Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

2014 MLB Draft Thread

Featured Replies

Didn't even notice until now! That Vin Winkle bourbon is supposed to be tasty stuff.

I am a bourbon man myself, guess I gotta try it.

I give them an incomplete. We dont know who they are going to sign and at this time the only firm news is Blake Anderson(comp pick) will be signing on Wednesday. Locking up some of that prep talent will be nice and I hope they can get it done.

Let's give it some time (at least two seasons) before giving it a grade. :D

 

Well, it would be an easy, conclusive grade down the line but right now we can give it a grade based on what we know about the prospects. At this current moment we can grade the picks on their current value.

I give them an incomplete. We dont know who they are going to sign and at this time the only firm news is Blake Anderson(comp pick) will be signing on Wednesday. Locking up some of that prep talent will be nice and I hope they can get it done.

Very well put. Can't determine this draft yet until the signing deadline and see who we locked up first. Then, move forward.

And unlike many I really liked the Anderson pick even if it was a bit of a reach. After watching some video, he has a really smooth, simple, repeatable swing. It is a nice line drive swing. Granted you cant tell much by watching a little video, but I liked what I saw. You can work on bat speed by adding strength and hopefully he has some decent pitch recognition. And hopefully the reports about his defense are accurate.

I am a bourbon man myself, guess I gotta try it.

They are pretty pricey and tough to find, but if you see one, give it a go! Just getting into bourbon myself. So far I've really like Bulleit and Four Roses Single Barrel.

And unlike many I really liked the Anderson pick even if it was a bit of a reach. After watching some video, he has a really smooth, simple, repeatable swing. It is a nice line drive swing. Granted you cant tell much by watching a little video, but I liked what I saw. You can work on bat speed by adding strength and hopefully he has some decent pitch recognition. And hopefully the reports about his defense are accurate.

 

What the fuck this new leaf spike is scaring me

The last time we had the 2nd overall pick we took a prep power arm from Texas.

 

I guess I'm just surprised so many people were surprised. This is the most Marlins pick ever. Heaney was a departure from tradition. Kolek fits the traditional Marlins mold much more than Rodon does. Even the ballpark fits pitchers like Kolek. And while I'm far from a scout, I'm very impressed by Kolek's athleticism. He is a nimble giant.

 

That 2nd overall pick from Texas was made under a completely different front office, so tradition doesn't really hold up there. It is certainly true that the Marlins in the Loria years have leaned toward high school arms, but I don't think that you can compare mid-round picks to the 2nd overall.

Nope, no evidence at all that they really wanted a guy who can throw 102 in high school. Stan Meek, Marlins’ VP of scouting:

 

 

http://www.palmbeachpost.com/news/sports/marlins-select-hard-throwing-high-schooler-with-no/ngFf2/

 

"88-90 mph changeup." Randy "My fastball hits 90 on a good day" Wolf, eat your heart out.

 

Meanwhile, the desire to trash Loria continues unabated.

 

And again if it was any other team the assumption would be they just liked him better. This ownership has lost the benefit of the doubt based on previous transactions including one just last week.

 

They just sacrificed draft talent for money with that trade so it isn't exactly absurd to believe the team would once again do the same thing with this pick.

 

And again I like Kolek better than Rodon. But if Kolek wanted more money and Rodon wanted less we probably would have taken Rodon.

 

If talent maximization was the goal they would have kept all of their picks AND taken a bunch of overslot guys later in the draft. If the goal was to minimize cost they would trade away a pick to lower their cap and go for overall under slot talent.

 

Guess which one the team did?

Well, we'll find out who was over-or-under-slot after they've signed (hopefully all of) them.

 

They scouted Kolek multiple times over many months, and were highly impressed. I've seen nothing that even hints that the FO ever liked Rodon over Kolek. They wanted Kolek, they got him.

