Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins ballpark in jeopardy once again

Featured Replies

A growing turf battle between Miami and Miami-Dade police officers -- and their respective politicians -- threatens to delay or derail the long-sought $525 million Florida Marlins ballpark, even as cranes ready to take down the historic Orange Bowl.

 

The fight is simple at its core, centered on which agency gets to patrol the ballpark grounds and reap millions in off-duty pay during the team's 35-year lease. While the ballpark would be built in the city, the county would own the facility.

 

Politically, the solution is not so simple, as each governing body -- Miami on one side and Miami-Dade on the other -- wants to ensure its officers get their share of the spoils. Each has passed dueling resolutions.

 

Elected leaders fear giving in means they'd lose the support of two of the most powerful voting blocks in South Florida, the Police Benevolent Association representing county police and the Fraternal Order of Police overseeing Miami.

 

The unions' political might extends beyond the 5,000 officers, said former Miami Police Chief Ken Harms, to the ability to organize and campaign for commissioners.

 

'No reasonable politician wants to alienate his or her police or fire department. They want to be able to say down the line, `we supported you guys,' '' said Harms.

 

The police issue threatens to delay the aggressive schedule the Marlins have crafted to complete the massive construction job within a 28-month window so the team can play in Little Havana by 2011.

 

Despite the Baseball Stadium Agreement being approved two weeks ago in broad form by the city and county, a host of other issues -- including a management contract that would include the policing duties -- must be resolved and voted on by commissioners before the digging begins in November.

 

The agreement also says that if the plan falls apart because a management agreement isn't reached, the county could be on the hook for one-third of any money spent to that point -- Marlins architectural drawings, for example, or any Miami public works -- whether the county spent any money, or not.

 

The coveted off-duty pay -- which averages $28 an hour in Miami and $30 in the county -- is significant to Miami police, and even more so to county officers who use it to bulk up their pensions. The BSA calls for the Marlins to fund police presence.

 

The agreement calls for land under the stadium to be deeded to the county -- freeing the city from a pricey property tax bill.

 

But the decision to deed those 13 acres or so has set off a threat by the county's most powerful union boss ''to blow up'' negotiations; a protest by the union representing Miami police; and the specter of a grievance by Miami police -- against city commissioners.

 

''They're [county police] proposing to have double the amount of police officers, just so they don't get sweaty outside,'' said FOP boss Armando Aguilar, who represents Miami's 940 police officers.

 

The turf battle surfaced unexpectedly two weeks ago as county commissioners prepared to vote to finance the stadium, when John Rivera, the PBA union boss, threatened to detonate the deal if his members were left out.

 

Commissioners, their aides and Marlins officials searched for a way to appease Rivera. Several hours later, Rivera accepted the financing vote under the condition that city and county administrators return with a negotiated settlement within 30 days -- or the ballpark deal would die.

 

Last week, as city commissioners passed a unanimous vote for Miami officers to patrol the stadium, about 100 members carried signs and strolled the circular City Hall parking lot protesting any potential county presence.

 

Said city Commissioner Tomas Regalado: ``Common sense never is present in any dealings with the county.''

 

Then Tuesday, after county commissioners passed a similar unanimous vote for county officers to patrol the new ballpark, city commissioners were put on notice -- by their own police department.

 

FOP attorney Osnat K. Rind cited the city's collective bargaining agreement in contending there was no leeway when it comes to patrolling in Miami. ''The union considers the city's action a serious breach of its obligation to act in good faith and fairly with employees,'' wrote Rind.

 

During the county hearing, commissioners harped on how county forces lost lucrative jobs at the AmericanAirlines Arena and the Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts. They vowed to never let that happen again.

 

''I'm not blinking,'' piped in Commissioner Joe Martinez.

 

County Mayor Carlos Alvarez and Manager George Burgess, and city Mayor Manny Diaz and Manager Pete Hernandez, aim to settle the dispute. Alvarez and Burgess declined comment.

 

Hernandez said he's trying to get the two police departments to talk. He said he spoke with FOP's Aguilar Tuesday and is willing to sit down with Rivera.

 

The parties have two weeks to reach resolution. With that deadline looming, some see signs of light, others not so much.

 

Union bosses representing city and county firefighters -- who, like police, are also negotiating for territorial rights -- are talking. PBA's Rivera said he's fine with his troops working from the stadium sidewalk in, and city police the adjacent streets.

 

''I never implied we wanted to encroach,'' he said.

 

Replied Aguilar: ``They want to be the boss. Well, let them build it outside, in the county, then. Let them build it in the Everglades.''

http://www.miamiherald.com/459/story/446822.html

Are you kidding me??!?!?

This is exactly why I wont be convinced we have a stadium until im sitting in the damn thing watching the MIAMI marlins play ball.

Without a stadium, nobody gets any of the overtime pay. There will be yelling and screaming and then it will get resolved.

