May 13, 201412 yr Author As Admin says, trading for Samardzija will now command a lot. There's likely no deal that can be worked out that will benefit the Marlins. Then I wouldn't make a deal. If I only had to sacrifice one top arm, like a Nicolino, fine. I certainly wouldn't part with 2-3. We shouldn't be trading for any starting pitchers. I'd like a new shortstop and first baseman please and thank you. Too bad Garrett Jones is allergic to injury, I'd like to see Bour get a shot.
May 13, 201412 yr I'd hate to see what Wild Card is like when he plays fantasy baseball. On a similar note, I had a friend who would keep proposing trash trades where he traded me 5 pieces of shit for 1 stud. I would rage.
May 13, 201412 yr On a similar note, I had a friend who would keep proposing trash trades where he traded me 5 pieces of s*** for 1 stud. I would rage. There's always at least one asshole like that in every league.
May 13, 201412 yr No way is one or two years (I don't know how arb works after trades) of Samardzja worth depleting our farm system. If Slowey and co can't step up and get it done until Heaney gets the call then so be it. Can't risk the future for a questionable now.
May 14, 201412 yr The Marlins need more than just pitching. It would be dumb to make a trade that isn't going to fill multiple holes.
May 14, 201412 yr The Marlins need more than just pitching. It would be dumb to make a trade that isn't going to fill multiple holes. I think pitching is the only thing they really need. They are pretty solid across the board offensively with a small question mark in the middle infield. The bullpen is awful and the rotation needs help now without Jose.
May 14, 201412 yr If that's how you define "imploding," then the stats absolutely say that he will implode. That's not me being "negative" or a "debbie downer." That's me simply communicating what the facts (the statistics) are loudly and definitively saying about Samardzija's performance thus far. Frisaro clearly did not even bother to look at the stats before he proclaimed that Samardzija was an ace. I'm done with your persistent negativity.
May 14, 201412 yr I only want Samardzija because I'm pretty sure we'd get some kind of award or other recognition just for having Samardzija and Saltalamacchia on the same team. After the ceremony, ship him back to Chicago and get back whatever we sent in the first place. You can do that right? Doesn't expanded replay include that? Like challenging a bad trade.
May 14, 201412 yr I think pitching is the only thing they really need. They are pretty solid across the board offensively with a small question mark in the middle infield. The bullpen is awful and the rotation needs help now without Jose. Naaaa man. The Marlins have no infield. McGehee and Salty are playing way over their heads, and Jones and Hech still suck. Not to mention the future is still up in the air at second and center (though I like Ozuna and Deitrich). It's about filling those needs for the future. Pitching has depth in the minors and should be fine going forward.
May 14, 201412 yr Naaaa man. The Marlins have no infield. McGehee and Salty are playing way over their heads, and Jones and Hech still suck. Not to mention the future is still up in the air at second and center (though I like Ozuna and Deitrich). It's about filling those needs for the future. Pitching has depth in the minors and should be fine going forward. Srsly. To everyone who thought this team could actually provide average offensive production it is apparant that unrealistic dream has been squashed during this road trip. This offense is STANKY. Onward to 2016!
May 14, 201412 yr 2016 people. It will be like this season but with more road wins, no impending regression, and a healthy Fernandez. No, because we'll find another reason to start all over again after 2015.
May 14, 201412 yr Well the Harang thing is just ridiculous. The difference is Smarge can be a good pitcher and is still pretty young. He's got some other things going for him besides that completely and utterly unsustainable ERA. BTW I'm not trying to agree with wild card or anything, but I do think Smarge is a pretty decent pitcher and that perhaps he's turned a corner this year. Regardless, I don't want him on the fish unless it's for Brian Flynn or something stupid like that Samardzija isnt that young. He will be 30 before spring training next year.
May 14, 201412 yr And at the deadline: See you Cishek Trade Saltalamacchia, McGhee, and Alvarez while their value is high Get what you can for Jones, Baker, Johnson, and Dunn Get whatever filler you can for Hand,Turner, and Slowey This is the perfect season to jettison players to improve the farm system/team for the next few seasons while still retaining a core group(Stanton, Yelich, Ozuna).