 

In any case, if they had really wanted Rodon, since Loria is almost universally (although often unjustifiably) known as "cheap" (or worse) it would have been no big deal for them to say "we were equally interested in (or even would have preferred) Rodon but were concerned about signing him."

I would love to pile on Loria because I can't stand him but when it comes to the selection of Kolek, that definitely was not Loria.

That was all Hill/Jennings. That was a brave baseball decision and I applaud them for taking it. If you look at it in the way that Rodon was the safe decision... Rodon is a S Floridian and I am sure that he would not have been difficult to sign to play within 30-45 mins of his home. They really believed in Kolek. They expect him to be be the better pitcher, not now, but 3 years from now. I think they are right, not just because he throws 102 mph, not just because of the rating of 65 on his slider and 60 of his curve. Not because at the of the age of 18 he is 6'5 and 250 lbs. It's all that and that his developmental growth curve is amazing. He just gets it...He works very hard but it's more. He is a one in a lifetime talent...Pitching for him is like Mozart is for music or Da Vinci is for art, Einstein is for science. You can't actually put it in words, you have to see it... I think all along it was Kolek and in a few years we will see why. I had my doubts on Fernandez myself and look how quickly that worked out for the Marlins.Kolek will make his mark quickly as well. How big will the splash be? It's going to be fun to find out

I do however blame Loria for the trade of the 39th pick. We could have gotten an additional solid prospect with that pick as well

Well, we'll find out who was over-or-under-slot after they've signed (hopefully all of) them.

 

They scouted Kolek multiple times over many months, and were highly impressed. I've seen nothing that even hints that the FO ever liked Rodon over Kolek. They wanted Kolek, they got him.

 

In any case, if they had really wanted Rodon, since Loria is almost universally (although often unjustifiably) known as "cheap" (or worse) it would have been no big deal for them to say "we were equally interested in (or even would have preferred) Rodon but were concerned about signing him."

 

We will find out but I have a feeling you will have a way to spin it when we come in under.

 

As I said before I like Kolek better and with any other team I would assume they did too. You can't ignore past history though. If a house in the neighborhood catches fire, the first person I'm questioning is the guy who was in jail for arson. And again if the primary goal of this draft was to maximize talent you don't trade away a draft pick and you take over slot guys with your next couple of picks since you took the cheaper guy #2

 

And yes Loria is universally known as cheap but he still has no reason to admit it. The team can come out and say we wanted Kolek the whole time. Why even admit the money concern regardless?

 

Wouldn't be the first time they spun an obvious money move as a baseball move. As I have repeated several times they could just prefer Kolek on merit (I do) but they no longer deserve that benefit of the doubt with all of their other cheap moves.

I would love to pile on Loria because I can't stand him but when it comes to the selection of Kolek, that definitely was not Loria.

That was all Hills/Jennings. That was a brave baseball decision and I applaud them for taking it. If you look at it in the way that Rodon was the safe decision... Rodon is a S Floridian and I am sure that he would not have been difficult to sign to play within 30-45 mins of his home. They really believed in Kolek. They expect him to be be the better pitcher, not now, but 3 years from now. I think they are right, not just because he throws 102 mph, not just because of the rating of 65 on his slider and 60 of his curve. Not because at the of the age of 18 he is 6'5 and 250 lbs. It's all that and that his developmental growth curve is amazing. He just gets it...He works very hard but it's more. He is a one in a lifetime talent...Pitching for him is like Mozart is for music or Da Vinci is for art, Einstein is for science. You can't actually put it in words, you have to see it... I think all along it was Kolek and in a few years we will see why. I had my doubts on Fernandez myself and look how quickly that worked out for the Marlins.Kolek will make his mark quickly as well. How big will the splash be? It's going to be fun to find out

I do however blame Loria for the trade of the 39th pick. We could have gotten an additional solid prospect with that pick as well

 

I can agree with this. My philosophy is go upside in the draft since its such a crap shoot and fill organizational holes with free agency and trades. I like the Kolek pick in terms of upside.

