December 10, 200718 yr You guys are getting all worked up and I love the way the newbs just follow and get influenced by just a couple of voices on this board because of post #. It's hilarious actually. maybe you dont realize it because you fail to accept logic in your life or was born without the ability to think rationally but the majority of the people posting against you have the same ideas about maybin because at this moment in time they are what would be best for the team and most of us despite getting screwed by the club over and over again still want what is best for the team
December 10, 200718 yr Another thing, you fail to answer my question that I ask you for the 4th time: Do we have any better option right now than to play Maybin? He is pretty much ready (just about), and we pretty much don't have a choice. You're putting wayyyyyyy too much emphasis on a rookie player and arbitration. Way too much emphasis on that. You're thinking 3 years from now. This club doesn't think like that. We think year to year dude. If we CAN help it, like in Miguel's case where we waited a little and we could afford to do that (that was a veteran team), then you hold out a few weeks to gain an extra year in arbitration. That's the only time you hold a rookie back.. But yea, go ahead, just ramble for the 3rd time about putting Maybin in AAA/AA again without addressing anything I just said and bore us all. It is foolish to believe that any club, even the Marlins, does not think longterm. With Maybin and the season the Marlins are likely to have, I have no problem letting him percolate in the minor league for a few months to make sure he is ready for the show. From all reports I've read, he was overmatched after the Tigers called him up late last season. So you're saying Maybin should start in the Minors? I can almost guarantee he doesn't. So you think Maybin is our best option to start in CF, we pretty much don't have a choice but use him and he will start next season with the Marlins... and now you are falling back on some line about him getting 200 at bats? You've been writing about fans in this thread being "outta control" and unclear but you seem to be the only one who keeps on moving the goalposts and unsure about where they stand. What exactly do you think Maybin's role will be come Opening Day 2008, since you think he'll be on 25-man roster then, and throughout the season? 200 minimum. Meaning he will be up inevitably. I love how you guys think that is what my sole argument was all about. Retarded man. This one does get worked up very easily, doesn't he? Read what you wrote above. First you were all about him starting the season with the Marlins and being their only option. Now you are basically taking MarlinsLou's position. Funny, that.
December 10, 200718 yr You guys don't understand what the minimum is huh? Like I said earlier, my argument was that he will be up for a chunk of this season one way or another. Interpret "CHUNK" or "SIGNIFICANT" however you want. El Penguino, MarlinsLou mentioned they want Maybin in the Minors all season. Thats fine. They interpreted this as what they would do, not what's going to happen. I mentioned what's going to happen. You guys are getting all worked up and I love the way the newbs just follow and get influenced by just a couple of voices on this board because of post #. It's hilarious actually. This is wrong. Like multiple have said. Zero reading comprehension. Or maybe it's intuition. Or common sense. You can interpret that however you want. The point is service time. The Marlins need to keep Maybin in the minors so they don't start his service clock to the point of starting his arbitration a year sooner and losing his club controlled rights. EDIT: Since you don't get it I realize I did not clarify this well enough. Maybin can play June-September in the major leagues and this would not set off his arbitration clock. Playing him from day 1 or May would. This is the huge difference.
December 10, 200718 yr You guys don't understand what the minimum is huh? Like I said earlier, my argument was that he will be up for a chunk of this season one way or another. Interpret "CHUNK" or "SIGNIFICANT" however you want. El Penguino, MarlinsLou mentioned they want Maybin in the Minors all season. Thats fine. They interpreted this as what they would do, not what's going to happen. I mentioned what's going to happen. You guys are getting all worked up and I love the way the newbs just follow and get influenced by just a couple of voices on this board because of post #. It's hilarious actually. This is wrong. Like multiple have said. Zero reading comprehension. Or maybe it's intuition. Or common sense. You can interpret that however you want. The point is service time. The Marlins need to keep Maybin in the minors so they don't start his service clock to the point of starting his arbitration a year sooner and losing his club controlled rights. basically we want a cabrera situation rather than a willis. we do not want maybin's service clock to start this year and we do not want him in the super-2 category for arbitration reasons. we want to maximize the time maybin is with the marlins on competitive teams
December 10, 200718 yr You guys don't understand what the minimum is huh? Like I said earlier, my argument was that he will be up for a chunk of this season one way or another. Interpret "CHUNK" or "SIGNIFICANT" however you want. El Penguino, MarlinsLou mentioned they want Maybin in the Minors all season. Thats fine. They interpreted this as what they would do, not what's going to happen. I mentioned what's going to happen. You guys are getting all worked up and I love the way the newbs just follow and get influenced by just a couple of voices on this board because of post #. It's hilarious actually. This is wrong. Like multiple have said. Zero reading comprehension. Or maybe it's intuition. Or common sense. You can interpret that however you want. The point is service time. The Marlins need to keep Maybin in the minors so they don't start his service clock to the point of starting his arbitration a year sooner and losing his club controlled rights. basically we want a cabrera situation rather than a willis. we do not want maybin's service clock to start this year and we do not want him in the super-2 category for arbitration reasons. we want to maximize the time maybin is with the marlins on competitive teams Absolutely. But I don't want to blow that guy's head up by adding a super 2 variable. I'll take a super 2 as long as we have Maybin through 2014 when it comes down to it. It would just be really nice to not even have to deal with it in a non contending year. Which can easily be accomplished by keeping him in the minors for 3 months. We covered that 3 pages ago but I guess it's one of those days.
