood the impact of Bryan Harvey on this team and for the fans in South Florida. But beyond the numbers stats can't quantify how good he was that season just as a pitcher. Tremendous fastball, a virtually unhittable breaking ball, he was as good as it gets in 1993 embarrassing and gaining the respect of some of the greatest hitters in the game. Let me leave you with what former Braves pitching coach Leo Mazzone had to say on the subject. "When he came in, that son-of-a-bitchin' game was over."
  22. It wouldn't surprise me to see de la Cruz back.
  23. Awful pitch. exactly. you pray for that pitch.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.