Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Give Sheffield a shot?

Featured Replies

I say bring him in. He's a throwback, and he's our best shot at getting someone into the HOF as a 'Marlin'.

Bringing him back will have nothing to do with his hall eligibility.

 

 

Yeah but if he does get inducted I think it would all but insure that he goes in as a Marlin. I think right now if he were to be inducted there would be some debate on which team he would represent.

 

He won his ring here, he said this was his favorite place to play, I think if goes in he picks Florida

I say bring him in. He's a throwback, and he's our best shot at getting someone into the HOF as a 'Marlin'.

Bringing him back will have nothing to do with his hall eligibility.

 

 

Yeah but if he does get inducted I think it would all but insure that he goes in as a Marlin. I think right now if he were to be inducted there would be some debate on which team he would represent.

 

He won his ring here, he said this was his favorite place to play, I think if goes in he picks Florida

 

I don't think players gets to pick what team they go in as.

I say bring him in. He's a throwback, and he's our best shot at getting someone into the HOF as a 'Marlin'.

Bringing him back will have nothing to do with his hall eligibility.

 

 

Yeah but if he does get inducted I think it would all but insure that he goes in as a Marlin. I think right now if he were to be inducted there would be some debate on which team he would represent.

 

He won his ring here, he said this was his favorite place to play, I think if goes in he picks Florida

 

I don't think players gets to pick what team they go in as.

 

 

I believe the HoF picks it based on where they did the majority of their achievements.

i dont want sheff. its be like another lazy player in the clubhouse. i dont think he would see eye to eye with freddy

I would absolutely love this. Not only does he fit a role that this team needs, but he's Gary Freakin' Sheffield.

 

This would be an outstanding signing, especially at the minimum.

I've heard that Tampa is where he wants to play. It being his hometown, and of course Tampa being in the WS last year also doesn't hurt.

i dont want sheff. its be like another lazy player in the clubhouse. i dont think he would see eye to eye with freddy

Freddy should get along with Sheffield, seeing as Sheff and Freddy were together as Braves in 2002 and 2003.

So I just took 35 minutes of my team to calculate some of Sheffield's stats based on the teams he's played for...

 

294 games played with the brewers

146 games played with the padres*

446 games played with the marlins*

436 games played with the dodgers*

290 games played with the braves

347 games played with the yankees

247 games played with the tigers

 

287 hits with the brewers

184 hits with the padres*

432 hits with the marlins*

488 hits with the dodgers*

341 hits with the braves

381 hits with the yankees

225 hits with the tigers

 

21 homeruns with the brewers

43 homeruns with the padres*

116 homeruns with the marlins*

113 homeruns with the dodgers*

64 homeruns with the braves

76 homeruns with the yankees

44 homeruns with the tigers

 

133 RBI with the brewers

100 RBI with the padres*

315 RBI with the marlins*

310 RBI with the dodgers*

216 RBI with the braves

269 RBI with the yankees

132 RBI with the tigers

 

.259 BA with the brewers

.330 BA with the padres*

.288 BA with the marlins*

.312 BA with the dodgers*

.319 BA with the braves

.291 BA with the yankees

.247 BA with the tigers

 

okay. he has 3 all star games as a dodger. 1 with the marlins. 1 with the braves. 2 with the yankees, and 2 with the padres

 

*stats are not 100% correct due to wikipedia not seperating his stats for those teams on the years he was traded.. padres traded him to the marlins midseason in june and the marlins traded him to the dodgers pretty early in may.

 

so basically you can have an argument for Sheffield to go in as either a marlin or dodger. I think if either of those two teams sign him now and he hits his 500th homerun with that team that would be enough to push him into the HoF in that uniform (if he gets voted in).

Dan Lebatard just said that Sheffield once told him if he goes into the HoF he'll be wearing a Marlins hat.

The Phillies just released Geoff Jenkins.I would rather have Jenkins with the higher upside.

Yeah Jenkins could be our lefty 4th of. He's gotta be better than deaza and Ryan.

I love Sheff, but Jenkins would probably be the better choice right now.

 

Agreed, although Jenkins statistic nose-dive (at first glance) is quite ugly and something I wouldn't want to get caught in the middle of.

At 499 homeruns, its so not my thing, but you almost want to do a Sachel Paige and bring the guy in so he can hit #500, throw a big party, retire a Marlin...but the problem is Sheff I suspect would want to keep going and you couldn't get him out of here with a front-end loader.

Well sheff just mentioned on mlbn the fish as a team he'd posibly like to come to.

so basically you can have an argument for Sheffield to go in as either a marlin or dodger. I think if either of those two teams sign him now and he hits his 500th homerun with that team that would be enough to push him into the HoF in that uniform (if he gets voted in).

Alright, so the Dodgers rival the Marlins in playing time. 1996 was Sheffield's best season, and 1997 was his World Series.

 

If Shef gets in despite the steroids, he is 100% going to be a Marlin. I don't see much of a debate.

i say bring back the sheff..

 

hitting 500 as a marlins would be aweasome..

 

he will got the the hall of fame as a marlin too..

 

sheff had his best year ever as a marlin...1997 world champs :rolleyes:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.