May 14, 201412 yr Author No, because we'll find another reason to start all over again after 2015. Hopefully we won't suck this badly
May 14, 201412 yr And at the deadline: See you Cishek Trade Saltalamacchia, McGhee, and Alvarez while their value is high Get what you can for Jones, Baker, Johnson, and Dunn Get whatever filler you can for Hand,Turner, and Slowey This is the perfect season to jettison players to improve the farm system/team for the next few seasons while still retaining a core group(Stanton, Yelich, Ozuna). This absolutely isn't happening. Why do some people think its a given that this team blows up half the roster every single season? Whether some of those pieces being traded is justified or not is one thing, but this tweaked front office of Hill and Jennings isn't gonna send away a dozen players. Its just not happening.
May 14, 201412 yr This absolutely isn't happening. Why do some people think its a given that this team blows up half the roster every single season? Whether some of those pieces being traded is justified or not is one thing, but this tweaked front office of Hill and Jennings isn't gonna send away a dozen players. Its just not happening. I have to agree with you Bullet. Let's see where the Marlins are in late July before we think about blowing up the team.
May 14, 201412 yr I have to agree with you Bullet. Let's see where the Marlins are in late July before we think about blowing up the team. And even then, if we're in last place in July, I don't see a dozen players going. We're not that far from contention to be starting over yet again.
May 14, 201412 yr Author And even then, if we're in last place in July, I don't see a dozen players going. We're not that far from contention to be starting over yet again. As I've mentioned, almost the whole team is under control next season. No need to deal anyone if you think you can compete soon. Especially Cishek, considering the bullpen is ready to explode.
May 14, 201412 yr If the team is out of contention (which they will be) in July, Cishek should absolutely be traded. If they don't trade him because they like him so much, they should spend some money already, build a core and extend him. But of course, none of the above will happen.
May 14, 201412 yr If the team is out of contention (which they will be) in July, Cishek should absolutely be traded. If they don't trade him because they like him so much, they should spend some money already, build a core and extend him. But of course, none of the above will happen. That's it. It's not that trading Cishek or Cishek is bad in a vacuum; rather, it should be part of a coherent strategy. If you're going to spend and build a team now, then keep your top-notch closer, sure. On the other hand, if you're going to wait for the young guys to develop, then trade Cishek now because his value in a trade outweighs his value to a team that is not ready to compete quite yet (certainly not without spending significant money).
May 15, 201412 yr Despite what some want to think, the Marlins are still pretty far from contention. You trade guys like Alvarez, Saltalamacchia, Jones, McGhee while they are at their highest values and get pieces that will be ready to help contribute when the team is ready to compete.
May 15, 201412 yr I don't think the Marlins will get a whole lot for Cishek anyhow. You have to consider what he is versus what you get in return, and quite frankly I'm not sure a closer is going to net more than some rather unimpressive prospects. Another Urbina trade is unlikely to happen.
May 15, 201412 yr Despite what some want to think, the Marlins are still pretty far from contention. You trade guys like Alvarez, Saltalamacchia, Jones, McGhee while they are at their highest values and get pieces that will be ready to help contribute when the team is ready to compete. I completely agree with you in theory, but I think the team will tread lightly on that. I hope they move Cishek to a hungry contender who needs a top bullpen arm and overvalues him, but I can't see Miami trading Salty. They've been so staunch about 'veteran leadership blah' that I can't see them ridding the main piece of that.
May 15, 201412 yr They need to realize that all of those players are much more valuable to the team as trade pieces than being on the team, especially when guys like Saltalamacchia, McGhee, Jones, and Alvarez's values are so high and can only go down.
May 15, 201412 yr They need to realize that all of those players are much more valuable to the team as trade pieces than being on the team, especially when guys like Saltalamacchia, McGhee, Jones, and Alvarez's values are so high and can only go down. I'm not so sure the value of any of them is super high but Jones especially... he barely has any value.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.