May 15, 201412 yr Thats fair, but the others have value. Not to the Marlins so much but value to get what the Marlins need.
May 15, 201412 yr I don't think the Marlins will get a whole lot for Cishek anyhow. You have to consider what he is versus what you get in return, and quite frankly I'm not sure a closer is going to net more than some rather unimpressive prospects. Another Urbina trade is unlikely to happen. Closers in general seem to be a high need for a lot of teams this year. That coupled with the fact Cishek is still cheap and under club control and I bet we get something pretty juicy for him.
May 15, 201412 yr Cardinal Fan Here. What would it take to get McGehee to St. Louis? We could put him at 3rd, move Carpenter back to 2nd, and hope he starts hitting again.
May 15, 201412 yr As much as I believe this team is likely not a real playoff competitor, you can't trade guys when you're a half-game out of the wild card, like they currently are. They'll need to be 5+ games out or something for big trades to be seriously entertained, I think.
May 15, 201412 yr Author Agreed, no deals will be made to move pieces any time soon. Regardless of the wild card, the division itself is very much up for grabs...
May 15, 201412 yr If we are a little over .500 i would make deals to help us out in the stretch run by maybe trading a pitching prospect or 2 for a good power hitting 1b and try to make a wild card run. If not and this is obviously most likely now that Jose has gone down I would entertain offers for Cishek if we can get a big time hitting prospect, which is questionable. I wouldn't trade Mcgehee becasue apparently he isn't a free agent after the year and with the way Moran hasn't quite progressed like we had hoped he may be our best option to start the year at 3B again next year. I would also explore trading Jacob Turner and call up Flynn, Conley, or Heaney at that point in the year.
May 15, 201412 yr Well, at least they're being consistent. They didn't move any pitching to beef up the hitting before the season started, nor did they move any pitching to get a new arm in light of the Jose injury. There's no particular reason to think they're giving up on anything or are ready to move anyone, and why should there be? It's only May. Two months from now it could be an entirely different story.
May 15, 201412 yr If they could move Cishek for a real starting SS, even if that player is currently in A+ or AA, I would be so happy.
May 15, 201412 yr Author You could probably get a future starter at a less significant position, but not likely a SS.
May 15, 201412 yr If they could move Cishek for a real starting SS, even if that player is currently in A+ or AA, I would be so happy. I think they still think Hechavarria is a legit starter
May 15, 201412 yr I think they still think Hechavarria is a legit starter They probably still think he's a perennial all-star.
May 15, 201412 yr Cardinal Fan Here. What would it take to get McGehee to St. Louis? We could put him at 3rd, move Carpenter back to 2nd, and hope he starts hitting again. Oscar Tavares, Trevor Rosenthal, Carlos Martinez. Just might be good enough. (Kidding)
May 16, 201412 yr Okay I know there will be people on the board that are going to tell me I am absolutely off base. I'm crazy, stupid, or any other mean name possible for my next suggestion. Can those people please refrain from any such comments and try to entertain the thought. Can we trade Giancarlo Flynn and Turner for Puig and Ross stripling? Is this a plausible move?
May 16, 201412 yr They probably still think he's a perennial all-star. Hechavarria is probably gonna turn out to be another Alex Gonzalez...great glove (but not as good as Gonz) but not much pop with the bat.
May 16, 201412 yr Author Hechavarria is probably gonna turn out to be another Alex Gonzalez...great glove (but not as good as Gonz) but not much pop with the bat. Not a good comparison considering Gonzalez is... A former All-Starr. Lol
May 16, 201412 yr There's also no point in expending any trade pieces on another middle of the rotation guy for a season where the Marlins are highly unlikely to make the playoffs regardless. They should be considering the MarlinsLou approach and getting a better picture of Stanton's future and orchestrating their moves around that. If that means building for 2016, then so be it. There will be a point this season where it will be smarter to trade guys like Cishek than add pieces like Samardzija who are pitching over their heads and likely to walk at the end of the season. One day the franchise will consult you before signing any contract and we'll be better off for it. I guess. You now endorse the "MarlinsLou approach" of basically building around Stanton.....2 years ago, 1 year ago, 6 months ago...you and others derided the notion of 10/150+. Now...you endorse what would be 5/150? And hope he accepts. hmmmm. shoulda coulda woulda if only we knew what you did.
May 16, 201412 yr One day the franchise will consult you before signing any contract and we'll be better off for it. I guess. You now endorse the "MarlinsLou approach" of basically building around Stanton.....2 years ago, 1 year ago, 6 months ago...you and others derided the notion of 10/150+. Now...you endorse what would be 5/150? And hope he accepts. hmmmm. shoulda coulda woulda if only we knew what you did. I have no idea what this is supposed to mean. You originally proposed (10/200) (yes, yes you did) way back before Stanton was in his arbitration years. People ridiculed you because 10/200 was way above his market value at the time. I endorsed signing him back then when the amount required to lock him down was much lower than 10/200 and much lower than it will be if they try to sign him now.
May 17, 201412 yr There's always at least one asshole like that in every league. #iseewhatyoudidthere. Nice indirect whack at Wild Card.
May 18, 201412 yr I think come July if the team is still playing like this Loria will force Jennings to make a move to push us into contention. He won't dictate who or what to get- but he'll give him permission to put some chips on the table and try to sneak a playoff spot. Mostly for his own ego. Imagine one year removed from a fire sale and the teams competing for a playoff berth while Toronto is struggling. It will be the ultimate I told you so to all of those who cursed the trade. He'll open up the wallet, the question is what will we have to part with. A few middle relievers and a Nick Johnson type might do well on this team.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.