Without a stadium, nobody gets any of the overtime pay. There will be yelling and screaming and then it will get resolved.

 

 

 

 

This

Without a stadium, nobody gets any of the overtime pay. There will be yelling and screaming and then it will get resolved.

 

 

 

 

This

i agree...and if need be...bob dupuy will bring down the rath of MLB again and these people will figure something out

In order to resolve this between the huge egos of the law enforcement, I suggest we bring in an independent agency, like a UN peacekeeping force. JUST GET THE DAMN THING SETTLED AND LETS GET OUR STADIUM GOING.

This is just horsesh*t and will have no effect on the stadium deal. Let's remember Miami needs MDC police more than Miam-Dade County police need cops from Miami. People forget the city of Miami is relatively small and a lot of the overtime their cops get are outside the city limits under the interlocal with the county cops.

 

If all of a sudden that dries up for Miami cops because MDC police call in police from medley, Hialeah, North Miami, etc., when extra event details are needed the city of Miami cops will wish they had treated their county brothers in blue more respectfully.

 

Cooler heads will prevail. Non-issue.

This is just horsesh*t and will have no effect on the stadium deal. Let's remember Miami needs MDC police more than Miam-Dade County police need cops from Miami. People forget the city of Miami is relatively small and a lot of the overtime their cops get are outside the city limits under the interlocal with the county cops.

 

If all of a sudden that dries up for Miami cops because MDC police call in police from medley, Hialeah, North Miami, etc., when extra event details are needed the city of Miami cops will wish they had treated their county brothers in blue more respectfully.

 

Cooler heads will prevail. Non-issue.

 

:notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy

2003, you're OBJECTIVELY right about this, but it doesn't mean cooler heads will prevail. imo it is a very big issue, because the county has dug its heels in opposition to the city police getting the bulk of the services, and if they don't budge (which they probably shouldn't on principle considering they lost out on the AAA and PAC policing entirely), I'm not sure the city budges either. The city can't afford to have its own area NOT use its city police/fire services. I think everyone can agree that everyone will lose if the stadium doesn't get built, but we're not talking about politicians pandering to just anybody. The city of miami fire/police are the biggest lobbiests for the city representatives...if they can't be reasoned with to share the pie, then the city and the county are in a stare-down that neither can really afford to lose. in the past, the county folded, but i don't think this can happen again considering the abuse the county commisionsers took from failing to account for the county services before. I could care less (as am sure every person on the board could care less) WHO does the fire/policing, but this is more than just politics. the herald is really not sensationalizing it imo. its a big issue, and hopefully the city and county can agree to a 50/50 split on this (probably as it should be). cooler heads should prevail, but in light of the beatings the county took in the past, you really are asking cooler heads to prevail with the CITY, which is asking a lot.

2003, you're OBJECTIVELY right about this, but it doesn't mean cooler heads will prevail. imo it is a very big issue, because the county has dug its heels in opposition to the city police getting the bulk of the services, and if they don't budge (which they probably shouldn't on principle considering they lost out on the AAA and PAC policing entirely), I'm not sure the city budges either. The city can't afford to have its own area NOT use its city police/fire services. I think everyone can agree that everyone will lose if the stadium doesn't get built, but we're not talking about politicians pandering to just anybody. The city of miami fire/police are the biggest lobbiests for the city representatives...if they can't be reasoned with to share the pie, then the city and the county are in a stare-down that neither can really afford to lose. in the past, the county folded, but i don't think this can happen again considering the abuse the county commisionsers took from failing to account for the county services before. I could care less (as am sure every person on the board could care less) WHO does the fire/policing, but this is more than just politics. the herald is really not sensationalizing it imo. its a big issue, and hopefully the city and county can agree to a 50/50 split on this (probably as it should be). cooler heads should prevail, but in light of the beatings the county took in the past, you really are asking cooler heads to prevail with the CITY, which is asking a lot.

 

The only flaw in your argument is the stadium is not the city's, it's the county's and ditto the land it will be built on as I'm sure you remember part of the deal is the city turning the site over to the county. So it's the county's stadium built on county land. End of discussion.

I have an amazing source that says this is a total non issue. If they don't figure this out between themselves, the city and county officials are just going to decided something on their own. Like a split deal. There is zero chance this screws up the deal.

2003, you're OBJECTIVELY right about this, but it doesn't mean cooler heads will prevail. imo it is a very big issue, because the county has dug its heels in opposition to the city police getting the bulk of the services, and if they don't budge (which they probably shouldn't on principle considering they lost out on the AAA and PAC policing entirely), I'm not sure the city budges either. The city can't afford to have its own area NOT use its city police/fire services. I think everyone can agree that everyone will lose if the stadium doesn't get built, but we're not talking about politicians pandering to just anybody. The city of miami fire/police are the biggest lobbiests for the city representatives...if they can't be reasoned with to share the pie, then the city and the county are in a stare-down that neither can really afford to lose. in the past, the county folded, but i don't think this can happen again considering the abuse the county commisionsers took from failing to account for the county services before. I could care less (as am sure every person on the board could care less) WHO does the fire/policing, but this is more than just politics. the herald is really not sensationalizing it imo. its a big issue, and hopefully the city and county can agree to a 50/50 split on this (probably as it should be). cooler heads should prevail, but in light of the beatings the county took in the past, you really are asking cooler heads to prevail with the CITY, which is asking a lot.

