Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Opening Day Roster?

Featured Replies

Hi guys, new poster here althouh I've been reading the forums for a couple years. With all the moves going on in the last few days am I right in assuming this to be what we can expect to see on April 6th.

 

Starting 8

2. Baker

3. Cantu

4. Uggla

5. Bonifacio

6. Ramirez

7. Hermida

8. Maybin

9. Ross

 

Bench 5

Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez

 

Starting 5

Nolasco, Johnson, Volstad, Miller, Sanchez

 

Relief 7

Lindstrom, Nunez, Pinto, Meyer, Calero, Penn, Kensing

 

DL

Amezaga, Proctor

 

Thanks.

Hi guys, new poster here althouh I've been reading the forums for a couple years. With all the moves going on in the last few days am I right in assuming this to be what we can expect to see on April 6th.

 

Starting 8

2. Baker

3. Cantu

4. Uggla

5. Bonifacio

6. Ramirez

7. Hermida

8. Maybin

9. Ross

 

Bench 5

Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez

 

Starting 5

Nolasco, Johnson, Volstad, Miller, Sanchez

 

Relief 7

Lindstrom, Nunez, Pinto, Meyer, Calero, Penn, Kensing

 

DL

Amezaga, Proctor

 

Thanks.

 

This is right, barring any injuries, acquisitions, etc. Calero is not officially a lock, but he certainly looks to be the front-runner for that 5th right-hander spot.

ummmmm who said penn was a lock? the guy has a 10.90 era in spring. Carlos Martinez deserves the spot. Penn whould be in the minors and prove to us that he can do something better than a 4.71 era last year. He doesnt come close to deserving a spot.

ummmmm who said penn was a lock? the guy has a 10.90 era in spring. Carlos Martinez deserves the spot. Penn whould be in the minors and prove to us that he can do something better than a 4.71 era last year. He doesnt come close to deserving a spot.

 

This is only if they think they can sneak him down past waivers, which might be very likely. I don't know how many teams would be willing to give him a guaranteed job.

 

I personally would much rather see Martinez in the bullpen. I hope they don't just hand Penn a spot.

ummmmm who said penn was a lock? the guy has a 10.90 era in spring. Carlos Martinez deserves the spot. Penn whould be in the minors and prove to us that he can do something better than a 4.71 era last year. He doesnt come close to deserving a spot.

 

This is only if they think they can sneak him down past waivers, which might be very likely. I don't know how many teams would be willing to give him a guaranteed job.

 

I personally would much rather see Martinez in the bullpen. I hope they don't just hand Penn a spot.

I agree. I remember Martinez being flat out nasty before he got injured; and though he's not as young as Penn, he still did do much better than him this ST.

ummmmm who said penn was a lock? the guy has a 10.90 era in spring. Carlos Martinez deserves the spot. Penn whould be in the minors and prove to us that he can do something better than a 4.71 era last year. He doesnt come close to deserving a spot.

Out of options, and Penn has no shot at falling through waivers.

I'm so glad we have Hayden Penn. I mean, who needs Eulogio De La Cruz when you have Hayden Penn?

Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason.

I'm so glad we have Hayden Penn. I mean, who needs Eulogio De La Cruz when you have Hayden Penn?

Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason.

 

You say it like there's a huge difference between the two? Penn is younger, and has a great minor league track record. De La Cruz had good minor league numbers too. Neither has proven a thing in the majors. I don't know why you're up in arms.

i don't want carroll as our 4th outfielder. the guys just can't hit major league pitching. since catalanotto was released i hope we sign him which will give as a 4th outfielder/1st baseman. then when amezaga returns he'll take gonzalez's spot as the primary backup middle infielder.

I'm so glad we have Hayden Penn. I mean, who needs Eulogio De La Cruz when you have Hayden Penn?

Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason.

 

You say it like there's a huge difference between the two? Penn is younger, and has a great minor league track record. De La Cruz had good minor league numbers too. Neither has proven a thing in the majors. I don't know why you're up in arms.

 

 

I'm up in arms b/c we let the guy go for no good reason.

De La Cruz was once projected to be a future closer in the Tigers organization, and the Marlins just let him go without really having any better options on the team (or the organization, for that matter).

I'm so glad we have Hayden Penn. I mean, who needs Eulogio De La Cruz when you have Hayden Penn?

Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason.

 

You say it like there's a huge difference between the two? Penn is younger, and has a great minor league track record. De La Cruz had good minor league numbers too. Neither has proven a thing in the majors. I don't know why you're up in arms.

 

 

I'm up in arms b/c we let the guy go for no good reason.

De La Cruz was once projected to be a future closer in the Tigers organization, and the Marlins just let him go without really having any better options on the team (or the organization, for that matter).