December 10, 200718 yr Ummmm, havent you guys seen JPierre's member #?!?!? so hes been a member who didnt voice his irrational logic for a few years. your point?
December 10, 200718 yr Ummmm, havent you guys seen JPierre's member #?!?!? so hes been a member who didnt voice his irrational logic for a few years. your point? I was being sarcastic.... He has pointed out in multiple threads that he knows more than people assume he does.... because he has one the lowest member #s.
December 10, 200718 yr Ummmm, havent you guys seen JPierre's member #?!?!? so hes been a member who didnt voice his irrational logic for a few years. your point? I was being sarcastic.... He has pointed out in multiple threads that he knows more than people assume he does.... because he has one the lowest member #s. i know i saw a few of those posts but i wanted to comment on it anyway
December 10, 200718 yr this thread is done. somebody close it. You can't just say something retarded and then get all "close the thread" so that noone, er, everyone can't keep calling you on it. Honestly, what is wrong with you?
December 10, 200718 yr this thread is done. somebody close it. Honestly, what is wrong with you? He's new. Give him some time...
December 10, 200718 yr a .255 hitter in AAA. I'm pumped That was 2006 , maybe you missed that. .278 in 2007 and .308 over August and September. He still sucks though... Thank you for your astute evaluation...too bad so many disagree. Best Defensive Player of the Year award from his team, PCL all-star, now the Topps award. But what do they know? Okay, what do you think he will project in the majors with? Give me a BA, and power numbers. I can't wait to laugh. Ready to laugh? I project Andino to be a .290 hitter, with about ten homeruns and about 50 rbi's. YES I AM HIGH ON ANDINO, and EVERYONE HERE WILL SEE WHAT THIS KID CAN DO!
December 10, 200718 yr a .255 hitter in AAA. I'm pumped That was 2006 , maybe you missed that. .278 in 2007 and .308 over August and September. He still sucks though... Thank you for your astute evaluation...too bad so many disagree. Best Defensive Player of the Year award from his team, PCL all-star, now the Topps award. But what do they know? Okay, what do you think he will project in the majors with? Give me a BA, and power numbers. I can't wait to laugh. Ready to laugh? I project Andino to be a .290 hitter, with about ten homeruns and about 50 rbi's. YES I AM HIGH ON ANDINO, and EVERYONE HERE WILL SEE WHAT THIS KID CAN DO! Are you sure you are not just high? :mis2 Andino has built his reputation on his own. He was THE SHORTSTOP and rapidly has become a utility player at best if he works hard enough. He may always have a problem managing to hit his weight let alone being able to hit .290. He still could be valuable but he also has had a decline defensively. His luster is long gone
December 10, 200718 yr this thread is done. somebody close it. You can't just say something retarded and then get all "close the thread" so that noone, er, everyone can't keep calling you on it. Honestly, what is wrong with you? Easy Rabb, he is just a kid
December 10, 200718 yr a .255 hitter in AAA. I'm pumped That was 2006 , maybe you missed that. .278 in 2007 and .308 over August and September. He still sucks though... Thank you for your astute evaluation...too bad so many disagree. Best Defensive Player of the Year award from his team, PCL all-star, now the Topps award. But what do they know? Okay, what do you think he will project in the majors with? Give me a BA, and power numbers. I can't wait to laugh. Ready to laugh? I project Andino to be a .290 hitter, with about ten homeruns and about 50 rbi's. YES I AM HIGH ON ANDINO, and EVERYONE HERE WILL SEE WHAT THIS KID CAN DO! Are you sure you are not just high? :mis2 Andino has built his reputation on his own. He was THE SHORTSTOP and rapidly has become a utility player at best if he works hard enough. He may always have a problem managing to hit his weight let alone being able to hit .290. He still could be valuable but he also has had a decline defensively. His luster is long gone Since he received three awards this season based on his defense I'd say you might be a little behind the curve on your statement. He's also had three consecutive years of improvement offensively, this year being his best, and while its a microscopic sample size, in his 14 13 PAs this Sept @ the MLB level he had five hits for a .385 average, drawing nothing from that except he wasn't wholesale overmatched. And he's a kid, just 23. Hard to believe at that age "his luster is long gone."