What can the police lobbyists do? The deal is done. All parties signed on. Some groups don't like the details. For this to go anywhere, the county or city would have to relent to their demands and reverse the vote in an appropriate matter of time. As this is an incidental matter, the politicians will likely work to resolve it. Had the police made some noise before the vote, maybe this would have been an issue. Not now. The politicians would lose much more than votes and campaign dollars if they reverse the deal now. They'd lose all their credibility. Can you imagine any one voting to re-elect a politician because they reversed a decision due only to the threats of a lobbyist group? No amount of support from that group would allow that politician to be re-elected.

Now this may be a big deal and it may take some work to craft an appropriate resolution, but to suggest the stadium deal is in jeopardy is a load of you know what.

2003, you're OBJECTIVELY right about this, but it doesn't mean cooler heads will prevail. imo it is a very big issue, because the county has dug its heels in opposition to the city police getting the bulk of the services, and if they don't budge (which they probably shouldn't on principle considering they lost out on the AAA and PAC policing entirely), I'm not sure the city budges either. The city can't afford to have its own area NOT use its city police/fire services. I think everyone can agree that everyone will lose if the stadium doesn't get built, but we're not talking about politicians pandering to just anybody. The city of miami fire/police are the biggest lobbiests for the city representatives...if they can't be reasoned with to share the pie, then the city and the county are in a stare-down that neither can really afford to lose. in the past, the county folded, but i don't think this can happen again considering the abuse the county commisionsers took from failing to account for the county services before. I could care less (as am sure every person on the board could care less) WHO does the fire/policing, but this is more than just politics. the herald is really not sensationalizing it imo. its a big issue, and hopefully the city and county can agree to a 50/50 split on this (probably as it should be). cooler heads should prevail, but in light of the beatings the county took in the past, you really are asking cooler heads to prevail with the CITY, which is asking a lot.

What can the police lobbyists do? The deal is done. All parties signed on. Some groups don't like the details. For this to go anywhere, the county or city would have to relent to their demands and reverse the vote in an appropriate matter of time. As this is an incidental matter, the politicians will likely work to resolve it. Had the police made some noise before the vote, maybe this would have been an issue. Not now. The politicians would lose much more than votes and campaign dollars if they reverse the deal now. They'd lose all their credibility. Can you imagine any one voting to re-elect a politician because they reversed a decision due only to the threats of a lobbyist group? No amount of support from that group would allow that politician to be re-elected.

Now this may be a big deal and it may take some work to craft an appropriate resolution, but to suggest the stadium deal is in jeopardy is a load of you know what.

 

I agree with what you're saying rferry, but I think you have to accept that these groups in particular hold more weight than others, considering their public service, and all the politico's just love kissing their asses and getting more votes.

 

In the end this can get ugly because of the same thing that has kept this issue unsolved for so long... politics.

Not even a school teacher's union in Massachusetts would have that power. Not enough for the city or county to reverse the deal. Especially as people pointed out that no such problem would even exist without a stadium. They disagree to a minor matter related to the stadium. They can fight all they want about the matter, but at the end of the day, it's not going to affect the ballpark. If the argument is that such matters should have been resolved in the process of crafting the proposal, then guess what? They've already lost the argument. The politicians pushed ahead. Now they can concern themselves with the minor matter instead of arguing how much sway they should have had. That's not important any more. It's not anything for the union to get upset about. How the matter is resolved might be.

Give me a break.

40 games to the city forces, 40 games to the county. Flip a coin as to who gets the first half of the season. 41st game is split juristiction, as are all special events that require more personnel (ASG, post season, etc.) The second year (and all folowing years,) flip the order, whoever had the second half the first year gets the first half the second.

Everybody wins.

 

 

But I know this will NEVER happen.

I can't believe this thread won't die. There is no war. There is nothing to be concerned about. There is ZERO chance that this will affect a stadium deal. The End.

  • Author

I know it sounds petty and SHOULDN'T affect the stadium deal but 30 days from Feb. 21st is March 22nd. Today means we are 11 days away. If we don't have anything by then, the deal is OFF. NO QUESTIONS ASKED.

I know it sounds petty and SHOULDN'T affect the stadium deal but 30 days from Feb. 21st is March 22nd. Today means we are 11 days away. If we don't have anything by then, the deal is OFF. NO QUESTIONS ASKED.

 

I wouldn't go that far. These folks have already showed us that they are pros at extending deadlines, remember?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.