March 31, 200917 yr The Tigers released Gary Sheffield today because of his poor spring. I was just wondering since we do need a 4th legitimate outfielder that we give him a minor league deal considering his age. It would be great that he would hit his 500th HR as a Marlin. Thoughts? I dont know if he would accept a minor league deal. Maybe 1yr for 1 mil with incentives? His asking price shouldn't be too much. I know the FO said that the payroll would gradually rise and i dont think Sheffield would be too expensive. He still has a pretty explosive bat and hell, maybe we can play him at first base. http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/spring2009/n...tory?id=4029706
March 31, 200917 yr I didn't bother to check his contract status but if the Tigers cut him they are eating whatever is left on his contract and whatever teams picks him up, if any do, it will be at the minimum. Honestly though, I have no idea how much he has left in the tank.
March 31, 200917 yr Author I didn't bother to check his contract status but if the Tigers cut him they are eating whatever is left on his contract and whatever teams picks him up, if any do, it will be at the minimum.Honestly though, I have no idea how much he has left in the tank. For some reason I can see him playing first base. But then the errors would go up. He may be better off in the outfield. I still think he has something left. Thats what they said about Luis Gonzalez. I would love to see him hit his 500th HR with us and let him retire as a Marlin.
March 31, 200917 yr Our lineup would greatly improve if we picked up Sheff for 1st base! He still has excellent strike zone judgement. Get it done FO....give us a future hall of famer to put fans in the seats!!! 1) Maybin- CF 2) Baker- C 3) Ramirez- SS 4) Cantu- 3B 5) Uggla- 2B 6) Ross- RF 7) Sheffield- 1B 8) Hermida- LF That lineup would be insane....Sheff can still hit 20!
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez?
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez? Because whilst he has the same intials, Gaby Sanchez is not called "Gary Sheffield".
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez? Because whilst he has the same intials, Gaby Sanchez is not called "Gary Sheffield". The Tigers were AWFUL last year. That team didn't have HALF of the team chemistry the Marlins do. Look at all the good players on that team that had down years but could be productive in the right environment..... Sheffield, Renteria, Verlander, Zumaya, hell even Granderson didn't live up to expectations Sure he's past his prime but Gaby Sanchez isn't even in the same class as Sheff whether Sheff is 40 or 20.
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez? Because whilst he has the same intials, Gaby Sanchez is not called "Gary Sheffield". The Tigers were AWFUL last year. That team didn't have HALF of the team chemistry the Marlins do. Look at all the good players on that team that had down years but could be productive in the right environment..... Sheffield, Renteria, Verlander, Zumaya, hell even Granderson didn't live up to expectations Sure he's past his prime but Gaby Sanchez isn't even in the same class as Sheff whether Sheff is 40 or 20. Hey hey hey, leave Curtis Granderson out of this! I'm too tired to look up his numbers right now...but don't hate on Grandy! I love him. 5 tools. Great attitude. The nostalgic side of me would kind of like to see Sheff back with the Fish...I heard him cuss out an ump once when he struck out looking. I was nine. It was magical. But in all seriousness, with "nobody watching" in South Fla, there would be no pressure, and Sheff could just hack away...I'm not opposed.
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez? Because whilst he has the same intials, Gaby Sanchez is not called "Gary Sheffield". The Tigers were AWFUL last year. That team didn't have HALF of the team chemistry the Marlins do. Look at all the good players on that team that had down years but could be productive in the right environment..... Sheffield, Renteria, Verlander, Zumaya, hell even Granderson didn't live up to expectations Sure he's past his prime but Gaby Sanchez isn't even in the same class as Sheff whether Sheff is 40 or 20. you'll have to rethink that in a few years
March 31, 200917 yr Might be worth a look as a fourth outfielder, but I bet we could get the currently unsigned Luis Gonzalez back for the same price and better production.
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez? Because whilst he has the same intials, Gaby Sanchez is not called "Gary Sheffield". The Tigers were AWFUL last year. That team didn't have HALF of the team chemistry the Marlins do. Look at all the good players on that team that had down years but could be productive in the right environment..... Sheffield, Renteria, Verlander, Zumaya, hell even Granderson didn't live up to expectations Sure he's past his prime but Gaby Sanchez isn't even in the same class as Sheff whether Sheff is 40 or 20. Hey hey hey, leave Curtis Granderson out of this! I'm too tired to look up his numbers right now...but don't hate on Grandy! I love him. 5 tools. Great attitude. The nostalgic side of me would kind of like to see Sheff back with the Fish...I heard him cuss out an ump once when he struck out looking. I was nine. It was magical. But in all seriousness, with "nobody watching" in South Fla, there would be no pressure, and Sheff could just hack away...I'm not opposed. I'm not saying Granderson had a bad year by any stretch. I'm saying he has AS much or MORE talent than any CFer in baseball right now. He should have had a better year.