December 10, 200718 yr a .255 hitter in AAA. I'm pumped That was 2006 , maybe you missed that. .278 in 2007 and .308 over August and September. He still sucks though... Thank you for your astute evaluation...too bad so many disagree. Best Defensive Player of the Year award from his team, PCL all-star, now the Topps award. But what do they know? Okay, what do you think he will project in the majors with? Give me a BA, and power numbers. I can't wait to laugh. Ready to laugh? I project Andino to be a .290 hitter, with about ten homeruns and about 50 rbi's. YES I AM HIGH ON ANDINO, and EVERYONE HERE WILL SEE WHAT THIS KID CAN DO! Are you sure you are not just high? :mis2 Andino has built his reputation on his own. He was THE SHORTSTOP and rapidly has become a utility player at best if he works hard enough. He may always have a problem managing to hit his weight let alone being able to hit .290. He still could be valuable but he also has had a decline defensively. His luster is long gone Since he received three awards this season based on his defense I'd say you might be a little behind the curve on your statement. He's also had three consecutive years of improvement offensively, this year being his best, and while its a microscopic sample size, in his 14 PAs this Sept @ the MLB level he had five hits for a .385 average, drawing nothing from that except he wasn't wholesale overmatched. And he's a kid, just 23. Hard to believe at that age "his luster is long gone." Well then bring him up and put him at SS! 2003, I will be waiting to see your post demanding to put Ramirez back at SS after Andino barely surpasses the Mendoza Line and starts making all kinds of errors. That would be entertaining of itself
December 10, 200718 yr WEll then bring him up and put him at SS! 2003 I will be waiting to see your post demanding to put Ramirez back at SS after Andino barely surpasses the Mendoza Line and starts making all kinds of errors SS. That would be entertaining of itself I didn't say that and just because you were wrong about everthing you said doesn't mean you have the right to put words in my mouth. Because that would be a mistake too. What I've said all along about Andino is : 1. I am pleased he had such a good season, making two in a row. 2. I'm happy for the kid to be recognized for his achievements. 3. If Uggla in fact moves to third Andino should be a candidate for 2nd base. 4. If you need a utility infielder he certainly should get a call. I don't think, at least in recent discussions meaning the last month or longer, I ever mentioned him going to SS. You seem so angry the kid is doing well? Why is that?
December 10, 200718 yr No one is angry that he is "doing well" more angry that he is being mislabeled. The defensive awards are hiding the large amount of errors he committed last season (errors aren't the definitive judgment, but they are certainly a large component). And he has not had two good seasons in a row. In 2006, he posted a .250 AVG and sub-.700 OPS. Under no circumstances would I call that a good offensive season in the hitter friendly PCL. On top of that, Andino's offensive numbers were dwarfed by virtually everyone else on the Isotopes roster this past season (from the journeymen like Seabol to the young failures like Abercrombie). Even everyone's favorite Eric Reed wasn't far below Andino's SLG figures, despite being a singles hitter. I fail to see how anything Andino did in 2007 can be labeled as an accomplishment, other than saying he didn't play as badly as he did in 2006. Wow. Defensive player of the year, PCL all-star, Topps top defensive award, much improved stat line. And you know the reason for the errors is his over agressiveness going after balls he can't reach. Improvement across the board. And he played in every game. His team nickname, Spiderman.