Law's breakdown on our draft: http://insider.espn.go.com/blog/mlb-draft/post?id=2032&ex_cid=espnapi_public

 

Miami Marlins

 

The Marlins landed the draft's hardest-throwing starter in Texas prep right-hander Tyler Kolek (Round 1), an enormous kid at 6-foot-6, 270-plus, who has hit 101 mph and can flash a plus slider; he needs work on all the finer points of pitching, from commanding the fastball to throwing the slider for strikes to developing any sort of changeup. It's a bet on tremendous raw material, the kind of bet that worked for them three years ago with Jose Fernandez, who was also a stuff-over-polish high school kid when drafted.

 

Blake Anderson (Round 1A) was the surprise pick of day one for me, not a top-five round prospect, a defense-first catcher with some pop but a below-average bat, and the history of Mississippi prep hitters in the draft is ugly. Justin Twine (Round 2) was a late riser this spring, a top high school quarterback who was committed to TCU for baseball, and probably moves off shortstop to second base in pro ball. He bars his lead arm a little but once he gets his hands started he's quick and direct to the ball, with line-drive power as well as above-average speed on the bases. He's a classic Marlins pick -- a two-sport guy with athleticism and significant offensive upside.

 

Arkansas second baseman/outfielder Brian Anderson (Round 3) is more of a utility guy than a starter, lacking a clear position in the infield but without the hit tool to profile at an outfield corner. Casey Soltis (Round 5) might be an outfield tweener, lacking the power for a corner but a little short defensively in center, although I think shortening his overly wide stance at the plate and allowing him to drive the ball better by transferring his weight will give him a chance to become an everyday right fielder.

 

Stone Garrett (Round 8) might be a tough sign as a Rice commit and I don't think his bat is advanced enough for him to profile as an everyday player in left field. The Marlins took two familiar names to finish day two, Oregon State senior Ben Wetzler (Round 9) and Texas junior Dillon Peters (Round 10), both solid college lefties. Wetzler was the player suspended by the NCAA after the Phillies reported him for using the services of an agent when they drafted him last summer; he had a great senior year, with a 0.78 ERA, doing it more with feel and command as his stuff is fifth starter material. Peters is an undersized southpaw but has a curveball that should be very effective against lefties in pro ball.

 

Oklahoma prep righty Nick White (Round 11) comes straight over the top in his delivery, creating some head violence and putting pressure on the shoulder, but he reaches 94 with downhill plane and has good depth on a 12-to-6 curveball.

I like the college lefties in rounds 9-10 for upper minor league depth. Like the Twine, Soltis and Stone picks for upside. Not a fan of the two Anderson picks at all.

I would love to pile on Loria because I can't stand him but when it comes to the selection of Kolek, that definitely was not Loria.

That was all Hill/Jennings. That was a brave baseball decision and I applaud them for taking it. If you look at it in the way that Rodon was the safe decision... Rodon is a S Floridian and I am sure that he would not have been difficult to sign to play within 30-45 mins of his home. They really believed in Kolek. They expect him to be be the better pitcher, not now, but 3 years from now. I think they are right, not just because he throws 102 mph, not just because of the rating of 65 on his slider and 60 of his curve. Not because at the of the age of 18 he is 6'5 and 250 lbs. It's all that and that his developmental growth curve is amazing. He just gets it...He works very hard but it's more. He is a one in a lifetime talent...Pitching for him is like Mozart is for music or Da Vinci is for art, Einstein is for science. You can't actually put it in words, you have to see it... I think all along it was Kolek and in a few years we will see why. I had my doubts on Fernandez myself and look how quickly that worked out for the Marlins.Kolek will make his mark quickly as well. How big will the splash be? It's going to be fun to find out

I do however blame Loria for the trade of the 39th pick. We could have gotten an additional solid prospect with that pick as well

Isn't kolek 17?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.