March 31, 200917 yr Gary has been a Cancer everywhere he has played. NO THANKS. Except in 1997 when he was crashing into the walls for catches in the playoffs :whistle (Thome hits it into deep right field, Gary Sheffield is back, at the wall, leaps, he caught it!!....it's the play of the series, it's the play of the 1997 World Series. —Bob Costas (NBC Sports) commentating on Marlins right fielder Gary Sheffield robbing a home run from Cleveland Indians first baseman Jim Thome.) Then again, Pudge was a malcontent before he came to Florida. So was Bonilla. So was Kevin Brown. So was Scott Olsen..... and the list goes on....our organization has used chemistry and winning against personalities. Sheffield knows this is his last chance to go into the Hall. I doubt he would be any worse than Manny Ramirez. :thumbup Then again, we couldn't even afford Pudge so there is a 2% chance of this happening even for the minimum after investing so much time in Bonifacio at 3B (even though his ideal position is the bench).
March 31, 200917 yr NO, THANK YOU! I wouldn't even spend the minimum on a 40yr old who hit .225 in 114 games, struck out 83 times, and has an OBP of .326. Why do that when you can probably get the same exact production out of Gaby Sanchez? Because whilst he has the same intials, Gaby Sanchez is not called "Gary Sheffield". The Tigers were AWFUL last year. That team didn't have HALF of the team chemistry the Marlins do. Look at all the good players on that team that had down years but could be productive in the right environment..... Sheffield, Renteria, Verlander, Zumaya, hell even Granderson didn't live up to expectations Sure he's past his prime but Gaby Sanchez isn't even in the same class as Sheff whether Sheff is 40 or 20. Hey hey hey, leave Curtis Granderson out of this! I'm too tired to look up his numbers right now...but don't hate on Grandy! I love him. 5 tools. Great attitude. The nostalgic side of me would kind of like to see Sheff back with the Fish...I heard him cuss out an ump once when he struck out looking. I was nine. It was magical. But in all seriousness, with "nobody watching" in South Fla, there would be no pressure, and Sheff could just hack away...I'm not opposed. Haha Pretty much what i remember about him being here, I was like 8. Striking out lookjng then screaming at the ump. It would be cool to have him here and hit his 500 as a but I dont know howd he mix with all the young guys.
March 31, 200917 yr Because Gary Sheffield as a player was one of my favorites along with Maddux, Gwynn, Conine, and Frank Thomas, here are some great quotes on GARY SHEFFIELD: QUOTES ABOUT SHEFF: ?He likes to win. His commitment to the team is above everything else.? ?Former teammates Jeff Conine ?The guy generates the most awesome bat speed I?ve ever seen?he doesn?t just hit balls, he kills them.? ?Braves manager Bobby Cox ?He gives it his all every day.? ?Pirates manager Jim Tracy ?He?s a guy who can change a game with one swing.? ?Former All-Star Charles Johnson ?He?s one of the most dynamic and consistent hitters in baseball.? ?Braves GM John Scheurholz ?We didn?t have that real star bat. Sheffield brings that to us. He?s a force.? ?Tigers GM Dave Dombrowski AND MY 2 FAVORITES (Notice all the love from Managers? huh funny)..... ?This is one of the ultimate bats in baseball and one of the ultimate people in baseball." ?Tigers manager Jim Leyland "He's a terrific teammate. All the players loved him. I've never heard a player say a bad word about Gary Sheffield." ?Former Marlins manager John Boles
March 31, 200917 yr I say bring him in. He's a throwback, and he's our best shot at getting someone into the HOF as a 'Marlin'.
March 31, 200917 yr I say bring him in. He's a throwback, and he's our best shot at getting someone into the HOF as a 'Marlin'. Bringing him back will have nothing to do with his hall eligibility.
March 31, 200917 yr So was Scott Olsen..... lolwut He was a malcontent with the Marlins. There was no before the Marlins. 7
March 31, 200917 yr I say bring him in. He's a throwback, and he's our best shot at getting someone into the HOF as a 'Marlin'. Bringing him back will have nothing to do with his hall eligibility. Yeah but if he does get inducted I think it would all but insure that he goes in as a Marlin. I think right now if he were to be inducted there would be some debate on which team he would represent.
March 31, 200917 yr ...I heard him cuss out an ump once when he struck out looking. I was nine. It was magical. :lol
March 31, 200917 yr BRING BACK THE SHEFFFFFFFF!!!!!!!! Prediction--------First Marlin to ever hit 500 Hrs and first ever Marlin Hall of Famer :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy :notworthy
March 31, 200917 yr I love Sheff. Yeah he can be surly but damn he was a great hitter. I love his bat waggle. He would still be feared coming off the bench to pinch hit.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.