 

And that has what to do with Hayden Penn, exactly?

Bench 5

Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez

 

...I just find it amazing that at the start of the offseason this would have seemed like a total randomly put together joke...

 

We thought it was something like... Rabelo, Helms, McPherson, Amezaga, Bonifacio (maybe throw in Sanchez) and we ended up with Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez...

 

I'm not really arguing if its better or worse, just saying its funny how baseball works... how a team can be the same year to year and sometimes a team can change drastically in just a few short weeks...

 

God I love this game!

Bench 5

Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez

 

...I just find it amazing that at the start of the offseason this would have seemed like a total randomly put together joke...

 

We thought it was something like... Rabelo, Helms, McPherson, Amezaga, Bonifacio (maybe throw in Sanchez) and we ended up with Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez...

 

I'm not really arguing if its better or worse, just saying its funny how baseball works... how a team can be the same year to year and sometimes a team can change drastically in just a few short weeks...

 

God I love this game!

A few weeks ago I would have gone with Pudge, Helms, McDallas, Amezaga, and Gibbons. What a load of wrong.

Bench 5

Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez

 

...I just find it amazing that at the start of the offseason this would have seemed like a total randomly put together joke...

 

We thought it was something like... Rabelo, Helms, McPherson, Amezaga, Bonifacio (maybe throw in Sanchez) and we ended up with Paulino,Helms,Gload,Carrol,Gonzalez...

 

I'm not really arguing if its better or worse, just saying its funny how baseball works... how a team can be the same year to year and sometimes a team can change drastically in just a few short weeks...

 

God I love this game!

A few weeks ago I would have gone with Pudge, Helms, McDallas, Amezaga, and Gibbons. What a load of wrong.

 

Gibbons still doesnt have a team. Gotta wonder why we released him so early in ST.

 

Tho maybe those first two sentences are linked....

i don't want carroll as our 4th outfielder. the guys just can't hit major league pitching. since catalanotto was released i hope we sign him which will give as a 4th outfielder/1st baseman. then when amezaga returns he'll take gonzalez's spot as the primary backup middle infielder.

Well first, Gload is the 4th outfielder, but I understand your point regardless. I typed this in another thread already, but I'm going to say it again.

 

Signing Catalanotto creates a mandatory financial obligation for the Marlins. Let's think about the bench. Amezaga, Helms, Paulino, and Gload all are getting paid this year. If the Marlins choose to release one of them, they are still on the hook for their salary. Let's add Catalanotto now, which is the same thing was soon as he breaks it onto the 25 man roster. We now have no flexibility in our 25 man, except for injury. This is a problem. You want to call up Gaby? You have to DFA somebody, and now you are eating the prorated portion of their contract. You want to call up Logan? Same thing. The only guy on the team (not including Maybin and Baker who are not going to be sent down) that has an option where we could send somebody down and replace them with a Gaby/Logan/Coghlan/Carroll/Raynor whoever, would be Bonifacio. And it seems the organization is really behind him right now, he and Amezaga serve as the two backup middle infielders which is a necessary thing on a 25 man roster, so it would be silly to lock in the rest of the 25 man roster around upgrading Carroll to Catalanotto. The Marlins aren't going to pay for a DFA, even if it's pro rated minimum like Gload or assumedly Catalanotto in this situation, and they can't assume one of these guys would be picked up by another team or be able to trade them to get rid of the financial obligation.

 

Basically, the Marlins NEED this last slot of the roster to be able to rotate in our 40 man options who have options, so if sent down, we are not on the hook for their salary commitment. Catalanotto ruins this, even if he is an upgrade to Carroll and is overall useful.

 

--

 

Here's a non-paragraph form of this

 

Locked on 25 man when healthy - Cantu, Uggla, Hanley, Hermida, Ross, Amezaga, Gload, Paulino, Helms (9)

Have options, but pretty much never going to come off 25 man - Baker, Maybin (2)

Options - Bonifacio, Last Spot on The Bench (which is probably Carroll) (2)

 

You sign Catalanotto, he gets that "last spot" on the bench and now it becomes problematic to try out anyone in the minors because the only way they come up, is sending Bonifacio to AAA or an injury. And I mentioned the reasons why that is a bad idea. This is really tough on your flexibility for all sorts of reasons.

 

---

 

The Marlins are done. They need to acquire young players with OPTIONS if anything, and really, with Carroll, J. Miller, De Aza, Cousins, Petersen, Burns, and Morrison as all potential OF options, and G. Sanchez, Coghlan, and Morrison as infield options, this team doesn't need to bring anyone in. Those guys all have their own specific traits that could make them valuable off the bench.

I'm so glad we have Hayden Penn. I mean, who needs Eulogio De La Cruz when you have Hayden Penn?

Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason.

 

You say it like there's a huge difference between the two? Penn is younger, and has a great minor league track record. De La Cruz had good minor league numbers too. Neither has proven a thing in the majors. I don't know why you're up in arms.

 

 

I'm up in arms b/c we let the guy go for no good reason.

De La Cruz was once projected to be a future closer in the Tigers organization, and the Marlins just let him go without really having any better options on the team (or the organization, for that matter).

 

There are a long line of pitchers who were once somebody's "closer of the future". That doesn't mean they are any good.

i don't want carroll as our 4th outfielder. the guys just can't hit major league pitching. since catalanotto was released i hope we sign him which will give as a 4th outfielder/1st baseman. then when amezaga returns he'll take gonzalez's spot as the primary backup middle infielder.

 

 

its hard for a young hitter to hit successfully in the major leagues when he gets like 1 start a week and maybe 2 pitch hit apperances off the bench.

Lou, I see that a lot more clearly now thanks to your post. In hindsight, I would have preferred them to sign FC for the minimum instead of trading for Gload, but that seems like it's a moot point.

"Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason."

 

"I'm up in arms b/c we let the guy go for no good reason."

 

Unless I missed a game going backwards through the Padres ST since he was traded, DLC has pitched 4.1 innings, given up seven runs and seven walks.

 

You might want to rethink this in light of his performance since being moved. Obviously something is wrong somewhere and it doesn't appear to be in the Marlins front office. There's probably a good chance (isn't he out of options?) he doesn't even make their Opening Day roster with his latest performance.

Lou, I see that a lot more clearly now thanks to your post. In hindsight, I would have preferred them to sign FC for the minimum instead of trading for Gload, but that seems like it's a moot point.

 

I agree 100%. FC has been an overall much more productive ballplayer, and he's more versatile. I really wish we had just waited 24 hours and picked him up.

I'm so glad we have Hayden Penn. I mean, who needs Eulogio De La Cruz when you have Hayden Penn?

Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason.

 

You say it like there's a huge difference between the two? Penn is younger, and has a great minor league track record. De La Cruz had good minor league numbers too. Neither has proven a thing in the majors. I don't know why you're up in arms.

 

 

I'm up in arms b/c we let the guy go for no good reason.

De La Cruz was once projected to be a future closer in the Tigers organization, and the Marlins just let him go without really having any better options on the team (or the organization, for that matter).

 

There are a long line of pitchers who were once somebody's "closer of the future". That doesn't mean they are any good.

 

 

It also doesn't mean you let him go for nothing when you really don't have better options.

"Letting De La Cruz go through waivers might've been the dumbest move by the organization this offseason."

 

"I'm up in arms b/c we let the guy go for no good reason."

 

Unless I missed a game going backwards through the Padres ST since he was traded, DLC has pitched 4.1 innings, given up seven runs and seven walks.

 

You might want to rethink this in light of his performance since being moved. Obviously something is wrong somewhere and it doesn't appear to be in the Marlins front office. There's probably a good chance (isn't he out of options?) he doesn't even make their Opening Day roster with his latest performance.

 

Oh, those Spring Training 4 inning sample size stats. :rolleyes:

Oh, those Spring Training 4 inning sample size stats. :rolleyes:

 

Actually Erick, I question whether there may a physical/pyschological/medical problem he's masking (certainly wouldn't be the first pitcher to do so in an effort to make or stay on a team) not so much his pitching of late. That's just evidential (at least to me). He's getting worse not better. Clearly he is underperforming everyone's expectation and I don't think it's bad luck or by accident, and for the record I have never penned a bad word about the guy since he's been acquired.

 

But keeping being smarmy. :rolleyes:

Oh, those Spring Training 4 inning sample size stats. :rolleyes:

 

Actually Erick, I question whether there may a physical/pyschological/medical problem he's masking (certainly wouldn't be the first pitcher to do so in an effort to make or stay on a team) not so much his pitching of late. That's just evidential (at least to me). He's getting worse not better. Clearly he is underperforming everyone's expectation and I don't think it's bad luck or by accident, and for the record I have never penned a bad word about the guy since he's been acquired.

 

But keeping being smarmy. :rolleyes:

 

He's a good prospect dude. Had a solid year last year in Albuquerque where not too many pitchers have solid years.

 

It was a bad move by the organization, and a sample of 4 innings doesn't change that.

 

They let De La Cruz go, yet they're picking up Hayden Penn via trade (who will now likely make the team...is that really an upgrade), and are interested in the likes of Angel Guzman and Merkin Valdez.

 

We're supposed to be keeping the young relievers with potential, not letting them go. The Marlins bullpen isn't that strong, to be letting go of guys like De La Cruz.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.