February 25, 200818 yr Looking at it from an economic standpoint, I think it could only hurt the organization. I think theres more people who would be turned away by this promotion than people who use this promotion as an incentive to go to a marlins game. I hate to be whiny about this, and I know there's nothing I can do about it, but It's just a pretty ridiculous move by the organization. People aren't gonna choose to go to or stay away from a Marlins game just cuz some fat people are gonna do routines that will last for about a minute at the most. Although I don't like the idea, I don't think it will "hurt" the organization.
February 25, 200818 yr Looking at it from an economic standpoint, I think it could only hurt the organization. I think theres more people who would be turned away by this promotion than people who use this promotion as an incentive to go to a marlins game. I hate to be whiny about this, and I know there's nothing I can do about it, but It's just a pretty ridiculous move by the organization. People aren't gonna choose to go to or stay away from a Marlins game just cuz some fat people are gonna do routines that will last for about a minute at the most. Although I don't like the idea, I don't think it will "hurt" the organization. Ok, Let's just say that there will COULD be people that are turned off by this and will never go to another game because of it. Will there be a lot? Probably not. But that number will probably be greater than the number of people who say "Hey, look! The Marlins have this new thing called the Marlins Manatees where fat guys dance! Let's go check it out!" That right there could "hurt" the organization. Every dollar lost is important in a business like this. Not saying it will be a multi million dollar loss or anything, but a loss is a loss, right? And let's say that perhaps this promotion does exactly what you said, not swaying anyones opinion on whether or not to go to a marlins game. Wouldn't that mean the marketing department has failed? I mean, the whole purpose of a marketing pitch like this is to get more people to come to the games. I really don't think this idea of marlins manatees will "get more people to come to games" It's either going to keep our fan base exactly the way it is (while looking ridiculous in the process) or it's going to cause an ever so slight disturbance in our fanbase. Either way, it's a lose-lose IMO
February 25, 200818 yr do people have to bitch about every little thing coming down the pipe? Relax, it's 5 days til' Spring Training and there's nothing else to talk about. I'm not "bitching", I'm voicing my opinion on what I think is a ridiculous sales pitch.
February 25, 200818 yr SoFlaFish, I wish I could have come up with your responses.. I could not agree with you more... This is such a silly gimmick, but if it means the Marlins are getting some attention, then so be it. People talk about the lack of media coverage for this team, but when we get some for the wrong reasons, we're a disgrace to MLB.... People need to get over it.. I loved the comment about some kid in Topeka opening up Yahoo! and seeing a Marlins jersey.. So true... Any exposure we get, can't hurt... Fact is, people are now hearing the name "Florida Marlins" more than they did before... I also heard that the Chicago Bulls do the same thing. I don't think it was something organized by their front office, but some large men started dancing on the jumbotron and now it's a big part of their games... Yeah, and I guess the OJ Simpson trial was good publicity for him too, huh? :thumbup Hmm.. yeah, that's almost the same thing... I said "any exposure", which does not equate to being on trial for murder. The Marlins need exposure... I just saw this on Fox News and could not believe that they were talking about the Marlins. When was the last time a national television media show uttered the words "Florida Marlins" on the air? Maybe in 2003 when they won the series... They even went so far as to have one of the Manatee's on the show. I missed the interview, but there was a fat dude with a Marlins jersey and Marlins cap on Fox News !!! Again, it's not the attention we necessarily want, but I'll take this over no attention at all. And again, comparing it to a murder trial is a bit extreme... And after reading the rest of your replies, I think you're a little too passionate about this one.. You do realize that they are only performing on Fridays and Saturdays and they are doing this for free, right? Get over it... Some people will laugh when they see it, and other will say how stupid it is.. But once the half inning is over, they will continue to watch the game, which is why we're all there to begin with.
February 25, 200818 yr SoFlaFish, I wish I could have come up with your responses.. I could not agree with you more... This is such a silly gimmick, but if it means the Marlins are getting some attention, then so be it. People talk about the lack of media coverage for this team, but when we get some for the wrong reasons, we're a disgrace to MLB.... People need to get over it.. I loved the comment about some kid in Topeka opening up Yahoo! and seeing a Marlins jersey.. So true... Any exposure we get, can't hurt... Fact is, people are now hearing the name "Florida Marlins" more than they did before... I also heard that the Chicago Bulls do the same thing. I don't think it was something organized by their front office, but some large men started dancing on the jumbotron and now it's a big part of their games... Yeah, and I guess the OJ Simpson trial was good publicity for him too, huh? :thumbup Hmm.. yeah, that's almost the same thing... I said "any exposure", which does not equate to being on trial for murder. The Marlins need exposure... I just saw this on Fox News and could not believe that they were talking about the Marlins. When was the last time a national television media show uttered the words "Florida Marlins" on the air? Maybe in 2003 when they won the series... They even went so far as to have one of the Manatee's on the show. I missed the interview, but there was a fat dude with a Marlins jersey and Marlins cap on Fox News !!! Again, it's not the attention we necessarily want, but I'll take this over no attention at all. And again, comparing it to a murder trial is a bit extreme... And after reading the rest of your replies, I think you're a little too passionate about this one.. You do realize that they are only performing on Fridays and Saturdays and they are doing this for free, right? Get over it... Some people will laugh when they see it, and other will say how stupid it is.. But once the half inning is over, they will continue to watch the game, which is why we're all there to begin with. :mis2 I didn't know it was only on the weekends and for one half inning, and being done for free. I guess that's not too bad... My opinion is still that it's a pretty ridiculous idea, and I'll leave the argument at that.