December 10, 200718 yr No one is angry that he is "doing well" more angry that he is being mislabeled. The defensive awards are hiding the large amount of errors he committed last season (errors aren't the definitive judgment, but they are certainly a large component). And he has not had two good seasons in a row. In 2006, he posted a .250 AVG and sub-.700 OPS. Under no circumstances would I call that a good offensive season in the hitter friendly PCL. On top of that, Andino's offensive numbers were dwarfed by virtually everyone else on the Isotopes roster this past season (from the journeymen like Seabol to the young failures like Abercrombie). Even everyone's favorite Eric Reed wasn't far below Andino's SLG figures, despite being a singles hitter. I fail to see how anything Andino did in 2007 can be labeled as an accomplishment, other than saying he didn't play as badly as he did in 2006. Wow. Defensive player of the year, PCL all-star, Topps top defensive award, much improved stat line. And you know the reason for the errors is his over agressiveness going after balls he can't reach. Improvement across the board. And he played in every game. His team nickname, Spiderman. You are making the same loaded comparisons the media articles you are posting are. You are viewing the issue superficially and almost in a vacuum. Even if one raises the OPS 80 pts, you can't ignore the fact that he was the second worst hitter in the lineup. In a league where hitters are supposed to thrive he did not. As for the errors, I honestly don't know. I've never been to a Topes game. All I know is that he committed far more than any utility player should on a major league club. I honestly don't give a damn about arbitray awards and distinctions. Looking at the cold hard facts, Andino is nothing special. talk about a vacuum. most hits, 4th in doubles, 1st in triples, fifth in hrs 3rd in stolen bases. his OBP could be better, he's far from perfect but i never said that. I'm pleased to see steady improvment there, I keep saying that over and over, I'm not equating him to Hanley or ARod or anyone, just happy he's doing well. And of course there's room for improvement. I realize you honestly believe you know more about talent evaluation than the professionals managing in the PCL, they happen to disagree with you. I suggest you go read Dean Treanor's interview - I think in the Alb daily or at website on Andino and then several more and the feeling about his play is consistently that he has major league ability and is probably ready for prime time. When you argue with me you're really arguing with them, I'm just paraphrasing the many positive comments about the kid in 2007.
December 10, 200718 yr No one is angry that he is "doing well" more angry that he is being mislabeled. The defensive awards are hiding the large amount of errors he committed last season (errors aren't the definitive judgment, but they are certainly a large component). And he has not had two good seasons in a row. In 2006, he posted a .250 AVG and sub-.700 OPS. Under no circumstances would I call that a good offensive season in the hitter friendly PCL. On top of that, Andino's offensive numbers were dwarfed by virtually everyone else on the Isotopes roster this past season (from the journeymen like Seabol to the young failures like Abercrombie). Even everyone's favorite Eric Reed wasn't far below Andino's SLG figures, despite being a singles hitter. I fail to see how anything Andino did in 2007 can be labeled as an accomplishment, other than saying he didn't play as badly as he did in 2006. Wow. Defensive player of the year, PCL all-star, Topps top defensive award, much improved stat line. And you know the reason for the errors is his over agressiveness going after balls he can't reach. Improvement across the board. And he played in every game. His team nickname, Spiderman. I don't care if his team nickname was "Spiderpig", Andino has not yet shown anything to prove he can play in the Majors, defensively or offensively. i wwouldn't even call him a Quadruple A Ballplayer because his performance in Triple A is totally average and uninspiring
December 10, 200718 yr Major league pitchers pump fastballs right by Andino. If he plays a big part on the Marlins next season they will be even worse than they will be projected to be.
December 10, 200718 yr this thread is done. somebody close it. Honestly, what is wrong with you? He's new. Give him some time... havent you seen his member number as for andino i want to see this defense first hand he should get a shot next year
December 10, 200718 yr Because none of those statistics are correlated to his higher number of ABs. He's playing below average on his team in a league for AAAA players. That is foreboding of his final resting place. He's too young to be called a AAAA right now, but everything outside of good wishes from his manager and his Topps trophy indicate that's where he's headed. I was going to point out the PA thing with the quantity of stuff but you beat me to it. However, I am going to side with 03 on this one a little bit. Not with the awards and trophys shenanigans, but just sticking up for Andino. Everyone thinks he sucks because of his small stint in the bigs and since he's been in the organization for 5 years now and not claimed a 25 man roster spot, but it's important to remember he was 21 and 22 years old those years. He's always been young for his level and now his age is finally catching up to that. He did show a lot of improvement in AAA this year even if it needs to still be categorized as below average. If anything, we can use his 2007 as a hopeful jumping off point that he plays better in 2008 and becomes Amezaga's replacement in 2009 (or stopgap to Coghlan). I wouldn't give up on him for another few years (this is ignoring the out of options problem which will occur next year, but still). Like you said, he's still to young to make a definitive call on but he absolutely needs to improve. Also to note. Amezaga during his 23/24 year old seasons in the PCL hit approx. .250/.315/.350 (.665). He then started posting an .800+ OPS in AAA starting at age 25-27. If we're going to judge Andino to this standard, as in slap hitting defensive minded infielders need a lot of time to learn how to hit, he is already way ahead of the curve and has shown substantial more power. I'm optimistic but not counting on him, which is how I feel the organization views him too.
December 10, 200718 yr I like the Amezaga comparison, it actually took several years of hitting around .205-.220 in the majors and several stints in Mexican Winter Leagues before he has developed to a .260-.265 hitter. Only in Marlinland do the wonders of Alfredo "Pasta" Amezaga be spoken of with great admiration. Face it Amezaga is a very good utility player and no more
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.