February 25, 200818 yr Would the Yankees or Red Sox do something like this? Hell no. How about the Cubs, Dodgers, Cardinals? Come to think of it, the Marlins are just about the only team I can think of that would pull something like this. Baseball is a game that is based on tradition, and whether you like to admit it or not....male dancers are NOT part of the game and never were intended to be. What these clowns in the Marlins PR are doing is making us look bad and are a disgrace to the game of baseball Right now, the Florida Marlins organization is more of a three-ring circus than it is a baseball franchise. I can't wait til' this garbage comes to an end. :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy I would rather have no exposure and keep my team's dignity and respect than this shameless garbage.
February 25, 200818 yr Looking at it from an economic standpoint, I think it could only hurt the organization. I think theres more people who would be turned away by this promotion than people who use this promotion as an incentive to go to a marlins game. I hate to be whiny about this, and I know there's nothing I can do about it, but It's just a pretty ridiculous move by the organization. Don't kid yourself. There is very little this organization can do to hurt its image than what has already been done. People seem to forget both firesales that last couple of years. Add the trade of Cabs to that. I think THOSE are prime examples of this organization turning people away. One can't compare the Manatee promotion to those actions.
February 25, 200818 yr Apparently people showed up. Whatever, they look like they're having fun. It's harmless. Heh, that looks pretty funny. I think some of you guys are taking this way to serious. It's just a bunch of fat dudes dancing. It is as the op said, Harmless.
February 25, 200818 yr Apparently people showed up. Whatever, they look like they're having fun. It's harmless. Heh, that looks pretty funny. I think some of you guys are taking this way to serious. It's just a bunch of fat dudes dancing. It is as the op said, Harmless. Harmless 'til one of 'em falls off the dugout onto a toddler in the first row... :mischief
February 26, 200818 yr :mis2 I didn't know it was only on the weekends and for one half inning, and being done for free. I guess that's not too bad... My opinion is still that it's a pretty ridiculous idea, and I'll leave the argument at that. I don't know that they are only appearing in one half inning.. I just meant that they'll be out in between some innings and when it's over, it's back to baseball.. But they are volunteering and it's only a couple of days on the weekends.
February 26, 200818 yr meh the chicago bulls have the matadors which are essentially the same thing...
February 26, 200818 yr it sounds like the sort of promotion that minor league teams do. but whatever.
February 26, 200818 yr So they all made the team? Dang, if I would've known that I would have taken my 150 pound frame out to the tryout. Looking like a jackass for a half inning is well worth the free admission. And if they said I wasn't fat enough then I could have played the weight card. After all it's the 21st century, there's no room for weightism in this country.
February 26, 200818 yr it sounds like the sort of promotion that minor league teams do. but whatever. Which is my only problem with this. The nation views the Marlins as a minor league team or a farm system for clubs like the Yankees or Red Sox. I don't see how this dispels that notion to any extent. Thus it is an example of negative publicity. The way the nation perceives our organization will have long lasting effects. Try being an out of state fan who has probably been asked "So why are you a Marlins fan?" every other day for the last 15 years. It all comes to the fact that I view the stadium announcement as a considerable step forward in establishing the legitimacy of this franchise, but ridiculous promotions like this (despite how trivial they might seem) remind people more about the 1998 team than the 1997 team.
February 26, 200818 yr it sounds like the sort of promotion that minor league teams do. but whatever. Well we are the Florida Marlins :whistle
February 26, 200818 yr #5 doesn't look fat enough. :confused I was thinking the same thing. i was gonna say "can he play cf?" but then i realized that jokes over. DAMN YOU CAMERON MAYBIN
February 26, 200818 yr Author #5 doesn't look fat enough. :confused I was thinking the same thing. i was gonna say "can he play cf?" but then i realized that jokes over. DAMN YOU CAMERON MAYBIN Can he play 3rd base?
February 26, 200818 yr The only problem I have is that they aren't fat enough. All of them should be 300+
February 28, 200818 yr There will also be the Marlins Minnows (a kids team) and the updated version of the Bleacher Brigade now called the Marlins Maniacs. The Manatees aren't a promotion of any kind. Just clean, family oriented entertainment on Fridays and Saturdays. Some folks take this stuff far too seriously. Especially those that either don't even live here or those that do and don't go to the games and yet for some reason want to inform those that do what they should determin to be funny and/or entertaining.
February 28, 200818 yr BTW We were at the game Wed night vs the Nats and I asked around how they ( the fans that actually attend games) felt about the Manatees. Not one voiced anything negative. Not one.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.